Khosrow’s Embassy to the Faghfoor and Makran
45 published couplets unchanged;8 notes;Mohl supports without troops;manufacturing inference qualified.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 45 published couplets unchanged;8 notes;Mohl supports without troops;manufacturing inference qualified. |
| Moscow | V344–346:1845–1889;45 running units;with army;hundred-thousand dinars;bridge wording in actual apparatus. |
| Mohl | IV83–84:1885–1929;45 running units;without troops;hundred-thousand dinars;city of Khutan/city reception. |
| Ganjoor | mahmood/sh20:32–76;45 running units;with army;hundred-thousand dinars. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | IV289–292:1854–1898;45 running units;with army;thirty-thousand main,hundred-thousand actual variant. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6Diplomacy under an ultimatum
English 1–6; individual edition accounts and actual apparatus loci below.
Moscow V344:1845 running text · Mohl IV83:1885 running text · Khaleghi IV289:1854 running text · Ganjoor sh20:32 running body · Moscow V344:1846 running text · Mohl IV83:1886 running text · Khaleghi IV289:1855 running text · Ganjoor sh20:33 running body · Moscow V344:1847 running text · Mohl IV83:1887 running text · Khaleghi IV289:1856 running text · Ganjoor sh20:34 running body · Moscow V344:1848 running text · Mohl IV83:1888 running text · Khaleghi IV289:1857 running text · Ganjoor sh20:35 running body · Moscow V344:1849 running text · Mohl IV83:1889 running text · Khaleghi IV290:1858 running text · Ganjoor sh20:36 running body · Moscow V344:1850 running text · Mohl IV83:1890 running text · Khaleghi IV290:1859 running text · Ganjoor sh20:37 running body
All four begin by selecting men competent in speaking and listening, making communication a qualification for embassy rather than merely dispatching soldiers. English’s serve his will specifies the purpose of that competence. Justice, obedience and repentance are then tied to supplying the army and meeting its advance. Within your land gives the encounter a territorial location that the unit itself leaves as the road. The warning’s second term differs: Moscow and Ganjoor use covenant, Mohl combat, and Khaleghi meeting or presence. English’s undertaking accommodates the broader demand without reproducing each branch. The final contrast is between battle and bazm, the convivial alternative. Peace my terms would yield makes the diplomatic implication explicit, but should not be treated as a separately stated peace agreement.
7–12Submission and the repair of the route
English 7–12; individual edition accounts and actual apparatus loci below.
Moscow V344:1851 running text · Mohl IV83:1891 running text · Khaleghi IV290:1860 running text · Ganjoor sh20:38 running body · Moscow V344:1852 running text · Mohl IV83:1892 running text · Khaleghi IV290:1861 running text · Ganjoor sh20:39 running body · Moscow V344:1853 running text · Mohl IV83:1893 running text · Khaleghi IV290:1862 running text · Ganjoor sh20:40 running body · Moscow V344:1854 running text · Mohl IV83:1894 running text · Khaleghi IV290:1863 running text · Ganjoor sh20:41 running body · Moscow V344:1855 running text · Mohl IV83:1895 running text · Khaleghi IV290:1864 running text · Ganjoor sh20:42 running body · Moscow V344:1856 running text · Mohl IV83:1896 running text · Khaleghi IV290:1865 running text · Ganjoor sh20:43 running body
The envoys reach renowned rulers, whose distress gives way to warm words and soft speech in every presentation. English intensifies their feelings into bitter woe and generalizes the ambassador addressed into each man greeted. The submission formula differs locally. Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor deny movement over the earth except by royal command; Khaleghi instead pictures servants bowing their heads to command and judgment. English turns the restrictive formula into movement when commanded, retaining obedience but weakening the explicit exclusion of independent action. The ensuing survey and repair of damaged passages is shared. English’s road repair follows the condition of ruin, while diligence and grace add qualities to the promised provisioning and service rather than identifying additional work or supplies.
13–18Conditional generosity and the Makran refusal
English 13–18; individual edition accounts and actual apparatus loci below.
Moscow V344:1857 running text · Mohl IV83:1897 running text · Khaleghi IV290:1866 running text · Ganjoor sh20:44 running body · Moscow V344:1858 running text · Mohl IV83:1898 running text · Khaleghi IV290:1867 running text · Ganjoor sh20:45 running body · Moscow V344:1859 running text · Mohl IV83:1899 running text · Khaleghi IV290:1868 running text · Ganjoor sh20:46 running body · Moscow V344:1860 running text · Mohl IV83:1900 running text · Khaleghi IV290:1869 running text · Ganjoor sh20:47 running body · Moscow V344:1861 running text · Mohl IV83:1901 running text · Khaleghi IV290:1870 running text · Ganjoor sh20:48 running body · Moscow V344:1862 running text · Mohl IV83:1902 running text · Khaleghi IV290:1871 running text · Ganjoor sh20:49 running body
The wise speakers’ promise is conditional in all four accounts: if the king passes without harming them, they will give generously to the poor and prepare food and ceremonial offerings. English’s turning sky adds imagery without changing that practical condition. Welcome gifts interprets the scattering offerings as reception, while the gifts to departing envoys mark a distinct diplomatic exchange. Their joyful return then contrasts with the envoy’s reception in Makran. English interprets the king’s different heart as resistance, an interpretation confirmed by the following hostile response rather than a separate quoted declaration. The letter and oral message are both delivered. As he first had heard strengthens faithful repetition, and reviled specifies a verbal form for the source’s humiliation of the envoy.
19–24Sovereignty and the terms of passage
English 19–24; individual edition accounts and actual apparatus loci below.
Moscow V344:1863 running text · Mohl IV83:1903 running text · Khaleghi IV290:1872 running text · Ganjoor sh20:50 running body · Moscow V345:1864 running text · Mohl IV83:1904 running text · Khaleghi IV290:1873 running text · Ganjoor sh20:51 running body · Moscow V345:1865 running text · Mohl IV84:1905 running text · Khaleghi IV291:1874 running text · Ganjoor sh20:52 running body · Moscow V345:1866 running text · Mohl IV84:1906 running text · Khaleghi IV291:1875 running text · Ganjoor sh20:53 running body · Moscow V345:1867 running text · Mohl IV84:1907 running text · Khaleghi IV291:1876 running text · Ganjoor sh20:54 running body · Moscow V345:1868 running text · Mohl IV84:1908 running text · Khaleghi IV291:1877 running text · Ganjoor sh20:55 running body
The Makran king rejects a claim of superiority made without seeing him or his people; English adds a gate as the imagined point of encounter. His claim that the sun first shines on his land is royal speech, not evidence for a modern geographical identification. English personifies shining as seeing with eyes. The inventory of wisdom, treasure and strength then leads to the maxim that every creature is a king and may legitimately seek passage. The precise condition of transit differs. Mohl explicitly gives without troops, supporting English, whereas Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi’s running texts say with the army. All prohibit harm. Keeping the branches distinct explains the English’s restriction without making the other editions say the same thing.
25–30The rejection and the march toward Khutan
English 25–30; individual edition accounts and actual apparatus loci below.
Moscow V345:1869 running text · Mohl IV84:1909 running text · Khaleghi IV291:1878 running text · Ganjoor sh20:56 running body · Moscow V345:1870 running text · Mohl IV84:1910 running text · Khaleghi IV291:1879 running text · Ganjoor sh20:57 running body · Moscow V345:1871 running text · Mohl IV84:1911 running text · Khaleghi IV291:1880 running text · Ganjoor sh20:58 running body · Moscow V345:1872 running text · Mohl IV84:1912 running text · Khaleghi IV291:1881 running text · Ganjoor sh20:59 running body · Moscow V345:1873 running text · Mohl IV84:1913 running text · Khaleghi IV291:1882 running text · Ganjoor sh20:60 running body · Moscow V345:1874 running text · Mohl IV84:1914 running text · Khaleghi IV291:1883 running text · Ganjoor sh20:61 running body
The king’s subsequent refusal denies an armed entrant any share in his kingship and forbids crossing his territory. English’s gate gives a concrete threshold to the threatened entry, while long endure and seem sure elaborate the rejection of victory even under a favorable star. All four then move from the reported answer to Khosrow’s departure. No second ultimatum is required to connect these actions. The destination’s wording varies slightly: Mohl names the city of Khutan, Moscow and Ganjoor movement toward Khutan, and Khaleghi the road of Khutan. English’s city therefore has direct support. The Khan and Faghfoor meet the advancing king with apologies and blessings, contrasting their conciliatory reception with Makran’s refusal without assigning them an unrecorded motive.
31–35Three stages and the prepared welcome
English 31–35; individual edition accounts and actual apparatus loci below.
Moscow V345:1875 running text · Mohl IV84:1915 running text · Khaleghi IV291:1884 running text · Ganjoor sh20:62 running body · Moscow V345:1876 running text; actual V345n20 bridge-and-road variant · Mohl IV84:1916 running text · Khaleghi IV291:1885 running text · Ganjoor sh20:63 running body · Moscow V345:1877 running text · Mohl IV84:1917 running text · Khaleghi IV291:1886 running text · Ganjoor sh20:64 running body · Moscow V345:1878 running text · Mohl IV84:1918 running text · Khaleghi IV291:1887 running text · Ganjoor sh20:65 running body · Moscow V345:1879 running text · Mohl IV84:1919 running text · Khaleghi IV291:1888 running text · Ganjoor sh20:66 running body
All four locate the meeting three stages from Chin, but that narrative measure should not be converted into a modern distance. English’s short of Chin supplies direction and bright array adds visual display. The repaired route is compared with a hand; cleared and leveled interprets the simile rather than reproducing an engineering specification. Khaleghi names bridges and road, a branch also printed in Moscow’s apparatus, while Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor’s main wording centers on the road. Provisioning includes food, clothing and festive furnishings. English’s road follows Mohl and Khaleghi’s local wording. Their next unit also gives the city where Moscow and Ganjoor give the king; English adds the gate. Brocade, saffron and scattered dirhams are shared, with the ground supplied as their landing surface.
36–40The Faghfoor’s invitation
English 36–40; individual edition accounts and actual apparatus loci below.
Moscow V345:1880 running text · Mohl IV84:1920 running text · Khaleghi IV291:1889 running text · Ganjoor sh20:67 running body · Moscow V345:1881 running text · Mohl IV84:1921 running text · Khaleghi IV292:1890 running text · Ganjoor sh20:68 running body · Moscow V346:1882 running text · Mohl IV84:1922 running text · Khaleghi IV292:1891 running text · Ganjoor sh20:69 running body · Moscow V346:1883 running text · Mohl IV84:1923 running text · Khaleghi IV292:1892 running text · Ganjoor sh20:70 running body · Moscow V346:1884 running text · Mohl IV84:1924 running text · Khaleghi IV292:1893 running text · Ganjoor sh20:71 running body
The Faghfoor’s growing ease with Khosrow precedes his movement toward the palace in all four accounts. English explains that movement as leading the guest into his halls, drawing purpose from the sequence. The address then combines acknowledged subordination with a modest question about whether the hosts are worthy of such service. In his land adds a territorial frame to the relationship. Khosrow’s fortune makes the world prosperous and his friends happy; English bright and pure delight heighten those effects. The comparison between inadequate halls and the road is an invitation shaped by self-deprecation rather than an objective assessment of accommodation. English preserves that rhetoric, then adds shared placement and royal pride to the king’s entrance and occupation of the honored seat.
41–45The gift’s quantity and the departure
English 41–45; individual edition accounts and actual apparatus loci below.
Moscow V346:1885 running text · Mohl IV84:1925 running text · Khaleghi IV292:1894 running text; actual IV292n15 hundred-thousand variant · Ganjoor sh20:72 running body · Moscow V346:1886 running text · Mohl IV84:1926 running text · Khaleghi IV292:1895 running text · Ganjoor sh20:73 running body · Moscow V346:1887 running text · Mohl IV84:1927 running text · Khaleghi IV292:1896 running text · Ganjoor sh20:74 running body · Moscow V346:1888 running text · Mohl IV84:1928 running text · Khaleghi IV292:1897 running text · Ganjoor sh20:75 running body · Moscow V346:1889 running text · Mohl IV84:1929 running text · Khaleghi IV292:1898 running text · Ganjoor sh20:76 running body
Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor give the Faghfoor’s offering as a hundred thousand Chinese dinars, supporting English. Khaleghi prints thirty thousand in the running text and records the hundred-thousand branch in actual apparatus. The difference must remain visible rather than being normalized to the translation. In Chin wrought interprets the coins’ description as their place of manufacture; the checked term does not independently establish a minting location. The Faghfoor’s standing service with the frontier lords and his repeated morning gifts are shared. English adds holding court to the three-month stay and first rays to the mornings. Departure in the fourth month follows that duration naturally. Rostam remains behind, but apart from his king’s band does not establish his assignment or the reason for staying.
Source record and limits
45 English couplets;8 notes. Moscow V344–346:1845–1889,Mohl IV83–84:1885–1929,Ganjoor mahmood/sh20:32–76,and Khaleghi IV289–292:1854–1898 each have45 running units. All45 English couplets mapped individually to both primary editions before secondary comparison. No source-only running unit and no running-text gap in this chapter’s declared spans.
Actual Moscow V345n20 records bridge-and-road wording for English32. Actual Khaleghi IV292n15 records hundred thousand against thirty thousand in its running text for English41. Khaleghi IV291n11 actually prints additional messenger-return/report wording near the transition from refusal to Khosrow hearing it; the checked main sequences proceed directly from refusal to hearing/movement (Moscow1871→1872,Mohl1911→1912,Ganjoor20:58→59,Khaleghi1880→1881). This remains actual apparatus evidence,not an added running unit or English count. No appendix evidence used;no appendix-wide or manuscript-wide absence certified. An unprinted addition notice is not counted as verification.
Published English unchanged. Without troops at24 has direct Mohl main support against with army in Moscow/Ganjoor/Khaleghi. Hundred thousand at41 follows Moscow/Mohl/Ganjoor against Khaleghi thirty thousand; actual Khaleghi apparatus records the larger figure. City at29 and34 has Mohl main support. C4.34.41 in Chin wrought is an unverified manufacturing inference from Chinese dinars,not a certified minting fact. People at our gate at19 and gate at25/34 add setting;no physical gate encounter certified. Road engineering,modern geography,administrative boundaries and Rostam’s reason for remaining are not independently established. Every inherited flag retained,including C4.21.20 marble,C4.31.10/41,C4.32.55 and C4.33.13/26.
The Persian reference column follows Ganjoor. Moscow and Mohl were inspected individually first,then Ganjoor and Khaleghi. Every English unit has a running counterpart in each presentation,but numerical,lexical and political differences are retained individually. Actual apparatus evidence remains separate from running text;no appendix evidence is used. The additional messenger-report wording is not silently inserted into any running sequence.
Mohl IV84:1908 main; English24: بی سپاه
Moscow V345:1868 / Ganjoor sh20:55 / Khaleghi IV291:1877 main; English24: با سپاه
Moscow V345n20 actual variant; Khaleghi IV291:1885 main; English32: پل و راه
Moscow V346:1885 / Mohl IV84:1925 / Ganjoor sh20:72 main; English41: صد هزار
Khaleghi IV292:1894 main; English41: سی هزار
Khaleghi IV292n15 actual variant; English41: صد هزار
Ganjoor sh20:72 main; English41: دینار چینی
Ganjoor sh20:76 main; English45: و رستم آنجا بماند
C4.34 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | V344:1845 running text | IV83:1885 running text |
| 2 | V344:1846 running text | IV83:1886 running text |
| 3 | V344:1847 running text | IV83:1887 running text |
| 4 | V344:1848 running text | IV83:1888 running text |
| 5 | V344:1849 running text | IV83:1889 running text |
| 6 | V344:1850 running text | IV83:1890 running text |
| 7 | V344:1851 running text | IV83:1891 running text |
| 8 | V344:1852 running text | IV83:1892 running text |
| 9 | V344:1853 running text | IV83:1893 running text |
| 10 | V344:1854 running text | IV83:1894 running text |
| 11 | V344:1855 running text | IV83:1895 running text |
| 12 | V344:1856 running text | IV83:1896 running text |
| 13 | V344:1857 running text | IV83:1897 running text |
| 14 | V344:1858 running text | IV83:1898 running text |
| 15 | V344:1859 running text | IV83:1899 running text |
| 16 | V344:1860 running text | IV83:1900 running text |
| 17 | V344:1861 running text | IV83:1901 running text |
| 18 | V344:1862 running text | IV83:1902 running text |
| 19 | V344:1863 running text | IV83:1903 running text |
| 20 | V345:1864 running text | IV83:1904 running text |
| 21 | V345:1865 running text | IV84:1905 running text |
| 22 | V345:1866 running text | IV84:1906 running text |
| 23 | V345:1867 running text | IV84:1907 running text |
| 24 | V345:1868 running text | IV84:1908 running text |
| 25 | V345:1869 running text | IV84:1909 running text |
| 26 | V345:1870 running text | IV84:1910 running text |
| 27 | V345:1871 running text | IV84:1911 running text |
| 28 | V345:1872 running text | IV84:1912 running text |
| 29 | V345:1873 running text | IV84:1913 running text |
| 30 | V345:1874 running text | IV84:1914 running text |
| 31 | V345:1875 running text | IV84:1915 running text |
| 32 | V345:1876 running text; actual V345n20 bridge-and-road variant | IV84:1916 running text |
| 33 | V345:1877 running text | IV84:1917 running text |
| 34 | V345:1878 running text | IV84:1918 running text |
| 35 | V345:1879 running text | IV84:1919 running text |
| 36 | V345:1880 running text | IV84:1920 running text |
| 37 | V345:1881 running text | IV84:1921 running text |
| 38 | V346:1882 running text | IV84:1922 running text |
| 39 | V346:1883 running text | IV84:1923 running text |
| 40 | V346:1884 running text | IV84:1924 running text |
| 41 | V346:1885 running text | IV84:1925 running text |
| 42 | V346:1886 running text | IV84:1926 running text |
| 43 | V346:1887 running text | IV84:1927 running text |
| 44 | V346:1888 running text | IV84:1928 running text |
| 45 | V346:1889 running text | IV84:1929 running text |
New Naqqali