Bahram Sends Swords to Hormizd
The 52 numbered couplets cover the court report, interpretation, exchange of blades and interval without royal letters being read.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | The 52 numbered couplets cover the court report, interpretation, exchange of blades and interval without royal letters being read. |
| Moscow | Volume VIII pp.404–407, vv.1479–1525. The running text goes from the Shah’s regret to the blades. The fuller account of Bahram’s Fortune, opening the basket and the threat to the troops is physically printed in the apparatus. |
| Mohl | Volume VI pp.335–338, vv.1499–1554. A fuller rebuke about the costume and the four verses on Bahram’s Fortune are in the running text. The broken blades are made an explicit threat to the army. |
| Ganjoor | Hormizd §9:64–110. The report and the exchange of blades run more briefly. The end gives an interval without an exact number of days. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | Volume VII pp.590–594, vv.1485–1537. The Fortune passage has four running verses before the regret. The basket and the threat to the men also have fuller wording. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6The witness relays a story of roads and rooms
Moscow VIII404:1479 running text, VIII404:1480,1481 running text, VIII404:1482 running text, VIII404:1483 running text, VIII404:1483,1484 running text, VIII404:1485 running text · VIII405:1486 running text · Mohl VI335:1499 running text, VI335:1500,1501 running text, VI335:1502 running text, VI335:1503 running text, VI335:1503 running text · VI336:1504 running text, VI336:1505,1506 running text · Ganjoor sh9:64 running poem body, sh9:65, sh9:66 running poem body, sh9:67 running poem body, sh9:68 running poem body, sh9:68, sh9:69 running poem body, sh9:70, sh9:71 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII590:1485 running text, VII590:1486,1487 running text, VII590:1488 running text, VII590:1489 running text, VII590:1489,1490 running text, VII590:1491,1492 running text
Moscow VIII p.404 · Moscow VIII p.405 · Mohl VI p.335 · Mohl VI p.336 · Ganjoor §9:64 · Ganjoor §9:65 · Ganjoor §9:66 · Ganjoor §9:67 · Ganjoor §9:68 · Ganjoor §9:69 · Ganjoor §9:70 · Ganjoor §9:71 · Khaleghi VII p.590
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh give Kharrad’s arrival at court in secrecy and his disclosure of what was hidden. English lays the subject of the report out as a series of visible things, from wood and meadow to throne and crowned woman. Some information was seen and some obtained by inquiry, an explicit distinction in the Persian retained by the final couplet on the report. The change in the Shah when he remembers the Mobad shifts the scene from collecting testimony to interpreting it. English “inward dread” is well placed beside the cold wind that rises from his heart in the Persian. A previously heard warning can now make the event intelligible, while the report itself remains a mixture of kinds of evidence.
7–12The second account before a different audience
Moscow VIII405:1487 running text, VIII405:1488 running text, VIII405:1489 running text, VIII405:1490 running text, VIII405:1491 running text, VIII405:1492 running text · Mohl VI336:1507 running text, VI336:1508 running text, VI336:1509 running text, VI336:1510 running text, VI336:1511 running text, VI336:1512 running text · Ganjoor sh9:72 running poem body, sh9:73 running poem body, sh9:74 running poem body, sh9:75 running poem body, sh9:76 running poem body, sh9:77 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII590:1493 running text, VII590:1494 running text, VII590:1495 running text, VII591:1496 running text, VII591:1497 running text, VII591:1498 running text
Moscow VIII p.405 · Mohl VI p.336 · Ganjoor §9:72 · Ganjoor §9:73 · Ganjoor §9:74 · Ganjoor §9:75 · Ganjoor §9:76 · Ganjoor §9:77 · Khaleghi VII p.590 · Khaleghi VII p.591
The four witnesses bring in an omen-reader’s earlier prediction and have Hormizd summon the chief Mobad with Kharrad beside him. The English keeps the distinction between prediction and interpretation by giving both the teller and the priest space in the audience. Kharrad is asked to speak again and relates the particulars. When the Shah asks what it means, his speech rehearses the gur, the wilderness and the unlikely palace. English’s retelling closely follows that movement from a leading animal to a richly inhabited space without ordinary surroundings. The repetition need not be heard as redundant. It changes a report to a sovereign, which establishes what he has learned, into a report in front of someone charged with interpreting what the sovereign cannot judge alone.
13–18The dreamlike scene, recast by the Mobad
Moscow VIII405:1493 running text, VIII405:1494 running text, VIII405:1495 running text, VIII405:1496 running text, VIII405:1497 running text, VIII405:1498 running text · Mohl VI336:1513 running text, VI336:1514 running text, VI336:1515 running text, VI336:1516 running text, VI336:1517 running text, VI336:1518 running text · Ganjoor sh9:78 running poem body, sh9:79 running poem body, sh9:80 running poem body, sh9:81 running poem body, sh9:82 running poem body, sh9:83 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII591:1499 running text, VII591:1500 running text, VII591:1501 running text, VII591:1502 running text, VII591:1503 running text, VII591:1504 running text
Moscow VIII p.405 · Mohl VI p.336 · Ganjoor §9:78 · Ganjoor §9:79 · Ganjoor §9:80 · Ganjoor §9:81 · Ganjoor §9:82 · Ganjoor §9:83 · Khaleghi VII p.591
The resemblance to an old tale or dream is explicit across Moscow and Mohl and the Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh readings. English brings royal appearance ahead of the qualification about how real the scene seems. The Mobad calls the gur a hidden div and gives the palace and woman the character of sorcery. Mohl likens the place to a graveyard where Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh call it a place of sorcery. English chooses the constructed magical palace, and gives disaffection the more political label of mutiny. What the woman showed Bahram includes crown and throne. That supplies a Persian parallel for the theme of the oracle in E5.21, even where its precise words remain provisional. The shift from display to interpretation is thus distinct from deciding what the lady actually said.
19–24The insult becomes part of the explanation
Moscow VIII405:1499 running text, VIII405:1499,1500 running text, VIII405:1500 running text, VIII406:1501 running text · Mohl VI336:1519 running text, VI336:1519,1520,1523 running text, VI336:1521,1523 running text, VI336:1522,1523 running text, VI336:1523 running text, VI336:1524 running text · Ganjoor sh9:84 running poem body, sh9:84, sh9:85 running poem body, sh9:85 running poem body, sh9:86 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII591:1505 running text, VII591:1505 running text · VII592:1506 running text · VII591 note 27 actual printed verse on the spindle-case, VII592:1506 running text, VII592:1511 running text
Moscow VIII p.405 · Moscow VIII p.406 · Mohl VI p.336 · Ganjoor §9:84 · Ganjoor §9:85 · Ganjoor §9:86 · Khaleghi VII p.591 · Khaleghi VII p.592
Mohl prints three separate verses that connect the spindle-case to sorcery, declare the insulting robe ill-advised and say that the Iranians have lost hope in the Shah. Khaleghi-Motlagh prints the corresponding spindle-case verse in its apparatus. Moscow and Ganjoor move more directly from Bahram’s altered state to the advice to recall the troops. English draws out the fuller argument and puts the feminine clothing inside the Mobad’s explanation rather than leaving it as an object of remote regret. In the shorter running sequence the king does regret sending the clothes. The fuller passage makes his act a contributing cause of the political danger that the spectacle revealed. The proposed recall gives his regret an immediate decision to face.
25–30The army’s name for the apparition
Moscow VIII406 near v.1501 · checked local gap for this unit · VIII406 actual printed addition after v.1501, VIII406:1502,1503 running text, VIII406:1503 running text · Mohl VI336:1525 running text, VI336:1526,1527 running text, VI336:1527 running text, VI336:1528 running text, VI337:1529,1530 running text, VI337:1530 running text · Ganjoor Checked local gap near §9:86, sh9:87, sh9:88 running poem body, sh9:88 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII592:1507 running text, VII592:1508,1509 running text, VII592:1509 running text, VII592:1510 running text, VII592:1512,1513 running text, VII592:1513 running text
Moscow VIII p.406 · Mohl VI p.336 · Mohl VI p.337 · Ganjoor §9:86 · Ganjoor §9:87 · Ganjoor §9:88 · Khaleghi VII p.592
Mohl and Khaleghi-Motlagh print Kharrad’s report that the soldiers thought the woman was Bahram’s Fortune. Moscow has the four-verse sequence in its apparatus, and Ganjoor proceeds directly from the regret to the new message. English follows the fuller report and gives the common name “Bahram’s Luck.” This makes the soldiers’ interpretation legible alongside the Mobad’s account of sorcery. The next delivery is recognizable as a basket of sharp blades in the four Persian accounts. The English gives twelve and describes the steel at length. The count remains provisional at this locus, while the sharpening has a local parallel. The juxtaposition of fear of Fortune and the arrival of weapons makes the omen immediately relevant to a decision at court.
31–36The basket returns, its contents changed
Moscow VIII406:1504 running text, VIII406:1505 running text, VIII406:1506 running text, VIII406:1507 running text · VIII406 note 11 actual printed additional reading, VIII406:1507,1508 running text, VIII406:1509 running text · VIII406 note 15 actual printed additional reading · Mohl VI337:1531 running text, VI337:1532 running text, VI337:1533 running text, VI337:1534,1535 running text, VI337:1535,1536 running text, VI337:1537,1538 running text · Ganjoor sh9:89 running poem body, sh9:90 running poem body, sh9:91 running poem body, sh9:92 running poem body, sh9:92, sh9:93 running poem body, sh9:94 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII592:1514 running text, VII592:1515 running text, VII592:1516 running text, VII593:1518 running text · VII592:1517 running text, VII593:1518,1519 running text, VII593:1520,1521 running text
Moscow VIII p.406 · Mohl VI p.337 · Ganjoor §9:89 · Ganjoor §9:90 · Ganjoor §9:91 · Ganjoor §9:92 · Ganjoor §9:93 · Ganjoor §9:94 · Khaleghi VII p.592 · Khaleghi VII p.593
Moscow and Mohl have the presentation, the command to break the blades and the return with hostile words. Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh give the same exchange. English has the smiths and sledgehammers carry out the command in sight, giving the ruler’s response an audible physical form. The additional verse about Bahram opening the basket occurs in Mohl and Khaleghi-Motlagh and in Moscow’s apparatus. It grounds the close view of the fragments. The following accusation that the army is held worthless has a similarly fuller trail. This allows the English to move from broken objects to an explicitly collective threat. The Shah acted on swords sent by one man, but Bahram turns the returned basket into a message about everyone he summons.
37–42From broken blades to a conditional curse
Moscow VIII406:1509 running text · VIII406 note 15 actual printed additional reading, VIII406:1510 running text, VIII406:1511 running text, VIII407:1512 running text, VIII407:1513 running text, VIII407:1514 running text · Mohl VI337:1537,1538 running text, VI337:1539 running text, VI337:1540 running text, VI337:1541 running text, VI337 near v.1541 · checked local gap for this unit, VI337:1542 running text · Ganjoor sh9:94 running poem body, sh9:95 running poem body, sh9:96 running poem body, sh9:97 running poem body, sh9:98 running poem body, sh9:99 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII593:1520,1521 running text, VII593:1522 running text, VII593:1523 running text, VII593:1524 running text, VII593:1525 running text, VII593:1526 running text
Moscow VIII p.406 · Moscow VIII p.407 · Mohl VI p.337 · Ganjoor §9:94 · Ganjoor §9:95 · Ganjoor §9:96 · Ganjoor §9:97 · Ganjoor §9:98 · Ganjoor §9:99 · Khaleghi VII p.593
The fear of lost heads is explicit in Mohl and Khaleghi-Motlagh and printed among the variants of Moscow. Ganjoor turns directly to the troops’ reaction. The English centers the threat on the soldiers before they link the broken blades with the former robe and spindle. Moscow and Ganjoor, with Khaleghi-Motlagh, include a separate curse against a Shah who acts this way. Mohl goes to the conditional curse upon Bahram should he ride again to court. English keeps both and allows the soldiers first to reject the king and then to make future submission costly for their own commander. The name of Goshnasp gives the second utterance the force of a curse reaching the man through his lineage.
43–48Vigilance, compact and the fate of the army
Moscow VIII407:1515 running text, VIII407:1516 running text, VIII407:1517,1518 running text, VIII407:1519 running text, VIII407:1520 running text, VIII407:1521 running text · Mohl VI337:1543 running text, VI337:1544 running text, VI337:1545,1546 running text, VI337:1547 running text, VI337:1548 running text, VI337:1549 running text · Ganjoor sh9:100 running poem body, sh9:101 running poem body, sh9:102, sh9:103 running poem body, sh9:104 running poem body, sh9:105 running poem body, sh9:106 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII593:1527 running text, VII593:1528 running text, VII593:1529,1530 running text, VII593:1531 running text, VII594:1532 running text, VII594:1533 running text
Moscow VIII p.407 · Mohl VI p.337 · Ganjoor §9:100 · Ganjoor §9:101 · Ganjoor §9:102 · Ganjoor §9:103 · Ganjoor §9:104 · Ganjoor §9:105 · Ganjoor §9:106 · Khaleghi VII p.593 · Khaleghi VII p.594
The curse invokes brain and skin in the four witnesses. English changes the second term to bone and continues the destruction into the seed of the lineage. Bahram’s renewed address then names Kharrad as the person who has disclosed what was hidden. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh follow the disclosure with a call for vigilance and a compact, while wording and pronouns vary. English clearly moves from his private danger to the company’s obligation and keeps the threat of destruction visible behind the appeal. Its slack belt recalls the earlier belts of the resolute riders. Reusing that physical sign of readiness turns a dispute about insult into a statement of whether the army can still act together.
49–52No letter reaches a reader
Moscow VIII407:1522 running text, VIII407:1523,1524 running text, VIII407:1524 running text, VIII407:1525 running text · Mohl VI337:1550,1551 running text, VI337:1552,1553 running text, VI337:1553 running text, VI338:1554 running text · Ganjoor sh9:107 running poem body, sh9:108, sh9:109 running poem body, sh9:109 running poem body, sh9:110 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII594:1534 running text, VII594:1535,1536 running text, VII594:1536 running text, VII594:1537 running text
Moscow VIII p.407 · Mohl VI p.337 · Mohl VI p.338 · Ganjoor §9:107 · Ganjoor §9:108 · Ganjoor §9:109 · Ganjoor §9:110 · Khaleghi VII p.594
Mohl adds a direct statement that Bahram tested the men because he feared the army in his heart. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh turn from the changed plan to the riders sent out. English retains the test but moves the fear to the troops, a consequential redistribution of motive. The purpose of dispersing riders is clarified through the prospect of royal letters and of what Iranians would do on receiving them. English makes interception explicit and closes on a week. The Persian gives an interval without that exact duration and says no one read a letter of the Shah. That ending moves the struggle from public tokens to control of written news. The following summons of the chiefs begins E5.24.
Source record and limits
F&R English
The 52 numbered couplets cover the court report, interpretation, exchange of blades and interval without royal letters being read.
Moscow
Volume VIII pp.404–407, vv.1479–1525. The running text goes from the Shah’s regret to the blades. The fuller account of Bahram’s Fortune, opening the basket and the threat to the troops is physically printed in the apparatus.
Mohl
Volume VI pp.335–338, vv.1499–1554. A fuller rebuke about the costume and the four verses on Bahram’s Fortune are in the running text. The broken blades are made an explicit threat to the army.
Ganjoor
Hormizd §9:64–110. The report and the exchange of blades run more briefly. The end gives an interval without an exact number of days.
Khaleghi-Motlagh
Volume VII pp.590–594, vv.1485–1537. The Fortune passage has four running verses before the regret. The basket and the threat to the men also have fuller wording.
Consequential readings
The fortune interpretation and the fuller reading of the threat have support in printed Persian beyond the Ganjoor sequence. Mohl also explicitly describes testing the troops because Bahram fears them.
Limits of the evidence
The blade count, use of smiths and sledgehammers and exact concluding week are provisional local details. The basket, breaking of the blades and interruption of royal correspondence are attested.
Moscow VIII p.404 · Moscow VIII p.405 · Moscow VIII p.406 · Moscow VIII p.407
Mohl VI p.335 · Mohl VI p.336 · Mohl VI p.337 · Mohl VI p.338
Khaleghi VII p.590 · Khaleghi VII p.591 · Khaleghi VII p.592 · Khaleghi VII p.593 · Khaleghi VII p.594
Selected printed readings
- Khaleghi VII591 note 27 · Actual printed apparatus · به دل داغش از دوکدان تو بود
The variant links the injury in his heart to the spindle-case. - Moscow VIII406 addition after v.1501 · Actual printed apparatus · کان بخت بهرام بود
The printed report calls her Bahram’s Fortune. - Mohl VI336:1527 · Running text · بگفتند کین بخت بهرام بود
The army gives her this name in the running poem. - Khaleghi VII592:1509 · Running text · بگفتند کآن بخت بهرام بود
The name occurs before the king’s regret. - Moscow VIII406 note 15 · Actual printed apparatus · سر یک تن از من نیابد رها
The fuller reading warns that no one’s head will be spared. - Khaleghi VII593:1521 · Running text · سر یک تن از من نیابد رها
The threat occurs in the numbered sequence. - Moscow VIII407:1525 · Running text · برین نیز بگذشت یک روزگار
This describes an interval without specifying a week.
E5.23 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | VIII404:1479 running text | VI335:1499 running text |
| 2 | VIII404:1480,1481 running text | VI335:1500,1501 running text |
| 3 | VIII404:1482 running text | VI335:1502 running text |
| 4 | VIII404:1483 running text | VI335:1503 running text |
| 5 | VIII404:1483,1484 running text | VI335:1503 running text · VI336:1504 running text · VI p.336 |
| 6 | VIII404:1485 running text · VIII405:1486 running text · VIII p.405 | VI336:1505,1506 running text |
| 7 | VIII405:1487 running text | VI336:1507 running text |
| 8 | VIII405:1488 running text | VI336:1508 running text |
| 9 | VIII405:1489 running text | VI336:1509 running text |
| 10 | VIII405:1490 running text | VI336:1510 running text |
| 11 | VIII405:1491 running text | VI336:1511 running text |
| 12 | VIII405:1492 running text | VI336:1512 running text |
| 13 | VIII405:1493 running text | VI336:1513 running text |
| 14 | VIII405:1494 running text | VI336:1514 running text |
| 15 | VIII405:1495 running text | VI336:1515 running text |
| 16 | VIII405:1496 running text | VI336:1516 running text |
| 17 | VIII405:1497 running text | VI336:1517 running text |
| 18 | VIII405:1498 running text | VI336:1518 running text |
| 19 | VIII405:1499 running text | VI336:1519 running text |
| 20 | VIII405:1499,1500 running text | VI336:1519,1520,1523 running text |
| 21 | VIII405:1500 running text | VI336:1521,1523 running text |
| 22 | VIII405:1500 running text | VI336:1522,1523 running text |
| 23 | VIII405:1500 running text | VI336:1523 running text |
| 24 | VIII406:1501 running text | VI336:1524 running text |
| 25 | VIII406 near v.1501 · checked local gap for this unit · VIII406 actual printed addition after v.1501 | VI336:1525 running text |
| 26 | VIII406 near v.1501 · checked local gap for this unit · VIII406 actual printed addition after v.1501 | VI336:1526,1527 running text |
| 27 | VIII406 near v.1501 · checked local gap for this unit · VIII406 actual printed addition after v.1501 | VI336:1527 running text |
| 28 | VIII406 near v.1501 · checked local gap for this unit · VIII406 actual printed addition after v.1501 | VI336:1528 running text |
| 29 | VIII406:1502,1503 running text | VI337:1529,1530 running text |
| 30 | VIII406:1503 running text | VI337:1530 running text |
| 31 | VIII406:1504 running text | VI337:1531 running text |
| 32 | VIII406:1505 running text | VI337:1532 running text |
| 33 | VIII406:1506 running text | VI337:1533 running text |
| 34 | VIII406:1507 running text · VIII406 note 11 actual printed additional reading | VI337:1534,1535 running text |
| 35 | VIII406:1507,1508 running text | VI337:1535,1536 running text |
| 36 | VIII406:1509 running text · VIII406 note 15 actual printed additional reading | VI337:1537,1538 running text |
| 37 | VIII406:1509 running text · VIII406 note 15 actual printed additional reading | VI337:1537,1538 running text |
| 38 | VIII406:1510 running text | VI337:1539 running text |
| 39 | VIII406:1511 running text | VI337:1540 running text |
| 40 | VIII407:1512 running text | VI337:1541 running text |
| 41 | VIII407:1513 running text | VI337 near v.1541 · checked local gap for this unit |
| 42 | VIII407:1514 running text | VI337:1542 running text |
| 43 | VIII407:1515 running text | VI337:1543 running text |
| 44 | VIII407:1516 running text | VI337:1544 running text |
| 45 | VIII407:1517,1518 running text | VI337:1545,1546 running text |
| 46 | VIII407:1519 running text | VI337:1547 running text |
| 47 | VIII407:1520 running text | VI337:1548 running text |
| 48 | VIII407:1521 running text | VI337:1549 running text |
| 49 | VIII407:1522 running text | VI337:1550,1551 running text |
| 50 | VIII407:1523,1524 running text | VI337:1552,1553 running text |
| 51 | VIII407:1524 running text | VI337:1553 running text |
| 52 | VIII407:1525 running text | VI338:1554 running text |
New Naqqali