Praise for Sultan Mahmud
Published index C4.1 Praise for Sultan Mahmud,102 couplets;next C4.2 Kay Khosrow Musters against Afrasiab. C4 section64 chapters/3152 published couplets;only C4.1 analyzed here.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | C4 section64 chapters/3152 published couplets;only C4.1 analyzed here. |
| Moscow | V235–240 physical95 main units, plus individually printed additions237n19,237n23,238n12 and cited variants. Nasr/fifty-seven/affirmative listening main. |
| Mohl | New Persian volumeIV printed3–7(PDF9–13),98 main units. Fazl/fifty-eight/intoxication,negative future listening,brocade main. Physical row locators count Persian running couplets from each printed page top, excluding headings and apparatus. Moscow V235:L1–L8,236:L1–L21,237:L1–L16,238:L1–L19,239:L1–L17,240:L1–L14 =95 main units. Moscow opening margin numbering is not certified as a continuous sequence; physical row locators are authoritative here. Mohl IV3:L1–L8,4:L1–L25,5:L1–L25,6:L1–L25,7:L1–L15 =98 main units. New Mohl IV printed3=PDF9; offset6 independently checked. Khaleghi IV169–176:1–94, PDF185–192; offset16. Moscow offset0. |
| Ganjoor | mahmood/sh1:1–95 body;comments excluded.95 main units. Local gaps for English46,48,55/56 and S2. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | IV169–176:1–94(PDF185–192),94 main units. Fazl/fifty-eight/affirmative hearing main. English77–80 in actual174n11 and89 in actual175n8;English46 checked local main gap. S1 and S2 main. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6Royal possessions and the speaking treasury
English 1–6; individual edition locators and evidence classes below.
Moscow V235:L1 running text · Mohl IV3:L1 running text · Khaleghi IV169:1 running text · Ganjoor sh1:1 running body · Moscow V235:L4 running text · Mohl IV3:L2 running text · Khaleghi IV169:2 running text · Ganjoor sh1:4 running body · Ganjoor sh1:4 running body · Moscow V235:L2 running text · Mohl IV3:L3 running text · Khaleghi IV169:3 running text · Ganjoor sh1:2 running body · Moscow V235:L3 running text · Mohl IV3:L4 running text · Khaleghi IV169:4 running text · Ganjoor sh1:3 running body · Moscow V235:L5 running text · Mohl IV3:L5 running text · Khaleghi IV170:5 running text · Ganjoor sh1:5 running body
The opening makes insignia receive their dignity from the king, establishing a person as the source of institutional splendor. Moscow and Ganjoor put the lordship inventory after the treasury and sea-to-sea dominion; Mohl and Khaleghi put it immediately after the blessing, as the English does. The English divides that inventory into two couplets, first wealth and fame, then sword, armor and toil. This gives practical burden equal prominence with possession. The groaning treasury remains a lively personification: generosity places a demand upon wealth rather than merely displaying its abundance. The hidden gold also acknowledges royal bounty. Those extravagant images belong to the praise rhetoric attested by all four presentations; they do not independently establish the territorial extent or finances of Mahmud's reign.
7–12Feast, battle and cultivated reason
English 7–12; individual edition locators and evidence classes below.
Moscow V236:L2 running text · Mohl IV3:L6 running text · Khaleghi IV170:8 running text · Ganjoor sh1:10 running body · Moscow V235:L6 running text · Mohl IV3:L7 running text · Khaleghi IV170:6 running text · Ganjoor sh1:6 running body · Moscow V235:L7 running text · Mohl IV3:L8 running text · Khaleghi IV172:38 running text · Ganjoor sh1:7 running body · Moscow V235:L8 running text · Mohl IV4:L1 running text · Khaleghi IV172:39 running text · Ganjoor sh1:8 running body · Moscow V236:L1 running text · Mohl IV4:L2 running text · Khaleghi IV170:7 running text · Ganjoor sh1:9 running body · Moscow V236:L3 running text · Mohl IV4:L3 running text · Khaleghi IV170:9 running text · Ganjoor sh1:11 running body
Mohl places taking from enemies and giving to friends before the feast-and-battle contrast; Moscow and Ganjoor place it after conquest's upheaval, and Khaleghi follows that later position. The English follows Mohl's movement from distribution to contrasting royal activities. Khaleghi's battle half increases treasure, whereas the toil wording in the other three presentations supports the English's physical burden. Faith and reason then grow like branches. Khaleghi relocates that pair of virtues and divine refuge after the hoped-for patron's qualifications, and nourishes the soul where the others nourish wisdom. The English root image develops the botanical figure coherently. Its Day of Doom renders the upheaval as an overwhelming experience, and lasting name states the reputational purpose that links warfare to jewel-scattering generosity.
13–18Witnesses and restrained wrath
English 13–18; individual edition locators and evidence classes below.
Moscow V236:L4 running text · Mohl IV4:L4 running text · Khaleghi IV170:10 running text · Ganjoor sh1:12 running body · Moscow V236:L5 running text · Mohl IV4:L5 running text · Khaleghi IV170:11 running text · Ganjoor sh1:13 running body · Ganjoor sh1:13 running body · Moscow V236:L6 running text · Mohl IV4:L6 running text · Khaleghi IV170:12 running text · Ganjoor sh1:14 running body · Moscow V236:L7 running text; actual V236n12 negative condition · Mohl IV4:L7 running text · Khaleghi IV170:13 running text; negative condition · Ganjoor sh1:15 running body · Moscow V236:L8 running text · Mohl IV4:L8 running text · Khaleghi IV170:15 running text · Ganjoor sh1:16 running body
Earth, water and sun testify in a single Persian couplet across the four sources; the English expands it into two, drawing peerlessness and martial valor from the following unit. The expansion produces a cosmic courtroom before the catalogue of virtues. The conditional about mercy deserves closer attention. Mohl and Khaleghi print the negative condition, and Moscow records the negative in its actual apparatus, while Moscow's main text and Ganjoor print positive mixing. The English's mercy restraining wrath therefore has direct textual support, but is not a neutral rendering of every displayed reading. Its stars fleeing anger and wind excluded by packed ranks make royal force perceptible at opposite scales. These hyperboles give grandeur to the scene without requiring literal astronomical or military measurements.
19–24Elephants, tribute and the armored mountain
English 19–24; individual edition locators and evidence classes below.
Moscow V236:L9 running text · Mohl IV4:L9 running text · Khaleghi IV170:16 running text · Ganjoor sh1:17 running body · Moscow V236:L9 running text; V236:L10 running text · Mohl IV4:L9 running text; IV4:L10 running text · Khaleghi IV170:14 running text; IV170:16 running text · Ganjoor sh1:17 running body; sh1:18 running body · Moscow V236:L11 running text · Mohl IV4:L11 running text · Khaleghi IV170:17 running text · Ganjoor sh1:19 running body · Moscow V236:L12 running text · Mohl IV4:L12 running text · Khaleghi IV170:18 running text · Ganjoor sh1:20 running body · Moscow V236:L13 running text · Mohl IV4:L13 running text · Khaleghi IV170:19 running text · Ganjoor sh1:21 running body · Moscow V236:L14 running text · Mohl IV4:L14 running text · Khaleghi IV170:20 running text · Ganjoor sh1:22 running body
The seven hundred elephants and divine helpers occupy one source couplet; tribute occupies another. The English redistributes their material so the elephants receive a complete visual couplet and God and Gabriel introduce the tribute claim. Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor support the source sequence, while Khaleghi moves tribute before the dense ranks and elephants. The English preserves the number but its mighty size elaborates the description. In the armored-mountain image, Mohl's world-throne supplies the English's throne, whereas Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi illuminate the world at the feast. This difference matters because the English turns a contrast between feasting and fighting into a contrast between royal seat and martial body. The wild ass seized from a lion then exemplifies daring through a concrete predatory contest.
25–30Kingship spread like a carpet
English 25–30; individual edition locators and evidence classes below.
Moscow V236:L15 running text · Mohl IV4:L15 running text · Khaleghi IV171:21 running text · Ganjoor sh1:23 running body · Moscow V236:L16 running text · Mohl IV4:L16 running text · Khaleghi IV171:22 running text · Ganjoor sh1:24 running body · Moscow V236:L17 running text · Mohl IV4:L17 running text · Khaleghi IV171:23 running text · Ganjoor sh1:25 running body · Moscow V236:L18 running text · Mohl IV4:L18 running text · Khaleghi IV171:24 running text · Ganjoor sh1:26 running body · Moscow V236:L19 running text · Mohl IV4:L19 running text · Khaleghi IV171:25 running text · Ganjoor sh1:27 running body · Moscow V236:L20 running text · Mohl IV4:L20 running text · Khaleghi IV171:26 running text · Ganjoor sh1:28 running body
All four presentations move from Mahmud's defeat of proud chiefs into blessings, heavenly ornament and the giving cloud. The English keeps the optative force of perpetual kingship: these lines wish for endurance rather than report it. Its cloud raining gifts makes the feast's liberality visible and continues the earlier sea metaphor. The administrative list is less uniform. Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor name a minister, while Khaleghi's main wording names a treasurer. English ministers broadens a singular office into a governing establishment. The carpet spread across the world provides a transition from expansive royal praise to a particular official's seat. The English possessive sign makes the connection to royal authority explicit, preparing the named minister without treating the carpet as a documented physical object.
31–36The minister and the poem's completion
English 31–36; individual edition locators and evidence classes below.
Moscow V236:L21 running text; Nasr main; actual V236n30 Fazl · Mohl IV4:L21 running text · Khaleghi IV171:27 running text; Fazl main; actual IV171n13 Nasr · Ganjoor sh1:29 running body · Moscow V237:L1 running text · Mohl IV4:L22 running text · Khaleghi IV171:28 running text · Ganjoor sh1:30 running body · Moscow V237:L2 running text · Mohl IV4:L23 running text · Khaleghi IV171:29 running text · Ganjoor sh1:31 running body · Moscow V237:L3 running text · Mohl IV4:L24 running text · Khaleghi IV171:30 running text · Ganjoor sh1:32 running body · Moscow V237:L4 running text; completed labor · Mohl IV4:L25 running text · Khaleghi IV171:31 running text; prospective main; actual IV171n22 past arrival · Ganjoor sh1:33 running body · Moscow V237:L5 running text · Mohl IV5:L1 running text · Khaleghi IV171:32 running text · Ganjoor sh1:34 running body
The official is Fazl ibn Ahmad in Mohl and Khaleghi, and Fazl appears in Moscow's actual name variant; Moscow's running text and Ganjoor instead have Nasr ibn Ahmad. The English thus follows an attested reading, not an unsupported substitution. No further historical identification is needed to explain its choice. The following ethical portrait connects open speech, generosity and clean hands with service to a God-worshipping ruler. English coordinates service to God and king, making the religious relationship more direct. Its completed labor agrees with the past achievement in Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor, whereas Khaleghi's main verb looks toward fruition and records the past reading in its apparatus. The ancient book then establishes an inherited source of authority distinct from the patron's material encouragement.
37–42Old-age reward and an accessible patron
English 37–42; individual edition locators and evidence classes below.
Moscow V237:L6 running text · Mohl IV5:L2 running text · Khaleghi IV171:33 running text · Ganjoor sh1:35 running body · Moscow V237:L7 running text · Mohl IV5:L3 running text · Khaleghi IV171:34 running text · Ganjoor sh1:36 running body · Moscow V237:L8 running text · Mohl IV5:L4 running text · Khaleghi IV171:35 running text · Ganjoor sh1:37 running body · Moscow V237:L9 running text · Mohl IV5:L5 running text · Khaleghi IV172:36 running text · Ganjoor sh1:38 running body · Moscow V237:L10 running text · Mohl IV5:L6 running text · Khaleghi IV172:37 running text · Ganjoor sh1:39 running body · Moscow V237:L11 running text · Mohl IV5:L7 running text · Khaleghi IV172:40 running text · Ganjoor sh1:40 running body
Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor connect the poet's expected reward with an absent generous ruler on the royal throne; Khaleghi retains the expectation but describes the sought lord through lofty generosity rather than the same throne formulation. The English openly preserves the promised coins, honor and crown. That candor gives the later appeal for support a material basis instead of turning patronage into disembodied admiration. Bounty needing no key becomes a door that never needs unlocking, a small explanatory addition that makes access immediate. All four sources then join guardianship of faith and kingship with martial competence and understanding of questions. The English cause and reason expands that questioning idiom intelligibly. Poverty over sixty-five years provides the personal pressure behind this otherwise ideal portrait.
43–48Ages, bodily change and the proclamation
English 43–48; individual edition locators and evidence classes below.
Moscow V237:L12 running text; decline main · Mohl IV5:L8 running text · Khaleghi IV172:41 running text; decline main; actual IV172n11 sixty-six/intoxication variant · Ganjoor sh1:41 running body · Moscow V237:L13 running text · Mohl IV5:L9 running text · Khaleghi IV172:42 running text · Ganjoor sh1:42 running body · Ganjoor sh1:42 running body · Moscow actual V237n19 full addition; checked main gap V237:L13–L14 · Mohl IV5:L10 running text · Khaleghi IV172:42–43 checked main gap; IV172n12 inspected, no full addition printed there · Ganjoor checked sh1:42–43 local body gap · Moscow V237:L14 running text; fifty-seven main; actual V237n21 eight variant · Mohl IV5:L11 running text · Khaleghi IV172:43 running text; fifty-eight main · Ganjoor sh1:43 running body · Moscow actual V237n23 first full addition; checked main gap V237:L14–L15 · Mohl IV5:L12 running text · Khaleghi IV172:44 running text · Ganjoor checked sh1:43–44 local body gap
The English preserves competing age statements rather than smoothing them into a biography. Mohl supplies the intoxication wording associated with sixty-six; Moscow and Ganjoor describe decline, and Khaleghi prints decline in its main text but records the intoxication variant in its actual apparatus. Fifty-eight follows Mohl and Khaleghi, against Moscow and Ganjoor's fifty-seven, with eight recorded in Moscow's variant. The split complexion-and-hair couplet gives tulip, straw, musk and camphor their own space. Bent stature and failing vision are Mohl running text and a fully printed Moscow addition; they are checked local main-text gaps in Ganjoor and Khaleghi. The proclamation is Mohl and Khaleghi main text and actual Moscow apparatus. Khaleghi additionally asks who has news of Fereydoon, recorded separately as source-only material.
49–54Fereydoon renewed and the listening ear
English 49–54; individual edition locators and evidence classes below.
Moscow V237:L15 running text · Mohl IV5:L13 running text · Khaleghi IV172:46 running text · Ganjoor sh1:44 running body · Moscow V237:L16 running text · Mohl IV5:L14 running text · Khaleghi IV172:47 running text · Ganjoor sh1:45 running body · Moscow V238:L1 running text · Mohl IV5:L15 running text · Khaleghi IV172:48 running text · Ganjoor sh1:46 running body · Moscow V238:L2 running text; affirmative listening · Mohl IV5:L16 running text; negative future refusal to listen · Khaleghi IV172:49 running text; affirmative listening · Ganjoor sh1:47 running body · Moscow V238:L3 running text · Mohl IV5:L17 running text · Khaleghi IV172:50 running text · Ganjoor sh1:48 running body · Moscow V238:L6 running text · Mohl IV5:L18 running text · Khaleghi IV173:51 running text · Ganjoor sh1:51 running body
The revived Fereydoon is a figure within praise of the contemporary ruler. English quotation marks help readers hear a proclamation rather than mistake the passage for the epic hero's literal return. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi share justice, generosity and enduring roots in the surrounding praise, but they do not agree about the listening ear. Mohl prints a negative future refusal to lend an ear; Moscow and Ganjoor describe attentive hearing, and Khaleghi also prints affirmative attention. The English therefore has direct affirmative support while departing from Mohl at this crucial verb. Its naming of the poem for the patron remains common. The old-age support request follows Mohl and Khaleghi's earlier placement, making patronal assistance immediately answer the poet's expressed bodily need.
55–60Finishing the story before death
English 55–60; individual edition locators and evidence classes below.
Moscow actual V238n12 first full addition; checked main after V238:L6 · Mohl IV5:L19 running text · Khaleghi IV173:52 running text · Ganjoor checked sh1:48–49 local body gap · Moscow actual V238n12 second full addition; checked main after V238:L6 · Mohl IV5:L20 running text · Khaleghi IV173:53 running text · Ganjoor checked sh1:48–49 local body gap · Moscow V238:L4 running text · Mohl IV5:L21 running text · Khaleghi IV173:54 running text · Ganjoor sh1:49 running body · Moscow V238:L5 running text · Mohl IV5:L22 running text · Khaleghi IV173:55 running text · Ganjoor sh1:50 running body · Moscow V238:L7 running text · Mohl IV5:L23 running text · Khaleghi IV173:56 running text · Ganjoor sh1:52 running body · Moscow V238:L8 running text · Mohl IV5:L24 running text · Khaleghi IV173:57 running text · Ganjoor sh1:53 running body
The prayer to remain unharmed and tell the story without concealment is running text in Mohl and Khaleghi. Moscow prints both couplets fully in its actual addition, while Ganjoor has a checked local gap between dedication and bodily dissolution. The English's omitting nothing expresses that aspiration to completeness without establishing that every surviving manuscript passage is included. Body returning to earth and soul to a pure source occur across all four presentations, though Moscow and Ganjoor place them earlier. Worthless adds self-depreciation not required by their body wording. The following lord-of-the-world title agrees with Mohl and Khaleghi; Moscow's Nasir wording and Ganjoor's spear-giving wording remain distinct. The territorial titles and freedom from blame continue panegyric claims, not independently verified political boundaries.
61–66Voice, need and the generous feast
English 61–66; individual edition locators and evidence classes below.
Moscow V238:L9 running text · Mohl IV5:L25 running text · Khaleghi IV173:58 running text · Ganjoor sh1:54 running body · Ganjoor sh1:54 running body · Moscow V238:L11 running text · Mohl IV6:L1 running text · Khaleghi IV173:60 running text · Ganjoor sh1:56 running body · Moscow V238:L12 running text · Mohl IV6:L2 running text · Khaleghi IV173:61 running text · Ganjoor sh1:57 running body · Moscow V238:L13 running text · Mohl IV6:L3 running text · Khaleghi IV173:62 running text · Ganjoor sh1:58 running body · Moscow V238:L10 running text · Mohl IV6:L4 running text · Khaleghi IV173:59 running text · Ganjoor sh1:55 running body
One Persian couplet makes the ruler's voice rend mountain stone, the sea creature and the leopard. The English expands it into two, first dwelling on rocky masses, then carrying the same destructive force into sea and land. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi attest the shared image; the animal name is preserved without imposing one modern zoological identification. The next praise and request expose the purpose of this scale: the poet hopes for relief from want and standing among nobles. The English follows Mohl in placing the dinar-and-dust comparison after the blessing on fortune; the other three place it before the sunlike king. That arrangement closes the sequence on the ease of giving, making the requested aid seem proportionate to the patron's professed abundance.
67–72Praise and the palace of verse
English 67–72; individual edition locators and evidence classes below.
Moscow V238:L14 running text · Mohl IV6:L5 running text · Khaleghi IV173:63 running text · Ganjoor sh1:59 running body · Moscow V238:L15 running text · Mohl IV6:L6 running text · Khaleghi IV173:64 running text · Ganjoor sh1:60 running body · Moscow V238:L16 running text · Mohl IV6:L7 running text · Khaleghi IV173:65 running text · Ganjoor sh1:61 running body · Moscow V238:L17 running text · Mohl IV6:L8 running text · Khaleghi IV173:66 running text · Ganjoor sh1:62 running body · Moscow V238:L18 running text · Mohl IV6:L9 running text · Khaleghi IV173:67 running text · Ganjoor sh1:63 running body · Moscow V238:L19 running text · Mohl IV6:L10 running text · Khaleghi IV174:68 running text · Ganjoor sh1:64 running body
Mohl and Khaleghi call the person who praises the king bold, while Moscow and Ganjoor ask who can know how to praise him. The English chooses the former challenge and preserves the difficulty of finding a hearer equal to such praise. Jupiter's crown then lifts the king beyond ordinary capacity. The poet's service leaves a memorial in all four texts, but deathless gratitude states an interpretation of its desired permanence. Buildings ruined by sun and rain supply the controlling contrast for a palace made from verse. Song gives that durable construction an audible English medium. The future wise reader completes the argument: endurance is realized through continued reading, not through stone surviving weather. Royal praise and poetic self-confidence therefore depend on one another in this passage.
73–78Blessing the king and specifying his powers
English 73–78; individual edition locators and evidence classes below.
Moscow V239:L1 running text · Mohl IV6:L11 running text · Khaleghi IV174:69 running text · Ganjoor sh1:65 running body · Moscow V239:L2 running text · Mohl IV6:L12 running text · Khaleghi IV174:70 running text · Ganjoor sh1:66 running body · Moscow V239:L3 running text · Mohl IV6:L13 running text · Khaleghi IV174:71 running text · Ganjoor sh1:67 running body · Moscow V239:L4 running text; wisdom · Mohl IV6:L14 running text · Khaleghi IV174:72 running text; wisdom · Ganjoor sh1:68 running body · Moscow V239:L5 running text · Mohl IV6:L15 running text · Khaleghi actual IV174n11 first full addition; main gap72–73 · Ganjoor sh1:69 running body · Moscow V239:L6 running text · Mohl IV6:L16 running text; bodily mastery, not speech · Khaleghi actual IV174n11 second full addition; body main addition, speech variant; main gap72–73 · Ganjoor sh1:70 running body
The wise reader's blessing leads to deeds that praise their own author and the poet's profession of inadequate praise. All four presentations sustain that movement, but their details should remain visible. Wisdom illuminates the throne in Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi, whereas Mohl prints fortune. English follows the wisdom reading. The springlike heart and people's delight are running text in Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor, but the corresponding first two closing blessings are fully printed in Khaleghi's apparatus. Mohl's mastery is bodily; English sovereign speech follows Moscow and Ganjoor, with speech also recorded within Khaleghi's apparatus variants. These are different royal capacities, not interchangeable decorations. The English's wish that time cause no injury interprets the favorable turning of time rather than reproducing a separate physical protection formula.
79–84From royal stars to the poet's craft
English 79–84; individual edition locators and evidence classes below.
Moscow V239:L7 running text · Mohl IV6:L17 running text; generic stars · Khaleghi actual IV174n11 third full addition; Jupiter; main gap72–73 · Ganjoor sh1:71 running body · Moscow V239:L8 running text · Mohl IV6:L18 running text · Khaleghi actual IV174n11 fourth full addition; main gap72–73 · Ganjoor sh1:72 running body · Moscow V239:L9 running text · Mohl IV6:L19 running text · Khaleghi IV174:73 running text · Ganjoor sh1:73 running body · Moscow V239:L10 running text · Mohl IV6:L20 running text · Khaleghi IV174:74 running text · Ganjoor sh1:74 running body · Moscow V239:L11 running text · Mohl IV6:L21 running text · Khaleghi IV174:75 running text · Ganjoor sh1:75 running body · Moscow V239:L12 running text · Mohl IV6:L22 running text · Khaleghi IV174:76 running text · Ganjoor sh1:76 running body
Mohl's generic stars support the English vault of light; Moscow and Ganjoor specify Jupiter, as does the third closing blessing in Khaleghi's actual apparatus. The fourth apparatus blessing supplies freedom from evil eye and want, so those lines must not be described as Khaleghi running text. Resuming the ancient story then changes the speaker's authority: experience of time makes an instructor unnecessary, and the coming Khosrow battles invite wonder. All four sources sustain this turn toward poetic craft. Showered pearls and tulips planted in rock combine precious utterance with growth in resistant material. The English recitation makes the first image explicitly audible. Its magic words describe the poet's wondrous performance here; the actual military narrative still begins in the next published chapter.
85–90Brocade and unequal lives
English 85–90; individual edition locators and evidence classes below.
Moscow V239:L13 running text; pen/core-of-speech · Mohl IV6:L23 running text · Khaleghi IV174:77 running text; oratorical main; actual IV174n16 brocade variant · Ganjoor sh1:77 running body · Moscow V239:L14 running text · Mohl IV6:L24 running text · Khaleghi IV174:78 running text · Ganjoor sh1:78 running body · Moscow V239:L15 running text · Mohl IV6:L25 running text · Khaleghi IV175:79 running text · Ganjoor sh1:79 running body · Moscow V239:L17 running text · Mohl IV7:L1 running text · Khaleghi IV175:81 running text · Ganjoor sh1:81 running body · Moscow V240:L1 running text · Mohl IV7:L2 running text · Khaleghi actual IV175n8 full addition; main gap81–82 · Ganjoor sh1:82 running body · Moscow V240:L2 running text · Mohl IV7:L3 running text · Khaleghi IV175:82 running text · Ganjoor sh1:83 running body
The English brocade follows Mohl's woven fabric and already-found meaning. Moscow and Ganjoor instead use a pen and the substance of speech; Khaleghi's main reading is oratorical and its actual apparatus records the brocade alternative. The English therefore selects a coherent textile image rather than translating a unanimous source. Its life's stage develops the testing eyes of the address to the reader. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi then add a reflection that time has always behaved this way; Mohl locally lacks it, and it has no separate English counterpart. Honeyed ease contrasts with constricted suffering. The latter couplet is main text in Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor but a fully printed Khaleghi addition. Treacherous movement follows Mohl and Khaleghi's deceit wording, sharpening the instability of fortune.
91–96Age as a limit that cannot be escaped
English 91–96; individual edition locators and evidence classes below.
Moscow V240:L3 running text · Mohl IV7:L4 running text · Khaleghi IV175:83 running text · Ganjoor sh1:84 running body · Moscow V240:L4 running text · Mohl IV7:L5 running text · Khaleghi IV175:84 running text · Ganjoor sh1:85 running body · Moscow V240:L5 running text · Mohl IV7:L6 running text · Khaleghi IV175:85 running text · Ganjoor sh1:86 running body · Moscow V240:L6 running text · Mohl IV7:L7 running text · Khaleghi IV175:86 running text · Ganjoor sh1:87 running body · Moscow V240:L7 running text · Mohl IV7:L8 running text · Khaleghi IV175:87 running text · Ganjoor sh1:88 running body · Moscow V240:L8 running text · Mohl IV7:L9 running text · Khaleghi IV175:88 running text · Ganjoor sh1:89 running body
The flower and thorn image weighs beauty against pain, and the English turns color's pleasure into joy to make that balance explicit. Across all four sources the advice at sixty is to relinquish excess, followed by the speaker's severe judgment about life beyond seventy. These are poetic counsels and personal generalizations; the commentary does not certify them as demographic or medical facts. The hypothetical fish trap is especially effective in English because it gives the wise person an imaginable means of escape before denying any exit from time itself. The Persian wording joins the age expression to the trapping image, while the English clearly separates their functions. Its final day extends the source's sun-and-moon pair without changing the creator's ultimate control over mortal duration.
97–102Khosrow as the measure of worldly effort
English 97–102; individual edition locators and evidence classes below.
Moscow V240:L9 running text · Mohl IV7:L10 running text · Khaleghi IV175:89 running text · Ganjoor sh1:90 running body · Moscow V240:L10 running text · Mohl IV7:L11 running text · Khaleghi IV175:90 running text · Ganjoor sh1:91 running body · Moscow V240:L11 running text · Mohl IV7:L12 running text · Khaleghi IV176:91 running text · Ganjoor sh1:92 running body · Moscow V240:L12 running text · Mohl IV7:L13 running text · Khaleghi IV176:92 running text · Ganjoor sh1:93 running body · Moscow V240:L13 running text · Mohl IV7:L14 running text · Khaleghi IV176:93 running text · Ganjoor sh1:94 running body · Moscow V240:L14 running text · Mohl IV7:L15 running text · Khaleghi IV176:94 running text · Ganjoor sh1:95 running body
The closing six couplets turn royal magnificence into an example of impermanence. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all move through toil, revenge and treasure toward departure and abandoned effort. English sphere elevates the source's other dwelling but preserves the unavoidable transition. Khosrow is then the measure by which to judge such achievement. The Persian explicitly names vengeance for the father against the grandfather; English instead identifies the maternal grandfather and leaves the murdered father implicit. That makes the family connection accessible while reducing the stated motive. Alchemy retains the source's kimia without resolving its practical mechanism. Even victorious Khosrow cannot keep the world reading his charter. The final counsel closes this reflective prelude before the next chapter begins the military muster.
Source record and limits
C4.1 only:102 English couplets/204 lines,17 substantive notes. Moscow V235–240:95 physical main units; Mohl IV3–7:98 physical main units; Ganjoor mahmood/sh1:1–95 body units; Khaleghi IV169–176:1–94 main units. Every declared main unit accounted. Four source units split across English2/3,14/15,44/45,61/62; English19/20 redistribute elephant/helpers and tribute. S1=time reflection (Moscow/Ganjoor/Khaleghi main); S2=Fereydoon question (Khaleghi main,actual Moscow237n23 second addition). Source-only rows excluded from English denominator.
Physical row locators count Persian running couplets from each printed page top, excluding headings and apparatus. Moscow V235:L1–L8,236:L1–L21,237:L1–L16,238:L1–L19,239:L1–L17,240:L1–L14 =95 main units. Moscow opening margin numbering is not certified as a continuous sequence; physical row locators are authoritative here. Mohl IV3:L1–L8,4:L1–L25,5:L1–L25,6:L1–L25,7:L1–L15 =98 main units. New Mohl IV printed3=PDF9; offset6 independently checked. Khaleghi IV169–176:1–94, PDF185–192; offset16. Moscow offset0.
Existing Moscow/Khaleghi PDFs reused; new MohlIV retrieved from Commons after volumeIII boundary check. Local PNGs used for reading, not packaged.
- F&R English: Published index C4.1 Praise for Sultan Mahmud,102 couplets;next C4.2 Kay Khosrow Musters against Afrasiab. C4 section64 chapters/3152 published couplets;only C4.1 analyzed here.
- Moscow: V235–240 physical95 main units, plus individually printed additions237n19,237n23,238n12 and cited variants. Nasr/fifty-seven/affirmative listening main.
- Mohl: New Persian volumeIV printed3–7(PDF9–13),98 main units. Fazl/fifty-eight/intoxication,negative future listening,brocade main. Physical row locators count Persian running couplets from each printed page top, excluding headings and apparatus. Moscow V235:L1–L8,236:L1–L21,237:L1–L16,238:L1–L19,239:L1–L17,240:L1–L14 =95 main units. Moscow opening margin numbering is not certified as a continuous sequence; physical row locators are authoritative here. Mohl IV3:L1–L8,4:L1–L25,5:L1–L25,6:L1–L25,7:L1–L15 =98 main units. New Mohl IV printed3=PDF9; offset6 independently checked. Khaleghi IV169–176:1–94, PDF185–192; offset16. Moscow offset0.
- Ganjoor: mahmood/sh1:1–95 body;comments excluded.95 main units. Local gaps for English46,48,55/56 and S2.
- Khaleghi-Motlagh: IV169–176:1–94(PDF185–192),94 main units. Fazl/fifty-eight/affirmative hearing main. English77–80 in actual174n11 and89 in actual175n8;English46 checked local main gap. S1 and S2 main.
All inherited provisional flags retained verbatim. NEW C4.1 qualifications:English follows different attested readings, including Fazl against Moscow/Ganjoor Nasr, fifty-eight against fifty-seven, Mohl intoxication against main decline elsewhere, and affirmative listening against Mohl negative future. English46 main in Mohl/actual Moscow237n19; Ganjoor and Khaleghi checked local main gaps, Khaleghi172n12 does not print full addition. English48 actual Moscow237n23 first addition;55/56 actual Moscow238n12 two additions;77–80 actual Khaleghi174n11 four additions;89 actual Khaleghi175n8 addition. No unprinted addition notice counts as verified reading. No appendix evidence invoked or appendix-wide search certified; absence claims restricted to checked local text. No historical harmonization of ages, named minister biography, exact territorial control, species identity or practical kimia meaning certified. All204 English lines preserved.
First:God bless the Shah, the pride of crown and throne, Last:Strive to keep suffering from drawing near.. Next section begins: When old Gudarz and Piran’s war had ceased. C4.2 not analyzed.
- Mohl IV4:L21 running;Fazl — نشستنگه فضل بن احمدست
- Moscow V236:L21 running;Nasr — نشستنگه نصر بن احمدست
- Moscow V236n30 actual variant — فضل
- Khaleghi IV171:27 running;Fazl — نشستنگه فضل بن احمدست
- Mohl IV5:L8 running;intoxication — من از شست و شش مست گشتم چو مست
- Moscow V237:L14 running;age — پنجاه و هفت
- Mohl IV5:L11 andKhaleghi IV172:43 running;age — پنجاه و هشت
- Mohl IV5:L16 running;negative future — نخواهم نهادن بآواز گوش
- Moscow V238:L2 running;affirmative — نهادم بر آن تیز آواز گوش
- Khaleghi IV172:49 running;affirmative — نهادم بدان فرخ آواز گوش
- Mohl IV6:L16 running;body — چیره تن
- Moscow V239:L6 running;speech — چیره سخن
- Mohl IV6:L23 running;brocade — کنون دیبه بافتم زین نشان
- Ganjoor sh1:80 source-only time reflection — چنین بود تا بود دور زمان / به نوی تو اندر شگفتی ممان
- Khaleghi IV172:45 source-only question — که ای نامداران گردنکشان / که جست از فریدون فرخ نشان
C4.1 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | V235:L1 running text | IV3:L1 running text |
| 2 | V235:L4 running text | IV3:L2 running text |
| 3 | V235:L4 running text | IV3:L2 running text |
| 4 | V235:L2 running text | IV3:L3 running text |
| 5 | V235:L3 running text | IV3:L4 running text |
| 6 | V235:L5 running text | IV3:L5 running text |
| 7 | V236:L2 running text | IV3:L6 running text |
| 8 | V235:L6 running text | IV3:L7 running text |
| 9 | V235:L7 running text | IV3:L8 running text |
| 10 | V235:L8 running text | IV4:L1 running text |
| 11 | V236:L1 running text | IV4:L2 running text |
| 12 | V236:L3 running text | IV4:L3 running text |
| 13 | V236:L4 running text | IV4:L4 running text |
| 14 | V236:L5 running text | IV4:L5 running text |
| 15 | V236:L5 running text | IV4:L5 running text |
| 16 | V236:L6 running text | IV4:L6 running text |
| 17 | V236:L7 running text; actual V236n12 negative condition | IV4:L7 running text |
| 18 | V236:L8 running text | IV4:L8 running text |
| 19 | V236:L9 running text | IV4:L9 running text |
| 20 | V236:L9 running text; V236:L10 running text | IV4:L9 running text; IV4:L10 running text |
| 21 | V236:L11 running text | IV4:L11 running text |
| 22 | V236:L12 running text | IV4:L12 running text |
| 23 | V236:L13 running text | IV4:L13 running text |
| 24 | V236:L14 running text | IV4:L14 running text |
| 25 | V236:L15 running text | IV4:L15 running text |
| 26 | V236:L16 running text | IV4:L16 running text |
| 27 | V236:L17 running text | IV4:L17 running text |
| 28 | V236:L18 running text | IV4:L18 running text |
| 29 | V236:L19 running text | IV4:L19 running text |
| 30 | V236:L20 running text | IV4:L20 running text |
| 31 | V236:L21 running text; Nasr main; actual V236n30 Fazl | IV4:L21 running text |
| 32 | V237:L1 running text | IV4:L22 running text |
| 33 | V237:L2 running text | IV4:L23 running text |
| 34 | V237:L3 running text | IV4:L24 running text |
| 35 | V237:L4 running text; completed labor | IV4:L25 running text |
| 36 | V237:L5 running text | IV5:L1 running text |
| 37 | V237:L6 running text | IV5:L2 running text |
| 38 | V237:L7 running text | IV5:L3 running text |
| 39 | V237:L8 running text | IV5:L4 running text |
| 40 | V237:L9 running text | IV5:L5 running text |
| 41 | V237:L10 running text | IV5:L6 running text |
| 42 | V237:L11 running text | IV5:L7 running text |
| 43 | V237:L12 running text; decline main | IV5:L8 running text |
| 44 | V237:L13 running text | IV5:L9 running text |
| 45 | V237:L13 running text | IV5:L9 running text |
| 46 | actual V237n19 full addition; checked main gap V237:L13–L14 | IV5:L10 running text |
| 47 | V237:L14 running text; fifty-seven main; actual V237n21 eight variant | IV5:L11 running text |
| 48 | actual V237n23 first full addition; checked main gap V237:L14–L15 | IV5:L12 running text |
| 49 | V237:L15 running text | IV5:L13 running text |
| 50 | V237:L16 running text | IV5:L14 running text |
| 51 | V238:L1 running text | IV5:L15 running text |
| 52 | V238:L2 running text; affirmative listening | IV5:L16 running text; negative future refusal to listen |
| 53 | V238:L3 running text | IV5:L17 running text |
| 54 | V238:L6 running text | IV5:L18 running text |
| 55 | actual V238n12 first full addition; checked main after V238:L6 | IV5:L19 running text |
| 56 | actual V238n12 second full addition; checked main after V238:L6 | IV5:L20 running text |
| 57 | V238:L4 running text | IV5:L21 running text |
| 58 | V238:L5 running text | IV5:L22 running text |
| 59 | V238:L7 running text | IV5:L23 running text |
| 60 | V238:L8 running text | IV5:L24 running text |
| 61 | V238:L9 running text | IV5:L25 running text |
| 62 | V238:L9 running text | IV5:L25 running text |
| 63 | V238:L11 running text | IV6:L1 running text |
| 64 | V238:L12 running text | IV6:L2 running text |
| 65 | V238:L13 running text | IV6:L3 running text |
| 66 | V238:L10 running text | IV6:L4 running text |
| 67 | V238:L14 running text | IV6:L5 running text |
| 68 | V238:L15 running text | IV6:L6 running text |
| 69 | V238:L16 running text | IV6:L7 running text |
| 70 | V238:L17 running text | IV6:L8 running text |
| 71 | V238:L18 running text | IV6:L9 running text |
| 72 | V238:L19 running text | IV6:L10 running text |
| 73 | V239:L1 running text | IV6:L11 running text |
| 74 | V239:L2 running text | IV6:L12 running text |
| 75 | V239:L3 running text | IV6:L13 running text |
| 76 | V239:L4 running text; wisdom | IV6:L14 running text |
| 77 | V239:L5 running text | IV6:L15 running text |
| 78 | V239:L6 running text | IV6:L16 running text; bodily mastery, not speech |
| 79 | V239:L7 running text | IV6:L17 running text; generic stars |
| 80 | V239:L8 running text | IV6:L18 running text |
| 81 | V239:L9 running text | IV6:L19 running text |
| 82 | V239:L10 running text | IV6:L20 running text |
| 83 | V239:L11 running text | IV6:L21 running text |
| 84 | V239:L12 running text | IV6:L22 running text |
| 85 | V239:L13 running text; pen/core-of-speech | IV6:L23 running text |
| 86 | V239:L14 running text | IV6:L24 running text |
| 87 | V239:L15 running text | IV6:L25 running text |
| 88 | V239:L17 running text | IV7:L1 running text |
| 89 | V240:L1 running text | IV7:L2 running text |
| 90 | V240:L2 running text | IV7:L3 running text |
| 91 | V240:L3 running text | IV7:L4 running text |
| 92 | V240:L4 running text | IV7:L5 running text |
| 93 | V240:L5 running text | IV7:L6 running text |
| 94 | V240:L6 running text | IV7:L7 running text |
| 95 | V240:L7 running text | IV7:L8 running text |
| 96 | V240:L8 running text | IV7:L9 running text |
| 97 | V240:L9 running text | IV7:L10 running text |
| 98 | V240:L10 running text | IV7:L11 running text |
| 99 | V240:L11 running text | IV7:L12 running text |
| 100 | V240:L12 running text | IV7:L13 running text |
| 101 | V240:L13 running text | IV7:L14 running text |
| 102 | V240:L14 running text | IV7:L15 running text |
New Naqqali