The Court Is Closed to the Nobles
44 published couplets unchanged;8 notes.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 44 published couplets unchanged;8 notes. |
| Moscow | V382–384:2469–2512;44 main units;actual382n22 armor and383n17 greeting variants. |
| Mohl | IV110–112:2524–2567;44 main units;bloodface/fireheart,nurture andunturnedheart branches. |
| Ganjoor | mahmood/sh29:4–47;44 main units. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | IV330–332:2485–2528;44 main units;greeting,divineanswer andunturnedheart branches. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6The uncertain nobles gain an audience
English 1–6;individual four-edition running-text loci below.
Moscow V382:2469 running text · Mohl IV110:2524 running text · Khaleghi IV330:2485 running text · Ganjoor sh29:4 running body · Moscow V382:2470 running text · Mohl IV110:2525 running text · Khaleghi IV330:2486 running text · Ganjoor sh29:5 running body · Moscow V382:2471 running text · Mohl IV110:2526 running text · Khaleghi IV330:2487 running text · Ganjoor sh29:6 running body · Moscow V382:2472 running text · Mohl IV110:2527 running text · Khaleghi IV330:2488 running text · Ganjoor sh29:7 running body · Moscow V382:2473 running text · Mohl IV110:2528 running text · Khaleghi IV330:2489 running text · Ganjoor sh29:8 running body · Moscow V382:2474 running text · Mohl IV110:2529 running text · Khaleghi IV330:2490 running text · Ganjoor sh29:9 running body
All four begin with the Iranian champions astonished by the king’s conduct and forming different explanations. English grief cutting pleasure short interprets the preceding withdrawal; it does not supply a diagnosis that the Persian narrator independently confirms. The return to the throne brings the chamberlain, the raised curtain and admission of the waiting company. These actions matter because the title’s closure is not continuous throughout the chapter: an audience intervenes before access is barred again. The nobles’ folded arms or hands tucked against the body accompany praise of their elephant-felling strength and lion-like bearing. The English keeps that contrast between martial power and courtly deference. All four name the same six champions. Reordering Bijan and Rohham in English changes neither the membership of the group nor Rohham’s lion epithet.
7–12Royal praise and the equipment of the warrior
English 7–12;individual four-edition running-text loci below.
Moscow V382:2475 running text · Mohl IV110:2530 running text · Khaleghi IV330:2491 running text · Ganjoor sh29:10 running body · Moscow V382:2476 running text · Mohl IV110:2531 running text · Khaleghi IV330:2492 running text · Ganjoor sh29:11 running body · Moscow V382:2477 running text · Mohl IV110:2532 running text · Khaleghi IV330:2493 running text · Ganjoor sh29:12 running body · Moscow V382:2478 running text;actual382n22 armor variant · Mohl IV110:2533 running text · Khaleghi IV330:2494 running text · Ganjoor sh29:13 running body · Moscow V382:2479 running text · Mohl IV110:2534 running text · Khaleghi IV330:2495 running text · Ganjoor sh29:14 running body · Moscow V382:2480 running text · Mohl IV110:2535 running text · Khaleghi IV330:2496 running text · Ganjoor sh29:15 running body
Obeisance precedes the disclosure of concern in every edition. The address combines kingship, heroism, judgment and supremacy over other chiefs. English great and small broadens the implied reach of judgment. Mohl and Ganjoor explicitly deny that a comparable king has occupied the ivory throne, supporting the English negative formulation where Moscow and Khaleghi use a when-you-sit construction. Radiance passing from the king to sun and crown remains shared. The equipment list differs: Mohl supports jowshan, sword and horse together, while Moscow and Ganjoor name spear, sword and horse, and Khaleghi names armor, saddle and horse. Moscow’s actual apparatus also records the armor branch. Labor exceeding treasure and the champions living through their sight of the king then complete praise that is devotional and political, not a financial or physiological report.
13–18The nobles’ uncertainty and their pledge of service
English 13–18;individual four-edition running-text loci below.
Moscow V383:2481 running text · Mohl IV110:2536 running text · Khaleghi IV330:2497 running text · Ganjoor sh29:16 running body · Moscow V383:2482 running text · Mohl IV110:2537 running text · Khaleghi IV330:2498 running text · Ganjoor sh29:17 running body · Moscow V383:2483 running text · Mohl IV110:2538 running text · Khaleghi IV330:2499 running text · Ganjoor sh29:18 running body · Moscow V383:2484 running text · Mohl IV111:2539 running text · Khaleghi IV330:2500 running text · Ganjoor sh29:19 running body · Moscow V383:2485 running text · Mohl IV111:2540 running text · Khaleghi IV330:2501 running text · Ganjoor sh29:20 running body · Moscow V383:2486 running text · Mohl IV111:2541 running text · Khaleghi IV330:2502 running text · Ganjoor sh29:21 running body
All four contrast the destruction of enemies and possession of troops and treasure with an unexplained darkening of royal thought. English inwardly confined gives that uncertainty an interior image; the nobles still do not know its cause. They argue that this should be a time of enjoyment rather than care and withering. Their suggestion that they may have offended him includes a defensive denial of guilt in the Persian formulations. English if any fault smooths that tension, drawing the offer of a remedy forward from the following unit. The blood and fire imagery must be checked individually. Mohl places blood in the face and fire in the heart, directly supporting the English distribution. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi place blood in the heart and fire in the face. The English is therefore not an unsupported reversal.
19–24A martial remedy and the king’s answer
English 19–24;individual four-edition running-text loci below.
Moscow V383:2487 running text · Mohl IV111:2542 running text · Khaleghi IV331:2503 running text · Ganjoor sh29:22 running body · Moscow V383:2488 running text · Mohl IV111:2543 running text · Khaleghi IV331:2504 running text · Ganjoor sh29:23 running body · Moscow V383:2489 running text · Mohl IV111:2544 running text · Khaleghi IV331:2505 running text · Ganjoor sh29:24 running body · Moscow V383:2490 running text · Mohl IV111:2545 running text · Khaleghi IV331:2506 running text · Ganjoor sh29:25 running body · Moscow V383:2491 running text;actual383n17 greeting variant · Mohl IV111:2546 running text · Khaleghi IV331:2507 running text · Ganjoor sh29:26 running body · Moscow V383:2492 running text · Mohl IV111:2547 running text · Khaleghi IV331:2508 running text · Ganjoor sh29:27 running body
The nobles ask in all four accounts whether a concealed enemy troubles the king. English we shall meet that foe supplies their anticipated action. Their model of kingship remains martial: taking heads or giving their own while wearing warriors’ helmets. English distributes this argument across two couplets. Mohl’s throne and royal cap support the English regalia, where the other three name treasure and army. The request to reveal the secret and seek a remedy then leads to Khosrow’s answer. Mohl and Khaleghi begin with a greeting to the chiefs, as does an actually printed Moscow variant; Moscow and Ganjoor’s running text instead tells them there is no warfare for them. The king denies both an enemy’s pressure and scattered treasure. English loss interprets dispersal without establishing an audited royal balance.
25–30From completed vengeance to music and wine
English 25–30;individual four-edition running-text loci below.
Moscow V383:2493 running text · Mohl IV111:2548 running text · Khaleghi IV331:2509 running text · Ganjoor sh29:28 running body · Moscow V383:2494 running text · Mohl IV111:2549 running text · Khaleghi IV331:2510 running text · Ganjoor sh29:29 running body · Moscow V383:2495 running text · Mohl IV111:2550 running text · Khaleghi IV331:2511 running text · Ganjoor sh29:30 running body · Moscow V383:2496 running text · Mohl IV111:2551 running text · Khaleghi IV331:2512 running text · Ganjoor sh29:31 running body · Moscow V383:2497 running text · Mohl IV111:2552 running text · Khaleghi IV331:2513 running text · Ganjoor sh29:32 running body · Moscow V383:2498 running text · Mohl IV111:2553 running text · Khaleghi IV331:2514 running text · Ganjoor sh29:33 running body
All four deny that the army has offended the king or that a guilty man among the chiefs explains his withdrawal. English failed in any loyal part makes that assurance more general. The king then describes avenging his father and adorning the world through justice and religion. The English garden rising adds an organic image to this account of ordered rule; it remains his own description of his achievement. The seal acknowledged throughout the earth similarly expresses comprehensive dominion rather than authenticating a surviving document. Sheathed swords and brought wine establish a shared transition from fighting to enjoyment. Bowstring noise gives way to flute and harp, with wine and scent accompanying the music. His week standing before Yazdan explains the recent absence, without necessarily adding another week to the chronology already narrated.
31–36The undisclosed wish and the promise to explain
English 31–36;individual four-edition running-text loci below.
Moscow V384:2499 running text · Mohl IV111:2554 running text · Khaleghi IV331:2515 running text · Ganjoor sh29:34 running body · Moscow V384:2500 running text · Mohl IV111:2555 running text · Khaleghi IV331:2516 running text · Ganjoor sh29:35 running body · Moscow V384:2501 running text · Mohl IV111:2556 running text · Khaleghi IV331:2517 running text · Ganjoor sh29:36 running body · Moscow V384:2502 running text · Mohl IV111:2557 running text · Khaleghi IV331:2518 running text · Ganjoor sh29:37 running body · Moscow V384:2503 running text · Mohl IV111:2558 running text · Khaleghi IV331:2519 running text · Ganjoor sh29:38 running body · Moscow V384:2504 running text · Mohl IV111:2559 running text · Khaleghi IV332:2520 running text · Ganjoor sh29:39 running body
The hidden wish is present in all four, but the promised answer differs grammatically. Mohl and Khaleghi use a third-person granting or response, supporting English He as the divine answerer. Moscow and Ganjoor use a second-person plural reply formulation. English spirit glad interprets the favorable day resulting from the answer; the wish has not yet been reported as fulfilled. The king then urges prayer and gratitude for joy, acknowledging divine power over good and evil and the shown path. This does not authorize wrongdoing. The invitation to rejoice with him follows Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor’s companionship wording, against Khaleghi’s wine reading at that point. Finally, unstable heaven distinguishes neither lowly person nor ruler. English briefly ours turns that instability into an explicit reminder of the short duration of possession.
37–40The sky’s nurture and the renewed closure
English 37–40;individual four-edition running-text loci below.
Moscow V384:2505 running text · Mohl IV111:2560 running text · Khaleghi IV332:2521 running text · Ganjoor sh29:40 running body · Moscow V384:2506 running text · Mohl IV111:2561 running text · Khaleghi IV332:2522 running text · Ganjoor sh29:41 running body · Moscow V384:2507 running text · Mohl IV111:2562 running text · Khaleghi IV332:2523 running text · Ganjoor sh29:42 running body · Moscow V384:2508 running text · Mohl IV111:2563 running text · Khaleghi IV332:2524 running text · Ganjoor sh29:43 running body
The treatment of young and old presents a consequential disagreement. Mohl uses nurturing or fostering language, supporting English cherishes. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi instead say that heaven reaps the old and young together. The shared pairing of justice and oppression therefore follows different preceding images; the four should not be credited with one unanimous account of kindly care. The nobles then leave in distress in every presentation. English cried aloud makes their grief audibly manifest, whereas the corresponding unit describes their afflicted inner state. Khosrow instructs the chamberlain to sit behind the curtain and exclude both strangers and his own people. English friend and kin expands that second category. The renewed closure follows an actual exchange with the chiefs, sharpening their inability to reach the king despite the audience just granted.
41–44The final prayer and the unturned heart
English 41–44;individual four-edition running-text loci below.
Moscow V384:2509 running text · Mohl IV112:2564 running text · Khaleghi IV332:2525 running text · Ganjoor sh29:44 running body · Moscow V384:2510 running text · Mohl IV112:2565 running text · Khaleghi IV332:2526 running text · Ganjoor sh29:45 running body · Moscow V384:2511 running text · Mohl IV112:2566 running text · Khaleghi IV332:2527 running text · Ganjoor sh29:46 running body · Moscow V384:2512 running text · Mohl IV112:2567 running text · Khaleghi IV332:2528 running text · Ganjoor sh29:47 running body
All four return to worship at night and an address to the divine sustainer, beyond height and the increaser of purity and greatness. English solitude draws on the closed court, while without cease adds duration to the praise. The request for guidance to heaven and departure from the temporary dwelling remains a prayer, not a narrated completion of death or disappearance. The closing assertion differs substantially. Mohl and Khaleghi describe a heart not turned toward crookedness, supporting the English claim to truth and right. Moscow and Ganjoor instead address God as not leaving the heart unfulfilled. Mohl and Khaleghi also support the soul’s finding the place of bright-hearted people, where the other branch has shining wording. These differences should remain visible rather than being merged into a single four-edition quotation.
Source record and limits
44 English couplets;8 notes. Moscow V382–384:2469–2512;Mohl IV110–112:2524–2567;Ganjoor mahmood/sh29:4–47;Khaleghi IV330–332:2485–2528. Each edition has44 running units,accounted once. English17–18 and20–21 redistribute material within neighboring blocks. No source-only unit.
All44 English units have corresponding running-text units or neighboring blocks in each edition. ActualMoscow V382n22 armor variant andV383n17 greeting unit inspected separately fromrunningtext. No apparatus-only unit needed forcoverage;no checkedlocalgap or source-onlyunit. No appendix evidenceused. No unprintedadditionnotice treatedasverification. Ganjoor29:1–3 belongsC4.47 andisnotrecounted.
Published English preserved verbatim. Mohl supportsEnglish9 no-comparable-king,10armor/sword/horse,18bloodface/fireheart,20regalia,23greeting,32divineanswer,37cherishingyoungold,44unturnedheart. Khaleghi also supports23greeting,32divineanswer,44unturnedheart;Moscow actualapparatus supports10armor/23greeting. English26garden,38audiblecry andother specifications distinguishedfromrunningwording. No clinicaldiagnosis,financialaudit,ritualmanual,documentauthentication or completeddeparture certified. Every inheritedflag retained,especiallyC4.21.20 unverifiedmarble.
The Persian reference follows Ganjoor throughout;edition variants and redistribution within neighboring blocks are kept distinct. Moscow and Mohl were inspected individually first,then Ganjoor and Khaleghi. Printed-page to one-based PDF offsets are Moscow0,Mohl6,Khaleghi16.
Mohl IV111:2541 main;English18: پر از خون رخ و دل پر آتش کنیم
Ganjoor29:21;Moscow/Khaleghi relatedmain;English18: پر از خون دل و رخ پر آتش کنیم
Moscow V383n17 actual greeting variant;English23: چنین داد پاسخ گرانمایه شاه / که ای پهلوانان جوینده راه
Khaleghi IV331:2516 main;English32: بگویم گشاده چو پاسخ دهد / به پاسخ مرا روز فرخ نهد
Ganjoor29:35;Moscow relatedmain;English32: بگویم گشاده چو پاسخ دهید / به پاسخ مرا روز فرخ نهید
Mohl IV111:2560 main;English37: همی پرورد پیر و برنا بهم
Ganjoor29:40;Moscow/Khaleghi relatedmain;English37: همی بدرود پیر و برنا به هم
Mohl IV112:2567 / Khaleghi IV332:2528 main;English44: به کژی دلم هیچ ناتافته / روان جای روشن دلان یافته
Ganjoor29:47;Moscow relatedmain;English44: نکردی دلم هیچ نایافته / روان جای روشن دلان تافته
C4.48 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | V382:2469 running text | IV110:2524 running text |
| 2 | V382:2470 running text | IV110:2525 running text |
| 3 | V382:2471 running text | IV110:2526 running text |
| 4 | V382:2472 running text | IV110:2527 running text |
| 5 | V382:2473 running text | IV110:2528 running text |
| 6 | V382:2474 running text | IV110:2529 running text |
| 7 | V382:2475 running text | IV110:2530 running text |
| 8 | V382:2476 running text | IV110:2531 running text |
| 9 | V382:2477 running text | IV110:2532 running text |
| 10 | V382:2478 running text;actual382n22 armor variant | IV110:2533 running text |
| 11 | V382:2479 running text | IV110:2534 running text |
| 12 | V382:2480 running text | IV110:2535 running text |
| 13 | V383:2481 running text | IV110:2536 running text |
| 14 | V383:2482 running text | IV110:2537 running text |
| 15 | V383:2483 running text | IV110:2538 running text |
| 16 | V383:2484 running text | IV111:2539 running text |
| 17 | V383:2485 running text | IV111:2540 running text |
| 18 | V383:2486 running text | IV111:2541 running text |
| 19 | V383:2487 running text | IV111:2542 running text |
| 20 | V383:2488 running text | IV111:2543 running text |
| 21 | V383:2489 running text | IV111:2544 running text |
| 22 | V383:2490 running text | IV111:2545 running text |
| 23 | V383:2491 running text;actual383n17 greeting variant | IV111:2546 running text |
| 24 | V383:2492 running text | IV111:2547 running text |
| 25 | V383:2493 running text | IV111:2548 running text |
| 26 | V383:2494 running text | IV111:2549 running text |
| 27 | V383:2495 running text | IV111:2550 running text |
| 28 | V383:2496 running text | IV111:2551 running text |
| 29 | V383:2497 running text | IV111:2552 running text |
| 30 | V383:2498 running text | IV111:2553 running text |
| 31 | V384:2499 running text | IV111:2554 running text |
| 32 | V384:2500 running text | IV111:2555 running text |
| 33 | V384:2501 running text | IV111:2556 running text |
| 34 | V384:2502 running text | IV111:2557 running text |
| 35 | V384:2503 running text | IV111:2558 running text |
| 36 | V384:2504 running text | IV111:2559 running text |
| 37 | V384:2505 running text | IV111:2560 running text |
| 38 | V384:2506 running text | IV111:2561 running text |
| 39 | V384:2507 running text | IV111:2562 running text |
| 40 | V384:2508 running text | IV111:2563 running text |
| 41 | V384:2509 running text | IV112:2564 running text |
| 42 | V384:2510 running text | IV112:2565 running text |
| 43 | V384:2511 running text | IV112:2566 running text |
| 44 | V384:2512 running text | IV112:2567 running text |
New Naqqali