Afrasiab Writes to the Faghfoor
25 published couplets; letter, fortification, provision and feast.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 25 published couplets; letter, fortification, provision and feast. |
| Moscow | V298–300:1062–1085; maxim actual300n3; envoy actual298n30; letter expansion V423 Appendix IX. |
| Mohl | IV49–50:1095–1119; maxim in running text. |
| Ganjoor | sh11:117–139 and sh12:1; checked gap for maxim. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | IV238–240:1068–1094; bracketed1074–1075 source-only; maxim in running text. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5The appeal combines grievance and affection
English 1–5; individual edition accounts below.
Moscow V298:1062 running text · Mohl IV49:1095 running text · Khaleghi IV238:1068 running text · Ganjoor sh11:117 running body · Moscow V298:1063 running text · Mohl IV49:1096 running text · Khaleghi IV238:1069 running text · Ganjoor sh11:118 running body · Moscow V298:1064 running text · Mohl IV49:1097 running text · Khaleghi IV238:1070 running text · Ganjoor sh11:119 running body · Moscow V298:1065 running text · Mohl IV49:1098 running text · Khaleghi IV238:1071 running text · Ganjoor sh11:120 running body · Moscow V298:1066 running text · Mohl IV49:1099 running text · Khaleghi IV238:1072 running text · Ganjoor sh11:121 running body · Moscow V423 Appendix IX, six couplets after1063
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi begin with blessings and Afrasiab’s complaint that fortune grants him only warfare. English names Khosrow where the main texts refer to the person whom Afrasiab nurtured instead of killing; this clarifies the grievance without changing its object. The request then turns to the Faghfoor’s affection, expressed as friendship in Khaleghi and as love in the other main texts. English preserves the appeal to the speaker’s soul as witness. Moscow’s Appendix IX prints six further couplets after the complaint, elaborating the losses and request for help; these are appendix evidence, not part of Moscow’s running letter or the English sequence. The alternative request for troops remains in all four. English’s strike and slay intensifies the approaching enemy’s purpose.
6–10A messenger is welcomed while the king cannot rest
English 6–10; individual edition accounts below.
Moscow V298:1067 running text · Mohl IV49:1100 running text · Khaleghi IV239:1073 running text · Ganjoor sh11:122 running body · Moscow V299:1068 running text · Mohl IV49:1101 running text · Khaleghi IV239:1076 running text · Ganjoor sh11:123 running body · Moscow V299:1069 running text · Mohl IV49:1102 running text · Khaleghi IV239:1077 running text · Ganjoor sh11:124 running body · Moscow V299:1070 running text · Mohl IV49:1103 running text · Khaleghi IV239:1078 running text · Ganjoor sh11:125 running body · Moscow V299:1071 running text · Mohl IV49:1104 running text · Khaleghi IV239:1079 running text · Ganjoor sh11:126 running body
All four send the messenger to Chin at sleeping time and give him a gracious reception. English makes that timing dead of night. Khaleghi additionally prints two bracketed couplets for his greeting, report and delivery of the letter; Moscow’s actual apparatus also preserves an expanded envoy sequence, with different wording. Neither becomes an extra English couplet, and Mohl and Ganjoor have checked local gaps at that point. The welcome contrasts with Afrasiab’s inability to eat, sleep or rest at Gang. English retains that contrast before turning to the preparations on the walls. The defensive equipment and heavy stones are common to all four, as are the magicians summoned for the task. Their presence is textual; no particular magical technique or engineering method is supplied.
11–16Weapons are named without reconstructing their machinery
English 11–16; individual edition accounts below.
Moscow V299:1072 running text · Mohl IV50:1105 running text · Khaleghi IV239:1080 running text · Ganjoor sh11:127 running body · Moscow V299:1073 running text · Mohl IV50:1106 running text · Khaleghi IV239:1081 running text · Ganjoor sh11:128 running body · Moscow V299:1074 running text · Mohl IV50:1107 running text · Khaleghi IV239:1082 running text · Ganjoor sh11:129 running body · Moscow V299:1075 running text · Mohl IV50:1108 running text · Khaleghi IV239:1083 running text · Ganjoor sh11:130 running body · Moscow V299:1076 running text · Mohl IV50:1109 running text · Khaleghi IV239:1084 running text · Ganjoor sh11:131 running body · Moscow V299:1077 running text · Mohl IV50:1110 running text · Khaleghi IV239:1085 running text · Ganjoor sh11:132 running body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi summon experts from Rum and name the Jathaliq alongside the paired siege engines. English’s ballistae and catapults makes that equipment intelligible, while towered tall adds scale beyond the concise naming. The rhinoceros shields and crossbows are shared. For body armor, however, the main texts give khaftan rather than English’s jowshan; actual readings in Moscow’s and Khaleghi’s apparatus supply the latter term. This supports the vocabulary without making the main texts identical. The steel claws made by smiths and fixed to long spears then receive a clear purpose: catching anyone climbing the wall or forcing retreat. English follows the action closely. The passage does not establish the precise mechanical design, the identity of the Roman specialists or a historical officeholder.
17–20Provision gives way to celebration
English 17–20; individual edition accounts below.
Moscow V299:1078 running text · Mohl IV50:1111 running text · Khaleghi IV239:1086 running text · Ganjoor sh11:133 running body · Moscow V299:1079 running text · Mohl IV50:1112 running text · Khaleghi IV239:1087 running text · Ganjoor sh11:134 running body · Moscow V299:1080 running text · Mohl IV50:1113 running text · Khaleghi IV239:1088 running text · Ganjoor sh11:135 running body · Moscow V299:1081 running text · Mohl IV50:1114 running text · Khaleghi IV239:1089 running text · Ganjoor sh11:136 running body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi describe payment and fair dealing before listing weapons and distributing them, especially to fighting men. English puts justice before wages, reversing the main half-line order but keeping both actions; Moscow’s apparatus also records a reversed order. Swords, protective horse equipment, helmets, bows, Chinese shields and arrows remain a concrete inventory rather than a general assertion of readiness. English’s greater share interprets the special attention to warriors as a quantitative preference, although the sources do not specify a proportion. Once the work is complete, the king sits at a feast with his loyal warriors. That transition matters: the celebration follows organization and supply. The English’s festive cheer therefore has a narrative basis, while the preceding sleeplessness remains part of the portrait.
21–25Music, expenditure and the uncertainty of tomorrow
English 21–25; individual edition accounts below.
Moscow V299:1082 running text · Mohl IV50:1115 running text · Khaleghi IV240:1090 running text · Ganjoor sh11:137 running body · Moscow V299:1083 running text · Mohl IV50:1116 running text · Khaleghi IV240:1091 running text · Ganjoor sh11:138 running body · Moscow V300:1084 running text · Mohl IV50:1117 running text · Khaleghi IV240:1092 running text · Ganjoor sh11:139 running body · Moscow V300:1084–1085 checked main gap; actual V300n3 added couplet · Mohl IV50:1118 running text · Khaleghi IV240:1093 running text · Ganjoor sh11:139–sh12:1 checked local gap · Moscow V300:1085 running text · Mohl IV50:1119 running text · Khaleghi IV240:1094 running text · Ganjoor sh12:1 running body
All four place a hundred fairy-faced harpists at court and describe continual feasting and expenditure. Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor associate song with Turkish lips; Khaleghi’s main wording differs, with the former construction also printed in its apparatus. English’s Turkish songs shifts attention from performers to repertoire, without proving the language of their songs. The maxim against grief appears in Mohl and Khaleghi’s running text and in Moscow’s actual apparatus, but Ganjoor has a checked local gap. English thus retains an attested reflection before the shared two weeks of ease and the question of tomorrow’s happiness. Ganjoor and Khaleghi place a new section heading before that final couplet; the published English keeps it here. Its closing uncertainty qualifies the apparent escape from anxiety.
Source record and limits
25 English couplets and 5 notes. Moscow V298–300:1062–1085 (24 running units); Mohl IV49–50:1095–1119 (25); Ganjoor mahmood/sh11:117–139 and sh12:1 (24); Khaleghi IV238–240:1068–1094 (27, including two bracketed source-only units1074–1075). Published English retains the final two-week reflection despite headings in Ganjoor and Khaleghi.
- F&R English: 25 published couplets; letter, fortification, provision and feast.
- Moscow: V298–300:1062–1085; maxim actual300n3; envoy actual298n30; letter expansion V423 Appendix IX.
- Mohl: IV49–50:1095–1119; maxim in running text.
- Ganjoor: sh11:117–139 and sh12:1; checked gap for maxim.
- Khaleghi-Motlagh: IV238–240:1068–1094; bracketed1074–1075 source-only; maxim in running text.
English24 has Mohl/Khaleghi running support and actual Moscow V300n3 apparatus support, with checked Moscow and Ganjoor main gaps. Khaleghi’s two bracketed envoy units are recorded separately. Moscow Appendix IX expands the letter in six appendix couplets, not running text. English jowshan has actual apparatus lexical support despite main khaftan wording. Technical reconstruction, historical identification of the Jathaliq and the language of the songs remain unverified. All inherited flags retained.
Moscow V298n22 points to Appendix IX; its six couplets are actually printed at V423 and expand the letter with recollection of losses, Khosrow’s attack, wounded pride and hope of Chinese help. They are not mapped as English running equivalents. Actual Moscow298n30 envoy additions;299n1 reception additions,n8 armor,n16 order,n22 harpist wording;300n3 fate maxim. Actual Khaleghi238n32 affection wording;239n10 armor;240n7 song wording. Khaleghi239:1074–1075 are bracketed running text, not apparatus.
Moscow Appendix IX; Ganjoor closing couplet
- Mohl IV50:1118 running; English24: اگر بودنی بود دل را به غم / سزد گر نداری نمایی دژم
- Moscow V299:1074 running armor: خفتان و ترگ
- Moscow V299n8 actual armor variant: جوشن و خود
- Khaleghi IV240:1091 running song phrase: سرود و لب ترک و می خواستی
- Moscow V299:1083 / Mohl IV50:1116 song phrase: سرود از لب ترک و می خواستی
- Moscow V423 Appendix IX:6, appendix only: امیدم چنانست که فغفور چین / بیاید بیاری بتوران زمین
C4.17 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | V298:1062 running text | IV49:1095 running text |
| 2 | V298:1063 running text | IV49:1096 running text |
| 3 | V298:1064 running text | IV49:1097 running text |
| 4 | V298:1065 running text | IV49:1098 running text |
| 5 | V298:1066 running text | IV49:1099 running text |
| 6 | V298:1067 running text | IV49:1100 running text |
| 7 | V299:1068 running text | IV49:1101 running text |
| 8 | V299:1069 running text | IV49:1102 running text |
| 9 | V299:1070 running text | IV49:1103 running text |
| 10 | V299:1071 running text | IV49:1104 running text |
| 11 | V299:1072 running text | IV50:1105 running text |
| 12 | V299:1073 running text | IV50:1106 running text |
| 13 | V299:1074 running text | IV50:1107 running text |
| 14 | V299:1075 running text | IV50:1108 running text |
| 15 | V299:1076 running text | IV50:1109 running text |
| 16 | V299:1077 running text | IV50:1110 running text |
| 17 | V299:1078 running text | IV50:1111 running text |
| 18 | V299:1079 running text | IV50:1112 running text |
| 19 | V299:1080 running text | IV50:1113 running text |
| 20 | V299:1081 running text | IV50:1114 running text |
| 21 | V299:1082 running text | IV50:1115 running text |
| 22 | V299:1083 running text | IV50:1116 running text |
| 23 | V300:1084 running text | IV50:1117 running text |
| 24 | V300:1084–1085 checked main gap; actual V300n3 added couplet | IV50:1118 running text |
| 25 | V300:1085 running text | IV50:1119 running text |
New Naqqali