Kay Khosrow Crosses the Sea
49 published couplets unchanged;9 notes;Mohl supports creature anatomy and Turanian agency at45.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 49 published couplets unchanged;9 notes;Mohl supports creature anatomy and Turanian agency at45. |
| Moscow | V350–353:1956–2002;47 main units;23/39 actual apparatus;45 relocated with Siavash’s-son subject. |
| Mohl | IV87–89:1996–2044;49 main units;full primary running counterpart for every English couplet. |
| Ganjoor | mahmood/sh21:52–98;47 units;local gaps for23/39;45 relocated with Siavash’s-son subject. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | IV296–299:1964–2011;48 main units;23 actual apparatus;Turanian subject/placement at45;different second creature anatomy. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5Preparation and the year’s provisions
English 1–5; individual edition accounts and actual apparatus loci below.
Moscow V350:1956 running text · Mohl IV87:1996 running text · Khaleghi IV296:1964 running text · Ganjoor sh21:52 running body · Moscow V350:1957 running text · Mohl IV87:1997 running text · Khaleghi IV296:1965 running text · Ganjoor sh21:53 running body · Moscow V350:1958 running text · Mohl IV87:1998 running text · Khaleghi IV296:1966 running text · Ganjoor sh21:54 running body · Moscow V350:1959 running text · Mohl IV88:1999 running text · Khaleghi IV296:1967 running text · Ganjoor sh21:55 running body · Moscow V350:1960 running text · Mohl IV88:2000 running text · Khaleghi IV296:1968 running text · Ganjoor sh21:56 running body
All four accounts begin with arrival at Zereh, the warriors loosening their belts, maritime specialists brought from Chin and Makran, and preparation before launching. English makes their expertise concrete through sail and oar, while finest evaluates the men beyond the checked wording. Their skills do not establish a modern occupational category. The year belongs to the provision or journey horizon here; it should not override the seven months later given for the completed crossing. English resolves the provisioning sense clearly, but the farther coast is an anticipated destination rather than a separate promise in that unit. The fortunate king’s honorable departure is shared. His purposefulness and his ensuing dependence on divine protection can therefore coexist without making careful preparation unnecessary.
6–11The order and scope of the prayer
English 6–11; individual edition accounts and actual apparatus loci below.
Moscow V350:1961 running text · Mohl IV88:2001 running text · Khaleghi IV296:1969 running text · Ganjoor sh21:57 running body · Moscow V350:1963 running text · Mohl IV88:2002 running text · Khaleghi IV297:1971 running text · Ganjoor sh21:59 running body · Moscow V350:1962 running text · Mohl IV88:2003 running text · Khaleghi IV297:1970 running text · Ganjoor sh21:58 running body · Moscow V350:1964 running text · Mohl IV88:2004 running text · Khaleghi IV297:1972 running text · Ganjoor sh21:60 running body · Moscow V350:1965 running text · Mohl IV88:2005 running text · Khaleghi IV297:1973 running text · Ganjoor sh21:61 running body · Moscow V350:1966 running text · Mohl IV88:2006 running text · Khaleghi IV297:1974 running text · Ganjoor sh21:62 running body
The prayer covers king, army, Iranian chiefs, equipment and throne in all four sources. Its order differs: Mohl names the collective charge before the request for safe landfall, whereas Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi place the landfall request first. English follows Mohl and turns the connected list into a complete act of prayer. The direct address then moves from knowledge of the manifest and hidden to guardianship of land, sea and the cosmos. English’s mystery emphasizes hidden things, and its starry heights generalizes the named Pleiades. Khaleghi’s celestial sphere differs from the earthward member of the other three cosmic pairings. The final protective petition preserves the royal inventory; all my own broadens it without turning a spoken request into guaranteed immunity.
12–17The dangerous wind and the Lion’s Mouth
English 12–17; individual edition accounts and actual apparatus loci below.
Moscow V351:1967 running text · Mohl IV88:2007 running text · Khaleghi IV297:1975 running text · Ganjoor sh21:63 running body · Moscow V351:1968 running text · Mohl IV88:2008 running text · Khaleghi IV297:1976 running text · Ganjoor sh21:64 running body · Moscow V351:1969 running text · Mohl IV88:2009 running text · Khaleghi IV297:1977 running text · Ganjoor sh21:65 running body · Moscow V351:1970 running text · Mohl IV88:2010 running text · Khaleghi IV297:1978 running text · Ganjoor sh21:66 running body · Moscow V351:1971 running text · Mohl IV88:2011 running text · Khaleghi IV297:1979 running text · Ganjoor sh21:67 running body · Moscow V351:1972 running text · Mohl IV88:2012 running text · Khaleghi IV297:1980 running text · Ganjoor sh21:68 running body
The sea is perilous in all four presentations, and English expresses that danger through fear and blood running cold. The blood image and the sleeping ship’s timbers add physical concreteness beyond the checked words. Six months of sailing lead into a seventh-month danger; the English’s half-year formulation follows Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor against Khaleghi’s different wording about the year renewing. The sail turns under the north wind. Moscow and Ganjoor introduce lightning, while Mohl and Khaleghi mention the sailor’s pole; English’s struggle to regain the route interprets the difficulty. All retain the sailors’ name Lion’s Mouth. No modern location or weather regime is established here. Divine protection then distinguishes Khosrow’s fortunate passage from the general danger, rather than denying that danger exists.
18–23Wonders whose anatomy varies by edition
English 18–23; individual edition accounts and actual apparatus loci below.
Moscow V351:1973 running text · Mohl IV88:2013 running text · Khaleghi IV297:1981 running text · Ganjoor sh21:69 running body · Moscow V351:1974 running text · Mohl IV88:2014 running text · Khaleghi IV297:1982 running text · Ganjoor sh21:70 running body · Moscow V351:1975 running text · Mohl IV88:2015 running text · Khaleghi IV297:1983 running text · Ganjoor sh21:71 running body · Moscow V351:1977 running text · Mohl IV88:2016 running text · Khaleghi IV298:1985 running text · Ganjoor sh21:73 running body · Moscow V351:1976 running text · Mohl IV88:2017 running text · Khaleghi IV297:1984 running text · Ganjoor sh21:72 running body · Moscow V351n18 actual full bear/lamb unit with explicit hog variant;checked main gap1977→1978 · Mohl IV88:2018 running text · Khaleghi IV298n2 actual full hog/lamb unit;checked main gap1985→1986 · Ganjoor Checked local running gap sh21:73→74
The soldiers’ pointing, the cattle resisting lions, and the woolly human forms occur in all four sources. Brave adds a moral quality to the cattle’s resistance. The composite creatures require closer discrimination. Mohl supports both English forms: fish body with leopard head, and gur head with nahang body. Khaleghi agrees on the first but reverses body and head in the second. Moscow’s running text combines a fishlike form with leopard body and gur feet with nahang body; Ganjoor combines fish head with nahang body and gur feet with leopard body. These are textual differences, not equivalent zoological descriptions. English also follows Mohl in placing those creatures before the buffalo-headed forms. The hog-headed, lamb-bodied creature is running text in Mohl and printed apparatus in Khaleghi. Moscow’s full apparatus unit gives a bear’s head with an explicit hog variant; Ganjoor has a checked local gap. The English therefore has direct primary support without requiring the four accounts to share one anatomy.
24–29A safe crossing and the response on shore
English 24–29; individual edition accounts and actual apparatus loci below.
Moscow V351:1978 running text · Mohl IV88:2019 running text · Khaleghi IV298:1986 running text · Ganjoor sh21:74 running body · Moscow V351:1979 running text · Mohl IV88:2020 running text · Khaleghi IV298:1987 running text · Ganjoor sh21:75 running body · Moscow V352:1980 running text · Mohl IV88:2021 running text · Khaleghi IV298:1988 running text · Ganjoor sh21:76 running body · Moscow V352:1981 running text · Mohl IV88:2022 running text · Khaleghi IV298:1989 running text · Ganjoor sh21:77 running body · Moscow V352:1982 running text · Mohl IV88:2023 running text · Khaleghi IV298:1990 running text · Ganjoor sh21:78 running body · Moscow V352:1983 running text · Mohl IV89:2024 running text · Khaleghi IV298:1991 running text · Ganjoor sh21:79 running body
All four move from mutual pointing and praise to favorable air, a seven-month crossing and landfall. English’s hostile wind interprets the adverse wind in context; it need not mean that all movement of air ceases. Keeping the completed seven months distinct from the earlier year’s provisions avoids an artificial chronological contradiction. On landing, the king sees the open plain and then turns to the Creator with his face upon the ground. English anticipates thanksgiving in the landing couplet and makes praise explicit in the next. Khaleghi also specifies weeping, which English does not retain there. The ships and boats are drawn out of the water before urgent departure. Needless waiting renders that urgency without establishing a particular omitted task or delay.
30–35Resemblance, delegated rule and detachment
English 30–35; individual edition accounts and actual apparatus loci below.
Moscow V352:1984 running text · Mohl IV89:2025 running text · Khaleghi IV298:1992 running text · Ganjoor sh21:80 running body · Moscow V352:1985 running text · Mohl IV89:2026 running text · Khaleghi IV298:1993 running text · Ganjoor sh21:81 running body · Moscow V352:1986 running text · Mohl IV89:2027 running text · Khaleghi IV298:1994 running text · Ganjoor sh21:82 running body · Moscow V352:1987 running text · Mohl IV89:2028 running text · Khaleghi IV298:1995 running text · Ganjoor sh21:83 running body · Moscow V352:1988 running text;actual V352n9 heart/city/things variant · Mohl IV89:2029 running text · Khaleghi IV298:1996 running text · Ganjoor sh21:84 running body · Moscow V352:1989 running text · Mohl IV89:2030 running text · Khaleghi IV298:1997 running text · Ganjoor sh21:85 running body
The easy passage over sand, cities resembling Chin, and speech resembling Makran are shared by all four. English’s dunes, shape and stamp make the landscape and resemblance more visual, but they do not identify a modern region, architectural style or language. Rest and provisions precede Giv’s appointment; harvest gives the wish for benefit from fortune an agricultural metaphor. The instruction to treat even offenders without harshness is common. Mohl and Khaleghi then say that city and possessions have lost value in the king’s heart, supporting the English; Moscow and Ganjoor’s running wording instead concerns people and relief from wealth or things. Moscow’s actual apparatus records the heart-centered branch. English’s trust condenses the following worship of the divine rescuer, while superiority to crown and throne adds a royal comparison.
36–40The summons and its threatened consequence
English 36–40; individual edition accounts and actual apparatus loci below.
Moscow V352:1990 running text · Mohl IV89:2031 running text · Khaleghi IV298:1998 running text · Ganjoor sh21:86 running body · Moscow V352:1991 running text · Mohl IV89:2032 running text · Khaleghi IV298:1999 running text · Ganjoor sh21:87 running body · Moscow V352:1992 running text;actual V352n14 benevolent-heart variant · Mohl IV89:2033 running text · Khaleghi IV298:2000 running text · Ganjoor sh21:88 running body · Moscow V352n14 actual full punishment unit;checked main gap1992→1993 · Mohl IV89:2034 running text · Khaleghi IV299:2001 running text · Ganjoor Checked local running gap sh21:88→89 · Moscow V352:1993 running text · Mohl IV89:2035 running text · Khaleghi IV299:2002 running text · Ganjoor sh21:89 running body
The selected notable understands others’ speech in all four accounts. English interprets that ability as command of foreign tongues and the work of making them plain; no particular languages are named. Kings seeking ease and contentment are summoned to court. Mohl and Khaleghi support joyful, benevolent attendance, while Moscow and Ganjoor’s running second half already states compliance. Moscow’s apparatus records the benevolent-heart wording. The following punishment warning is running text in Mohl and Khaleghi and a full printed apparatus unit in Moscow; Ganjoor has a checked local gap. English’s justice gives the consequence an explicitly normative framing, where the Persian connects punishment with the disobedient person’s bad disposition or counsel. The chiefs’ compliant attendance is then narrated by all four, without any punishment being carried out.
41–45The road ahead and the responsibility for devastation
English 41–45; individual edition accounts and actual apparatus loci below.
Moscow V352:1994 running text · Mohl IV89:2036 running text · Khaleghi IV299:2003 running text · Ganjoor sh21:90 running body · Moscow V352:1995 running text · Mohl IV89:2037 running text · Khaleghi IV299:2004 running text · Ganjoor sh21:91 running body · Moscow V352:1996 running text · Mohl IV89:2038 running text · Khaleghi IV299:2005 running text · Ganjoor sh21:92 running body · Moscow V353:1997 running text · Mohl IV89:2039 running text · Khaleghi IV299:2006 running text · Ganjoor sh21:93 running body · Moscow V353:2002 running text;relocated after2001 departure;Siavash’s son · Mohl IV89:2040 running text · Khaleghi IV299:2007 running text · Ganjoor sh21:98 running body;relocated after21:97 departure;Siavash’s son
Royal favor raises the chiefs toward the sun in all four versions; English’s as though makes the hyperbole explicit. The spokesman then reports a route without water or mountain and a distance no greater than one hundred farsangs. Sea narrows water to the preceding voyage’s context, but the unit farsang itself is securely present here. Responsibility for depopulation is more consequential. Mohl and Khaleghi name Turan’s ruler and place the statement before the report of Afrasiab remaining at Gang. Moscow and Ganjoor place the related unit after Khosrow’s departure and name Siavash’s son. English follows Mohl and Khaleghi in both agency and sequence. Cruel spite and flight elaborate oppression and passage; the alternative subject must not be silently harmonized with Afrasiab.
46–49News, gifts and renewed movement
English 46–49; individual edition accounts and actual apparatus loci below.
Moscow V353:1998 running text · Mohl IV89:2041 running text · Khaleghi IV299:2008 running text · Ganjoor sh21:94 running body · Moscow V353:1999 running text · Mohl IV89:2042 running text · Khaleghi IV299:2009 running text · Ganjoor sh21:95 running body · Moscow V353:2000 running text · Mohl IV89:2043 running text · Khaleghi IV299:2010 running text · Ganjoor sh21:96 running body · Moscow V353:2001 running text · Mohl IV89:2044 running text · Khaleghi IV299:2011 running text · Ganjoor sh21:97 running body
All four report Afrasiab and his followers at Gang after crossing the sea, followed by the king’s joy and the lightening of his hardships. English’s still remain makes the report’s continuing relevance explicit, but it remains information received at this moment rather than a guarantee about the later arrival. Every word amplifies Khosrow’s response. Robes and the calling for experienced men’s horses prepare the renewed movement; Mohl and Khaleghi address nobles where Moscow and Ganjoor use regional wording. English’s leading horses by the rein supplies handling that the checked unit does not narrate. Dismissal of the rulers and the march toward Gang close the published chapter. Homage paid summarizes their preceding attendance rather than adding a separately attested ceremony.
Source record and limits
49 English couplets;9 notes. Moscow V350–353:1956–2002 has47 running units plus actual V351n18 for English23 and V352n14 for English39. Mohl IV87–89:1996–2044 has49 running units. Ganjoor mahmood/sh21:52–98 has47 running units,with checked local gaps73→74 for English23 and88→89 for English39. Khaleghi IV296–299:1964–2011 has48 running units plus actual IV298n2 for English23. Moscow2002/Ganjoor21:98 align to English45 but occur after departure and name Siavash’s son;Mohl2040/Khaleghi2007 name Turan’s ruler before the report of Afrasiab at Gang. All running units accounted;no source-only unit.
Actual Moscow V351n18 prints the full extra creature unit with bear-head wording and an explicit hog-head variant for English23;actual Khaleghi IV298n2 prints the hog/lamb unit. Their running gaps are1977→1978 and1985→1986;Ganjoor’s checked local gap is21:73→74. Actual Moscow V352n14 records benevolent-heart wording for English38 and prints the full disobedience/punishment unit for39;Mohl2034 and Khaleghi2001 print39 in main,while Moscow main gap1992→1993 and Ganjoor21:88→89 remain explicit. Actual Moscow V352n9 records the heart/city/things variant for34 against its different running wording. Moscow V353n11 records an alternative Siavash-blood wording near2002;it does not justify silently replacing the main Siavash’s-son subject. No appendix evidence used;no appendix-wide or manuscript-wide absence certified. Actual readings,local gaps,relocations and interpretations are separate evidence classes.
Published English unchanged. English21 creature anatomy and45 Turanian agency/placement have direct Mohl running support;these are not unverified readings. English13 timbers,15 sailors struggling,36 explicit interpreting role and48 leading horses by rein elaborate rather than reproduce explicit actions/material wording. English12 blood-cold fear is an added image;28 does not retain Khaleghi’s explicit weeping. The named Lion’s Mouth,Zereh,Chin-like cities and Makran-like speech do not establish modern geography,languages,zoological species or meteorology. One-year provisions and seven-month completed crossing remain distinct. Farsangs at44 is verified,without modifying C4.35.22’s unverified unit substitution. Every inherited provisional flag remains,including C4.21.20 marble and C4.35.37 funerary qualification.
The Persian reference uses Ganjoor except English23 and39,which use individually checked Mohl running units. Differences in anatomy,agency and ordering are deliberately visible rather than normalized. Moscow and Mohl were inspected individually first,then Ganjoor and Khaleghi. The delayed Moscow2002/Ganjoor21:98 unit is accounted here against English45;it must not be counted a second time in C4.37. Adjacent army-arrangement openings were observed only to establish the next boundary. No C4.37 analysis is included.
Mohl IV88:2016 running;English21: یکی تن چو ماهی و سر چون پلنگ / یکی سر چو گور و تن چون نهنگ
Khaleghi IV298:1985 running second half;English21: یکی تن چو گور و سرش چون نهنگ
Ganjoor sh21:73 running;English21: یکی سر چو ماهی و تن چون نهنگ / یکی پای چون گور و تن چون پلنگ
Mohl IV88:2018 running;English23;full related apparatus Moscow V351n18 and Khaleghi IV298n2: یکی را سر خوک و تن چون بره / همه آب از اینها بدی یکسره
Mohl IV89:2029 and Khaleghi IV298:1996 main;actual Moscow V352n9 variant;English34: که بی ارج شد بر دلم شهر و چیز
Mohl IV89:2034 running;English39: هر آنکس که او زین سخن بگذرد / ز خوی بد خویش کیفر خورد
Moscow V352n14 actual full apparatus unit;English39: هر آنکس که او زین سخن بگذرد / ز رای بد خویش کیفر برد
Mohl IV89:2040 running first half;English45: بر آن سو که سالار توران براند
Moscow V353:2002 / Ganjoor sh21:98 running first half;English45 relocated,alternative agent: بر آن سو که پور سیاوش براند
All four running;English44: فرسنگ صد
C4.36 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | V350:1956 running text | IV87:1996 running text |
| 2 | V350:1957 running text | IV87:1997 running text |
| 3 | V350:1958 running text | IV87:1998 running text |
| 4 | V350:1959 running text | IV88:1999 running text |
| 5 | V350:1960 running text | IV88:2000 running text |
| 6 | V350:1961 running text | IV88:2001 running text |
| 7 | V350:1963 running text | IV88:2002 running text |
| 8 | V350:1962 running text | IV88:2003 running text |
| 9 | V350:1964 running text | IV88:2004 running text |
| 10 | V350:1965 running text | IV88:2005 running text |
| 11 | V350:1966 running text | IV88:2006 running text |
| 12 | V351:1967 running text | IV88:2007 running text |
| 13 | V351:1968 running text | IV88:2008 running text |
| 14 | V351:1969 running text | IV88:2009 running text |
| 15 | V351:1970 running text | IV88:2010 running text |
| 16 | V351:1971 running text | IV88:2011 running text |
| 17 | V351:1972 running text | IV88:2012 running text |
| 18 | V351:1973 running text | IV88:2013 running text |
| 19 | V351:1974 running text | IV88:2014 running text |
| 20 | V351:1975 running text | IV88:2015 running text |
| 21 | V351:1977 running text | IV88:2016 running text |
| 22 | V351:1976 running text | IV88:2017 running text |
| 23 | V351n18 actual full bear/lamb unit with explicit hog variant;checked main gap1977→1978 | IV88:2018 running text |
| 24 | V351:1978 running text | IV88:2019 running text |
| 25 | V351:1979 running text | IV88:2020 running text |
| 26 | V352:1980 running text | IV88:2021 running text |
| 27 | V352:1981 running text | IV88:2022 running text |
| 28 | V352:1982 running text | IV88:2023 running text |
| 29 | V352:1983 running text | IV89:2024 running text |
| 30 | V352:1984 running text | IV89:2025 running text |
| 31 | V352:1985 running text | IV89:2026 running text |
| 32 | V352:1986 running text | IV89:2027 running text |
| 33 | V352:1987 running text | IV89:2028 running text |
| 34 | V352:1988 running text;actual V352n9 heart/city/things variant | IV89:2029 running text |
| 35 | V352:1989 running text | IV89:2030 running text |
| 36 | V352:1990 running text | IV89:2031 running text |
| 37 | V352:1991 running text | IV89:2032 running text |
| 38 | V352:1992 running text;actual V352n14 benevolent-heart variant | IV89:2033 running text |
| 39 | V352n14 actual full punishment unit;checked main gap1992→1993 | IV89:2034 running text |
| 40 | V352:1993 running text | IV89:2035 running text |
| 41 | V352:1994 running text | IV89:2036 running text |
| 42 | V352:1995 running text | IV89:2037 running text |
| 43 | V352:1996 running text | IV89:2038 running text |
| 44 | V353:1997 running text | IV89:2039 running text |
| 45 | V353:2002 running text;relocated after2001 departure;Siavash’s son | IV89:2040 running text |
| 46 | V353:1998 running text | IV89:2041 running text |
| 47 | V353:1999 running text | IV89:2042 running text |
| 48 | V353:2000 running text | IV89:2043 running text |
| 49 | V353:2001 running text | IV89:2044 running text |
New Naqqali