Bahram Chubin Rides against Saveh
The 109 numbered couplets cover the commission of a recorder, the omen and attempted recall, the payment rule, Kharrad’s mission, and the inquiry that exposes his departure.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | The 109 numbered couplets cover the commission of a recorder, the omen and attempted recall, the payment rule, Kharrad’s mission, and the inquiry that exposes his departure. |
| Moscow | Volume VIII p.345 v.518 through p.352 v.636. The recorder is a young Mehran. The route of the disciplined march is toward the territory of the Khuz. |
| Mohl | Volume VI p.295 v.535 through p.300 v.657. The recorder is an old Mehran. This edition includes a continuing just march, a blessing to be carried to Bahram and the proposed inspection of the travelers. |
| Ganjoor | Hormizd §4:106–200 and §5:1–24. The night inquiry crosses the online section break, while the next English chapter begins with the new emissary at §5:25. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | Volume VII p.508 v.522 through p.518 v.640. The edited text retains the young Mehran, the Khuz route and the rebuke for thinking the theft small. It uses the title Faghfoor for Saveh’s son. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6The record is part of the commander’s request
Moscow VIII345:518 running text, VIII345:519 running text, VIII345:520 running text, VIII345:521 running text, VIII345:522 running text, VIII345:523 running text · Mohl VI295:535 running text, VI295:536 running text, VI295:537 running text, VI295:538 running text, VI295:539 running text, VI295:540 running text · Ganjoor sh4:106 running poem body, sh4:107 running poem body, sh4:108 running poem body, sh4:109 running poem body, sh4:110 running poem body, sh4:111 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII508:522 running text, VII508:523 running text, VII508:524 running text, VII508:525 running text, VII508:526 running text, VII508:527 running text
Moscow VIII p.345 · Mohl VI p.295 · Ganjoor §4:106 · Ganjoor §4:107 · Ganjoor §4:108 · Ganjoor §4:109 · Ganjoor §4:110 · Ganjoor §4:111 · Khaleghi VII p.508
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh place a bright shield at the opening of dawn and give Bahram a formal appearance before Hormizd. Mohl uses a stronger bodily gesture of obeisance. English’s low bow thus has a firm place alongside the language of royal farr, which Bahram credits for raising his own standing. His request concerns the reputation of other men: successful fighters need a witness who can write down their names. The English develops that process into fame being sown abroad. It makes the practical act of keeping a record the reward a commander can request for soldiers distinct from the pay and equipment already granted.
7–12A recorder leaves and a private conference begins
Moscow VIII345:524 running text, VIII346:525 running text, VIII346:526 running text, VIII346:527 running text, VIII346:528 running text, VIII346:528,529 running text · Mohl VI295:541 running text, VI295:542 running text, VI295:543 running text, VI295:544 running text, VI295:545,546 running text, VI295:546,547 running text · Ganjoor sh4:112 running poem body, sh4:113 running poem body, sh4:114 running poem body, sh4:115 running poem body, sh4:116 running poem body, sh4:116, sh4:117 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII508:528 running text, VII508:529 running text, VII508:530 running text, VII508:531 running text, VII508:532 running text, VII508:532 running text · VII509:533 running text
Moscow VIII p.345 · Moscow VIII p.346 · Mohl VI p.295 · Ganjoor §4:112 · Ganjoor §4:113 · Ganjoor §4:114 · Ganjoor §4:115 · Ganjoor §4:116 · Ganjoor §4:117 · Khaleghi VII p.508 · Khaleghi VII p.509
The running texts in Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh name Mehran as the recorder. Mohl calls him old, while the other three call him young. English names Nastooh and substitutes a martial image for writing down names in the ordinary sense. That substitution reinforces the interpretive point of the previous request even as the identity remains provisional. Mohl separately marks the king’s private conversation when the army has gone. English uses that separation to move from the future witness of soldiers’ acts to a private witness of Bahram’s disposition. The king’s question about his commander’s visible joy creates the bridge between the two ways of observing an army.
13–18The priest interprets ambition where the ruler sees merit
Moscow VIII346:530 running text, VIII346:531,532 running text, VIII346:533 running text, VIII346:534 running text, VIII346:535 running text, VIII346:536 running text · Mohl VI295:548 running text, VI296:549,550 running text, VI296:551 running text, VI296:552 running text, VI296:553 running text, VI296:554 running text · Ganjoor sh4:118 running poem body, sh4:119, sh4:120 running poem body, sh4:121 running poem body, sh4:122 running poem body, sh4:123 running poem body, sh4:124 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII509:534 running text, VII509:535,536 running text, VII509:537 running text, VII509:538 running text, VII509:539 running text, VII509:540 running text
Moscow VIII p.346 · Mohl VI p.295 · Mohl VI p.296 · Ganjoor §4:118 · Ganjoor §4:119 · Ganjoor §4:120 · Ganjoor §4:121 · Ganjoor §4:122 · Ganjoor §4:123 · Ganjoor §4:124 · Khaleghi VII p.509
All four accounts make the priest predict success on the basis of Bahram’s stature and speech and then fear that the same man will turn against the sovereign. The English’s barren world made fertile gives the positive forecast a quality not expressed in those terms in the Persian. Its lion speaking in a royal place makes the warning easier to visualize through the conduct already seen at court. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh also have Hormizd dismiss the priest’s poison and say the victorious man merits the crown. The English keeps that striking answer, which makes later anxiety about disloyalty a reversal of a principle Hormizd originally states himself.
19–24The second witness watches for signs
Moscow VIII346:537 running text, VIII346:538,539 running text, VIII347:540 running text, VIII347:541 running text, VIII347:542,543 running text, VIII347:543 running text · Mohl VI296:555 running text, VI296:556,557 running text, VI296:558 running text, VI296:559 running text, VI296:560,561 running text, VI296:561 running text · Ganjoor sh4:125 running poem body, sh4:126, sh4:127 running poem body, sh4:128 running poem body, sh4:129 running poem body, sh4:130, sh4:131 running poem body, sh4:131 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII509:541 running text, VII509:542,543 running text, VII509:544 running text, VII510:545 running text, VII510:546,547 running text, VII510:547 running text
Moscow VIII p.346 · Moscow VIII p.347 · Mohl VI p.296 · Ganjoor §4:125 · Ganjoor §4:126 · Ganjoor §4:127 · Ganjoor §4:128 · Ganjoor §4:129 · Ganjoor §4:130 · Ganjoor §4:131 · Khaleghi VII p.509 · Khaleghi VII p.510
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh follow the king’s blessing with the priest’s visible pain and then a confidential commission. The English links these moments through the king retaining the thought, giving the covert inquiry a cause that can be followed without introducing an overt accusation. The confidential man is an omen reader and a guide or interpreter. His skills mark a change from the recorder requested by Bahram: this man reports a possible future to the ruler instead of recording valor for posterity. English’s moon and sun widen the setting imaginatively while retaining secrecy, the condition that allows the visit to yield information independent of Bahram’s intentions.
25–30The seller’s wares become a prophecy
Moscow VIII347:544 running text, VIII347:545,546 running text, VIII347:546 running text, VIII347:547 running text, VIII347:548,549 running text, VIII347:549 running text · Mohl VI296:562 running text, VI296:563,564 running text, VI296:564 running text, VI296:565 running text, VI296:566,567 running text, VI296:567 running text · Ganjoor sh4:132 running poem body, sh4:133, sh4:134 running poem body, sh4:134 running poem body, sh4:135 running poem body, sh4:136, sh4:137 running poem body, sh4:137 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII510:548 running text, VII510:549,550 running text, VII510:550 running text, VII510:551 running text, VII510:552,553 running text, VII510:553 running text
Moscow VIII p.347 · Mohl VI p.296 · Ganjoor §4:132 · Ganjoor §4:133 · Ganjoor §4:134 · Ganjoor §4:135 · Ganjoor §4:136 · Ganjoor §4:137 · Khaleghi VII p.510
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh give a seller with heads on a tray, and Bahram takes one on the point of his spear. English divides the sight into a basket and a clean cloth, giving a more recognizable visual arrangement where the Persian describes washed heads. The gesture passes from taking the head to throwing it away, and the king’s name enters only as Bahram supplies his interpretation. The English raises the head before the army, turning what could have been a private appropriation into a spectacle. This additional exposure makes his oath seem addressed to his own troops as well as to the omen.
31–36The same gesture has two audiences
Moscow VIII347:550 running text, VIII347:551,552 running text, VIII347:553 running text, VIII347:554 running text · VIII348:555 running text, VIII348:556 running text, VIII348:557 running text · Mohl VI296:568 running text, VI296:569,570 running text, VI296:571 running text, VI296:572,573 running text, VI297:574 running text, VI297:575 running text · Ganjoor sh4:138 running poem body, sh4:139, sh4:140 running poem body, sh4:141 running poem body, sh4:142, sh4:143 running poem body, sh4:144 running poem body, sh4:145 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII510:554 running text, VII510:555 running text · VII511:556 running text, VII511:557 running text, VII511:558,559 running text, VII511:560 running text, VII511:561 running text
Moscow VIII p.347 · Moscow VIII p.348 · Mohl VI p.296 · Mohl VI p.297 · Ganjoor §4:138 · Ganjoor §4:139 · Ganjoor §4:140 · Ganjoor §4:141 · Ganjoor §4:142 · Ganjoor §4:143 · Ganjoor §4:144 · Ganjoor §4:145 · Khaleghi VII p.510 · Khaleghi VII p.511
The four texts have Bahram interpret the cast head as the defeat of Saveh, then let the observer infer a throne and resistance to Hormizd. English keeps the reversal of perspective, while it makes the first interpretation a more public promise and the second a moment of confident breakthrough. The courtier’s return makes the king’s fear immediate enough to act on without requiring any actual revolt. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh all make the verdant leaf darken when the king hears the report. English’s withering gives visible loss of vigor to the metaphor, and the command to camp confirms that at least one person accepts the danger as present.
37–42A recall threatens the army’s reading of its own movement
Moscow VIII348:558 running text, VIII348:558,559 running text, VIII348:560 running text, VIII348:561 running text, VIII348:562 running text, VIII348:563 running text · Mohl VI297:576 running text, VI297:576,577 running text, VI297:578 running text, VI297:579 running text, VI297:580 running text, VI297:581 running text · Ganjoor sh4:146 running poem body, sh4:146, sh4:147 running poem body, sh4:148 running poem body, sh4:149 running poem body, sh4:150 running poem body, sh4:151 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII511:562 running text, VII511:562,563 running text, VII511:564 running text, VII511:565 running text, VII511:566 running text, VII512:567 running text
Moscow VIII p.348 · Mohl VI p.297 · Ganjoor §4:146 · Ganjoor §4:147 · Ganjoor §4:148 · Ganjoor §4:149 · Ganjoor §4:150 · Ganjoor §4:151 · Khaleghi VII p.511 · Khaleghi VII p.512
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh have Hormizd ask Bahram to return privately at dawn and present his fresh advice. Bahram refuses on the ground that turning a force around while it is on the march is a bad omen and strengthens its opponent. English makes that strength a more immediate human response, the enemy rejoicing along its line. Its added “horse and all” gives the argument a concrete body that would have to turn. This is an answer about army morale as well as divination. The promise to return only after success gives a timetable that leaves the king’s private concerns room to persist without immediately depriving the expedition of its purpose.
43–48The route invites a test of discipline
Moscow VIII348:564 running text, VIII348:565 running text, VIII348:566 running text, VIII348:567 running text, VIII348:568 running text, VIII348:569 running text · Mohl VI297:582 running text, VI297:583 running text, VI297:584 running text, VI297:585 running text, VI297:586 running text, VI297:587 running text · Ganjoor sh4:152 running poem body, sh4:153 running poem body, sh4:154 running poem body, sh4:155 running poem body, sh4:156 running poem body, sh4:157 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII512:568 running text, VII512:569 running text, VII512:570 running text, VII512:571 running text, VII512:572 running text, VII512:573 running text
Moscow VIII p.348 · Mohl VI p.297 · Ganjoor §4:152 · Ganjoor §4:153 · Ganjoor §4:154 · Ganjoor §4:155 · Ganjoor §4:156 · Ganjoor §4:157 · Khaleghi VII p.512
All four give the successful return of the young messenger, the king’s acceptance, and a new dawn. The English makes clear that the recall is dropped. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh take the expedition toward the country of the Khuz. The English names Rey instead, so the route should be read with this local textual difference in view. The witnesses emphasize that the troops have caused no harm when a horseman takes the straw without paying. English slows the exchange through “bought” and the rider’s departure. Putting those two actions in separate phrases exposes the difference between an apparent purchase and the absence of payment.
49–54Complaint, recognition and the commander’s rebuke
Moscow VIII348:570 running text, VIII348:571 running text, VIII348:572 running text, VIII349:573 running text, VIII349:574 running text, VIII349:575 running text · Mohl VI297:588 running text, VI297:589 running text, VI297:590 running text, VI297:591 running text, VI297:592 running text, VI297:593 running text · Ganjoor sh4:158 running poem body, sh4:159 running poem body, sh4:160 running poem body, sh4:161 running poem body, sh4:162 running poem body, sh4:163 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII512:574 running text, VII512:575 running text, VII512:576 running text, VII513:577 running text, VII513:578 running text, VII513:579 running text
Moscow VIII p.348 · Moscow VIII p.349 · Mohl VI p.297 · Ganjoor §4:158 · Ganjoor §4:159 · Ganjoor §4:160 · Ganjoor §4:161 · Ganjoor §4:162 · Ganjoor §4:163 · Khaleghi VII p.512 · Khaleghi VII p.513
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh bring the complainant before the commander, give her an identifying detail and find the rider. English’s “paid no gold” is an interpretive expansion of unpaid price, and the iron helmet preserves the clue. The rebuke at the point of judgment is sharper in English and has support in Mohl and Khaleghi-Motlagh, where Bahram asks whether the man thinks the offense small. Moscow and Ganjoor announce the consequences more directly. The contrast matters because the English prepares the punishment as a reply to a dismissive attitude about a minor theft. The actual gravity assigned to that theft then becomes plain in the next actions.
55–60The general rule follows the individual punishment
Moscow VIII349:576 running text, VIII349:577 running text, VIII349:578 running text, VIII349:579 running text, VIII349 near v.579 · checked local gap for the additional detail · Mohl VI297:594 running text, VI297:595 running text, VI297:596 running text, VI297:597 running text, VI297:598 running text · resumed march, with no named destination here · Ganjoor sh4:164 running poem body, sh4:165 running poem body, sh4:166 running poem body, sh4:167 running poem body, Checked local gap for this detail · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII513:580 running text, VII513:581 running text, VII513:582 running text, VII513:583 running text, VII513 near v.583 · checked local gap for the additional detail
Moscow VIII p.349 · Mohl VI p.297 · Ganjoor §4:164 · Ganjoor §4:165 · Ganjoor §4:166 · Ganjoor §4:167 · Khaleghi VII p.513
In Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh the punishment is followed by a proclamation against taking even a straw and a command to pay for what is needed. English closely retains the scale of the offense and expands the rule into a direct prohibition on any intervention for the offender. It also makes fair payment explicit, which recovers the central issue of the woman’s complaint. Mohl adds a verse about the justice of the continuing march. The English names Damaghan as the destination, a specification that remains provisional here. The sequence embodies the commander’s earlier instructions through a public example whose violence makes the restoration of commercial order morally difficult.
61–66One mission answers two fears
Moscow VIII349:580,581,582 running text, VIII349:583 running text, VIII349:584 running text, VIII349:585 running text, VIII349:586 running text · VIII350:587 running text · Mohl VI298:599,600,601 running text, VI298:602 running text, VI298:603 running text, VI298:604 running text, VI298:605,606 running text · Ganjoor sh4:168, sh4:169, sh4:170 running poem body, sh4:171 running poem body, sh4:172 running poem body, sh4:173 running poem body, sh4:174, sh4:175 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII513:584,585 running text · VII514:586 running text, VII514:587 running text, VII514:588 running text, VII514:589 running text, VII514:590,591 running text
Moscow VIII p.349 · Moscow VIII p.350 · Mohl VI p.298 · Ganjoor §4:168 · Ganjoor §4:169 · Ganjoor §4:170 · Ganjoor §4:171 · Ganjoor §4:172 · Ganjoor §4:173 · Ganjoor §4:174 · Ganjoor §4:175 · Khaleghi VII p.513 · Khaleghi VII p.514
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh make Hormizd fear both Saveh’s forces and Bahram’s fortunes. English states these fears together and gives the moonrise to the interview with Kharrad. The repeated English questions about commanders and notable warriors slow down the commission long enough to make its observational task distinct from simple delivery of a letter. The following gift is itself part of the persuasive apparatus, not simply a sign of friendly feeling. In the Persian it is beyond counting. English keeps material scale as a contrast with the narrow purpose of the instructions, allowing one royal expedition to combine intelligence about men and an attempt to make another sovereign believe what is said.
67–72A confidential plan and a visible gift
Moscow VIII350:588,589 running text, VIII350:590 running text, VIII350:591 running text, VIII350:592 running text, VIII350:593 running text, VIII350:594 running text · Mohl VI298:607,608 running text, VI298:609,610 running text, VI298:611 running text, VI298:612 running text, VI298:613 running text, VI298:614 running text · Ganjoor sh4:176, sh4:177 running poem body, sh4:178 running poem body, sh4:179 running poem body, sh4:180 running poem body, sh4:181 running poem body, sh4:182 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII514:592,593 running text, VII514:594 running text, VII515:595 running text, VII515:596 running text, VII515:597 running text, VII515:598 running text
Moscow VIII p.350 · Mohl VI p.298 · Ganjoor §4:176 · Ganjoor §4:177 · Ganjoor §4:178 · Ganjoor §4:179 · Ganjoor §4:180 · Ganjoor §4:181 · Ganjoor §4:182 · Khaleghi VII p.514 · Khaleghi VII p.515
The four running accounts connect the Herat approach to recognizing Bahram’s force and keeping identity and purpose concealed while a trap is laid. Mohl supplies an explicit blessing in a separate verse. The English retains the blessing and turns the trap into a recognizable instruction to keep out of sight. Its second person and language of parley make the proposal more immediate, even as the precise allocation of who will lay the trap is less transparent than the Persian exchanges. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh then name Kharrad as the envoy who actually leaves. This permits a firm identification here, independent of the earlier order to summon Bahram.
73–78The encampment’s subject changes
Moscow VIII350:595 running text, VIII350:596 running text, VIII350:597 running text, VIII350:598 running text, VIII350:599,600 running text, VIII350:600 running text · Mohl VI298:615 running text, VI298:616 running text, VI298:617 running text, VI298:618 running text, VI298:619,620 running text, VI298:620 running text · Ganjoor sh4:183 running poem body, sh4:184 running poem body, sh4:185 running poem body, sh4:186 running poem body, sh4:187, sh4:188 running poem body, sh4:188 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII515:599 running text, VII515:600 running text, VII515:601 running text, VII515:602 running text, VII515:603,604 running text, VII515:604 running text
Moscow VIII p.350 · Mohl VI p.298 · Ganjoor §4:183 · Ganjoor §4:184 · Ganjoor §4:185 · Ganjoor §4:186 · Ganjoor §4:187 · Ganjoor §4:188 · Khaleghi VII p.515
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh send Kharrad first to Bahram and then to Saveh, where he embellishes the message. The person who pitches a pavilion near a stream is less explicitly named in Persian than the next line’s identification of the army the scouts see as Bahram’s. English specifies Saveh as the one who arrives and camps. It makes the next dispatch of outposts plausible, but changes how the adjacent couplets attach the pavilion to the approaching force. That change in subject is worth separating from the recurring riverbank and Herat imagery. It alters who has made the conspicuous new approach that the scouts must explain.
79–84The camp becomes evidence against the envoy
Moscow VIII350:601,602 running text, VIII350:602 running text, VIII350:603 running text · VIII351:604 running text, VIII351:605 running text, VIII351:606 running text, VIII351:607 running text · Mohl VI299:621,622 running text, VI299:622 running text, VI299:623,624 running text, VI299:625 running text, VI299:626 running text, VI299:627 running text · Ganjoor sh4:189, sh4:190 running poem body, sh4:190 running poem body, sh4:191, sh4:192 running poem body, sh4:193 running poem body, sh4:194 running poem body, sh4:195 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII515:605,606 running text, VII515:606 running text, VII515:607 running text · VII516:608 running text, VII516:609 running text, VII516:610 running text, VII516:611 running text
Moscow VIII p.350 · Moscow VIII p.351 · Mohl VI p.299 · Ganjoor §4:189 · Ganjoor §4:190 · Ganjoor §4:191 · Ganjoor §4:192 · Ganjoor §4:193 · Ganjoor §4:194 · Ganjoor §4:195 · Khaleghi VII p.515 · Khaleghi VII p.516
All four witnesses bring the scouts’ report to Saveh and have him accuse Kharrad of drawing him toward an Iranian army. The English first makes the report emphasize the pomp of the arrival, preparing for the king’s sense of a threat. It then calls the envoy Ahriman, where Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh characterize him by deceit and warn him about the fall that follows a height. The English named figure concentrates the insult, and the “doom” makes its implicit threat direct. The argument itself remains rooted in observable actions: an envoy’s proposal, a force in the Herat plain and tents that could equally show orderly passage or deliberate opposition.
85–90Plausible stories give the envoy time to leave
Moscow VIII351:608 running text, VIII351:609 running text, VIII351:610,611 running text, VIII351:612 running text, VIII351 near v.612 · checked local gap for the additional detail, VIII351:613 running text · Mohl VI299:628 running text, VI299:629 running text, VI299:630,631 running text, VI299:632 running text, VI299:633 running text, VI299:634 running text · Ganjoor sh4:196 running poem body, sh4:197 running poem body, sh4:198, sh4:199 running poem body, sh4:200 running poem body, Checked local gap for this additional verse, sh5:1 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII516:612 running text, VII516:613 running text, VII516:614,615 running text, VII516:616 running text, VII516 near v.616 · checked local gap for the additional detail, VII516:617 running text
Moscow VIII p.351 · Mohl VI p.299 · Ganjoor §4:196 · Ganjoor §4:197 · Ganjoor §4:198 · Ganjoor §4:199 · Ganjoor §4:200 · Ganjoor §5:1 · Khaleghi VII p.516
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh let Kharrad explain the force through several possible identities, including a frontier commander, a refugee and a protected trading venture. English preserves the plurality, a strategic choice because any one account could be tested and disproved. It also gives a concrete purpose to inspection. Mohl has a separate running verse proposing that a man identify the party. The other running texts move directly to Saveh’s assent after Kharrad’s rhetorical question about who could oppose the king. English broadens the proposal to an inquiry into intent. The extra time produced by a plausible answer is what the envoy needs before the danger of discovery returns.
91–96Night conceals two different missions
Moscow VIII351:613 running text · Saveh approves the explanation, VIII351:614 running text, VIII351:615 running text, VIII351:616 running text, VIII351:617,618 running text, VIII351:619,620 running text · Mohl VI299:634 running text · Saveh approves the explanation, VI299:635 running text, VI299:636 running text, VI299:637 running text, VI299:638,639 running text, VI299:640,641 running text · Ganjoor Checked local gap for this detail, sh5:2 running poem body, sh5:3 running poem body, sh5:4 running poem body, sh5:5, sh5:6 running poem body, sh5:7, sh5:8 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII516:617 running text · Saveh approves the explanation, VII516:618 running text, VII516:619 running text, VII517:620 running text, VII517:621,622 running text, VII517:623,624 running text
Moscow VIII p.351 · Mohl VI p.299 · Ganjoor §5:1 · Ganjoor §5:2 · Ganjoor §5:3 · Ganjoor §5:4 · Ganjoor §5:5 · Ganjoor §5:6 · Ganjoor §5:7 · Ganjoor §5:8 · Khaleghi VII p.516 · Khaleghi VII p.517
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh make Saveh approve the explanation, then Kharrad prepares to escape under darkness while the king sends his son. English supplies an explicit decision to scout as well as a midnight hour. The running texts give deepening night and call the son Faghfoor. English identifies him as Parmudeh, drawing the prince’s familiar name into a scene that introduces him by title. He sends a horseman ahead on reaching the Iranian army. That asymmetry is important to the passage: Kharrad needs darkness to leave unseen, whereas the prince’s man arrives openly with questions that announce the presence of his master.
97–102The son asks for a commander before asking for a cause
Moscow VIII351:621 running text, VIII351:622 running text, VIII352:623 running text, VIII352:624 running text, VIII352:625 running text, VIII352:626,627 running text · Mohl VI299:642 running text, VI299:643 running text, VI299:644 running text, VI299:645 running text, VI300:646 running text, VI300:647,648 running text · Ganjoor sh5:9 running poem body, sh5:10 running poem body, sh5:11 running poem body, sh5:12 running poem body, sh5:13 running poem body, sh5:14, sh5:15 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII517:625 running text, VII517:626 running text, VII517:627 running text, VII517:628 running text, VII517:629 running text, VII517:630,631 running text
Moscow VIII p.351 · Moscow VIII p.352 · Mohl VI p.299 · Mohl VI p.300 · Ganjoor §5:9 · Ganjoor §5:10 · Ganjoor §5:11 · Ganjoor §5:12 · Ganjoor §5:13 · Ganjoor §5:14 · Ganjoor §5:15 · Khaleghi VII p.517
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh give the rider’s questions about command, the prince’s wish to see the head of the force and Bahram’s appearance with a shining standard. The English makes the sequence impressive through the prince’s speedy approach and the banner above assembled men. In the Persian the prince immediately connects the meeting with a rumor of flight, offense and bloodshed from Pars. English emphasizes estrangement through a short reported phrase. This makes a question about station become a test of allegiance with little delay. The position of the banner in the narrative turns it from a gift conferred by Hormizd into visible evidence beside a still-unanswered question.
103–108The two inquiries meet in a missing envoy
Moscow VIII352:628 running text, VIII352:629 running text, VIII352:630 running text, VIII352:631 running text, VIII352:632,633 running text, VIII352:634,635 running text · Mohl VI300:649 running text, VI300:650 running text, VI300:651 running text, VI300:652 running text, VI300:653,654 running text, VI300:655,656 running text · Ganjoor sh5:16 running poem body, sh5:17 running poem body, sh5:18 running poem body, sh5:19 running poem body, sh5:20, sh5:21 running poem body, sh5:22, sh5:23 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII517:632 running text, VII518:633 running text, VII518:634 running text, VII518:635 running text, VII518:636,637 running text, VII518:638,639 running text
Moscow VIII p.352 · Mohl VI p.300 · Ganjoor §5:16 · Ganjoor §5:17 · Ganjoor §5:18 · Ganjoor §5:19 · Ganjoor §5:20 · Ganjoor §5:21 · Ganjoor §5:22 · Ganjoor §5:23 · Khaleghi VII p.517 · Khaleghi VII p.518
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh have Bahram deny enmity toward the Shah and say that he came from Baghdad by command. English gives the order a listed succession of weapons and an objective of driving the force back. This makes the answer unequivocal in the prince’s hearing. Once he carries it to Saveh, the court looks for Kharrad. The English preserves the quick change from an encounter between commanders to a search for the man who explained away the army. The two separate reports cannot now be reconciled. The prince’s account reveals that what passed for an open road was part of the trouble the king thought had been avoided.
109–109The sentries become the remaining question
Moscow VIII352:636 running text · Mohl VI300:657 running text · Ganjoor sh5:24 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VII518:640 running text
Moscow VIII p.352 · Mohl VI p.300 · Ganjoor §5:24 · Khaleghi VII p.518
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh end this exchange by asking why the outposts performed so poorly when darkness and a vast army should have made escape difficult. The English changes the rebuke into a question about letting the envoy slip from sight. This is an apt conclusion to a long sequence of deliberate observation. Saveh’s agents saw the Iranian troops and missed the single man whose departure would have made his deception unmistakable. At the next opening the four witnesses send a wholly new messenger to Bahram. The English chapter boundary therefore closes a failed search and leaves Saveh’s next response to the officer who can still be reached.
Source record and limits
F&R English
The 109 numbered couplets cover the commission of a recorder, the omen and attempted recall, the payment rule, Kharrad’s mission, and the inquiry that exposes his departure.
Moscow
Volume VIII p.345 v.518 through p.352 v.636. The recorder is a young Mehran. The route of the disciplined march is toward the territory of the Khuz.
Mohl
Volume VI p.295 v.535 through p.300 v.657. The recorder is an old Mehran. This edition includes a continuing just march, a blessing to be carried to Bahram and the proposed inspection of the travelers.
Ganjoor
Hormizd §4:106–200 and §5:1–24. The night inquiry crosses the online section break, while the next English chapter begins with the new emissary at §5:25.
Khaleghi-Motlagh
Volume VII p.508 v.522 through p.518 v.640. The edited text retains the young Mehran, the Khuz route and the rebuke for thinking the theft small. It uses the title Faghfoor for Saveh’s son.
Consequential readings
The identity of the recorder, Rey and Damaghan, the subject of the Herat arrival and the use of Parmudeh in the English involve distinct questions. The source comparison locates each.
Limits of the evidence
Nastooh as recorder, Damaghan as the immediate destination and the exact midnight hour lack direct local support. The English uses Parmudeh where the running verses use the title Faghfoor.
Moscow VIII p.345 · Moscow VIII p.346 · Moscow VIII p.347 · Moscow VIII p.348 · Moscow VIII p.349 · Moscow VIII p.350 · Moscow VIII p.351 · Moscow VIII p.352
Mohl VI p.295 · Mohl VI p.296 · Mohl VI p.297 · Mohl VI p.298 · Mohl VI p.299 · Mohl VI p.300
Khaleghi VII p.508 · Khaleghi VII p.509 · Khaleghi VII p.510 · Khaleghi VII p.511 · Khaleghi VII p.512 · Khaleghi VII p.513 · Khaleghi VII p.514 · Khaleghi VII p.515 · Khaleghi VII p.516 · Khaleghi VII p.517 · Khaleghi VII p.518
Selected printed readings
- Moscow VIII345:524 · Running text · مهران دبیر جوانست و گوینده و یادگیر
The young scribe is Mehran. - Mohl VI295:541 · Running text · مهران پیر بزرگست و گوینده و یادگیر
Mohl keeps the name and changes the age. - Moscow VIII348:567 · Running text · همیرفت تا کشور خوزیان
The route names the country of the Khuz. - Khaleghi VII513:578 · Running text · که این جرم چونین شمردی تو خرد؟
The commander asks whether the offense seemed small. - Mohl VI297:598 · Running text · همی راند با داد بر ره سپاه
The march continues under the rule of justice. - Mohl VI298:610 · Running text · که پیروز بادی و روشنروان
The blessing is explicit. - Mohl VI299:633 · Running text · فرستم یکی مرد نزدیک اوی
The proposal to send someone is explicit. - Khaleghi VII517:620 · Running text · به فغفور فرمود تا بیسپاه
The son is identified by the title Faghfoor.
E5.7 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | VIII345:518 running text | VI295:535 running text |
| 2 | VIII345:519 running text | VI295:536 running text |
| 3 | VIII345:520 running text | VI295:537 running text |
| 4 | VIII345:521 running text | VI295:538 running text |
| 5 | VIII345:522 running text | VI295:539 running text |
| 6 | VIII345:523 running text | VI295:540 running text |
| 7 | VIII345:524 running text | VI295:541 running text |
| 8 | VIII346:525 running text | VI295:542 running text |
| 9 | VIII346:526 running text | VI295:543 running text |
| 10 | VIII346:527 running text | VI295:544 running text |
| 11 | VIII346:528 running text | VI295:545,546 running text |
| 12 | VIII346:528,529 running text | VI295:546,547 running text |
| 13 | VIII346:530 running text | VI295:548 running text |
| 14 | VIII346:531,532 running text | VI296:549,550 running text |
| 15 | VIII346:533 running text | VI296:551 running text |
| 16 | VIII346:534 running text | VI296:552 running text |
| 17 | VIII346:535 running text | VI296:553 running text |
| 18 | VIII346:536 running text | VI296:554 running text |
| 19 | VIII346:537 running text | VI296:555 running text |
| 20 | VIII346:538,539 running text | VI296:556,557 running text |
| 21 | VIII347:540 running text | VI296:558 running text |
| 22 | VIII347:541 running text | VI296:559 running text |
| 23 | VIII347:542,543 running text | VI296:560,561 running text |
| 24 | VIII347:543 running text | VI296:561 running text |
| 25 | VIII347:544 running text | VI296:562 running text |
| 26 | VIII347:545,546 running text | VI296:563,564 running text |
| 27 | VIII347:546 running text | VI296:564 running text |
| 28 | VIII347:547 running text | VI296:565 running text |
| 29 | VIII347:548,549 running text | VI296:566,567 running text |
| 30 | VIII347:549 running text | VI296:567 running text |
| 31 | VIII347:550 running text | VI296:568 running text |
| 32 | VIII347:551,552 running text | VI296:569,570 running text |
| 33 | VIII347:553 running text | VI296:571 running text |
| 34 | VIII347:554 running text · VIII348:555 running text · VIII p.348 | VI296:572,573 running text |
| 35 | VIII348:556 running text | VI297:574 running text |
| 36 | VIII348:557 running text | VI297:575 running text |
| 37 | VIII348:558 running text | VI297:576 running text |
| 38 | VIII348:558,559 running text | VI297:576,577 running text |
| 39 | VIII348:560 running text | VI297:578 running text |
| 40 | VIII348:561 running text | VI297:579 running text |
| 41 | VIII348:562 running text | VI297:580 running text |
| 42 | VIII348:563 running text | VI297:581 running text |
| 43 | VIII348:564 running text | VI297:582 running text |
| 44 | VIII348:565 running text | VI297:583 running text |
| 45 | VIII348:566 running text | VI297:584 running text |
| 46 | VIII348:567 running text | VI297:585 running text |
| 47 | VIII348:568 running text | VI297:586 running text |
| 48 | VIII348:569 running text | VI297:587 running text |
| 49 | VIII348:570 running text | VI297:588 running text |
| 50 | VIII348:571 running text | VI297:589 running text |
| 51 | VIII348:572 running text | VI297:590 running text |
| 52 | VIII349:573 running text | VI297:591 running text |
| 53 | VIII349:574 running text | VI297:592 running text |
| 54 | VIII349:575 running text | VI297:593 running text |
| 55 | VIII349:576 running text | VI297:594 running text |
| 56 | VIII349:577 running text | VI297:595 running text |
| 57 | VIII349:578 running text | VI297:596 running text |
| 58 | VIII349:579 running text | VI297:597 running text |
| 59 | VIII349:579 running text | VI297:597 running text |
| 60 | VIII349 near v.579 · checked local gap for the additional detail | VI297:598 running text · resumed march, with no named destination here |
| 61 | VIII349:580,581,582 running text | VI298:599,600,601 running text |
| 62 | VIII349:583 running text | VI298:602 running text |
| 63 | VIII349:584 running text | VI298:603 running text |
| 64 | VIII349:585 running text | VI298:604 running text |
| 65 | VIII349:585 running text | VI298:604 running text |
| 66 | VIII349:586 running text · VIII350:587 running text · VIII p.350 | VI298:605,606 running text |
| 67 | VIII350:588,589 running text | VI298:607,608 running text |
| 68 | VIII350:590 running text | VI298:609,610 running text |
| 69 | VIII350:591 running text | VI298:611 running text |
| 70 | VIII350:592 running text | VI298:612 running text |
| 71 | VIII350:593 running text | VI298:613 running text |
| 72 | VIII350:594 running text | VI298:614 running text |
| 73 | VIII350:595 running text | VI298:615 running text |
| 74 | VIII350:596 running text | VI298:616 running text |
| 75 | VIII350:597 running text | VI298:617 running text |
| 76 | VIII350:598 running text | VI298:618 running text |
| 77 | VIII350:599,600 running text | VI298:619,620 running text |
| 78 | VIII350:600 running text | VI298:620 running text |
| 79 | VIII350:601,602 running text | VI299:621,622 running text |
| 80 | VIII350:602 running text | VI299:622 running text |
| 81 | VIII350:603 running text · VIII351:604 running text · VIII p.351 | VI299:623,624 running text |
| 82 | VIII351:605 running text | VI299:625 running text |
| 83 | VIII351:606 running text | VI299:626 running text |
| 84 | VIII351:607 running text | VI299:627 running text |
| 85 | VIII351:608 running text | VI299:628 running text |
| 86 | VIII351:609 running text | VI299:629 running text |
| 87 | VIII351:610,611 running text | VI299:630,631 running text |
| 88 | VIII351:612 running text | VI299:632 running text |
| 89 | VIII351 near v.612 · checked local gap for the additional detail | VI299:633 running text |
| 90 | VIII351:613 running text | VI299:634 running text |
| 91 | VIII351:613 running text · Saveh approves the explanation | VI299:634 running text · Saveh approves the explanation |
| 92 | VIII351:614 running text | VI299:635 running text |
| 93 | VIII351:615 running text | VI299:636 running text |
| 94 | VIII351:616 running text | VI299:637 running text |
| 95 | VIII351:617,618 running text | VI299:638,639 running text |
| 96 | VIII351:619,620 running text | VI299:640,641 running text |
| 97 | VIII351:621 running text | VI299:642 running text |
| 98 | VIII351:622 running text | VI299:643 running text |
| 99 | VIII352:623 running text | VI299:644 running text |
| 100 | VIII352:624 running text | VI299:645 running text |
| 101 | VIII352:625 running text | VI300:646 running text |
| 102 | VIII352:626,627 running text | VI300:647,648 running text |
| 103 | VIII352:628 running text | VI300:649 running text |
| 104 | VIII352:629 running text | VI300:650 running text |
| 105 | VIII352:630 running text | VI300:651 running text |
| 106 | VIII352:631 running text | VI300:652 running text |
| 107 | VIII352:632,633 running text | VI300:653,654 running text |
| 108 | VIII352:634,635 running text | VI300:655,656 running text |
| 109 | VIII352:636 running text | VI300:657 running text |
New Naqqali