Hormizd’s Accession and Address
The published opening combines the garden prelude and Makh’s account with the entire accession speech and its reception.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | The published opening combines the garden prelude and Makh’s account with the entire accession speech and its reception. |
| Moscow | Volume VIII prints the red-apple opening on p.315 and the audience’s responses on p.318. Verse numbers restart at Hormizd. The heading says twelve years. Page 316 note 16 actually prints the full forbearance verse as apparatus. |
| Mohl | Volume VI prints the opening on p.273 and closes the address on p.275. The heading gives fourteen years. Mohl’s running text places the forbearance verse at VI274:23. |
| Ganjoor | Hormizd §1:1–14 is the seasonal prelude. §2:1–47 covers Makh, the address and the response. There is a checked local running gap for the independent forbearance verse between §2:8 and §2:9. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | Volume VII starts at p.465 and records the relieved poor at p.470 v.61. Page 467 note 9 actually prints the forbearance reading in the apparatus. The heading says twelve years. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6Summer prices the apple’s finery
Moscow VIII315:1 · running, VIII315:2, VIII315:3 · running, VIII315:4 · running, VIII315:5 · running, VIII315:8 · running, VIII315:10 · running · Mohl VI273:1 · running, VI273:2, VI273:3 · running, VI273:4 · running, VI273:5 · running, VI273:8 · running, VI273:10 · running · Ganjoor §1:1, §1:2, §1:3, §1:4, §1:5, §1:8, §1:10 · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII465:1 · running, VII465:2, VII465:3 · running, VII465:4 · running, VII465:5 · running, VII466:8 · running, VII466:10 · running
Moscow VIII p.315 · Mohl VI p.273 · Ganjoor §1:1 · Ganjoor §1:2 · Ganjoor §1:3 · Ganjoor §1:4 · Ganjoor §1:5 · Ganjoor §1:8 · Ganjoor §1:10 · Khaleghi VII p.465 · Khaleghi VII p.466
All four witnesses let summer reproach the red apple by imagining an exchange between spring blossoms and jeweled fruit. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh associate the blossom with a remembered beloved. Mohl gives the scent of affection, which helps explain why fragrance enters the English early. The sober mind overcome by the flowers also draws on the Persian memory of holding them in intoxication. The English’s Jupiter is the planet named in all four. Its wine gives the blood-colored droplets a cause that the Persian leaves open, and crystal recasts the pearl. The purple skin and the comparison to the Kayanian banner are recorded separately. The English concentrates on the speaker's disappointment that no finery can restore the flower.
7–10What will survive the poet
Moscow VIII316:11 · running, VIII316:12 · running, VIII316:13 · running, VIII316:14 · running · Mohl VI273:11 · running, VI273:12 · running, VI273:13 · running, VI273:14 · running · Ganjoor §1:11, §1:12, §1:13, §1:14 · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII466:11 · running, VII466:12 · running, VII466:13 · running, VII466:14 · running
Moscow VIII p.316 · Mohl VI p.273 · Ganjoor §1:11 · Ganjoor §1:12 · Ganjoor §1:13 · Ganjoor §1:14 · Khaleghi VII p.466
Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh have the speaker promise to praise the season when its color turns green. Mohl gives yellow, which supports the English’s waning autumn and gives the pledge a sharper emotional turn. All four make the adornment of Hormizd’s crown the pivot from the garden to the reign. The next line is a more consequential divergence. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh describe the poet’s market as brisk and say his traces will disappear after death. Mohl has an affirmative future about seeing those traces. The English follows that affirmation, while changing current demand into present neglect. Its speaker trusts a later audience to recognize work that his own audience undervalues.
11–16Makh’s account and the first praise
Moscow VIII316:15 · running, VIII316:16 · running, VIII316:17 · running, VIII316:18 · running, VIII316:18, VIII316:19 · running, VIII316:19, VIII316:20 · running · Mohl VI273:15 · running, VI273:16 · running, VI274:17 · running, VI274:18 · running, VI274:18, VI274:19 · running, VI274:19, VI274:20 · running · Ganjoor §2:1, §2:2, §2:3, §2:4, §2:5, §2:6 · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII466:15 · running, VII466:16 · running, VII466:17 · running, VII466:18 · running, VII466:18, VII467:19 · running, VII467:19, VII467:20 · running
Moscow VIII p.316 · Mohl VI p.273 · Mohl VI p.274 · Ganjoor §2:1 · Ganjoor §2:2 · Ganjoor §2:3 · Ganjoor §2:4 · Ganjoor §2:5 · Ganjoor §2:6 · Khaleghi VII p.466 · Khaleghi VII p.467
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh put the account in the mouth of Makh, an experienced border lord of Herat, after the poet asks what he remembers of Hormizd. They carry the elder's answer directly into the king’s enthronement and praise of the Creator. The English’s cheerful face makes Makh approachable. The Persian describes his distinction with eloquence, splendor and the idiom of mane and horn, which gives the character more public authority. English then extends divine power into the claim that it has no peer. The surrounding Persian identifies the Creator as powerful and knowing, which supports the grandeur of the apostrophe. The silence of the chiefs belongs to the English staging of the ensuing address.
17–22Forbearance as a principle of rule
Moscow VIII316:20 · running, VIII316:21 · running, VIII316:22 · running, VIII316 note 16, placement after v.22 · actual printed apparatus, VIII316:23 · running, VIII316:24 · running · Mohl VI274:20 · running, VI274:21 · running, VI274:22 · running, VI274:23 · running, VI274:24 · running, VI274:25 · running · Ganjoor §2:6, §2:7, §2:8, §2:9, §2:10 · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII467:20 · running, VII467:21 · running, VII467:22 · running, VII467 note 9 to v.22 · actual printed apparatus, VII467:23 · running, VII467:24 · running
Moscow VIII p.316 · Mohl VI p.274 · Ganjoor §2:6 · Ganjoor §2:7 · Ganjoor §2:8 · Ganjoor §2:9 · Ganjoor §2:10 · Khaleghi VII p.467
The promise to keep the world under the king’s wing is visible in all four witnesses. The English carries his father’s example into the promise of peace, then makes fear and relief the opposed consequences of wrongdoing and oppression. Mohl supplies the full additional couplet behind English 20, in which the king bears with a wrongdoer and helps him when he suffers. Moscow prints parallel wording below the running text, and Khaleghi-Motlagh prints both phrases in the apparatus with the supplied placement. Ganjoor moves directly from fear and relief to the pillars of greatness. The English thereby makes the claim to forbearance an enacted principle before the next couplet states the attributes of kingship.
23–28The king’s claim to justice
Moscow VIII316:25 · running, VIII316:26 · running, VIII316:27 · running, VIII317:28 · running, VIII317:29, VIII317:30 · running, VIII317:31 · running · Mohl VI274:26 · running, VI274:27 · running, VI274:28 · running, VI274:29 · running, VI274:30, VI274:31 · running, VI274:32 · running · Ganjoor §2:11, §2:12, §2:13, §2:14, §2:15, §2:16, §2:17 · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII467:25 · running, VII467:26 · running, VII467:27 · running, VII467:28 · running, VII467:29, VII467:30 · running, VII467:31 · running
Moscow VIII p.316 · Moscow VIII p.317 · Mohl VI p.274 · Ganjoor §2:11 · Ganjoor §2:12 · Ganjoor §2:13 · Ganjoor §2:14 · Ganjoor §2:15 · Ganjoor §2:16 · Ganjoor §2:17 · Khaleghi VII p.467
All four measure Hormizd against crowned ancestors who won praise by justice and whose dealings vary with the status and conduct of those around them. The English describes the relationship to the lowly as service, a more active pledge than the Persian’s arrangement of deference and favor. In the assertion of royal power, Moscow and Ganjoor name strength, justice and covenant. Khaleghi-Motlagh names judgment and covenant, while Mohl has judgment and proof or sanction. The English binds power, counsel, rule and judgment into one inventory of what the shah can command. It then gives bounty a public purpose. The Persian says it brings ease to the age and English makes the needy the first beneficiaries.
29–33Who can trust a royal promise
Moscow VIII317:31, VIII317:32 · running, VIII317:33, VIII317:34 · running, VIII317:35, VIII317:36 · running, VIII317:36, VIII317:37 · running, VIII317:38, VIII317:39 · running · Mohl VI274:32, VI274:33 · running, VI274:34, VI274:35 · running, VI274:36, VI274:37 · running, VI274:37, VI274:38 · running, VI274:39, VI274:40 · running · Ganjoor §2:17, §2:18, §2:19, §2:20, §2:21, §2:22, §2:23, §2:24, §2:25 · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII467:31, VII467:32 · running, VII467:33, VII468:34 · running, VII468:35, VII468:36 · running, VII468:36, VII468:37 · running, VII468:38, VII468:39 · running
Moscow VIII p.317 · Mohl VI p.274 · Ganjoor §2:17 · Ganjoor §2:18 · Ganjoor §2:19 · Ganjoor §2:20 · Ganjoor §2:21 · Ganjoor §2:22 · Ganjoor §2:23 · Ganjoor §2:24 · Ganjoor §2:25 · Khaleghi VII p.467 · Khaleghi VII p.468
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh contrast compassion for the needy with protection for the affluent. The English makes attention to the rich sound watchful and ties their right to prosper to how they earned their wealth. That gives a moral interpretation to the Persian line about confidence in one’s conduct and one’s standing with the ruler. When Hormizd welcomes requests and tells the fortunate to rejoice, the English gives the audience an immediate stake in the king’s promise. It also changes the general warning against two practices into the language of fearing God. The Persian names rancor and greed immediately before that warning and asks the mighty and lowly alike to please the Creator in a separate couplet.
34–39Good deeds and straight seed
Moscow VIII317:40 · running, VIII317:41 · running, VIII317:42 · running, VIII317:43 · running, VIII317:44 · running, VIII318:45 · running · Mohl VI274:41 · running, VI275:42 · running, VI275:43 · running, VI275:44 · running, VI275:45 · running, VI275:46 · running · Ganjoor §2:26, §2:27, §2:28, §2:29, §2:30, §2:31 · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII468:40 · running, VII468:41 · running, VII468:42 · running, VII468:43 · running, VII468:44 · running, VII468:45 · running
Moscow VIII p.317 · Moscow VIII p.318 · Mohl VI p.274 · Mohl VI p.275 · Ganjoor §2:26 · Ganjoor §2:27 · Ganjoor §2:28 · Ganjoor §2:29 · Ganjoor §2:30 · Ganjoor §2:31 · Khaleghi VII p.468
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh join gratitude, giving without return and care about the company one keeps. The English uses the language of recompense twice, making the rule against treating good deeds as bargains unusually clear. The crooked talker then leads into a warning against misjudging a just king. The Persian entertains the accusation that the king only recites the sayings of earlier rulers. The English turns that possible accusation into a defense of knowledge gained from their example. It preserves the contrast between royal mercy and crooked seed at the end of the passage. The added crop of grief gives readers the result of sowing falsely rather than leaving it in the proverb’s negative command.
40–45Counsel, rebuke and the crown of seventy
Moscow VIII318:46 · running, VIII318:47 · running, VIII318:48 · running, VIII318:49 · running, VIII318:50 · running, VIII318:51 · running · Mohl VI275:47 · running, VI275:48 · running, VI275:49 · running, VI275:50 · running, VI275:51 · running, VI275:52 · running · Ganjoor §2:32, §2:33, §2:34, §2:35, §2:36, §2:37 · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII468:46 · running, VII468:47 · running, VII469:48 · running, VII469:49 · running, VII469:50 · running, VII469:51 · running
Moscow VIII p.318 · Mohl VI p.275 · Ganjoor §2:32 · Ganjoor §2:33 · Ganjoor §2:34 · Ganjoor §2:35 · Ganjoor §2:36 · Ganjoor §2:37 · Khaleghi VII p.468 · Khaleghi VII p.469
Moscow and Ganjoor speak of spurning counsel, while Mohl and Khaleghi-Motlagh speak of spurning a threat. The English keeps counsel, so the line can follow the preceding plea to respond well to mercy. Each witness next associates turning against the king with loss and takes severity in admonition as a form of gentleness. English makes the king’s concern more personal by adding the hypothetical foe. The four Persian witnesses then make a person who has obtained his desires give what he accumulated to an enemy when he wears the crown of seventy. The English keeps the age and the unsettling crown image, while giving more weight to the loneliness of losing what one has amassed.
46–50Bounty to the poor and force against a rival
Moscow VIII318:52 · running, VIII318:53, VIII318:54 · running, VIII318:54 · running, VIII318:55 · running, VIII318:56 · running · Mohl VI275:53 · running, VI275:54, VI275:55 · running, VI275:55 · running, VI275:56 · running, VI275:57 · running · Ganjoor §2:38, §2:39, §2:40, §2:41, §2:42 · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII469:52 · running, VII469:53, VII469:54 · running, VII469:54 · running, VII469:55 · running, VII469:56 · running
Moscow VIII p.318 · Mohl VI p.275 · Ganjoor §2:38 · Ganjoor §2:39 · Ganjoor §2:40 · Ganjoor §2:41 · Ganjoor §2:42 · Khaleghi VII p.469
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh make concern for the poor continuous and ask the Creator for time to gladden them with treasure. The Persian joins that use of the treasury to a refusal to vex the righteous. English distributes the two ideas over successive promises, though it makes the positive source of help less materially specific. The next two couplets turn to someone who acts like a king through hoarding or seeking wealth. All four use the expression of twisting or turning the man’s head in connection with his ambition. The English chooses an explicit beheading. That reading heightens the threat and anticipates the violence of the reign, while the Persian gives a less explicit description of the penalty.
51–55One address and two audiences
Moscow VIII318:57 · running, VIII318:58 · running, VIII318:59 · running, VIII318:60 · running, VIII318:61 · running · Mohl VI275:58 · running, VI275:59 · running, VI275:60 · running, VI275:61 · running, VI275:62 · running · Ganjoor §2:43, §2:44, §2:45, §2:46, §2:47 · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII469:57 · running, VII469:58 · running, VII469:59 · running, VII470:60 · running, VII470:61 · running
Moscow VIII p.318 · Mohl VI p.275 · Ganjoor §2:43 · Ganjoor §2:44 · Ganjoor §2:45 · Ganjoor §2:46 · Ganjoor §2:47 · Khaleghi VII p.469 · Khaleghi VII p.470
All four witnesses close the speech by distinguishing public and private words and extending a blessing to the audience. The English makes the distinction a claim to consistency in intent. Its wish that the turning sky fulfill each goal draws on the Persian image of the revolving sky, where the blessing can be read as granting the earth beneath it to the listeners. All four then separate the reaction of treasury holders and oppressors from that of the wise and poor. The English keeps the social division and explains the relief as confidence in justice. The Persian lets the joy stand as a reaction to what was heard, immediately before the narrative tests the promises made by the young sovereign.
Source record and limits
F&R English
The published opening combines the garden prelude and Makh’s account with the entire accession speech and its reception.
Moscow
Volume VIII prints the red-apple opening on p.315 and the audience’s responses on p.318. Verse numbers restart at Hormizd. The heading says twelve years. Page 316 note 16 actually prints the full forbearance verse as apparatus.
Mohl
Volume VI prints the opening on p.273 and closes the address on p.275. The heading gives fourteen years. Mohl’s running text places the forbearance verse at VI274:23.
Ganjoor
Hormizd §1:1–14 is the seasonal prelude. §2:1–47 covers Makh, the address and the response. There is a checked local running gap for the independent forbearance verse between §2:8 and §2:9.
Khaleghi-Motlagh
Volume VII starts at p.465 and records the relieved poor at p.470 v.61. Page 467 note 9 actually prints the forbearance reading in the apparatus. The heading says twelve years.
Consequential readings
Mohl’s yellow and affirmative seeing after death inform the English autumn and the poet’s afterlife. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh give green and a negative future. The English’s present neglect changes the Persian market image. At English 50, the four running witnesses give an idiom of turning or twisting the head. Literal beheading remains provisional.
Persian units without a separate English couplet
The register accounts separately for the flower’s price as the source of the apple’s color, the blush and musk of the garment, and the purple skin and Kayanian banner comparison. The English preserves part of the last image through the emerald leaves.
Limits of the evidence
Running text, actual printed apparatus and a checked local gap are labeled separately. The edition headings disagree about the duration of the reign. The Persian column uses Ganjoor for the running parallels and the explicitly labeled Mohl verse for English 20.
Moscow VIII p.315 · Moscow VIII p.316 · Moscow VIII p.317 · Moscow VIII p.318
Mohl VI p.273 · Mohl VI p.274 · Mohl VI p.275
Khaleghi VII p.465 · Khaleghi VII p.466 · Khaleghi VII p.467 · Khaleghi VII p.468 · Khaleghi VII p.469 · Khaleghi VII p.470
Selected printed readings
- Mohl VI273:13 · Running text · چو رنگت شود زرد
Yellow supports the English fading color. - Moscow VIII316:13 · Running text · چو رنگت شود سبز
Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh give green. - Mohl VI273:14 · Running text · ببینی پس از مرگ آثار من
The reader will see the traces after the poet’s death. - Khaleghi VII466:14 · Running text · نبینی پس از مرگ آثار من
The negative is shared by Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh. - Mohl VI274:23 · Running text · کسی بد کند بردباری کنیم / چو رنج آیدش پیش یاری کنیم
Forbearance and aid appear as a full running verse. - Moscow VIII316 note 16 · Actual printed apparatus · کسی بد کند بردباری کنیم / چو رنج آیدش پیش یاری کنیم
The text of the couplet is present below the running verses. - Khaleghi VII467 note 9 · Actual printed apparatus · کسی بد کند بردباری کنیم / چو رنج آیدش پیش یاری کنیم
The two phrases are printed in the critical apparatus. - Moscow VIII318:56 · Running text · سرش را بپیچم ز کنداوری
The idiom is less anatomically explicit than the English.
E5.1 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | VIII315:1 · running | VI273:1 · running |
| 2 | VIII315:2, VIII315:3 · running | VI273:2, VI273:3 · running |
| 3 | VIII315:4 · running | VI273:4 · running |
| 4 | VIII315:5 · running | VI273:5 · running |
| 5 | VIII315:8 · running | VI273:8 · running |
| 6 | VIII315:10 · running | VI273:10 · running |
| 7 | VIII316:11 · running | VI273:11 · running |
| 8 | VIII316:12 · running | VI273:12 · running |
| 9 | VIII316:13 · running | VI273:13 · running |
| 10 | VIII316:14 · running | VI273:14 · running |
| 11 | VIII316:15 · running | VI273:15 · running |
| 12 | VIII316:16 · running | VI273:16 · running |
| 13 | VIII316:17 · running | VI274:17 · running |
| 14 | VIII316:18 · running | VI274:18 · running |
| 15 | VIII316:18, VIII316:19 · running | VI274:18, VI274:19 · running |
| 16 | VIII316:19, VIII316:20 · running | VI274:19, VI274:20 · running |
| 17 | VIII316:20 · running | VI274:20 · running |
| 18 | VIII316:21 · running | VI274:21 · running |
| 19 | VIII316:22 · running | VI274:22 · running |
| 20 | VIII316 note 16, placement after v.22 · actual printed apparatus | VI274:23 · running |
| 21 | VIII316:23 · running | VI274:24 · running |
| 22 | VIII316:24 · running | VI274:25 · running |
| 23 | VIII316:25 · running | VI274:26 · running |
| 24 | VIII316:26 · running | VI274:27 · running |
| 25 | VIII316:27 · running | VI274:28 · running |
| 26 | VIII317:28 · running | VI274:29 · running |
| 27 | VIII317:29, VIII317:30 · running | VI274:30, VI274:31 · running |
| 28 | VIII317:31 · running | VI274:32 · running |
| 29 | VIII317:31, VIII317:32 · running | VI274:32, VI274:33 · running |
| 30 | VIII317:33, VIII317:34 · running | VI274:34, VI274:35 · running |
| 31 | VIII317:35, VIII317:36 · running | VI274:36, VI274:37 · running |
| 32 | VIII317:36, VIII317:37 · running | VI274:37, VI274:38 · running |
| 33 | VIII317:38, VIII317:39 · running | VI274:39, VI274:40 · running |
| 34 | VIII317:40 · running | VI274:41 · running |
| 35 | VIII317:41 · running | VI275:42 · running |
| 36 | VIII317:42 · running | VI275:43 · running |
| 37 | VIII317:43 · running | VI275:44 · running |
| 38 | VIII317:44 · running | VI275:45 · running |
| 39 | VIII318:45 · running | VI275:46 · running |
| 40 | VIII318:46 · running | VI275:47 · running |
| 41 | VIII318:47 · running | VI275:48 · running |
| 42 | VIII318:48 · running | VI275:49 · running |
| 43 | VIII318:49 · running | VI275:50 · running |
| 44 | VIII318:50 · running | VI275:51 · running |
| 45 | VIII318:51 · running | VI275:52 · running |
| 46 | VIII318:52 · running | VI275:53 · running |
| 47 | VIII318:53, VIII318:54 · running | VI275:54, VI275:55 · running |
| 48 | VIII318:54 · running | VI275:55 · running |
| 49 | VIII318:55 · running | VI275:56 · running |
| 50 | VIII318:56 · running | VI275:57 · running |
| 51 | VIII318:57 · running | VI275:58 · running |
| 52 | VIII318:58 · running | VI275:59 · running |
| 53 | VIII318:59 · running | VI275:60 · running |
| 54 | VIII318:60 · running | VI275:61 · running |
| 55 | VIII318:61 · running | VI275:62 · running |
New Naqqali