Afrasiab Flees to Gang-Behesht
C4.13 Afrasiab Flees to Gang-Behesht. Thirty couplets:flight,mourning,counsel,retreat and temporary pleasure interrupted by an intelligence warning.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | C4.13 Afrasiab Flees to Gang-Behesht. Thirty couplets:flight,mourning,counsel,retreat and temporary pleasure interrupted by an intelligence warning. |
| Moscow | V287–288:869–895. Twenty-seven running units. Battle/staying,heart full of blood and waiting in main;actual treasure,city and drinking alternatives in apparatus. Local gap for the final three warning units between895–896. |
| Mohl | IV41–42:894–923. Thirty running units. Treasure/battle,heart full of blood,city and drinking. Three distinct final warning units921–923 print the agents,river-crossing report and call to prepare. |
| Ganjoor | mahmood/sh10:15–41. Twenty-seven body units. Battle/staying,heart full of blood and waiting. Local gap for the three warning units between41–42. Automated explanations are excluded. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | IV226–228:875–901. Twenty-seven running units. Routes to treasure/war,face full of blood,Gang and waiting in main;actual alternatives in apparatus. Local gap for the three warning units between901–902. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5Flight gives way to mourning
English 1–5; edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V287:869 running text · Mohl IV41:894 running text · Khaleghi IV226:875 running text · Ganjoor sh10:15 · Moscow V287:870 running text · Mohl IV41:895 running text · Khaleghi IV226:876 running text · Ganjoor sh10:16 · Moscow V287:871 running text · Mohl IV41:896 running text · Khaleghi IV226:877 running text · Ganjoor sh10:17 · Moscow V287:872 running text · Mohl IV41:897 running text · Khaleghi IV226:878 running text · Ganjoor sh10:18 · Moscow V287:873 running text · Mohl IV41:898 running text · Khaleghi IV227:879 running text · Ganjoor sh10:19
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all carry Afrasiab across the Jihun with a wind comparison, bring him to Qarakhan’s army and turn immediately to mourning for his family and chiefs. The English keeps the shift from outward speed to inward grief. Its second line about the heart’s suffering expands the lament rather than naming another casualty. The next couplet identifies the son, relatives and leading men without treating the list as a complete genealogy. Most strikingly, all four presentations join a cloud with blood falling from a lion’s eyes. English retains that extravagant conjunction instead of replacing it with ordinary tears. The lion remains an image for the grieving warrior, and the cloud comparison measures the scale of lament; neither requires a literal weather event.
6–10The surviving council
English 6–10; edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V287:874 running text · Mohl IV41:899 running text · Khaleghi IV227:880 running text · Ganjoor sh10:20 · Moscow V287:875 running text · Mohl IV41:900 running text · Khaleghi IV227:881 running text · Ganjoor sh10:21 · Moscow V287:876 running text · Mohl IV41:901 running text · Khaleghi IV227:882 running text · Ganjoor sh10:22 · Moscow V287:877 running text · Mohl IV41:902 running text · Khaleghi IV227:883 running text · Ganjoor sh10:23 · Moscow V287:878 running text · Mohl IV41:903 running text · Khaleghi IV227:884 running text · Ganjoor sh10:24
In Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi, the halt at Bukhara is connected with waiting for fighting lions, followed by a summons to the remaining magnates and the gathering of counselors. English preserves the martial metaphor while making the survivors’ status explicit. Its description of prudent words develops their role as advisers, not a guarantee that their next proposal is correct. The repeated references to exhaustion and mourning turn the council into the speech of a damaged army. English makes that connection legible through hearts worn down by warfare. The declaration that the foremost men have died belongs to these speakers, rather than to a separate narrator’s casualty assessment. All four source accounts retain this distinction between the king’s personal mourning and the collective complaint that follows.
11–15Losses and guarded criticism
English 11–15; edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V287:879 running text · Mohl IV41:904 running text · Khaleghi IV227:885 running text · Ganjoor sh10:25 · Moscow V288:880 running text · Mohl IV41:905 running text · Khaleghi IV227:886 running text · Ganjoor sh10:26 · Moscow V288:881 running text · Mohl IV41:906 running text · Khaleghi IV227:887 running text · Ganjoor sh10:27 · Moscow V288:882 running text · Mohl IV41:907 running text · Khaleghi IV227:888 running text · Ganjoor sh10:28 · Moscow V288:883 running text · Mohl IV41:908 running text · Khaleghi IV227:889 running text · Ganjoor sh10:29
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi give the survivors’ stark ratio: twenty remain from a hundred, followed by the obligation to mourn the dead. English scarcely sharpens the lament without supplying an independently verified casualty census. The speakers then describe separation from treasure, children and kin. In English the broadened language of rooted ties conveys the cost of campaigning, while leaving the source’s temporal qualification less explicit. All four recall that the battlefield beyond the Jihun was made at the king’s command and connect the resulting predicament with folly. English preserves the delicate combination of criticism and deference: the counselors acknowledge his authority while seeking a remedy. Its Chakh corresponds to the printed place-name Chach; this spelling is retained, without certifying an alternative location or a modern geographical identification.
16–20What the refuge promises
English 16–20; edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V288:884 running text · Mohl IV41:909 running text · Khaleghi IV227:890 running text · Ganjoor sh10:30 · Moscow V288:885 running text · Mohl IV41:910 running text · Khaleghi IV227:891 running text · Ganjoor sh10:31 · Moscow V288:886 running text;battle/staying main;V288n10–11 actual treasure/battle variants · Mohl IV41:911 running text;treasure/battle main · Khaleghi IV227:892 running text;routes to treasure/war main;IV227n27 actual alternatives · Ganjoor sh10:32 · Moscow V288:887 running text · Mohl IV41:912 running text · Khaleghi IV227:893 running text · Ganjoor sh10:33 · Moscow V288:888 running text;heart full of blood · Mohl IV41:913 running text;heart full of blood · Khaleghi IV227:894 running text;face full of blood;IV227n29 actual heart variant · Ganjoor sh10:34
The four presentations agree on preparing an army for Khosrow’s vengeance, passing Gulzaryun, choosing Gang and accepting the proposal without a competing plan. They differ in the refuge’s advertised advantages. Moscow and Ganjoor describe a place for battle and staying; Mohl couples treasure with battle, while Khaleghi speaks of a way to treasure and a way to war. Actual Moscow and Khaleghi apparatus entries preserve alternative formulations. English’s peaceful remaining follows the staying tradition rather than translating treasure. Its broken ranks makes the need for reorganization explicit where the shared instruction is to arrange the army. In the departure lament, English’s hearts filled with blood follows Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor; Khaleghi main instead has bloodied faces, with heart printed as a variant. Both images preserve grief, but locate it differently.
21–25Pleasure and apparent safety
English 21–25; edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V288:889 running text · Mohl IV41:914 running text · Khaleghi IV227:895 running text · Ganjoor sh10:35 · Moscow V288:890 running text · Mohl IV41:915 running text · Khaleghi IV228:896 running text · Ganjoor sh10:36 · Moscow V288:891 running text;place main;V288n19 actual city variant · Mohl IV41:916 running text;city main · Khaleghi IV228:897 running text;Gang main;IV228n3 actual place/city variants · Ganjoor sh10:37 · Moscow V288:892 running text · Mohl IV42:917 running text · Khaleghi IV228:898 running text · Ganjoor sh10:38 · Moscow V288:893 running text · Mohl IV42:918 running text · Khaleghi IV228:899 running text · Ganjoor sh10:39
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all give the three-day stay with baz and yuz, the onward movement and the splendid refuge. English identifies the hunting companions as hawks and cheetahs and supplies relief from anxious thought as a psychological explanation; the passage does not establish a precise species or reconstruct a hunt. Mohl explicitly calls the destination a city, while the other main formulations describe the place or Gang itself. The musk clay and golden bricks belong to its paradisal portrayal, not a certified account of building materials. English retains the qualification as though when Afrasiab lies down smiling. All four also show him calling forces from every direction. His pleasure therefore coexists with continued military preparation, and the apparent safety is never an assurance that pursuit has ended.
26–30The warning interrupts repose
English 26–30; edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V288:894 running text · Mohl IV42:919 running text · Khaleghi IV228:900 running text · Ganjoor sh10:40 · Moscow V288:895 running text;waiting main;V288n28 actual drinking variant · Mohl IV42:920 running text;drinking main · Khaleghi IV228:901 running text;waiting main;IV228n14 actual drinking variant · Ganjoor sh10:41 · Moscow V288:895–896 checked local gap;no corresponding full warning addition printed at the inspected locus · Mohl IV42:921 running text · Khaleghi IV228:901–902 checked local gap;no corresponding full warning addition printed at the inspected locus · Mohl IV42:922 running text · Mohl IV42:923 running text
All four presentations retain the sequence of wine, gardens, instruments and flowers followed by uncertainty about what time conceals. English makes drinking explicit, following Mohl’s main verb and actual variants in Moscow and Khaleghi against their main waiting wording; Ganjoor also has waiting. Its final warning requires a separate account. Mohl prints three further couplets: informed agents arrive secretly, report Khosrow’s crossing and urge preparations against a sudden approach. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi proceed directly from the uncertainty couplet to the narrative of Khosrow’s arrival, leaving checked local gaps for these three units. English therefore preserves an attested warning scene, not an unsupported invention. The agents’ report anticipates the next narrative movement without becoming another independently dated crossing. One word in Mohl’s preparation line remains unread and is excluded from interpretation; the command and sudden-arrival warning are independently clear. These local gaps do not establish absence from every manuscript or appendix.
Source record and limits
C4.13 contains 30 English couplets and six substantive notes. Unique running coverage is27 Moscow,30 Mohl,27 Ganjoor and27 Khaleghi units. The final three warning couplets are Mohl running text with checked local gaps in the other three presentations. No source-only row is required.
Moscow V287–288:869–895; Mohl IV41–42:894–923; Ganjoor mahmood/sh10:15–41; Khaleghi IV226–228:875–901. Checked warning gaps:Moscow288:895–896,Ganjoor41–42,Khaleghi228:901–902.
- F&R English: C4.13 Afrasiab Flees to Gang-Behesht. Thirty couplets:flight,mourning,counsel,retreat and temporary pleasure interrupted by an intelligence warning.
- Moscow: V287–288:869–895. Twenty-seven running units. Battle/staying,heart full of blood and waiting in main;actual treasure,city and drinking alternatives in apparatus. Local gap for the final three warning units between895–896.
- Mohl: IV41–42:894–923. Thirty running units. Treasure/battle,heart full of blood,city and drinking. Three distinct final warning units921–923 print the agents,river-crossing report and call to prepare.
- Ganjoor: mahmood/sh10:15–41. Twenty-seven body units. Battle/staying,heart full of blood and waiting. Local gap for the three warning units between41–42. Automated explanations are excluded.
- Khaleghi-Motlagh: IV226–228:875–901. Twenty-seven running units. Routes to treasure/war,face full of blood,Gang and waiting in main;actual alternatives in apparatus. Local gap for the three warning units between901–902.
The intelligence warning is present as three consecutive Mohl running couplets. The other presentations move directly from uncertainty about time to Khosrow’s arrival. Their local gaps do not invalidate Mohl’s positive evidence or certify an absence across the wider tradition.
Running text,actual printed variants and checked local gaps remain distinct. Mohl supplies the Persian reference for English28–30. No unprinted addition notice or appendix evidence is used to verify those readings;no appendix-wide absence is asserted.
Mohl923 has one unresolved word between باید and آن; […] marks that unread word in the partial transcription,not a printed omission. The warning’s remaining wording is verified and the uncertain word is unused. English peaceful remaining follows the battle/staying tradition against treasure/battle formulations. Blood in hearts follows Moscow/Mohl/Ganjoor against Khaleghi main faces. Drinking follows Mohl main and actual Moscow/Khaleghi variants. The last three couplets have direct Mohl support; local gaps elsewhere do not establish absence from every manuscript or appendix. Chakh corresponds to printed Chach,with no separate location or supporting kh-form certified. Casualty figures remain the counselors’ speech. No exact modern geography,hunting species,building materials or instrument reconstruction is certified. All inherited provisional flags remain unchanged.
- Moscow V288:886 main;English18 — بباشد به آرام به بهشت گنگ / که هم جای جنگست و جای درنگ
- Mohl IV41:911 main;English18 — بباشد به آرام به بهشت گنگ / که هم جای گنجست و هم جای جنگ
- Khaleghi IV227:892 main;English18 — بباشد به آرام بهشت گنگ / که هم راه گنجست و هم راه جنگ
- Khaleghi IV227:894 main;English20 — همه دیده پرآب و رخ پر ز خون
- Khaleghi IV227n29 actual variant;English20 — دل
- Mohl IV42:920 main;English27 — همی خورد تا بر چه گردد جهان / بدین آشکارا چه دارد نهان
- Moscow V288n28 actual variant;English27 — همی خورد
- Khaleghi IV228n14 actual variant;English27 — همی خورد
- Mohl IV42:921 running text;English28 — ز هر سوی کارآگهی از نهفت / که آینده آمد یکایک بگفت
- Mohl IV42:922 running text;English29 — که خسرو سپه را به جیحون کشید / برآمد ز جیحون به هامون رسید
- Mohl IV42:923 running text;English30;partial transcription:one unresolved word marked […] — نگر تا چه باید […] آن بساز / که ناگاه لشکر برآید فراز
C4.13 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | V287:869 running text | IV41:894 running text |
| 2 | V287:870 running text | IV41:895 running text |
| 3 | V287:871 running text | IV41:896 running text |
| 4 | V287:872 running text | IV41:897 running text |
| 5 | V287:873 running text | IV41:898 running text |
| 6 | V287:874 running text | IV41:899 running text |
| 7 | V287:875 running text | IV41:900 running text |
| 8 | V287:876 running text | IV41:901 running text |
| 9 | V287:877 running text | IV41:902 running text |
| 10 | V287:878 running text | IV41:903 running text |
| 11 | V287:879 running text | IV41:904 running text |
| 12 | V288:880 running text | IV41:905 running text |
| 13 | V288:881 running text | IV41:906 running text |
| 14 | V288:882 running text | IV41:907 running text |
| 15 | V288:883 running text | IV41:908 running text |
| 16 | V288:884 running text | IV41:909 running text |
| 17 | V288:885 running text | IV41:910 running text |
| 18 | V288:886 running text;battle/staying main;V288n10–11 actual treasure/battle variants | IV41:911 running text;treasure/battle main |
| 19 | V288:887 running text | IV41:912 running text |
| 20 | V288:888 running text;heart full of blood | IV41:913 running text;heart full of blood |
| 21 | V288:889 running text | IV41:914 running text |
| 22 | V288:890 running text | IV41:915 running text |
| 23 | V288:891 running text;place main;V288n19 actual city variant | IV41:916 running text;city main |
| 24 | V288:892 running text | IV42:917 running text |
| 25 | V288:893 running text | IV42:918 running text |
| 26 | V288:894 running text | IV42:919 running text |
| 27 | V288:895 running text;waiting main;V288n28 actual drinking variant | IV42:920 running text;drinking main |
| 28 | V288:895–896 checked local gap;no corresponding full warning addition printed at the inspected locus | IV42:921 running text |
| 29 | V288:895–896 checked local gap;no corresponding full warning addition printed at the inspected locus | IV42:922 running text |
| 30 | V288:895–896 checked local gap;no corresponding full warning addition printed at the inspected locus | IV42:923 running text |
New Naqqali