Afrasiab Escapes from Hohm
45 published couplets unchanged;8 notes.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 45 published couplets unchanged;8 notes. |
| Moscow | V368–371:2241–2283;43 main units;actual370n9 two fuller units;368n16/n22 variants. |
| Mohl | IV100–102:2291–2335;45 main units;royal blood,dragon neck,net wording and fuller resistance. |
| Ganjoor | mahmood/sh24:33–50 andsh25:1–25;43 main units;checked local gap25:15→16. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | IV315–318:2254–2298;45 main units;actual315n21,316n7,317n10 variants. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6The captive appeals to the man of prayer
English 1–6;individual four-edition loci,actual apparatus and checked gaps below.
Moscow V368:2241 running text · Mohl IV100:2291 running text · Khaleghi IV315:2254 running text · Ganjoor sh24:33 running body · Moscow V368:2242 running text · Mohl IV100:2292 running text · Khaleghi IV315:2255 running text · Ganjoor sh24:34 running body · Moscow V368:2243 running text · Mohl IV100:2293 running text · Khaleghi IV315:2256 running text;actual IV315n21 bottomless-cave variant · Ganjoor sh24:35 running body · Moscow V368:2244 running text · Mohl IV100:2294 running text · Khaleghi IV315:2257 running text · Ganjoor sh24:36 running body · Moscow V368:2245 running text · Mohl IV100:2295 running text · Khaleghi IV315:2258 running text · Ganjoor sh24:37 running body · Moscow V368:2246 running text · Mohl IV100:2296 running text · Khaleghi IV315:2259 running text · Ganjoor sh24:38 running body
All four begin with Hohm taking the bound king from his resting place. English into light turns removal into an illuminating contrast, although the source unit does not specify lighting. Afrasiab addresses a discerning worshipper of God; knowledge of God’s law and breathing mountain air develop that characterization without naming a legal text. His diminished question about who he is becomes the English reminder that he once was king. The main cave descriptions vary, and Khaleghi’s actual apparatus includes a bottomless-cave branch relevant to boundless. Hohm rejects refuge by invoking the captive’s worldwide name, then charges him with fratricide and defiance of God. English sharpens the rhetorical exclusivity of the accusation. Aghriras, Nohzar and Siavash remain the named victims, while pure and heir add characterization to Siavash’s remembered status.
7–12Royal blood and the defense of destiny
English 7–12;individual four-edition loci,actual apparatus and checked gaps below.
Moscow V368:2247 running text;innocent blood main;actual V368n16 royal variant · Mohl IV100:2297 running text · Khaleghi IV316:2260 running text · Ganjoor sh24:39 running body · Moscow V368:2248 running text · Mohl IV100:2298 running text · Khaleghi IV316:2261 running text · Ganjoor sh24:40 running body · Moscow V368:2249 running text · Mohl IV100:2299 running text · Khaleghi IV316:2262 running text · Ganjoor sh24:41 running body · Moscow V368:2250 running text;eye main;actual V368n22 neck variant · Mohl IV100:2300 running text · Khaleghi IV316:2263 running text;eye main;actual IV316n7 neck variant · Ganjoor sh24:42 running body · Moscow V368:2251 running text · Mohl IV100:2301 running text · Khaleghi IV316:2264 running text · Ganjoor sh24:43 running body · Moscow V368:2252 running text · Mohl IV100:2302 running text · Khaleghi IV316:2265 running text · Ganjoor sh24:44 running body
Mohl and Khaleghi print royal blood in the prohibition, directly supporting the English. Moscow and Ganjoor main texts instead refer to innocent blood, while Moscow’s actual apparatus records the royal branch. That difference changes the stated class of protected victims and should not disappear into general agreement. Afrasiab responds by questioning universal innocence and attributing the harm he causes to heaven’s decree. English bitter seed adds an image, but the claim remains his defense rather than the narrator’s theological judgment. The dragon comparison also branches: Mohl gives the neck, supported by actual Moscow and Khaleghi apparatus, against the dragon-eye wording of their main texts and Ganjoor. The English follows the neck branch. His admission of self-inflicted harm nevertheless retains personal responsibility beside the appeal to destiny, before ancestry becomes another argument for freedom.
13–18Beautiful speech, pity and escape
English 13–18;individual four-edition loci,actual apparatus and checked gaps below.
Moscow V368:2253 running text · Mohl IV100:2303 running text · Khaleghi IV316:2266 running text · Ganjoor sh24:45 running body · Moscow V369:2254 running text · Mohl IV100:2304 running text · Khaleghi IV316:2267 running text · Ganjoor sh24:46 running body · Moscow V369:2255 running text · Mohl IV100:2305 running text · Khaleghi IV316:2268 running text · Ganjoor sh24:47 running body · Moscow V369:2256 running text · Mohl IV100:2306 running text · Khaleghi IV316:2269 running text · Ganjoor sh24:48 running body · Moscow V369:2257 running text · Mohl IV101:2307 running text · Khaleghi IV316:2270 running text · Ganjoor sh24:49 running body · Moscow V369:2258 running text · Mohl IV101:2308 running text · Khaleghi IV316:2271 running text · Ganjoor sh24:50 running body
All four retain Afrasiab’s appeal to judgment day and Hohm’s answer that little time remains to him. The garden comparison acknowledges the freshness or attractiveness of his speech without clearing him of guilt. English spring supplies a season for that image, while Khosrow’s future role in his death remains explicit. The movement from condemnation to pity is therefore narratively consequential. English names pity in the first loosening unit; the next unit makes that motive clear when Afrasiab recognizes the holy man’s response to his lament. Loosening is not a deliberate decision to release him. The king exploits it by twisting free and plunging into the water, where he vanishes. English cold adds a sensory quality not specified in the checked units; neither a water temperature nor a drowning is established.
19–24A mistaken explanation at the water’s edge
English 19–24;individual four-edition loci,actual apparatus and checked gaps below.
Moscow V369:2259 running text · Mohl IV101:2309 running text · Khaleghi IV316:2272 running text · Ganjoor sh25:1 running body · Moscow V369:2260 running text · Mohl IV101:2310 running text · Khaleghi IV316:2273 running text · Ganjoor sh25:2 running body · Moscow V369:2261 running text · Mohl IV101:2311 running text · Khaleghi IV317:2274 running text · Ganjoor sh25:3 running body · Moscow V369:2262 running text · Mohl IV101:2312 running text · Khaleghi IV317:2275 running text · Ganjoor sh25:4 running body · Moscow V369:2263 running text · Mohl IV101:2313 running text · Khaleghi IV317:2276 running text · Ganjoor sh25:5 running body · Moscow V369:2264 running text · Mohl IV101:2314 running text · Khaleghi IV317:2277 running text;fish-tail main;actual IV317n10 fishing-net variant · Ganjoor sh25:6 running body
Gudarz, Giv and the nobles approach in all four presentations. Their view joins disturbed water with Hohm’s distressed appearance, prompting an explanation that remains Gudarz’s private conjecture. English from the plain supplies terrain, while the visible kamand becomes the basis for an imagined fishing net. Mohl prints the lake-name branch represented by Khanjast; Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi main texts use Chichast forms. These are textual names here, not a certified modern geographic identification. Mohl’s fishing-net wording also supports a net-based reading of the imagined nahang. The other three main formulations contain fish-tail wording, with the net variant actually recorded in Khaleghi’s apparatus. English fills his net reshapes the catch relation and keeps nahang untranslated. No animal capture is narrated as an event: Gudarz has misread the evidence before him.
25–30Questions answered by a night of worship
English 25–30;individual four-edition loci,actual apparatus and checked gaps below.
Moscow V369:2265 running text · Mohl IV101:2315 running text · Khaleghi IV317:2278 running text · Ganjoor sh25:7 running body · Moscow V369:2266 running text · Mohl IV101:2316 running text · Khaleghi IV317:2279 running text · Ganjoor sh25:8 running body · Moscow V369:2267 running text · Mohl IV101:2317 running text · Khaleghi IV317:2280 running text · Ganjoor sh25:9 running body · Moscow V369:2268 running text · Mohl IV101:2318 running text · Khaleghi IV317:2281 running text · Ganjoor sh25:10 running body · Moscow V370:2269 running text · Mohl IV101:2319 running text · Khaleghi IV317:2282 running text · Ganjoor sh25:11 running body · Moscow V370:2270 running text · Mohl IV101:2320 running text · Khaleghi IV317:2283 running text · Ganjoor sh25:12 running body
All four give Gudarz two approaches to the puzzle: he asks Hohm to reveal his purpose, then suggests that he might be washing himself. English blue adds a water color, while dirt selects a physical sense for the question about the dark or soiled body. The suggestion is not evidence that Hohm has bathed. Hohm replies by asking his listener to consider what happened and locating his dwelling on the mountain, apart from others. English prayer is my delight adds personal pleasure to the stated devotional function of that place. The repeated account of worship through the night preserves duration and emphasis. Bird calls mark the arrival of the lament; English dawn drew near interprets that natural time signal without supplying an exact hour. The story is now Hohm’s retrospective testimony.
31–36Hohm’s hope and the strength of his captive
English 31–36;individual four-edition loci,actual apparatus and checked gaps below.
Moscow V370:2271 running text · Mohl IV101:2321 running text · Khaleghi IV317:2284 running text · Ganjoor sh25:13 running body · Moscow V370:2272 running text · Mohl IV101:2322 running text · Khaleghi IV317:2285 running text · Ganjoor sh25:14 running body · Moscow V370:2273 running text · Mohl IV101:2323 running text · Khaleghi IV317:2286 running text · Ganjoor sh25:15 running body · Moscow V370n9 actual additional unit 1;main gap2273→2274 · Mohl IV101:2324 running text · Khaleghi IV317:2287 running text · Ganjoor Checked local running gap sh25:15→16 · Moscow V370n9 actual additional unit 2;main gap2273→2274 · Mohl IV101:2325 running text · Khaleghi IV317:2288 running text · Ganjoor Checked local running gap sh25:15→16 · Moscow V370:2274 running text · Mohl IV101:2326 running text · Khaleghi IV317:2289 running text · Ganjoor sh25:16 running body
The brightened heart and hope of uprooting vengeance occur in all four accounts. They describe Hohm’s expectation, not an accomplished end to violence. His recognition of Afrasiab’s voice leads to searching the mountain and cave. Mohl and Khaleghi then print two units about the king lamenting his crown and throne and springing up with force that crumbles stone beneath his feet. Moscow actually prints both in its apparatus; Ganjoor has a checked local gap before the binding. English therefore has direct support for this extraordinary resistance. Fierce and fit characterize the movement, while hardest stone renders the granite image emphatically. These remain actions reported by Hohm, rather than a physical measurement of strength. The binding produces blood from both hands in all four; English tight converts the stone-hard simile into pressure without suggesting mutilation.
37–41An account of mercy that failed
English 37–41;individual four-edition loci,actual apparatus and checked gaps below.
Moscow V370:2275 running text · Mohl IV101:2327 running text · Khaleghi IV318:2290 running text · Ganjoor sh25:17 running body · Moscow V370:2276 running text · Mohl IV101:2328 running text · Khaleghi IV318:2291 running text · Ganjoor sh25:18 running body · Moscow V370:2277 running text · Mohl IV101:2329 running text · Khaleghi IV318:2292 running text · Ganjoor sh25:19 running body · Moscow V370:2278 running text · Mohl IV101:2330 running text · Khaleghi IV318:2293 running text · Ganjoor sh25:20 running body · Moscow V370:2279 running text · Mohl IV101:2331 running text · Khaleghi IV318:2294 running text · Ganjoor sh25:21 running body
All four continue Hohm’s report with the descent from the mountain, the captive’s lament compared with that of women, and cries and oaths that persuade him to ease the bonds. English mourning women contextualizes the comparison without turning it into an independent statement about women’s behavior. The escape wounds Hohm’s heart and soul; English helpless on the strand makes his resulting position more explicit. His report closes by naming the water and affirming that the account is complete and true. Mohl again supplies the Khanjast-related name against the other three main Chichast forms. Gudarz’s recollection then differs in wording: Mohl and Khaleghi invoke an old saying, while Moscow and Ganjoor invoke the truthful ones. English the past had taught follows the temporal branch, without inventing the content of an otherwise unspecified proverb.
42–45From troubled thought to the kings’ departure
English 42–45;individual four-edition loci,actual apparatus and checked gaps below.
Moscow V370:2280 running text · Mohl IV102:2332 running text · Khaleghi IV318:2295 running text · Ganjoor sh25:22 running body · Moscow V370:2281 running text · Mohl IV102:2333 running text · Khaleghi IV318:2296 running text · Ganjoor sh25:23 running body · Moscow V370:2282 running text · Mohl IV102:2334 running text · Khaleghi IV318:2297 running text · Ganjoor sh25:24 running body · Moscow V371:2283 running text · Mohl IV102:2335 running text · Khaleghi IV318:2298 running text · Ganjoor sh25:25 running body
All four take Gudarz to the fire-temple in a state of distress or absorption. Mohl and Khaleghi explicitly mention thought at this point, supporting English deep lost in thought, while Moscow and Ganjoor foreground departure from the previous place. Prayer before the fire addresses the world’s Creator; English who rules its days extends that divine epithet. The distinction between the place or orientation of worship and its addressee remains essential to the account. After worship, Gudarz discloses the hidden matter to both kings. English all that he had heard emphasizes Hohm’s report, whereas the Persian reference to what he saw or encountered need not mean that he personally witnessed the capture. Both kings immediately mount and leave Azargashasp. This chapter ends with departure, before their ensuing encounter with Hohm.
Source record and limits
45 English couplets;8 notes. Moscow V368–371:2241–2283=43 running units,plus actual V370n9 two units correspondingEnglish34–35. Mohl IV100–102:2291–2335=45 running units. Ganjoor mahmood/sh24:33–50 and sh25:1–25=43 running units. Khaleghi IV315–318:2254–2298=45 running units. All declared running units accounted once;no source-only running unit. Prior C4.41 units excluded.
Actual Moscow V370n9 prints both crown/throne lament and stone-breaking leap units forEnglish34–35;Mohl/Khaleghi main include both;Ganjoor checked local gap25:15→16. Actual Moscow V368n16 royal-blood variant and V368n22 dragon-neck variant distinguished from innocent-blood/dragon-eye main. Actual Khaleghi IV315n21 bottomless-cave branch,IV316n7 dragon-neck branch and IV317n10 fishing-net variant checked individually. Main Khaleghi royal-blood wording is not apparatus-only. Mohl main lake spelling differs from Chichast main of other three. No appendix evidence used;no edition-wide/manuscript-wide absence certified.
Published English unchanged. English1 into light,2 God’s law/mountain air,6 pure/heir,9 bitter seed,12 soon,15 spring,18 cold,20 plain,23 deep/explicit net-casting,26 blue,28 delight,30 dawn,33 underground and35 fierce/fit are specifications or interpretations. English3 boundless has an actual Khaleghi cave variant;7 royal blood,10 dragon neck,23/40 Khanjast and24 net-based construal have Mohl support. English24 fills his net reshapes the catch relation;other three main texts use fish-tail wording. No animal catch actually occurs. English34–35 supported by Mohl/Khaleghi main and actual Moscow apparatus. Preserve every inherited flag,especially C4.21.20 unverified marble. No independent modern lake identification or zoological identification of nahang certified.
The Persian reference follows Ganjoor except English7,10,23,24,34,35 and40,which use individually checked Mohl main readings. Moscow and Mohl were inspected individually first,then Ganjoor and Khaleghi. Printed-page to one-based PDF offsets are Moscow0,Mohl6,Khaleghi16.
Ganjoor preceding section,opening scope at33
Mohl IV100:2297 / Khaleghi IV316:2260 main;English7: تو خون سر شهریاران مریز
Moscow V368:2247 / Ganjoor24:39 main;English7 alternative: تو خون سر بیگناهان مریز
Mohl IV100:2300 main;actual Moscow368n22 and Khaleghi316n7 related neck reading: و گر گردن اژدها بسپرد
Ganjoor24:42 main;Moscow/Khaleghi main related eye reading: وگر دیده اژدها بسپرد
Mohl IV101:2313 main;English23 lake-name branch: ز دریای خنجست گیرد شکار
Mohl IV101:2314 main;English24 net branch: نهنگی مگر دام ماهی گرفت
Ganjoor25:6 main;Moscow/Khaleghi related tail branch: نهنگی مگر دم ماهی گرفت
Mohl IV101:2324 main;Khaleghi IV317:2287 main;actual Moscow V370n9: به هنگ اندرون خفته آن شوربخت / همی زار بگریست بر تاج و تخت
Mohl IV101:2325 main;Khaleghi IV317:2288 related main;actual Moscow V370n9: چو در هنگ رفتم بجست او ز جای / همی سنگ خارا گرفتش دو پای
Mohl IV101:2331 / Khaleghi IV318:2294 main;English41: به یاد آمدش گفته باستان
Ganjoor25:21 / Moscow V370:2279 main;English41 alternative: بیاد آمدش گفته راستان
C4.42 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | V368:2241 running text | IV100:2291 running text |
| 2 | V368:2242 running text | IV100:2292 running text |
| 3 | V368:2243 running text | IV100:2293 running text |
| 4 | V368:2244 running text | IV100:2294 running text |
| 5 | V368:2245 running text | IV100:2295 running text |
| 6 | V368:2246 running text | IV100:2296 running text |
| 7 | V368:2247 running text;innocent blood main;actual V368n16 royal variant | IV100:2297 running text |
| 8 | V368:2248 running text | IV100:2298 running text |
| 9 | V368:2249 running text | IV100:2299 running text |
| 10 | V368:2250 running text;eye main;actual V368n22 neck variant | IV100:2300 running text |
| 11 | V368:2251 running text | IV100:2301 running text |
| 12 | V368:2252 running text | IV100:2302 running text |
| 13 | V368:2253 running text | IV100:2303 running text |
| 14 | V369:2254 running text | IV100:2304 running text |
| 15 | V369:2255 running text | IV100:2305 running text |
| 16 | V369:2256 running text | IV100:2306 running text |
| 17 | V369:2257 running text | IV101:2307 running text |
| 18 | V369:2258 running text | IV101:2308 running text |
| 19 | V369:2259 running text | IV101:2309 running text |
| 20 | V369:2260 running text | IV101:2310 running text |
| 21 | V369:2261 running text | IV101:2311 running text |
| 22 | V369:2262 running text | IV101:2312 running text |
| 23 | V369:2263 running text | IV101:2313 running text |
| 24 | V369:2264 running text | IV101:2314 running text |
| 25 | V369:2265 running text | IV101:2315 running text |
| 26 | V369:2266 running text | IV101:2316 running text |
| 27 | V369:2267 running text | IV101:2317 running text |
| 28 | V369:2268 running text | IV101:2318 running text |
| 29 | V370:2269 running text | IV101:2319 running text |
| 30 | V370:2270 running text | IV101:2320 running text |
| 31 | V370:2271 running text | IV101:2321 running text |
| 32 | V370:2272 running text | IV101:2322 running text |
| 33 | V370:2273 running text | IV101:2323 running text |
| 34 | V370n9 actual additional unit 1;main gap2273→2274 | IV101:2324 running text |
| 35 | V370n9 actual additional unit 2;main gap2273→2274 | IV101:2325 running text |
| 36 | V370:2274 running text | IV101:2326 running text |
| 37 | V370:2275 running text | IV101:2327 running text |
| 38 | V370:2276 running text | IV101:2328 running text |
| 39 | V370:2277 running text | IV101:2329 running text |
| 40 | V370:2278 running text | IV101:2330 running text |
| 41 | V370:2279 running text | IV101:2331 running text |
| 42 | V370:2280 running text | IV102:2332 running text |
| 43 | V370:2281 running text | IV102:2333 running text |
| 44 | V370:2282 running text | IV102:2334 running text |
| 45 | V371:2283 running text | IV102:2335 running text |
New Naqqali