The Death of Afrasiab and Garsivaz
46 published couplets unchanged;8 notes.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 46 published couplets unchanged;8 notes. |
| Moscow | V373–376:2326–2369;44 main units;actual374n17 and375n2. |
| Mohl | IV104–105:2378–2423;46 main units;fuller exchange,face and lips branches. |
| Ganjoor | mahmood/sh25:68–75 andsh26:1–36;44 main units;checked local gaps for19 and21. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | IV321–323:2340–2384;45 main units;actual322n12 reply. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6The second capture and the image of hunting
English 1–6;individual four-edition loci,actual apparatus and checked gaps below.
Moscow V373:2326 running text · Mohl IV104:2378 running text · Khaleghi IV321:2340 running text · Ganjoor sh25:68 running body · Moscow V373:2327 running text · Mohl IV104:2379 running text · Khaleghi IV321:2341 running text · Ganjoor sh25:69 running body · Moscow V373:2328 running text · Mohl IV104:2380 running text · Khaleghi IV321:2342 running text · Ganjoor sh25:70 running body · Moscow V373:2329 running text · Mohl IV104:2381 running text · Khaleghi IV321:2343 running text · Ganjoor sh25:71 running body · Moscow V373:2330 running text · Mohl IV104:2382 running text · Khaleghi IV321:2344 running text · Ganjoor sh25:72 running body · Moscow V373:2331 running text · Mohl IV104:2383 running text · Khaleghi IV321:2345 running text · Ganjoor sh25:73 running body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all move from the brothers’ speech to Hohm’s search or intention, his approach by the island route and the use of the kamand. English royal game and snare make the capture explicitly resemble hunting, while deftly characterizes the cast as skilled. The bent or doubled posture before the lion-like approach supports crouched; haste supplies additional speed. The cord catches the monarch by the head, and Hohm draws him from water to dry ground. Loss of strength and consciousness follows in all four accounts. It is not yet the king’s death. English lake and shore make the immediate setting concrete without establishing a modern location or a measured distance across the water. The swift physical sequence reverses the escape through pity in the preceding account.
7–12Hohm departs and the dream returns
English 7–12;individual four-edition loci,actual apparatus and checked gaps below.
Moscow V374:2332 running text · Mohl IV104:2384 running text · Khaleghi IV321:2346 running text · Ganjoor sh25:74 running body · Moscow V374:2333 running text · Mohl IV104:2385 running text · Khaleghi IV321:2347 running text · Ganjoor sh25:75 running body · Moscow V374:2334 running text · Mohl IV104:2386 running text · Khaleghi IV321:2348 running text · Ganjoor sh26:1 running body · Moscow V374:2335 running text · Mohl IV104:2387 running text · Khaleghi IV321:2349 running text · Ganjoor sh26:2 running body · Moscow V374:2336 running text · Mohl IV104:2388 running text · Khaleghi IV321:2350 running text · Ganjoor sh26:3 running body · Moscow V374:2337 running text · Mohl IV104:2389 running text · Khaleghi IV321:2351 running text · Ganjoor sh26:4 running body
All four repeat the humiliating removal and binding before Hohm hands over the captive and departs like a companion of the wind. English identifies the recipients as the Shahs and continues the hunting image through prey. Wind-borne departure remains a comparison rather than literal supernatural transport. Khosrow’s sharp sword and vengeful state then replace Hohm’s practical action. Afrasiab recalls having seen this day in a dream. Mohl and Khaleghi describe him with a lack-of-wisdom epithet, whereas Moscow and Ganjoor use ill-fortune wording; English bereft of might adapts his present condition. The revealed veil concerns formerly hidden matters, with fate making their significance explicit. His appeal to the avenger as grandfather preserves kinship but specifies the maternal relation. Old and weak strengthen the plea without constituting separate source descriptions in that unit.
13–18The charges against Afrasiab
English 13–18;individual four-edition loci,actual apparatus and checked gaps below.
Moscow V374:2338 running text · Mohl IV104:2390 running text · Khaleghi IV321:2352 running text · Ganjoor sh26:5 running body · Moscow V374:2339 running text · Mohl IV104:2391 running text · Khaleghi IV321:2353 running text · Ganjoor sh26:6 running body · Moscow V374:2340 running text · Mohl IV104:2392 running text · Khaleghi IV322:2354 running text · Ganjoor sh26:7 running body · Moscow V374:2341 running text · Mohl IV104:2393 running text · Khaleghi IV322:2355 running text · Ganjoor sh26:8 running body · Moscow V374:2342 running text · Mohl IV104:2394 running text · Khaleghi IV322:2356 running text · Ganjoor sh26:9 running body · Moscow V374:2343 running text · Mohl IV104:2395 running text · Khaleghi IV322:2357 running text · Ganjoor sh26:10 running body
The accusation proceeds through the brother, Nohzar and Siavash in all four presentations. Khosrow identifies the brother as one who had not sought calamity for the great, then recalls Nohzar’s descent from Iraj and the upheaval caused by his killing. English fame beneath the shining sun adds an elevated setting to the royal identification. The Siavash comparison remains martial, although Mohl and Khaleghi use the image of no distinguished man girding himself to match him, where Moscow and Ganjoor emphasize the unmatched mounted warrior. English no horseman matched him preserves the latter emphasis. The sheep-like beheading is deliberately degrading, and the ascent beyond heaven becomes arrogance through the English pride of name. These are Khosrow’s charges within a confrontation, not a detached narrator’s summary or a celebration of Afrasiab’s greatness.
19–24Foreseen punishment and the appeal to see a daughter
English 19–24;individual four-edition loci,actual apparatus and checked gaps below.
Moscow V374n17 actual father/evil-day unit;main gap2343→2344 · Mohl IV104:2396 running text · Khaleghi IV322:2358 running text · Ganjoor Checked local running gap sh26:10→11 · Moscow V374:2344 running text · Mohl IV104:2397 running text · Khaleghi IV322:2359 running text · Ganjoor sh26:11 running body · Moscow V375n2 actual reply unit;main gap2344→2345 · Mohl IV104:2398 running text · Khaleghi IV322n12 actual reply unit;main gap2359→2360 · Ganjoor Checked local running gap sh26:11→12 · Moscow V375:2345 running text · Mohl IV104:2399 running text · Khaleghi IV322:2360 running text · Ganjoor sh26:12 running body · Moscow V375:2346 running text · Mohl IV104:2400 running text · Khaleghi IV322:2361 running text · Ganjoor sh26:13 running body · Moscow V375:2347 running text · Mohl IV105:2401 running text · Khaleghi IV322:2362 running text · Ganjoor sh26:14 running body
Mohl and Khaleghi print the question about killing the father without anticipating an evil day. Moscow actually prints that unit in its apparatus, while Ganjoor has a checked local gap. English therefore has direct support for the additional challenge. The following reply concerning evil conduct, killing and reproach is printed by Mohl and in actual Moscow and Khaleghi apparatus, but not in Ganjoor’s checked local sequence. English makes that compact formulation a personal admission that slaughter clings to the speaker’s name, adding darkness; the witnesses should not all be credited with an identical first-person confession. The request to see Khosrow’s mother then invokes the daughter’s relationship to Afrasiab. English while I live follows Moscow’s life wording, against the face wording in Mohl and Khaleghi. Khosrow answers through the metaphor of fire inflicted upon his own life.
25–30Execution and the empty throne
English 25–30;individual four-edition loci,actual apparatus and checked gaps below.
Moscow V375:2348 running text · Mohl IV105:2402 running text · Khaleghi IV322:2363 running text · Ganjoor sh26:15 running body · Moscow V375:2349 running text · Mohl IV105:2403 running text · Khaleghi IV322:2364 running text · Ganjoor sh26:16 running body · Moscow V375:2350 running text · Mohl IV105:2404 running text · Khaleghi IV322:2365 running text · Ganjoor sh26:17 running body · Moscow V375:2351 running text · Mohl IV105:2405 running text · Khaleghi IV322:2366 running text · Ganjoor sh26:18 running body · Moscow V375:2352 running text · Mohl IV105:2406 running text · Khaleghi IV322:2367 running text · Ganjoor sh26:19 running body · Moscow V375:2353 running text · Mohl IV105:2407 running text · Khaleghi IV322:2368 running text · Ganjoor sh26:20 running body
All four retain the innocent father, the son still hidden or unborn, and the crown and ivory throne personified as mourners. English unborn resolves concealment through the narrative chronology without specifying a pregnancy date. Khosrow names the moment as divine recompense; English justice makes the normative claim explicit, but it remains part of his speech. The Indian sword, neck blow and fallen body then enact the sentence. English tyrant and wreck sharpen condemnation beside the source’s vulnerable bodily description. Mohl’s face-and-beard wording supports the English face becoming red with blood, whereas the other three main texts name beard and white hair. Garsivaz’s despair follows. The empty royal seat and end of greatness are shared, closing the reign without adding a further chronological measurement or a funeral scene.
31–36A warning about bloodshed after an execution
English 31–36;individual four-edition loci,actual apparatus and checked gaps below.
Moscow V375:2354 running text · Mohl IV105:2408 running text · Khaleghi IV322:2369 running text · Ganjoor sh26:21 running body · Moscow V375:2355 running text · Mohl IV105:2409 running text · Khaleghi IV323:2370 running text · Ganjoor sh26:22 running body · Moscow V375:2356 running text · Mohl IV105:2410 running text · Khaleghi IV323:2371 running text · Ganjoor sh26:23 running body · Moscow V375:2357 running text · Mohl IV105:2411 running text · Khaleghi IV323:2372 running text · Ganjoor sh26:24 running body · Moscow V375:2358 running text · Mohl IV105:2412 running text · Khaleghi IV323:2373 running text · Ganjoor sh26:25 running body · Moscow V375:2359 running text · Mohl IV105:2413 running text · Khaleghi IV323:2374 running text · Ganjoor sh26:26 running body
All four interrupt the action with a warning that evil returns upon its perpetrator, followed by counsel about royal anger and bloodshed. The English agricultural yield develops the principle of consequence into a sustained image, while the key that frees an evil deed interprets a compressed bond-and-key metaphor. Crucially, the favored ruler’s anger is expressed through bonds and prison. English curb his wrathful might reads this as restraint in punishment, not imprisonment of the ruler himself. Bloodshed then brings distress and heavenly recompense. Placed after Afrasiab’s execution, this general warning creates a tension that should remain visible rather than being explained away. The mobad’s address to Bahram reinforces the prohibition on innocent blood. English mercy interprets composure and sound judgment; no specific historical Bahram or independent legal doctrine is established by this passage alone.
37–42Wisdom’s crown and the condemned brother
English 37–42;individual four-edition loci,actual apparatus and checked gaps below.
Moscow V375:2360 running text · Mohl IV105:2414 running text · Khaleghi IV323:2375 running text · Ganjoor sh26:27 running body · Moscow V376:2361 running text · Mohl IV105:2415 running text · Khaleghi IV323:2376 running text · Ganjoor sh26:28 running body · Moscow V376:2362 running text · Mohl IV105:2416 running text · Khaleghi IV323:2377 running text · Ganjoor sh26:29 running body · Moscow V376:2363 running text · Mohl IV105:2417 running text · Khaleghi IV323:2378 running text · Ganjoor sh26:30 running body · Moscow V376:2364 running text · Mohl IV105:2418 running text · Khaleghi IV323:2379 running text · Ganjoor sh26:31 running body · Moscow V376:2365 running text · Mohl IV105:2419 running text · Khaleghi IV323:2380 running text · Ganjoor sh26:32 running body
The crown’s address to the head asks that wisdom accompany the mind in all four accounts. English reason and sound judgment preserves the personification without treating the crown as a literal speaking object. The narration then returns to Garsivaz, whose yellowed face and troubled heart respond to Afrasiab’s fate. Heavy bonds, guards and executioners organize his approach. English fitting state retains a moral judgment but replaces the source’s explicit ill-character designation with the condition of being bound. His blood-like tears reach a blue or darkened surface: Mohl names the lips, supporting the English, while Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi name the face. That distinction should not become a physiological diagnosis. The king’s recollection of the basin and dagger recalls the earlier killing; fatal bowl and the seared soul interpret its objects and emotional force.
43–46Remembered killings and the final bodies
English 43–46;individual four-edition loci,actual apparatus and checked gaps below.
Moscow V376:2366 running text · Mohl IV105:2420 running text · Khaleghi IV323:2381 running text · Ganjoor sh26:33 running body · Moscow V376:2367 running text · Mohl IV105:2421 running text · Khaleghi IV323:2382 running text · Ganjoor sh26:34 running body · Moscow V376:2368 running text · Mohl IV105:2422 running text · Khaleghi IV323:2383 running text · Ganjoor sh26:35 running body · Moscow V376:2369 running text · Mohl IV105:2423 running text · Khaleghi IV323:2384 running text · Ganjoor sh26:36 running body
All four name Tur, Fereydoon, Salm and Iraj before the executioner is summoned. English brought to death too soon supplies an explicit judgment about Iraj’s loss in place of the source description of his royal greatness. The named history frames the present punishment without requiring a new account of those earlier events here. The executioner draws the sharp sword and approaches with hostile intent; English naked makes the unsheathing visible and bloody deed states its anticipated use. Garsivaz is then cut at the waist, and fear passes through the army. English culprit identifies the condemned man rather than introducing another victim. Finally, the bodies are cast together like a mountain and people stand around them. The English mountain mound preserves that comparison; it does not establish burial, a cairn or an enacted funeral rite.
Source record and limits
46 English couplets;8 notes. Moscow V373–376:2326–2369=44 running units,plus actual V374n17 father/evil-day unit and V375n2 reply unit. Mohl IV104–105:2378–2423=46 running units. Ganjoor mahmood/sh25:68–75 andsh26:1–36=44 running units. Khaleghi IV321–323:2340–2384=45 running units,plus actual IV322n12 reply unit. All declared running units accounted once;no source-only running unit.
Actual Moscow V374n17 prints father-killing/evil-day unit correspondingEnglish19;Mohl2396/Khaleghi2358 main include it;Ganjoor checked gap26:10→11. Actual Moscow V375n2 and Khaleghi IV322n12 print related killing/reproach reply forEnglish21;Mohl2398 main;Ganjoor checked gap26:11→12. Individual printed units inspected,not merely addition notices. No appendix evidence used;no edition-wide/manuscript-wide absence certified. Main face/beard and blue-lips branches in Mohl kept distinct from other main readings.
Published English unchanged,including trailing spaces inEnglish21–22. English19 verifiedMohl/Khaleghi main andactualMoscow apparatus. English21 personal confession/darkness strengthens related reply wording;not identical first-person admission in every source. English22 daughter’s son contextual;29 face and41 blue lips haveMohl support. English33 restraint interpretation is punishment through prison,not king imprisoned. English46 mountain mound is simile,not burial. Other specifications include hunting imagery,12 old/weak,15 shining sun,18 pride of name,20 fruit,28 tyrant/wreck,32 field,36 mercy,43 too soon. Every inherited flag preserved,especiallyC4.21.20 unverified marble. No independent historicalBahram,legaldoctrine,physiology or funeral certification.
The Persian reference follows Ganjoor except English19 and21,which use individually checked Mohl main units. Variants remain separately identified. Moscow and Mohl were inspected individually first,then Ganjoor and Khaleghi. Printed-page to one-based PDF offsets are Moscow0,Mohl6,Khaleghi16.
Mohl IV104:2396 / Khaleghi IV322:2358 main;actualMoscow V374n17;English19: تو باب مرا از چه کردی تباه / چنین روز بد را نکردی نگاه
Mohl IV104:2398 main;English21: چنین داد پاسخ که از بدکنش / نیابی جز از کشتن و سرزنش
Moscow V375n2 actual reply;English21 related wording: چنین داد پاسخ که ای بدکنش / ندانی بجز کشتن و سرزنش
Khaleghi IV322n12 actual reply;English21 related wording: نباید جز از کشتن و سرزنش
Mohl IV105:2406 main;English29: ز خون لعل شد روی و ریش سپید
Ganjoor26:19 main;othermain beard/hair branch: ز خون لعل شد ریش و موی سپید
Ganjoor26:23;allfour main;English33: همه خشم او بند و زندان بود
Mohl IV105:2418 main;English41: ببارید خون بر لب لاژورد
Ganjoor26:31;Moscow/Khaleghi related main;English41: ببارید خون بر رخ لاژورد
Ganjoor26:36;allfour related main;English46: به هم برفگندندشان همچو کوه
C4.44 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | V373:2326 running text | IV104:2378 running text |
| 2 | V373:2327 running text | IV104:2379 running text |
| 3 | V373:2328 running text | IV104:2380 running text |
| 4 | V373:2329 running text | IV104:2381 running text |
| 5 | V373:2330 running text | IV104:2382 running text |
| 6 | V373:2331 running text | IV104:2383 running text |
| 7 | V374:2332 running text | IV104:2384 running text |
| 8 | V374:2333 running text | IV104:2385 running text |
| 9 | V374:2334 running text | IV104:2386 running text |
| 10 | V374:2335 running text | IV104:2387 running text |
| 11 | V374:2336 running text | IV104:2388 running text |
| 12 | V374:2337 running text | IV104:2389 running text |
| 13 | V374:2338 running text | IV104:2390 running text |
| 14 | V374:2339 running text | IV104:2391 running text |
| 15 | V374:2340 running text | IV104:2392 running text |
| 16 | V374:2341 running text | IV104:2393 running text |
| 17 | V374:2342 running text | IV104:2394 running text |
| 18 | V374:2343 running text | IV104:2395 running text |
| 19 | V374n17 actual father/evil-day unit;main gap2343→2344 | IV104:2396 running text |
| 20 | V374:2344 running text | IV104:2397 running text |
| 21 | V375n2 actual reply unit;main gap2344→2345 | IV104:2398 running text |
| 22 | V375:2345 running text | IV104:2399 running text |
| 23 | V375:2346 running text | IV104:2400 running text |
| 24 | V375:2347 running text | IV105:2401 running text |
| 25 | V375:2348 running text | IV105:2402 running text |
| 26 | V375:2349 running text | IV105:2403 running text |
| 27 | V375:2350 running text | IV105:2404 running text |
| 28 | V375:2351 running text | IV105:2405 running text |
| 29 | V375:2352 running text | IV105:2406 running text |
| 30 | V375:2353 running text | IV105:2407 running text |
| 31 | V375:2354 running text | IV105:2408 running text |
| 32 | V375:2355 running text | IV105:2409 running text |
| 33 | V375:2356 running text | IV105:2410 running text |
| 34 | V375:2357 running text | IV105:2411 running text |
| 35 | V375:2358 running text | IV105:2412 running text |
| 36 | V375:2359 running text | IV105:2413 running text |
| 37 | V375:2360 running text | IV105:2414 running text |
| 38 | V376:2361 running text | IV105:2415 running text |
| 39 | V376:2362 running text | IV105:2416 running text |
| 40 | V376:2363 running text | IV105:2417 running text |
| 41 | V376:2364 running text | IV105:2418 running text |
| 42 | V376:2365 running text | IV105:2419 running text |
| 43 | V376:2366 running text | IV105:2420 running text |
| 44 | V376:2367 running text | IV105:2421 running text |
| 45 | V376:2368 running text | IV105:2422 running text |
| 46 | V376:2369 running text | IV105:2423 running text |
New Naqqali