Kay Khosrow Hears of Afrasiab’s Advance
C4.4 Kay Khosrow Hears of Afrasiab’s Advance;29 couplets. Intelligence,reinforcement,reconnaissance,the defensive trench and the astrologers’ impasse.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | C4.4 Kay Khosrow Hears of Afrasiab’s Advance;29 couplets. Intelligence,reinforcement,reconnaissance,the defensive trench and the astrologers’ impasse. |
| Moscow | V255–257:330–358. Sunrise and Turkish muster precede Khosrow’s survey and trench;the king’s response precedes the companion survey. Two-day main reading;three-day alternative at256n23. |
| Mohl | IV17:L18–L22;IV18:L1–L24. The survey and trench precede sunrise and muster,as in English. Ashkash main. Iron-earth image precedes the two-day silence. |
| Ganjoor | mahmood/sh4:1–29. Earlier sunrise and royal response align with Moscow. The two-day silence precedes the iron-earth image. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | IV192–193:336–364. Sequence agrees with Mohl. Atashkash main342;Ashkash actual192n11. Two-day main359;three-day alternative193n14. Additional caltrop unit printed in actual193n7. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6Intelligence becomes a measured response
English 1–6;edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V255:330 running text · Mohl IV17:L18 running text · Khaleghi IV192:336 running text · Ganjoor sh4:1 running body · Moscow V255:331 running text · Mohl IV17:L19 running text · Khaleghi IV192:337 running text · Ganjoor sh4:2 running body · Moscow V255:332 running text · Mohl IV17:L20 running text · Khaleghi IV192:338 running text · Ganjoor sh4:3 running body · Moscow V255:333 running text · Mohl IV17:L21 running text · Khaleghi IV192:339 running text · Ganjoor sh4:4 running body · Moscow V255:334 running text; V255:335 running text · Mohl IV17:L22 running text; IV18:L1 running text · Mohl IV17:L22 running text; IV18:L1 running text · Khaleghi IV192:340 running text; IV192:341 running text · Ganjoor sh4:5 running body; sh4:6 running body · Moscow V255:335 running text · Mohl IV18:L1 running text · Khaleghi IV192:341 running text · Ganjoor sh4:6 running body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi agree on the arrival of informed reports, Afrasiab's position across the Jihun and the summoning of Iranian warriors. The English makes the intelligence network more specifically covert through spies and secret watchers; the Persian describes vigilant, knowledgeable informants without requiring those exact institutional roles. Its quotation of the vast crossing gives the reported news immediacy while preserving the image of ground hidden by troops. The selection of experienced men then draws on two Persian units: the first chooses suitable Iranian warriors, and the next joins worldly bitterness to assistance for Gostaham at Balkh. English redistributes that experience into its preceding couplet. The register therefore shares the second source unit rather than inventing an additional verse. Steadfast hearts and stern design add characterization to an otherwise closely supported reinforcement order.
7–12Protecting the rear without surrendering deliberation
English 7–12;edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V255:336 running text; Ashkash main · Mohl IV18:L2 running text · Khaleghi IV192:342 running text; Atashkash main342;actual IV192n11 Ashkash variant · Ganjoor sh4:7 running body · Moscow V255:337 running text · Mohl IV18:L3 running text · Khaleghi IV192:343 running text · Ganjoor sh4:8 running body · Moscow V256:338 running text; kus,not tabira · Mohl IV18:L4 running text · Khaleghi IV192:344 running text; kus,not tabira · Ganjoor sh4:9 running body · Moscow V256:339 running text · Mohl IV18:L5 running text · Khaleghi IV192:345 running text · Ganjoor sh4:10 running body · Moscow V256:340 running text · Mohl IV18:L6 running text · Khaleghi IV192:346 running text · Ganjoor sh4:11 running body · Moscow V256:341 running text · Mohl IV18:L7 running text · Khaleghi IV192:347 running text · Ganjoor sh4:12 running body
All four presentations connect the Zam detachment with protecting the army from a rear attack and preserving Iranian plans. The commander's name has a real textual distinction: Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor print Ashkash, while Khaleghi's main form is Atashkash and its apparatus supplies Ashkash. The English retains a supported reading without requiring the forms to be silently unified. Its bronze tabira, however, is a more particular instrument choice than the inspected Persian kus. The martial function remains a departure signal, but the terminology is not identical. The next couplet's deliberate pace is especially effective: military urgency does not erase counsel. Nothing but regret strengthens the source's warning against haste into an absolute maxim. The subsequent review of equipment and the Khwarazm-facing terrain supplies a practical setting for that restraint, without establishing an exact modern route.
13–18The survey, the grandfather and the trench
English 13–18;edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V256:342 running text · Mohl IV18:L8 running text · Khaleghi IV192:348 running text · Ganjoor sh4:13 running body · Moscow V256:347 running text; after sunrise,muster and royal response · Mohl IV18:L9 running text · Khaleghi IV192:349 running text; before royal response,sunrise and muster · Ganjoor sh4:18 running body · Moscow V256:348 running text · Mohl IV18:L10 running text · Khaleghi IV193:350 running text · Ganjoor sh4:19 running body · Moscow V256:346 running text; before companion survey;kimia · Mohl IV18:L11 running text · Khaleghi IV193:351 running text; after companion survey;kimia · Ganjoor sh4:17 running body · Moscow V256:349 running text · Mohl IV18:L12 running text · Khaleghi IV193:352 running text · Ganjoor sh4:20 running body · Moscow V256:350 running text · Mohl IV18:L13 running text · Khaleghi IV193:353 running text · Ganjoor sh4:21 running body
Mohl and Khaleghi place the named companions' survey, Khosrow's response to his grandfather's army and the digging of the trench before sunrise. Moscow and Ganjoor bring the sunrise and Turkish muster forward, then give the king's response before the companion survey. The English follows the former sequence, creating a particularly clear progression from reconnaissance to surprise and defensive preparation. All four retain the heart filled with kimia. Countless plans interprets this difficult image as resourceful contrivance; it should not be represented as the Persian's ordinary word for plans or as a literal chemical operation. The following line supplies firmer evidence for surprise: the army exceeds his reckoning. The English preserves that limit on royal knowledge while keeping the trench and dispersed scouts as purposeful responses rather than signs of panic.
19–24Water, sunrise and the silence of armed hosts
English 19–24;edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V256:351 running text; no separate caltrop unit in local main351–352 · Mohl IV18:L14 running text · Khaleghi IV193:354 running text; actual IV193n7 additional caltrop/sunset unit,not main · Ganjoor sh4:22 running body · Moscow V256:343 running text; before companion survey and trench · Mohl IV18:L15 running text · Khaleghi IV193:355 running text; after trench water · Ganjoor sh4:14 running body · Moscow V256:344 running text; nay horn;earlier placement · Mohl IV18:L16 running text · Khaleghi IV193:356 running text; nay horn;after trench · Ganjoor sh4:15 running body · Moscow V256:345 running text; buq;earlier placement · Mohl IV18:L17 running text · Khaleghi IV193:357 running text; buq;after trench · Ganjoor sh4:16 running body · Moscow V256:353 running text; after two-day silence · Mohl IV18:L18 running text · Khaleghi IV193:358 running text; before two-day silence · Ganjoor sh4:24 running body · Moscow V256:352 running text; two days/nights main352;actual V256n23 three-day/night variant · Mohl IV18:L19 running text · Khaleghi IV193:359 running text; two days/nights main359;actual IV193n14 three-day/night variant · Ganjoor sh4:23 running body
The trench's water and its orientation toward Afrasiab are common to Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi. Khaleghi's actual apparatus also prints a separate sunset-and-caltrop couplet, absent from the checked local running passages in the other three presentations; it is recorded separately rather than inserted into the English. Mohl and Khaleghi then place sunrise and the Turkish muster here, matching the English sequence. Moscow and Ganjoor place those events earlier, so the relative order of night works and dawn cannot be certified as identical across editions. Karnay is also more specific than the Persian nay and buq at these loci. The English vividly preserves the iron-covered earth and spear-filled air. Its two days and nights follows all four main readings, while the printed three-day alternative remains a variant, not a correction to impose.
25–29The armored sky refuses an answer
English 25–29;edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V257:354 running text · Mohl IV18:L20 running text · Khaleghi IV193:360 running text · Ganjoor sh4:25 running body · Moscow V257:355 running text · Mohl IV18:L21 running text · Khaleghi IV193:361 running text · Ganjoor sh4:26 running body · Moscow V257:356 running text · Mohl IV18:L22 running text · Khaleghi IV193:362 running text · Ganjoor sh4:27 running body · Moscow V257:357 running text · Mohl IV18:L23 running text · Khaleghi IV193:363 running text · Ganjoor sh4:28 running body · Moscow V257:358 running text · Mohl IV18:L24 running text · Khaleghi IV193:364 running text · Ganjoor sh4:29 running body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi agree on the mounted and foot formations, the iron mountain, the armored heavens and the astrologers before both rulers. The English's King and Shah differentiates the two sovereigns through diction without establishing two different offices in the Persian. Its tables and astrolabes retain the specialists' means of inquiry, and the question concerns which side will receive celestial favor. The ending sharply reverses that attempted scrutiny: heaven itself watches the battle, while those studying it cannot explain the outcome. No reply turns the source's helplessness into an audible absence that answers the armies' earlier silence. The English thus preserves the personification's narrative force. It need not be read as a claim that the poem has supplied a calculable horoscope, a precise battle date or a general refutation of every form of celestial knowledge.
Source record and limits
C4.4 contains29 English couplets and5 commentary notes. Each Persian presentation contains29 corresponding running couplets. English5 draws on the experience described in the source unit also used byEnglish6. The additional caltrop/sunset couplet in Khaleghi’s apparatus is shown separately asS1 and is excluded from the running-text and English totals.
Moscow V255–257:330–358;Mohl IV17:L18–L22 andIV18:L1–L24;Ganjoor mahmood/sh4:1–29;Khaleghi IV192–193:336–364. Mohl L identifiers count printed running couplets from the top of the page,excluding headings.
- F&R English: C4.4 Kay Khosrow Hears of Afrasiab’s Advance;29 couplets. Intelligence,reinforcement,reconnaissance,the defensive trench and the astrologers’ impasse.
- Moscow: V255–257:330–358. Sunrise and Turkish muster precede Khosrow’s survey and trench;the king’s response precedes the companion survey. Two-day main reading;three-day alternative at256n23.
- Mohl: IV17:L18–L22;IV18:L1–L24. The survey and trench precede sunrise and muster,as in English. Ashkash main. Iron-earth image precedes the two-day silence.
- Ganjoor: mahmood/sh4:1–29. Earlier sunrise and royal response align with Moscow. The two-day silence precedes the iron-earth image.
- Khaleghi-Motlagh: IV192–193:336–364. Sequence agrees with Mohl. Atashkash main342;Ashkash actual192n11. Two-day main359;three-day alternative193n14. Additional caltrop unit printed in actual193n7.
The principal difference is sequence. Moscow330–342 is followed by sunrise and the Turkish muster343–345,then Khosrow’s reaction346 and companion survey347–348. Mohl IV18:L9–L14 and Khaleghi349–354 place the survey,response and trench before sunrise. The English follows the latter arrangement. Ganjoor sh4:14–19 follows Moscow’s earlier sunrise and response.
English5–6 share part of the Persian selection-and-experience passage;no additional source couplet is implied. All29 running couplets in each presentation are represented. The separateS1 row preserves the caltrop addition without treating it as part of the main text.
Ashkash/Atashkash,relative placement of sunrise and muster,and the two-/three-day duration are distinct textual readings. Tabira and karnay are more specific English instrument terms than the kus,nay and buq printed at these loci. Countless plans interprets kimia;its exact practical sense is not independently established here. Modern geographical routes,a calendar date and a calculated horoscope are not certified. The caltrop couplet is actual printed apparatus evidence;the other editions’ local gaps do not establish absence everywhere. No appendix evidence is cited.
- Moscow V255:336 running;commander — به اشکش بفرمود تا سوی زم
- Khaleghi IV192:342 running;commander — به آتشکش بفرمود تا سوی زم
- Khaleghi IV192n11 actual variant;commander — اشکش
- Mohl IV18:L11 running;royal response — دل پادشا شد پر از کیمیا
- Moscow V256:346 running;royal response — دل پادشا شد پر از کیمیا
- Khaleghi IV193n7 actual addition;defensive measure — خسک بر پراگند بر گرد دشت / چو خورشید تابان ز گنبد بگشت
- Moscow V256:352 running;duration — دو روز و دو شب
- Moscow V256n23 actual variant;duration — سه روز و سه شب
- Khaleghi IV193:359 running;duration — دو روز و دو شب
- Khaleghi IV193n14 actual variant;duration — سه روز و سه شب
- Mohl IV18:L24 running;helpless astrologer — ستاره شمر سخت بیچاره بود
C4.4 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | V255:330 running text | IV17:L18 running text |
| 2 | V255:331 running text | IV17:L19 running text |
| 3 | V255:332 running text | IV17:L20 running text |
| 4 | V255:333 running text | IV17:L21 running text |
| 5 | V255:334 running text; V255:335 running text | IV17:L22 running text; IV18:L1 running text |
| 6 | V255:335 running text | IV18:L1 running text |
| 7 | V255:336 running text; Ashkash main | IV18:L2 running text |
| 8 | V255:337 running text | IV18:L3 running text |
| 9 | V256:338 running text; kus,not tabira | IV18:L4 running text |
| 10 | V256:339 running text | IV18:L5 running text |
| 11 | V256:340 running text | IV18:L6 running text |
| 12 | V256:341 running text | IV18:L7 running text |
| 13 | V256:342 running text | IV18:L8 running text |
| 14 | V256:347 running text; after sunrise,muster and royal response | IV18:L9 running text |
| 15 | V256:348 running text | IV18:L10 running text |
| 16 | V256:346 running text; before companion survey;kimia | IV18:L11 running text |
| 17 | V256:349 running text | IV18:L12 running text |
| 18 | V256:350 running text | IV18:L13 running text |
| 19 | V256:351 running text; no separate caltrop unit in local main351–352 | IV18:L14 running text |
| 20 | V256:343 running text; before companion survey and trench | IV18:L15 running text |
| 21 | V256:344 running text; nay horn;earlier placement | IV18:L16 running text |
| 22 | V256:345 running text; buq;earlier placement | IV18:L17 running text |
| 23 | V256:353 running text; after two-day silence | IV18:L18 running text |
| 24 | V256:352 running text; two days/nights main352;actual V256n23 three-day/night variant | IV18:L19 running text |
| 25 | V257:354 running text | IV18:L20 running text |
| 26 | V257:355 running text | IV18:L21 running text |
| 27 | V257:356 running text | IV18:L22 running text |
| 28 | V257:357 running text | IV18:L23 running text |
| 29 | V257:358 running text | IV18:L24 running text |
New Naqqali