Afrasiab Is Put to Flight
C4.11 Afrasiab Is Put to Flight. Thirty couplets: night withdrawal, deserted camp, royal thanksgiving, the army’s lament and care for the dead.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | C4.11 Afrasiab Is Put to Flight. Thirty couplets: night withdrawal, deserted camp, royal thanksgiving, the army’s lament and care for the dead. |
| Moscow | V285–286:825–854. Thirty running units. River and boats in the crossing order; world in the prayer; individual funeral provision. The explicit seventh-day and collective-funeral alternatives are actually printed in the apparatus. |
| Mohl | IV39–40:850–879. Thirty running units. Sequential Jihun crossing, explicitly named seventh-day departure and collective wording for funeral provision. |
| Ganjoor | mahmood/sh9:1–30. Thirty body units. Boats in the crossing order, world in the prayer, an arising/setting-out transition and one fitting dakhma for each man. Automated explanations are not textual evidence. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | IV223–225:831–860. Thirty running units. Goodness in the prayer, with world printed in apparatus; transition wording at departure, with seventh day printed in apparatus; collective funeral wording in main. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5An organized night withdrawal
English 1–5; edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V285:825 running text; mountain main · Mohl IV39:850 running text; mountain main · Khaleghi IV223:831 running text; different celestial wording;IV223n23 mountain variant · Ganjoor sh9:1 running body · Moscow V285:826 running text · Mohl IV39:851 running text · Khaleghi IV223:832 running text · Ganjoor sh9:2 running body · Moscow V285:827 running text · Mohl IV39:852 running text · Khaleghi IV224:833 running text · Ganjoor sh9:3 running body · Moscow V285:828 running text · Mohl IV39:853 running text · Khaleghi IV224:834 running text · Ganjoor sh9:4 running body · Moscow V285:829 running text; river/boat/no-delay wording · Mohl IV39:854 running text; sequential Jihun crossing · Khaleghi IV224:835 running text; river/boat/no-delay wording;IV224n4–5 actual variants · Ganjoor sh9:5 running body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all begin after half the night and follow the loading of baggage with helmets, armor and a ten-thousand mounted screen. English preserves this organization: flight does not become the dissolution of military command. Guard the band explains the screening force's function without requiring a reconstruction of its equipment. The river order has a meaningful difference. Mohl tells the men to follow one after another across the Jihun, closely matching the English. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi also name the river but retain boats and a warning not to delay. English follows the sequential-crossing expression and leaves the boats unstated. Its toward day and in our flight make the surrounding situation explicit rather than supplying independent astronomical or tactical evidence.
6–10Empty tents and a relieved king
English 6–10; edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V285:830 running text · Mohl IV39:855 running text · Khaleghi IV224:836 running text · Ganjoor sh9:6 running body · Moscow V285:831 running text · Mohl IV39:856 running text · Khaleghi IV224:837 running text · Ganjoor sh9:7 running body · Moscow V285:832 running text · Mohl IV39:857 running text · Khaleghi IV224:838 running text · Ganjoor sh9:8 running body · Moscow V285:833 running text; Shah explicitly relieved · Mohl IV39:858 running text; Shah explicitly relieved · Khaleghi IV224:839 running text; relieved subject not named in main clause;IV224n11 actual Shah variant · Ganjoor sh9:9 running body · Moscow V285:834 running text · Mohl IV39:859 running text · Khaleghi IV224:840 running text · Ganjoor sh9:10 running body
All four presentations contrast the army's dark crossing with the scouts' discovery of empty tents at dawn. English homeward bound interprets Afrasiab's direction, while the preserved Amvi spelling should not become a claim about a modern geographical coordinate. The Persian dawn line contains bakhtar; English omits that directional term and keeps the temporal effect. Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor explicitly make the Shah relieved of the battle, whereas Khaleghi's main formulation does not name the relieved subject in that clause. The English follows the royal reading and turns release into freedom from further strain. Its ordered ground adds a visual impression to the deserted tents. The report remains bounded by what the scouts see: no enemy rider in the camp and plain, not proof that opposition has disappeared everywhere.
11–15Praise, petition and the tyrant's removal
English 11–15; edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V285:835 running text · Mohl IV39:860 running text · Khaleghi IV224:841 running text · Ganjoor sh9:11 running body · Moscow V285:836 running text; Creator,ruler,watchful/provider;V285n17 actual variants · Mohl IV39:861 running text; Creator,ruler,watchful/provider · Khaleghi IV224:842 running text; Creator,ruler,watchful/provider;IV224n17 actual variants · Ganjoor sh9:12 running body · Moscow V285:837 running text · Mohl IV39:862 running text · Khaleghi IV224:843 running text · Ganjoor sh9:13 running body · Moscow V285:838 running text; world main;V285n19 actual goodness variant · Mohl IV39:863 running text; world main · Khaleghi IV224:844 running text; goodness main;IV224n18 actual world variant · Ganjoor sh9:14 running body · Moscow V285:839 running text · Mohl IV39:864 running text · Khaleghi IV224:845 running text · Ganjoor sh9:15 running body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all give Khosrow's earthward gesture, praise of the Creator, gratitude for royal power and a prayer against the enemy. English keeps gratitude and vengeance in the same devotional movement. Justice none can hide elaborates the divine epithets, while plural foes widens the source's singular enemy designation. The request to remove the tyrant differs: Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor have the world; Khaleghi main has goodness, with the world reading actually printed in apparatus. Earthly sphere therefore has direct support rather than being a loose substitute for Khaleghi's main wording. Fear and sickness remain requested consequences, not events the narrator has already certified. The golden shield and turquoise covering then restore the scene's visible morning, without requiring an exact identification of the textile or celestial mechanism.
16–20Royal display and the soldiers' dissatisfaction
English 16–20; edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V285:840 running text · Mohl IV39:865 running text · Khaleghi IV224:846 running text · Ganjoor sh9:16 running body · Moscow V285:841 running text · Mohl IV39:866 running text · Khaleghi IV224:847 running text · Ganjoor sh9:17 running body · Moscow V285:842 running text · Mohl IV39:867 running text · Khaleghi IV224:848 running text · Ganjoor sh9:18 running body · Moscow V285:843 running text · Mohl IV39:868 running text · Khaleghi IV224:849 running text · Ganjoor sh9:19 running body · Moscow V285:844 running text; high-value men main;V285n23 actual nobles variant · Mohl IV39:869 running text; nobles main · Khaleghi IV224:850 running text; nobles main;IV224n30 actual high-value variant · Ganjoor sh9:20 running body
All four texts seat the king on ivory beneath the heart-illuminating crown, praise his worthiness and describe enrichment from abandoned goods. English turns the crown's illumination into winning hearts and names Afrasiab where the sources identify the king of Chin. Both choices clarify the scene, but neither should erase the underlying wording. The army's disappointment then interrupts the victorious display: it has gained wealth yet lost the chance to catch the enemy. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi preserve the escaping army with its horns and drums. Noble or high-value men are the source of danger from which the fugitive escapes; English makes that danger their swords. This is effective martial specification, not a separately verified weapon detail. The lament belongs to the soldiers and prepares the king's corrective reply.
21–25A retreating enemy and divine freedom
English 21–25; edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V285:845 running text · Mohl IV39:870 running text · Khaleghi IV225:851 running text · Ganjoor sh9:21 running body · Moscow V286:846 running text; retreat from battle main · Mohl IV39:871 running text; retreat from battle main · Khaleghi IV225:852 running text; retreat from before him main;IV225n1 actual battle variant · Ganjoor sh9:22 running body · Moscow V286:847 running text · Mohl IV40:872 running text · Khaleghi IV225:853 running text · Ganjoor sh9:23 running body · Moscow V286:848 running text; praise/prayer;V286n2–4 actual alternatives · Mohl IV40:873 running text; praise/prayer · Khaleghi IV225:854 running text; prayer wording;IV225n5–7 actual alternatives · Ganjoor sh9:24 running body · Moscow V286:849 running text · Mohl IV40:874 running text · Khaleghi IV225:855 running text · Ganjoor sh9:25 running body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all let the king answer that an enemy killed or driven away is preferable. Khaleghi's main text describes retreat from before him, while the other main presentations refer to battle. English makes the alternatives clear and should not be read as announcing Afrasiab's death. All four then ground the reply in granted greatness and kingship and call for continuing praise, with differences in prayer vocabulary and the temporal expression. Every place and hour generalizes that exhortation without introducing a new ceremony. The king's next claim deliberately unsettles a simple equation between merit and power: divine will can make someone unfortunate and enthrone one without accomplishment. English worthless sharpens that evaluation. It remains the king's theological explanation, rather than an independently established judgment about every ruler.
26–30The seventh day and care for the dead
English 26–30; edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V286:850 running text; effort/questioning main;V286n8–9 actual alternatives · Mohl IV40:875 running text; effort/questioning main · Khaleghi IV225:856 running text; questioning/movement main;IV225n10–12 actual alternatives · Ganjoor sh9:26 running body · Moscow V286:851 running text; sixth Hormozd main;V286n11 actual phrasing variant · Mohl IV40:876 running text; sixth Hormozd main · Khaleghi IV225:857 running text; sixth Hormozd main;IV225n14–15 actual alternatives · Ganjoor sh9:27 running body · Moscow V286:852 running text; arising/setting-out transition;V286n12 actual seventh-day variant · Mohl IV40:877 running text; explicit seventh day main · Khaleghi IV225:858 running text; arising/setting-out transition;IV225n16 actual seventh-day variant · Ganjoor sh9:28 running body · Moscow V286:853 running text · Mohl IV40:878 running text · Khaleghi IV225:859 running text · Ganjoor sh9:29 running body · Moscow V286:854 running text; one dakhma for each main;V286n19 actual collective-dead variant · Mohl IV40:879 running text; fitting dakhma for the dead collectively · Khaleghi IV225:860 running text; fitting dakhma for the dead collectively;IV225n23 actual each-man variant · Ganjoor sh9:30 running body
All four sources connect submission to divine judgment with a pause for the Iranian dead. English slave gives bandeh a strong devotional register; it does not establish a social-legal classification of the chiefs. The five-day stay and sixth-day Hormozd are shared, but the departure differs in expression. Mohl explicitly gives the seventh day; Moscow and Khaleghi main use an arising or setting-out transition and actually print the seventh-day alternative. Ganjoor follows the transition form. The English day is therefore supported, although blessed in sacred lore adds explanation beyond the local wording. Funeral provision also differs: Moscow and Ganjoor assign a fitting dakhma to each man, while Mohl and Khaleghi describe the dead collectively. English tomb can preserve that collective phrasing without proving one communal building or a specific burial technology.
Source record and limits
C4.11 contains 30 English couplets and six substantive notes. Each of the four Persian presentations has 30 running units in the declared reference, all individually accounted for. No source-only unit or extra apparatus couplet is required for this alignment.
Moscow V285–286:825–854; Mohl IV39–40:850–879; Ganjoor mahmood/sh9:1–30; Khaleghi IV223–225:831–860.
- F&R English: C4.11 Afrasiab Is Put to Flight. Thirty couplets: night withdrawal, deserted camp, royal thanksgiving, the army’s lament and care for the dead.
- Moscow: V285–286:825–854. Thirty running units. River and boats in the crossing order; world in the prayer; individual funeral provision. The explicit seventh-day and collective-funeral alternatives are actually printed in the apparatus.
- Mohl: IV39–40:850–879. Thirty running units. Sequential Jihun crossing, explicitly named seventh-day departure and collective wording for funeral provision.
- Ganjoor: mahmood/sh9:1–30. Thirty body units. Boats in the crossing order, world in the prayer, an arising/setting-out transition and one fitting dakhma for each man. Automated explanations are not textual evidence.
- Khaleghi-Motlagh: IV223–225:831–860. Thirty running units. Goodness in the prayer, with world printed in apparatus; transition wording at departure, with seventh day printed in apparatus; collective funeral wording in main.
The seventh-day departure has direct support in Mohl; it is not inferred solely from the preceding five-day stay and sixth-day name. The funeral wording does not establish one communal structure. The king’s prayer, the soldiers’ lament and his theological reply remain attributed speech.
All declared units are running text. Actual local variants are distinguished from main readings. No source-only unit, checked local main-text gap or appendix evidence is invoked. No appendix-wide absence or exhaustive transcription of every apparatus variant is asserted.
The seventh-day departure follows Mohl main and actual Moscow/Khaleghi variants. The prayer’s earthly sphere follows the world reading against Khaleghi main goodness. Funeral provision is individual in Moscow/Ganjoor main and collectively phrased in Mohl/Khaleghi. English swords, homeward direction, sacred-lore explanation and crown winning hearts are interpretive specifications. No exact calendar date, modern geographical coordinate, armor construction, cloth fiber or funerary architecture is certified. All inherited provisional flags remain unchanged.
- Mohl IV39:854 running text; English5 — دمادم شما از پس یکدگر / ز جیحون همی باید کرد گذر
- Moscow V285:829 running text; English5 contrast — دمادم شما از پسم بگذرید / به جیحون و زورق زمان مشمرید
- Khaleghi IV224:844 main; English14 contrast — ز نیکی ستمکاره را دور دار
- Khaleghi IV224n18 actual variant; English14 — گیتی
- Mohl IV40:877 running text; English28 — به هفتم برانم از ایدر سپاه / که او کین فزایست و ما کینه خواه
- Moscow V286n12 actual variant; English28 — بهفتم
- Khaleghi IV225n16 actual variant; English28 — بهفتم
- Moscow V286:854 main; English30 — بشستند ایرانیان را ز گرد / سزاوار هر یک یکی دخمه کرد
- Mohl IV40:879 main; English30 — بشستند ایرانیان را ز گرد / سزاوار آن کشتگان دخمه کرد
- Khaleghi IV225:860 main; English30 — بشستند ایرانیان را ز گرد / سزاوار آن کشتگان دخمه کرد
C4.11 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | V285:825 running text; mountain main | IV39:850 running text; mountain main |
| 2 | V285:826 running text | IV39:851 running text |
| 3 | V285:827 running text | IV39:852 running text |
| 4 | V285:828 running text | IV39:853 running text |
| 5 | V285:829 running text; river/boat/no-delay wording | IV39:854 running text; sequential Jihun crossing |
| 6 | V285:830 running text | IV39:855 running text |
| 7 | V285:831 running text | IV39:856 running text |
| 8 | V285:832 running text | IV39:857 running text |
| 9 | V285:833 running text; Shah explicitly relieved | IV39:858 running text; Shah explicitly relieved |
| 10 | V285:834 running text | IV39:859 running text |
| 11 | V285:835 running text | IV39:860 running text |
| 12 | V285:836 running text; Creator,ruler,watchful/provider;V285n17 actual variants | IV39:861 running text; Creator,ruler,watchful/provider |
| 13 | V285:837 running text | IV39:862 running text |
| 14 | V285:838 running text; world main;V285n19 actual goodness variant | IV39:863 running text; world main |
| 15 | V285:839 running text | IV39:864 running text |
| 16 | V285:840 running text | IV39:865 running text |
| 17 | V285:841 running text | IV39:866 running text |
| 18 | V285:842 running text | IV39:867 running text |
| 19 | V285:843 running text | IV39:868 running text |
| 20 | V285:844 running text; high-value men main;V285n23 actual nobles variant | IV39:869 running text; nobles main |
| 21 | V285:845 running text | IV39:870 running text |
| 22 | V286:846 running text; retreat from battle main | IV39:871 running text; retreat from battle main |
| 23 | V286:847 running text | IV40:872 running text |
| 24 | V286:848 running text; praise/prayer;V286n2–4 actual alternatives | IV40:873 running text; praise/prayer |
| 25 | V286:849 running text | IV40:874 running text |
| 26 | V286:850 running text; effort/questioning main;V286n8–9 actual alternatives | IV40:875 running text; effort/questioning main |
| 27 | V286:851 running text; sixth Hormozd main;V286n11 actual phrasing variant | IV40:876 running text; sixth Hormozd main |
| 28 | V286:852 running text; arising/setting-out transition;V286n12 actual seventh-day variant | IV40:877 running text; explicit seventh day main |
| 29 | V286:853 running text | IV40:878 running text |
| 30 | V286:854 running text; one dakhma for each main;V286n19 actual collective-dead variant | IV40:879 running text; fitting dakhma for the dead collectively |
New Naqqali