Bahram Chubin Takes Command
The 100 numbered couplets cover Bahram’s arrival, the debate and muster, the choice of officers and riders, the appeal to precedent, and the award of the standard.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | The 100 numbered couplets cover Bahram’s arrival, the debate and muster, the choice of officers and riders, the appeal to precedent, and the award of the standard. |
| Moscow | Volume VIII p.339 v.406 through p.345 v.517. Its opening has Bahram take warriors. The apparatus on p.339 prints a line recalling Iran and Mehran Setad. The girded commander appears in a separate running verse at p.341 v.446. |
| Mohl | Volume VI p.290 v.423 through p.295 v.534. Bahram calls no warriors at the departure from Barda. The girdle is in the running text, and the form of a reading about household cares differs from the other editions. |
| Ganjoor | Hormizd §3:187–192 and §4:1–105. The two sections meet between the initial reception and the formal audience. The edition gives the positive troop gathering and a shorter transition to the muster. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | Volume VII p.499 v.409 through p.507 v.521. The opening emphasizes haste to court. The edition brackets the line invoking Iran and Mehran Setad, counts the girdle verse in the running text and prints Banda Gashasp in the rear. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6The departure changes the meaning of the summons
Moscow VIII339:406 running text, VIII339:407 running text, VIII339:408 running text, VIII339:409,410 running text, VIII339:410,411 running text, VIII339:412 running text · Mohl VI290:423 running text, VI290:424 running text, VI290:425 running text, VI290:426,427 running text, VI290:427 running text · VI291:428 running text, VI291:429 running text · Ganjoor sh3:187 running poem body, sh3:188 running poem body, sh3:189 running poem body, sh3:190, sh3:191 running poem body, sh3:191, sh3:192 running poem body, sh4:1 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII499:409 running text, VII499:410 running text, VII499:411 running text, VII499:412,413 running text, VII499:413,414 running text, VII499:415 running text
Moscow VIII p.339 · Mohl VI p.290 · Mohl VI p.291 · Ganjoor §3:187 · Ganjoor §3:188 · Ganjoor §3:189 · Ganjoor §3:190 · Ganjoor §3:191 · Ganjoor §3:192 · Ganjoor §4:1 · Khaleghi VII p.499
Moscow and Ganjoor have Bahram leave Barda with warriors. Mohl prints that he calls none, directly supporting the English. Khaleghi-Motlagh describes his haste to court. The English therefore continues the earlier solitary summons with unusual clarity. Its logistical precision also changes the first public appearance of the commander: he owes his access to the king and the signs remembered by Mehran Setad, while the men he will lead have yet to be selected. In all four accounts the king’s look moves from scrutiny to pleasure when the signs match. The night’s musky veil and the fresh sun then separate Bahram’s reception from the formal conversation about war.
7–12The place of honor becomes a place of dissent
Moscow VIII339:413 running text, VIII339:414 running text, VIII339 note 15 after v.414 · actual printed apparatus, VIII339:415 running text, VIII339:416 running text, VIII339:417 running text · Mohl VI291:430 running text, VI291:431 running text, VI291 near v.431 · checked local gap for the additional detail, VI291:432 running text, VI291:433 running text, VI291:434 running text · Ganjoor sh4:2 running poem body, sh4:3 running poem body, Checked local gap for this additional verse, sh4:4 running poem body, sh4:5 running poem body, sh4:6 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII499:416 running text, VII500:417 running text, VII500:418 running text, VII500:419 running text, VII500:420 running text, VII500:421 running text
Moscow VIII p.339 · Mohl VI p.291 · Ganjoor §4:2 · Ganjoor §4:3 · Ganjoor §4:4 · Ganjoor §4:5 · Ganjoor §4:6 · Khaleghi VII p.499 · Khaleghi VII p.500
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh seat Bahram among the nobles and give Hormizd the choice of peace or war. A fuller line recalling Iran’s affairs and Mehran’s words is printed in Moscow’s apparatus and bracketed by Khaleghi-Motlagh. English makes that line the motive for the king’s direct question. Bahram’s objection hinges on timing: appealing for peace when the enemy has prepared for battle would announce defeat in advance. The English makes the sequence easy to follow through two almost matching questions of initiative. The initial courtesy and the seat above other men establish the contrast with the direct declaration the king now hears from his guest.
13–18Water and fire as a theory of right action
Moscow VIII339:418,419 running text, VIII339:420 running text, VIII339:421 running text, VIII339:422 running text, VIII339:423 running text, VIII340:424 running text · Mohl VI291:435,436 running text, VI291:437 running text, VI291:438 running text, VI291:439 running text, VI291:440 running text, VI291:441 running text · Ganjoor sh4:7, sh4:8 running poem body, sh4:9 running poem body, sh4:10 running poem body, sh4:11 running poem body, sh4:12 running poem body, sh4:13 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII500:422,423 running text, VII500:424 running text, VII500:425 running text, VII500:426 running text, VII500:427 running text, VII500:428 running text
Moscow VIII p.339 · Moscow VIII p.340 · Mohl VI p.291 · Ganjoor §4:7 · Ganjoor §4:8 · Ganjoor §4:9 · Ganjoor §4:10 · Ganjoor §4:11 · Ganjoor §4:12 · Ganjoor §4:13 · Khaleghi VII p.500
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh give the banquet at the time of battle as a sign of submission. English sharpens the turning point by saying it is now war’s turn to speak. In the Persian, just action is aligned with a favorable omen, and water is brought against fire. English converts that action into a maxim about their incompatibility. The result is memorable and continues the language of refusal, while the Persian leaves more room for the constructive image of putting out a fire. The ancient sky then puts a limit on the warrior’s assurance. His claim depends on how one acts in uncertainty, which explains the later insistence on testing strength.
19–24Whether the ten thousand have fallen
Moscow VIII340:425,426,427 running text · related context, VIII340:426 running text, VIII340:427 running text, VIII340:428 running text, VIII340:429 running text, VIII340:430 running text · Mohl VI291:442,443,444 running text · related context, VI291:443 running text, VI291:444 running text, VI291:445 running text, VI291:446 running text, VI291:447 running text · Ganjoor Checked local gap for this detail, sh4:15 running poem body, sh4:16 running poem body, sh4:17 running poem body, sh4:18 running poem body, sh4:19 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII500:429,430,431 running text · related context, VII500:430 running text, VII500:431 running text, VII501:432 running text, VII501:433 running text, VII501:434 running text
Moscow VIII p.340 · Mohl VI p.291 · Ganjoor §4:14 · Ganjoor §4:15 · Ganjoor §4:16 · Ganjoor §4:17 · Ganjoor §4:18 · Ganjoor §4:19 · Khaleghi VII p.500 · Khaleghi VII p.501
All four witnesses connect shame before God and other heroes with the failure to use one’s strength. The running Persian makes Bahram imagine turning back while ten thousand Iranians remain unslain. English gives him ten thousand already dead and asks that their sacrifice count for something. This makes the appeal emotionally immediate and changes the logic: in Persian there are lives still available for the contest. The English nonetheless retains the distinction between capitulating early and trying the army’s full powers. The image of the bow as a spring cloud gives the latter alternative a visible measure. Maces and swords belong to the original sequence, with the English adding the roar of a massed charge.
25–30A pleased ruler and alarmed veterans
Moscow VIII340:431 running text, VIII340:432 running text, VIII340:433 running text, VIII340:434,435 running text, VIII340:436 running text, VIII340:437 running text · Mohl VI291:448 running text, VI291:449 running text, VI291:450 running text, VI291:451,452 running text, VI292:453 running text, VI292:454 running text · Ganjoor sh4:20 running poem body, sh4:21 running poem body, sh4:22 running poem body, sh4:23, sh4:24 running poem body, sh4:25 running poem body, sh4:26 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII501:435 running text, VII501:436 running text, VII501:437 running text, VII501:438,439 running text, VII501:440 running text, VII501:441 running text
Moscow VIII p.340 · Mohl VI p.291 · Mohl VI p.292 · Ganjoor §4:20 · Ganjoor §4:21 · Ganjoor §4:22 · Ganjoor §4:23 · Ganjoor §4:24 · Ganjoor §4:25 · Ganjoor §4:26 · Khaleghi VII p.501
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh allow that Fortune might withhold victory after the effort has been made. English develops this into an imagined concession of cities and possessions. Then the king smiles, and the veterans go out with hearts full of blood or distress. English gives them “bliss,” which transfers the king’s reaction to his older advisers. Their ensuing warning supplies a way to see the difference: the almost impassable press of Saveh’s army gives them a strong reason to be afraid of the terms on which Bahram has argued. Keeping joy and apprehension simultaneous in Persian allows the danger to survive an apparently successful audience.
31–36The report makes a commander
Moscow VIII340:438 running text, VIII340:439,440 running text, VIII340:441,442 running text, VIII341:443 running text, VIII341:444 running text, VIII341:445 running text · Mohl VI292:455 running text, VI292:456,457 running text, VI292:458,459 running text, VI292:460 running text, VI292:461 running text, VI292:462 running text · Ganjoor sh4:27 running poem body, sh4:28, sh4:29 running poem body, sh4:30, sh4:31 running poem body, sh4:32 running poem body, sh4:33 running poem body, sh4:34 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII501:442 running text, VII501:443,444 running text, VII501:445,446 running text, VII501:447 running text, VII502:448 running text, VII502:449 running text
Moscow VIII p.340 · Moscow VIII p.341 · Mohl VI p.292 · Ganjoor §4:27 · Ganjoor §4:28 · Ganjoor §4:29 · Ganjoor §4:30 · Ganjoor §4:31 · Ganjoor §4:32 · Ganjoor §4:33 · Ganjoor §4:34 · Khaleghi VII p.501 · Khaleghi VII p.502
The four texts have the veterans ask who dares command after such bold claims and give Bahram a direct answer conditioned on the king’s consent. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh then say the bearers of this exchange added ten to every statement. English reduces that complication to a report, letting the appointment follow on Bahram’s words as actually heard. The Persian gives intermediaries a more consequential role in creating the public image on which the appointment rests. The English stresses the king’s new confidence and then has the other warriors acclaim the leader. Together, the approval from above and the reputation among peers give practical effect to the earlier recognition through prophecy.
37–42A girdle and an obligation
Moscow VIII341:446 running text, VIII341:447 running text, VIII341:448 running text, VIII341:449 running text, VIII341:450 running text, VIII341:451 running text · Mohl VI292:463 running text, VI292:464 running text, VI292:465 running text, VI292:466 running text, VI292:467 running text, VI292:468 running text · Ganjoor Checked local gap for this additional verse, sh4:35 running poem body, sh4:36 running poem body, sh4:37 running poem body, sh4:38 running poem body, sh4:39 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII502:450 running text, VII502:451 running text, VII502:452 running text, VII502:453 running text, VII502:454 running text, VII502:455 running text
Moscow VIII p.341 · Mohl VI p.292 · Ganjoor §4:34 · Ganjoor §4:35 · Ganjoor §4:36 · Ganjoor §4:37 · Ganjoor §4:38 · Ganjoor §4:39 · Khaleghi VII p.502
The girded commander standing before the king is separately attested in Moscow, Mohl and Khaleghi-Motlagh. Ganjoor goes directly to the request to call the muster official. English preserves the bodily preparation and then renders the muster as a distinction between those who will stand and those who will retreat. That last test makes Bahram’s earlier criticism of recalling an army feel pertinent before it is ever ordered. All four turn the king’s assent into personal accountability for good and ill. The English’s steering image conveys real scope for command, while the following selection shows how quickly the license becomes a set of commitments about who must serve.
43–48The list selects an age and a voice
Moscow VIII341:452 running text, VIII341:453 running text, VIII341:454 running text, VIII341:455 running text, VIII341:456,457 running text, VIII341:457 running text · Mohl VI292:469 running text, VI292:470 running text, VI292:471 running text, VI292:472 running text, VI292:473,474 running text, VI292:474 running text · Ganjoor sh4:40 running poem body, sh4:41 running poem body, sh4:42 running poem body, sh4:43 running poem body, sh4:44, sh4:45 running poem body, sh4:45 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII502:456 running text, VII502:457 running text, VII502:458 running text, VII502:459 running text, VII502:460,461 running text, VII502:461 running text
Moscow VIII p.341 · Mohl VI p.292 · Ganjoor §4:40 · Ganjoor §4:41 · Ganjoor §4:42 · Ganjoor §4:43 · Ganjoor §4:44 · Ganjoor §4:45 · Khaleghi VII p.502
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh all give twelve thousand armored riders and forty-year-old men. The English turns the prohibition on paying those outside the age into a visible crossing off of names, so the restriction has force even for a reader unfamiliar with the pay roll. The vanguard leader’s name varies, but his riding before the ranks and declaring his lineage remain the means of stirring the men. English highlights those acts through a repeated verb of arousal. The arrangement distinguishes three kinds of confidence in one sequence: the numbered strength of the army, the age of the men and the commander’s ability to make a visible appeal to their courage.
49–54The baggage, both wings and the rear
Moscow VIII341:458 running text · VIII342:459 running text, VIII342:459 running text · wings in balance; personal assignment lacks direct support, VIII342:459 running text, VIII342:460 running text, VIII342:461 running text · Mohl VI292:475 running text · VI293:476 running text, VI293:476 running text · wings in balance; personal assignment lacks direct support, VI293:476 running text, VI293:477 running text, VI293:478 running text · Ganjoor sh4:46, sh4:47 running poem body, Checked local gap for this detail, sh4:47 running poem body, sh4:48 running poem body, sh4:49 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII503:462,463 running text, VII503:463 running text · wings in balance; personal assignment lacks direct support, VII503:463 running text, VII503:464 running text, VII503:465 running text
Moscow VIII p.341 · Moscow VIII p.342 · Mohl VI p.292 · Mohl VI p.293 · Ganjoor §4:46 · Ganjoor §4:47 · Ganjoor §4:48 · Ganjoor §4:49 · Khaleghi VII p.503
All four running accounts make Izad Gashasp responsible for the baggage and speak of ordering the wings. The English assigns the left specifically to Mardanshah and identifies him as Bahram’s brother. Those details and the placement of kinsmen in the right remain provisional in this passage. Moscow and Ganjoor give Hamadan Gashasp in the rear, while Khaleghi-Motlagh prints Banda Gashasp and Mohl gives another form. The English Kanda is linked to the same position by the distinctive feat of catching a lion’s tail. This contrast makes names or assignments separable from their function. The commander’s formation still moves from the security of supplies to the character of the troops addressed next.
55–60Restraint belongs to the march
Moscow VIII342:463 running text, VIII342:462 running text, VIII342:464 running text, VIII342:465 running text, VIII342:466 running text, VIII342:467 running text · Mohl VI293:479 running text, VI293:480 running text, VI293:481 running text, VI293:482 running text, VI293:483 running text, VI293:484 running text · Ganjoor sh4:51 running poem body, sh4:50 running poem body, sh4:52 running poem body, sh4:53 running poem body, sh4:54 running poem body, sh4:55 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII503:467 running text, VII503:466 running text, VII503:468 running text, VII503:469 running text, VII503:470 running text, VII503:471 running text
Moscow VIII p.342 · Mohl VI p.293 · Ganjoor §4:51 · Ganjoor §4:50 · Ganjoor §4:52 · Ganjoor §4:53 · Ganjoor §4:54 · Ganjoor §4:55 · Khaleghi VII p.503
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh connect the avoidance of harm with receiving divine help. In Mohl the appeal for help comes immediately before the restraint. English likewise makes the prohibitions follow from that appeal. The night trumpet, the common movement, and the continued readiness of horse and rider belong to the four texts. English uses “tumult” and spurring to make the response urgent. Rest after the movement then seems a product of confidence and discipline. It matters that the rules sit between the assignment of military positions and the king’s approval. They describe how an army must behave on the way to battle before the state rewards its preparation.
61–66Stores translate approval into resources
Moscow VIII342:468 running text, VIII342:469 running text, VIII342:470 running text, VIII342:471 running text, VIII342:472 running text, VIII342:473 running text · Mohl VI293:485 running text, VI293:486 running text, VI293:487 running text, VI293:488 running text, VI293:489 running text, VI293:490 running text · Ganjoor sh4:56 running poem body, sh4:57 running poem body, sh4:58 running poem body, sh4:59 running poem body, sh4:60 running poem body, sh4:61 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII503:472 running text, VII503:473 running text, VII504:474 running text, VII504:475 running text, VII504:476 running text, VII504:477 running text
Moscow VIII p.342 · Mohl VI p.293 · Ganjoor §4:56 · Ganjoor §4:57 · Ganjoor §4:58 · Ganjoor §4:59 · Ganjoor §4:60 · Ganjoor §4:61 · Khaleghi VII p.503 · Khaleghi VII p.504
In Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh the stores of weapons are opened in Pars and Ahvaz. Mohl consolidates the grant. English’s “every armory” gives the transaction breadth without stopping at named places. The assembly of loose warhorses is shared, and the king authorizes the commander to request what he needs. The English uses the transition to move almost imperceptibly from favor to scrutiny. The same man given access to the treasury is asked how much he truly knows about the enemy’s strength. The repetition of stores, arms and men before the question about numbers lets the king make the challenge through visible resources and gives the ensuing argument a practical ground.
67–72The quarrel is about scale and experience
Moscow VIII343:474 running text, VIII343:475 running text, VIII343:476 running text, VIII343:477 running text, VIII343:478,479 running text, VIII343:480 running text · Mohl VI293:491 running text, VI293:492 running text, VI293:493 running text, VI293:494 running text, VI293:495,496 running text, VI293:498 running text · Ganjoor sh4:62 running poem body, sh4:63 running poem body, sh4:64 running poem body, sh4:65 running poem body, sh4:66, sh4:67 running poem body, sh4:68 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII504:478 running text, VII504:479 running text, VII504:480 running text, VII504:481 running text, VII504:482,483 running text, VII504:484 running text
Moscow VIII p.343 · Mohl VI p.293 · Ganjoor §4:62 · Ganjoor §4:63 · Ganjoor §4:64 · Ganjoor §4:65 · Ganjoor §4:66 · Ganjoor §4:67 · Ganjoor §4:68 · Khaleghi VII p.504
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh contrast the army that can shake the ground with the selected twelve thousand and then ask why they are forty. English’s “force that darkens all the land” recalls the darkness made by dust earlier in the narrative, giving the objection force through a memory already established for the reader. Bahram answers with both fortune and precedent. The English distinguishes Fortune’s favor from the ability of a smaller force to range far and wide. That geographical idiom gives resourcefulness to a defense that could otherwise sound fatalistic. The examples will then demonstrate what smaller forces have done under different commanders with similarly favorable ends.
73–78Three stories make twelve thousand a deliberate number
Moscow VIII343:481 running text, VIII343:482 running text, VIII343:483,484 running text, VIII343:485 running text, VIII343:486 running text, VIII343:487 running text · Mohl VI293:497 running text, VI293:499 running text, VI293:500 running text · VI294:501 running text, VI294:502 running text, VI294:503 running text, VI294:504 running text · Ganjoor sh4:69 running poem body, sh4:70 running poem body, sh4:71, sh4:72 running poem body, sh4:73 running poem body, sh4:74 running poem body, sh4:75 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII504:485 running text, VII504:486 running text, VII504:487 running text · VII505:488 running text, VII505:489 running text, VII505:490 running text, VII505:491 running text
Moscow VIII p.343 · Mohl VI p.293 · Mohl VI p.294 · Ganjoor §4:69 · Ganjoor §4:70 · Ganjoor §4:71 · Ganjoor §4:72 · Ganjoor §4:73 · Ganjoor §4:74 · Ganjoor §4:75 · Khaleghi VII p.504 · Khaleghi VII p.505
The four witnesses name Rostam in the rescue of Kay Kavus, Gudarz in the vengeance for Siavash and Esfandiyar against Arjasp. English repeats twelve thousand so that the weight of the answer comes from three distinct enterprises, none of which is the present war. The sequence moves through rescue, retaliation and conflict with a defended enemy. The Persian also explicitly assures that the rescued notables were unharmed, which English compresses into the act of freeing them. This compression gives conversational speed to a retrospective passage. It preserves the role of each predecessor and establishes why the apparent modesty of Bahram’s force could be a claim to heroic competence.
79–84The tested rider and the hazards of excess
Moscow VIII343:488 running text, VIII343:489 running text, VIII344:490 running text, VIII344:491 running text, VIII344:492 running text, VIII344:493 running text · Mohl VI294:505 running text, VI294:506 running text, VI294:507 running text, VI294:508 running text, VI294:509 running text, VI294:510 running text · Ganjoor sh4:76 running poem body, sh4:77 running poem body, sh4:78 running poem body, sh4:79 running poem body, sh4:80 running poem body, sh4:81 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII505:492 running text, VII505:493 running text, VII505:494 running text, VII505:495 running text, VII505:496 running text, VII505:497 running text
Moscow VIII p.343 · Moscow VIII p.344 · Mohl VI p.294 · Ganjoor §4:76 · Ganjoor §4:77 · Ganjoor §4:78 · Ganjoor §4:79 · Ganjoor §4:80 · Ganjoor §4:81 · Khaleghi VII p.505
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh connect Esfandiyar’s victory to action against an army and stronghold. English makes “stratagem” the name for how the result became possible. It also renders objections to an overly large force as loss of ordered movement. The next distinction between a young man and one of forty continues the same argument about conduct under strain. Bread and salt, preserved in the running witnesses and made explicit as loyalty in English, are the social basis of the older fighter’s steadiness. The English seal image makes a material bond of service audible as an obligation while preserving the concrete objects remembered by the veteran.
85–90Dependents give experience different meanings
Moscow VIII344:494 running text, VIII344:495 running text, VIII344:496 running text, VIII344:497 running text, VIII344:498 running text, VIII344:499 running text · Mohl VI294:511 running text, VI294:512 running text, VI294:513 running text, VI294:514 running text, VI294:515 running text, VI294:516 running text · Ganjoor sh4:82 running poem body, sh4:83 running poem body, sh4:84 running poem body, sh4:85 running poem body, sh4:86 running poem body, sh4:87 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII505:498 running text, VII506:499 running text, VII506:500 running text, VII506:501 running text, VII506:502 running text, VII506:503 running text
Moscow VIII p.344 · Mohl VI p.294 · Ganjoor §4:82 · Ganjoor §4:83 · Ganjoor §4:84 · Ganjoor §4:85 · Ganjoor §4:86 · Ganjoor §4:87 · Khaleghi VII p.505 · Khaleghi VII p.506
Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh link wife, child and household to the turning or distress of the seasoned man’s spirit. Mohl gives a negative form closer to English’s refusal of distraction. In the following lines all four deny the youth comparable responsibilities and experience. English stresses how easily visible show defeats patience and how a young fighter lingers over his own success. Its veteran is therefore free of distraction while still remembering bonds of loyalty. The other running forms allow domestic ties to weigh on him, complicating the foundation of a virtue that initially appeared purely military. The difference affects why Bahram trusts the men he has chosen.
91–96The audience moves into public space
Moscow VIII344:500 running text, VIII344:501,502 running text, VIII344:502 running text, VIII344:503,504 running text, VIII344:505 running text, VIII344:506,507 running text · Mohl VI294:517 running text, VI294:518,519 running text, VI294:519 running text, VI294:520,521 running text, VI294:522 running text, VI294:523,524 running text · Ganjoor sh4:88 running poem body, sh4:89, sh4:90 running poem body, sh4:90 running poem body, sh4:91, sh4:92 running poem body, sh4:93 running poem body, sh4:94, sh4:95 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII506:504 running text, VII506:505,506 running text, VII506:506 running text, VII506:507,508 running text, VII506:509 running text, VII507:510,511 running text
Moscow VIII p.344 · Mohl VI p.294 · Ganjoor §4:88 · Ganjoor §4:89 · Ganjoor §4:90 · Ganjoor §4:91 · Ganjoor §4:92 · Ganjoor §4:93 · Ganjoor §4:94 · Ganjoor §4:95 · Khaleghi VII p.506 · Khaleghi VII p.507
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh move from the youth’s flight to the king’s pleasure and his order to arm for the field. English keeps the spring image for the king and retains the named coat and lasso. The Persian itemizes more of the armor and the separate equipment of the horse. Mohl and Khaleghi-Motlagh also explicitly give the Roman helmet in the field scene. English’s passage through the armory to an assembly with arms and polo equipment makes the occasion ceremonial rather than a second argument about battle. It gives Bahram’s obedience a public setting where the king can confer a visible emblem.
97–100The banner makes the comparison visible
Moscow VIII344:507 running text, VIII345:508,509 running text, VIII345:510,513,514 running text, VIII345:515,516 running text · Mohl VI294:524 running text, VI294:525 running text · VI295:526 running text, VI295:527,530,531 running text, VI295:532,533 running text · Ganjoor sh4:95 running poem body, sh4:96, sh4:97 running poem body, sh4:98, sh4:101, sh4:102 running poem body, sh4:103, sh4:104 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII507:511 running text, VII507:512,513 running text, VII507:514,517,518 running text, VII507:519,520 running text
Moscow VIII p.344 · Moscow VIII p.345 · Mohl VI p.294 · Mohl VI p.295 · Ganjoor §4:95 · Ganjoor §4:96 · Ganjoor §4:97 · Ganjoor §4:98 · Ganjoor §4:101 · Ganjoor §4:102 · Ganjoor §4:103 · Ganjoor §4:104 · Khaleghi VII p.507
All four accounts give the reception of the chief, the violet dragon standard and the tradition that it went before Rostam. English concentrates the king’s blessing and the comparison into the moment the banner passes hand to hand. The Persian says more about Rostam’s status and the regard in which the ancestors held him, and disperses the gathering after Bahram’s reception of the emblem. The English ending stays on the commander with the standard under his control. That is a distinct ending for the chapter and anticipates the record of his men’s feats in the next one. The flag carries the weight of the story that the king has made the assembled witnesses hear.
Source record and limits
F&R English
The 100 numbered couplets cover Bahram’s arrival, the debate and muster, the choice of officers and riders, the appeal to precedent, and the award of the standard.
Moscow
Volume VIII p.339 v.406 through p.345 v.517. Its opening has Bahram take warriors. The apparatus on p.339 prints a line recalling Iran and Mehran Setad. The girded commander appears in a separate running verse at p.341 v.446.
Mohl
Volume VI p.290 v.423 through p.295 v.534. Bahram calls no warriors at the departure from Barda. The girdle is in the running text, and the form of a reading about household cares differs from the other editions.
Ganjoor
Hormizd §3:187–192 and §4:1–105. The two sections meet between the initial reception and the formal audience. The edition gives the positive troop gathering and a shorter transition to the muster.
Khaleghi-Motlagh
Volume VII p.499 v.409 through p.507 v.521. The opening emphasizes haste to court. The edition brackets the line invoking Iran and Mehran Setad, counts the girdle verse in the running text and prints Banda Gashasp in the rear.
Consequential readings
The party leaving Barda, the status of the ten thousand Iranians, the veterans’ emotion and the names and duties of the officers are distinguished at the corresponding lines.
Persian without a separate English couplet
The appeal to use all available strength, the extended naming of Rostam and the breakup of the gathering have separate register entries.
Limits of the evidence
The explicit names and duties of Mardanshah, his kinship, the kinsmen on the right and the Kanda form remain provisional at the checked local passage.
Moscow VIII p.339 · Moscow VIII p.340 · Moscow VIII p.341 · Moscow VIII p.342 · Moscow VIII p.343 · Moscow VIII p.344 · Moscow VIII p.345
Mohl VI p.290 · Mohl VI p.291 · Mohl VI p.292 · Mohl VI p.293 · Mohl VI p.294 · Mohl VI p.295
Khaleghi VII p.499 · Khaleghi VII p.500 · Khaleghi VII p.501 · Khaleghi VII p.502 · Khaleghi VII p.503 · Khaleghi VII p.504 · Khaleghi VII p.505 · Khaleghi VII p.506 · Khaleghi VII p.507
Selected printed readings
- Moscow VIII339:406 · Running text · ز گردنکشان لشکری برد تفت
Bahram takes a force. - Mohl VI290:423 · Running text · ز گردان لشکر کسی را نخواند
This negative supports the English. - Khaleghi VII499:409 · Running text · خرامان به درگه شتابید و تفت
The emphasis falls on hurrying to court. - Moscow VIII339 note 15 · Actual printed apparatus · سخنهای ایران برو کرد یاد
The alternate wording is physically present. - Khaleghi VII500:418 · Bracketed running verse · همان نیز گفتار مهران ستاد
The court recalls Mehran Setad. - Khaleghi VII501:439 · Running text · جهاندیدگان دل پر از خون شدند
The elders go out distressed. - Moscow VIII341:446 · Running text · کمر بسته با آلت کارزار
The girdle and gear appear together. - Mohl VI292:463 · Running text · کمر بسته با آلت کارزار
The same preparation is explicit. - Moscow VIII342:460 · Running text · به پشت سپه بود همدان گشسپ
The rear guard has the Hamadan name form. - Khaleghi VII503:464 · Running text · به پشت سپه بود بنداگشسپ
The rear guard has the Banda name form. - Khaleghi VII507:510 · Running text · ابا جوشن و گرز و رومیکلاه
The coat, mace and Roman helmet are explicit.
E5.6 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | VIII339:406 running text | VI290:423 running text |
| 2 | VIII339:407 running text | VI290:424 running text |
| 3 | VIII339:408 running text | VI290:425 running text |
| 4 | VIII339:409,410 running text | VI290:426,427 running text |
| 5 | VIII339:410,411 running text | VI290:427 running text · VI291:428 running text · VI p.291 |
| 6 | VIII339:412 running text | VI291:429 running text |
| 7 | VIII339:413 running text | VI291:430 running text |
| 8 | VIII339:414 running text | VI291:431 running text |
| 9 | VIII339 note 15 after v.414 · actual printed apparatus | VI291 near v.431 · checked local gap for the additional detail |
| 10 | VIII339:415 running text | VI291:432 running text |
| 11 | VIII339:416 running text | VI291:433 running text |
| 12 | VIII339:417 running text | VI291:434 running text |
| 13 | VIII339:418,419 running text | VI291:435,436 running text |
| 14 | VIII339:420 running text | VI291:437 running text |
| 15 | VIII339:421 running text | VI291:438 running text |
| 16 | VIII339:422 running text | VI291:439 running text |
| 17 | VIII339:423 running text | VI291:440 running text |
| 18 | VIII340:424 running text | VI291:441 running text |
| 19 | VIII340:425,426,427 running text · related context | VI291:442,443,444 running text · related context |
| 20 | VIII340:426 running text | VI291:443 running text |
| 21 | VIII340:427 running text | VI291:444 running text |
| 22 | VIII340:428 running text | VI291:445 running text |
| 23 | VIII340:429 running text | VI291:446 running text |
| 24 | VIII340:430 running text | VI291:447 running text |
| 25 | VIII340:431 running text | VI291:448 running text |
| 26 | VIII340:432 running text | VI291:449 running text |
| 27 | VIII340:433 running text | VI291:450 running text |
| 28 | VIII340:434,435 running text | VI291:451,452 running text |
| 29 | VIII340:436 running text | VI292:453 running text |
| 30 | VIII340:437 running text | VI292:454 running text |
| 31 | VIII340:438 running text | VI292:455 running text |
| 32 | VIII340:439,440 running text | VI292:456,457 running text |
| 33 | VIII340:441,442 running text | VI292:458,459 running text |
| 34 | VIII341:443 running text | VI292:460 running text |
| 35 | VIII341:444 running text | VI292:461 running text |
| 36 | VIII341:445 running text | VI292:462 running text |
| 37 | VIII341:446 running text | VI292:463 running text |
| 38 | VIII341:447 running text | VI292:464 running text |
| 39 | VIII341:448 running text | VI292:465 running text |
| 40 | VIII341:449 running text | VI292:466 running text |
| 41 | VIII341:450 running text | VI292:467 running text |
| 42 | VIII341:451 running text | VI292:468 running text |
| 43 | VIII341:452 running text | VI292:469 running text |
| 44 | VIII341:453 running text | VI292:470 running text |
| 45 | VIII341:454 running text | VI292:471 running text |
| 46 | VIII341:455 running text | VI292:472 running text |
| 47 | VIII341:456,457 running text | VI292:473,474 running text |
| 48 | VIII341:457 running text | VI292:474 running text |
| 49 | VIII341:458 running text · VIII342:459 running text · VIII p.342 | VI292:475 running text · VI293:476 running text · VI p.293 |
| 50 | VIII342:459 running text · wings in balance; personal assignment lacks direct support | VI293:476 running text · wings in balance; personal assignment lacks direct support |
| 51 | VIII342:459 running text | VI293:476 running text |
| 52 | VIII342:460 running text | VI293:477 running text |
| 53 | VIII342:460 running text | VI293:477 running text |
| 54 | VIII342:461 running text | VI293:478 running text |
| 55 | VIII342:463 running text | VI293:479 running text |
| 56 | VIII342:462 running text | VI293:480 running text |
| 57 | VIII342:464 running text | VI293:481 running text |
| 58 | VIII342:465 running text | VI293:482 running text |
| 59 | VIII342:466 running text | VI293:483 running text |
| 60 | VIII342:467 running text | VI293:484 running text |
| 61 | VIII342:468 running text | VI293:485 running text |
| 62 | VIII342:469 running text | VI293:486 running text |
| 63 | VIII342:470 running text | VI293:487 running text |
| 64 | VIII342:471 running text | VI293:488 running text |
| 65 | VIII342:472 running text | VI293:489 running text |
| 66 | VIII342:473 running text | VI293:490 running text |
| 67 | VIII343:474 running text | VI293:491 running text |
| 68 | VIII343:475 running text | VI293:492 running text |
| 69 | VIII343:476 running text | VI293:493 running text |
| 70 | VIII343:477 running text | VI293:494 running text |
| 71 | VIII343:478,479 running text | VI293:495,496 running text |
| 72 | VIII343:480 running text | VI293:498 running text |
| 73 | VIII343:481 running text | VI293:497 running text |
| 74 | VIII343:482 running text | VI293:499 running text |
| 75 | VIII343:483,484 running text | VI293:500 running text · VI294:501 running text · VI p.294 |
| 76 | VIII343:485 running text | VI294:502 running text |
| 77 | VIII343:486 running text | VI294:503 running text |
| 78 | VIII343:487 running text | VI294:504 running text |
| 79 | VIII343:488 running text | VI294:505 running text |
| 80 | VIII343:489 running text | VI294:506 running text |
| 81 | VIII344:490 running text | VI294:507 running text |
| 82 | VIII344:491 running text | VI294:508 running text |
| 83 | VIII344:492 running text | VI294:509 running text |
| 84 | VIII344:493 running text | VI294:510 running text |
| 85 | VIII344:494 running text | VI294:511 running text |
| 86 | VIII344:495 running text | VI294:512 running text |
| 87 | VIII344:496 running text | VI294:513 running text |
| 88 | VIII344:497 running text | VI294:514 running text |
| 89 | VIII344:498 running text | VI294:515 running text |
| 90 | VIII344:499 running text | VI294:516 running text |
| 91 | VIII344:500 running text | VI294:517 running text |
| 92 | VIII344:501,502 running text | VI294:518,519 running text |
| 93 | VIII344:502 running text | VI294:519 running text |
| 94 | VIII344:503,504 running text | VI294:520,521 running text |
| 95 | VIII344:505 running text | VI294:522 running text |
| 96 | VIII344:506,507 running text | VI294:523,524 running text |
| 97 | VIII344:507 running text | VI294:524 running text |
| 98 | VIII345:508,509 running text | VI294:525 running text · VI295:526 running text · VI p.295 |
| 99 | VIII345:510,513,514 running text | VI295:527,530,531 running text |
| 100 | VIII345:515,516 running text | VI295:532,533 running text |
New Naqqali