Viseh Finds His Son Slain
Viseh encounters his son’s body before meeting Gharan. Grief motivates the pursuit but does not decide its result.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | Viseh encounters his son’s body before meeting Gharan. Grief motivates the pursuit but does not decide its result. |
| Moscow | Volume II contains Nohzar and Zav as separately listed reigns. Running text and apparatus readings for this passage remain unverified. |
| Mohl | The corresponding episode falls in the continuous Nohzar text, vol. I pp. 192–217. Local variants in this passage are unverified. |
| Ganjoor | 23 couplets in the corresponding digital section. |
| Khaleghi | The corresponding episode falls in the Nohzar text, vol. I pp. 285–322. Local apparatus readings in this passage are unverified. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the running reference. A labeled Mohl supplement supplies the accession oath. Select a number to open its note.
Narrative and poetic form
Viseh encounters his son’s body before meeting Gharan. Grief motivates the pursuit but does not decide its result.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–8A father finds the body
Moscow II vv. 327–330, Mohl I vv. 371–377, Ganjoor n8.1–4 and Khaleghi I p. 307 give Viseh finding his son among the fallen. Mohl puts the torn standard, overturned drum and colored shroud before the other dead chiefs. Moscow records that order in its apparatus, while its running text, Ganjoor and Khaleghi put the chiefs first. Mohl also prints the fuller grief and pursuit, with parallels in Moscow’s apparatus.
English follows Mohl’s progression from the son’s surroundings to the wider loss. The tulip-red shroud and yellow face arrest the action before the tears and cloudlike charge start it again. The extra couplets make pursuit grow directly from what the father sees.
9–15The banner comes into view
Moscow II vv. 331–336, Mohl I vv. 378–382, Ganjoor n8.5–10 and Khaleghi I pp. 307–308 move from word of Viseh’s approach to the Arabian mounts sent toward Nimruz and the black banner emerging through dust. Moscow brackets a separate line about Viseh rushing to Pars in grief, which Ganjoor also gives.
English names Gharan as the sender of the Tazi mounts, keeping responsibility clear during the changes in viewpoint. It also lets the banner appear before explicitly identifying Viseh at the head of his army. The sequence lets readers first know the force by report, then recognize it from what Gharan can see across the plain.
16–18Viseh claims the king’s territory
Moscow II vv. 337–340, Mohl I vv. 383–386, Ganjoor n8.11–14 and Khaleghi I p. 308 give Viseh’s taunt over the lost crown and the captive Shah. Moscow brackets the speech. Mohl names Ghaznin, which Moscow records in its apparatus. Moscow’s running text, Ganjoor and Khaleghi give Bost or Darest forms instead.
The English follows Mohl in naming Ghaznin and makes the palace markings “royal signs,” so the claim to control territory reads as a claim to rule. Viseh’s question about shelter then reduces that sweep of place names to a single practical challenge for Gharan. The speech presents possession through Viseh’s boast, whose certainty the ensuing combat tests.
19–21Gharan casts his felt into the stream
Moscow II vv. 341–343, Mohl I vv. 387–390, Ganjoor n8.15–17 and Khaleghi I p. 308 give the felt cast into running water and Gharan’s denial that fear drove him away. Moscow brackets the reply. Mohl also prints a further challenge to demonstrate prowess.
The English keeps the unusual felt image and adds “chose my way.” The addition makes the image intelligible in context as an assertion that Gharan acted on his own terms. The answer then moves from his reasons for leaving to what he did to Barman. Compressing the renewed challenge lets the turn from the son to the father end the speech.
22–26Victory without pursuit
Moscow II vv. 344–349, Mohl I vv. 391–397, Ganjoor n8.18–23 and Khaleghi I pp. 308–309 give the obscured moon, river of blood, Viseh’s retreat and Gharan’s refusal to follow. Mohl alone among these running texts explicitly sounds the karnay before the dust. The return to Afrasiab closes the episode with Viseh’s tears.
English uses Mohl’s horn to begin the clash and later gives the reversal to Viseh’s star. “Gharan pursued no field” preserves the decision against pursuit, though its wording is less direct than the Persian statement that he did not follow Viseh. The tears bring the scene back to the father who found Barman, so the episode closes on grief after giving Gharan the military victory.
Chapter source record
B1.8 · Printed verse collation
Running text checked directly in Moscow II pp. 27–29, vv. 327–349, and Mohl I pp. 207–208, vv. 371–397. A dash marks a gap at the corresponding point in the running text. Apparatus references are selective. Shared ranges record correspondences across multiple couplets.
Moscow scan · Mohl scan| English | Moscow II verse | Mohl I verse | Correspondence |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 327 | 371 | Viseh sets out with the Turanian army. Moscow explicitly characterizes the force as seeking vengeance. |
| 2 | 328 | 372 | Before reaching Gharan, Viseh finds his son slain and cast down. |
| 3 | 328–330 and p. 28 n. 5 | 372–374 | Both give the fallen son, torn standard, overturned koust, tulip-colored shroud and other fallen Turanians. Mohl puts the standard and shroud before the other fallen chiefs, as English does. Moscow prints the chiefs first, and records the reverse order for witnesses I and VI. |
| 4 | 328–330 and p. 28 n. 5 | 372–374 | Both give the fallen son, torn standard, overturned koust, tulip-colored shroud and other fallen Turanians. Mohl puts the standard and shroud before the other fallen chiefs, as English does. Moscow prints the chiefs first, and records the reverse order for witnesses I and VI. |
| 5 | 328–330 and p. 28 n. 5 | 372–374 | Both give the fallen son, torn standard, overturned koust, tulip-colored shroud and other fallen Turanians. Mohl puts the standard and shroud before the other fallen chiefs, as English does. Moscow prints the chiefs first, and records the reverse order for witnesses I and VI. |
| 6 | p. 27 n. 21, continued on p. 28, and p. 28 n. 3 | 375–377 | Mohl prints Viseh’s grief, hot tears and cloudlike pursuit in consecutive verses. Moscow records the grief and tears as a witness VI addition and the moving-cloud image in a related witness I addition. |
| 7 | p. 27 n. 21, continued on p. 28, and p. 28 n. 3 | 375–377 | Mohl prints Viseh’s grief, hot tears and cloudlike pursuit in consecutive verses. Moscow records the grief and tears as a witness VI addition and the moving-cloud image in a related witness I addition. |
| 8 | p. 27 n. 21, continued on p. 28, and p. 28 n. 3 | 375–377 | Mohl prints Viseh’s grief, hot tears and cloudlike pursuit in consecutive verses. Moscow records the grief and tears as a witness VI addition and the moving-cloud image in a related witness I addition. |
| 9 | 331 | 378 | Gharan receives word of Viseh’s approach. The news credits Viseh with victory and farr. |
| 10 | 332 | 379 | Swift Arabian mounts are dispatched toward Nimruz. The English names Gharan explicitly as the sender. |
| 11 | 334 | 380 | Gharan comes from Pars onto the plain and sees the rising dust to his left. Moscow v. 333, bracketed, separately describes Viseh rushing toward Pars in grief for his son. |
| 12 | 334 | 380 | Gharan comes from Pars onto the plain and sees the rising dust to his left. Moscow v. 333, bracketed, separately describes Viseh rushing toward Pars in grief for his son. |
| 13 | 335 | 381 | The black banner and the Turanian commander emerge from the dust. |
| 14 | 335 | 381 | The black banner and the Turanian commander emerge from the dust. |
| 15 | 336 | 382 | Both forces form their ranks and the warriors advance. |
| 16 | 337 [bracketed] | 383 | Viseh calls from the center that the crown and throne have gone to the wind. Moscow brackets this speech sequence. |
| 17 | 338–339 [bracketed] and p. 28 n. 21 | 384–385 | Both give Ghanooj, the Kabul border and Zabulistan, then claim the palaces bear their marks. Mohl explicitly names Ghaznin. Moscow’s running text names Darest, with Ghaznin in the apparatus reading of witnesses I and IV. |
| 18 | 340 [bracketed] | 386 | Viseh asks where Gharan can find refuge now that the Shah is captive. |
| 19 | 341 [bracketed] | 387 | Both give Gharan’s image of casting his felt into running water. |
| 20 | 342 [bracketed] | 388 | Gharan says he did not leave through fear or talk and came against Viseh’s son. |
| 21 | 343 [bracketed] | 389–390 | Gharan says he has rid himself of his enemy and now offers Viseh battle. Mohl prints a further challenge to prove their prowess, which has no separate English couplet. |
| 22 | 344 | 391–392 | Mohl explicitly gives the horses urged forward and the karnay sounding, then the dust and darkened moon. Moscow’s running text gives the dust and darkened sky and moon. |
| 23 | 345 | 393 | The forces meet and blood runs like a river. |
| 24 | 346 | 394 | Gharan advances against Viseh, who turns away in battle. |
| 25 | 347–348 | 395–396 | Many are killed, Viseh is bewildered by the reversal of his fortune, and Gharan does not follow him. |
| 26 | 349 | 397 | Viseh returns to Afrasiab in tears. Moscow explicitly attributes the tears to grief for his son. |
New Naqqali