Zal and Rostam Are Summoned
52 published couplets unchanged;9 notes.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 52 published couplets unchanged;9 notes. |
| Moscow | V384–387:2513–2562;50 main units;actual V386n24 supports English 39–40. |
| Mohl | IV112–114:2568–2619;52 main units;local gap for extra assembly unit. |
| Ganjoor | mahmood/sh30:1–50;50 main units;checkedgaps forEnglish 39–40. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | IV332–336:2529–2581;53 main units;fullpetition running text. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6A court interprets silence
English 1–6;individual four-edition running-text loci below.
Moscow V384:2513 running text · Mohl IV112:2568 running text · Khaleghi IV332:2529 running text · Ganjoor sh30:1 running body · Moscow V384:2514 running text · Mohl IV112:2569 running text · Khaleghi IV332:2530 running text · Ganjoor sh30:2 running body · Moscow V384:2515 running text · Mohl IV112:2570 running text · Khaleghi IV332:2531 running text · Ganjoor sh30:3 running body · Moscow V384:2516 running text · Mohl IV112:2571 running text · Khaleghi IV332:2532 running text · Ganjoor sh30:4 running body · Moscow V384:2517 running text · Mohl IV112:2572 running text · Khaleghi IV332:2533 running text · Ganjoor sh30:5 running body · Moscow V385:2518 running text · Mohl IV112:2573 running text · Khaleghi IV332:2534 running text · Ganjoor sh30:6 running body
The week of seclusion becomes a public problem because the nobles can observe the closed court but cannot observe the king’s intention. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh all move from collective assembly to historical comparison before Gudarz addresses Giv. The English preserves that reasoning: former rulers supply examples of service to God and misconduct, rather than proof that Khosrow has already become a tyrant. ‘Some tyrannous and bold’ gives the adverse category a more specific political coloring than the Persian bad conduct. ‘Men of proven worth’ similarly expands the dignified description of the assembled great. Neither expansion changes the sequence of deliberation. The affectionate address to Giv leads directly into his remembered service, making the proposed mission an appeal to established loyalty.
7–12A diagnosis carried by messengers
English 7–12;individual four-edition running-text loci below.
Moscow V385:2519 running text · Mohl IV112:2574 running text · Khaleghi IV332:2535 running text · Ganjoor sh30:7 running body · Moscow V385:2520 running text · Mohl IV112:2575 running text · Khaleghi IV333:2536 running text · Ganjoor sh30:8 running body · Moscow V385:2521 running text · Mohl IV112:2576 running text · Khaleghi IV333:2537 running text · Ganjoor sh30:9 running body · Moscow V385:2522 running text · Mohl IV112:2577 running text · Khaleghi IV333:2538 running text · Ganjoor sh30:10 running body · Moscow V385:2523 running text · Mohl IV112:2578 running text · Khaleghi IV333:2539 running text · Ganjoor sh30:11 running body · Moscow V385:2524 running text · Mohl IV112:2579 running text · Khaleghi IV333:2540 running text · Ganjoor sh30:12 running body
All four sources recall Giv’s earlier hardship and separation before announcing the present danger. The English’s messenger instruction follows the generic rider of Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh; Mohl instead names Bahman, commander of Kabul, in the corresponding second hemistich. This is a substantive difference in the instruction, not evidence that the English has accidentally omitted an agreed name. The accusation that the shah has abandoned God’s way belongs to Gudarz’s message. So does the conjecture that he sits with a div: the Persian qualification represented by ‘surely’ must be read as anxious inference, not narratorial confirmation. ‘Appealing to the justice that we knew’ explains the courtiers’ approach, but all four running texts speak more directly of their pleas and their effort to obtain his assent.
13–18Counsel summoned across the frontier
English 13–18;individual four-edition running-text loci below.
Moscow V385:2525 running text · Mohl IV112:2580 running text · Khaleghi IV333:2541 running text · Ganjoor sh30:13 running body · Moscow V385:2526 running text · Mohl IV112:2581 running text · Khaleghi IV333:2542 running text · Ganjoor sh30:14 running body · Moscow V385:2527 running text · Mohl IV112:2582 running text · Khaleghi IV333:2543 running text · Ganjoor sh30:15 running body · Moscow V385:2528 running text · Mohl IV112:2583 running text · Khaleghi IV333:2544 running text · Ganjoor sh30:16 running body · Moscow V385:2529 running text · Mohl IV112:2584 running text · Khaleghi IV333:2545 running text · Ganjoor sh30:17 running body · Moscow V385:2530 running text · Mohl IV112:2585 running text · Khaleghi IV333:2546 running text · Ganjoor sh30:18 running body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh agree on the frightening comparison with Kavus and on the appeal to wiser pahlavans. They do not thereby certify that a div has possessed Khosrow. The English rightly keeps ‘We fear,’ preserving the difference between the nobles’ interpretation and the king’s religious purpose. The regional summons then gathers the discerning, astrologers and men of pure character into one traveling company. English 16–17 rearranges that material: the place list and Kabul’s star-readers occupy one couplet, while Zabul’s worthy men occupy the next. This neighboring redistribution remains traceable in every edition. The printed forms of the middle place-name differ, and ‘Danbar’ is retained as published English, not certified here as a modern geographical identification or as an identical spelling in all four texts.
19–24Giv carries an unsettling report
English 19–24;individual four-edition running-text loci below.
Moscow V385:2531 running text · Mohl IV112:2586 running text · Khaleghi IV333:2547 running text · Ganjoor sh30:19 running body · Moscow V385:2532 running text · Mohl IV113:2587 running text · Khaleghi IV333:2548 running text · Ganjoor sh30:20 running body · Moscow V385:2533 running text · Mohl IV113:2588 running text · Khaleghi IV333:2549 running text · Ganjoor sh30:21 running body · Moscow V385:2534 running text · Mohl IV113:2589 running text · Khaleghi IV333:2550 running text · Ganjoor sh30:22 running body · Moscow V385:2535 running text · Mohl IV113:2590 running text · Khaleghi IV334:2551 running text · Ganjoor sh30:23 running body · Moscow V386:2536 running text · Mohl IV113:2591 running text · Khaleghi IV334:2552 running text · Ganjoor sh30:24 running body
The four running texts agree that concealment of Khosrow’s face and counsel has filled the realm with talk, and that the nobles now look to Dastan for resolution. The English’s ‘rumors, fear, and speech’ makes the atmosphere explicit; the Persian does not offer three separately enumerated social conditions. Giv selects capable men, becomes troubled and takes the road to Sistan. English 21–22 distributes those actions across its own line endings without inventing a second journey or a separate Kabul visit. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh all place his report to Zal and Rostam at arrival, followed by Zal’s grief. ‘Our lot is joined’ gives an idiomatic form to being coupled with suffering. It should not be read as a prediction of an already determined disaster.
25–30Two gatherings and an eighth day
English 25–30;individual four-edition running-text loci below.
Moscow V386:2537 running text · Mohl IV113:2592 running text · Khaleghi IV334:2553 running text · Ganjoor sh30:25 running body · Moscow V386:2538 running text · Mohl IV113:2593 running text · Khaleghi IV334:2554 running text · Ganjoor sh30:26 running body · Moscow V386:2539 running text; V386:2540 running text · Mohl IV113:2594 running text;checked local gap for separate assembly verse before this unit · Khaleghi IV334:2555 running text; IV334:2556 running text · Ganjoor sh30:27,sh30:28 running body · Moscow V386:2541 running text · Mohl IV113:2595 running text · Khaleghi IV334:2557 running text · Ganjoor sh30:29 running body · Moscow V386:2542 running text · Mohl IV113:2596 running text · Khaleghi IV334:2558 running text · Ganjoor sh30:30 running body · Moscow V386:2543 running text · Mohl IV113:2597 running text · Khaleghi IV334:2559 running text · Ganjoor sh30:31 running body
Zal’s summons and the reopening of Khosrow’s audience are consecutive narrative scenes, not an explicit claim that the returning party reached court within the same seven days. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh print a separate assembly verse naming priests, dignitaries and learned men before the verse of departure toward Iran. Mohl’s checked local sequence passes directly from the instruction to the departure. English 27 condenses the two-unit sequence preserved by the other three, while remaining compatible with Mohl’s shorter running sequence. All four then place the king’s standing vigil over seven days before the eighth-day audience. ‘In prayer’ interprets that vigil through its surrounding devotional context; the timing verse itself says he stood. The golden throne and the chamberlain’s removal of the curtain are directly represented in every edition.
31–36An audience that refuses to sit
English 31–36;individual four-edition running-text loci below.
Moscow V386:2545 running text · Mohl IV113:2598 running text · Khaleghi IV334:2561 running text · Ganjoor sh30:33 running body · Moscow V386:2544 running text · Mohl IV113:2599 running text · Khaleghi IV334:2560 running text · Ganjoor sh30:32 running body · Moscow V386:2546 running text · Mohl IV113:2600 running text · Khaleghi IV334:2562 running text · Ganjoor sh30:34 running body · Moscow V386:2547 running text · Mohl IV113:2601 running text · Khaleghi IV334:2563 running text · Ganjoor sh30:35 running body · Moscow V386:2548 running text · Mohl IV113:2602 running text · Khaleghi IV334:2564 running text · Ganjoor sh30:36 running body · Moscow V386:2549 running text · Mohl IV113:2603 running text · Khaleghi IV335:2565 running text · Ganjoor sh30:37 running body
The English gives the allocation of places before the description of prolonged standing. Mohl follows this order; Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh place the standing verse before the king’s welcome and assignment of rank. These are individually accounted units, not a missing verse in either arrangement. All four then say that none sat or opened his hands. ‘Arms still folded’ supplies a recognizable posture, but the Persian does not explicitly specify crossed arms. The address ‘Shah of Mobadan’ follows Mohl’s wording; the other three invoke the moving heaven before praising the just, luminous ruler. Sun and fish establish cosmic reach, while the following praise concerns knowledge of what will be. The English’s general confidence in the king’s understanding is warranted, without making the speech a neutral assertion of literal omniscience.
37–40The complaints in different textual locations
English 37–40;individual four-edition running-text loci below.
Moscow V386:2550 first hemistich shared with38;main unit counted once at38 · Mohl IV113:2604 running text · Khaleghi IV335:2566 running text · Ganjoor sh30:38 first hemistich shared;unit counted once at38 · Moscow V386:2550 running text · Mohl IV113:2605 running text · Khaleghi IV335:2567 running text · Ganjoor sh30:38 running body · Moscow V386n24 actual apparatus;checked running-text gap after2550 · Mohl IV113:2606 running text · Khaleghi IV335:2568 running text · Ganjoor checked local gap between sh30:38 and39 · Moscow V386n24 actual apparatus;checked running-text gap after2550 · Mohl IV113:2607 running text · Khaleghi IV335:2569 running text · Ganjoor checked local gap between sh30:38 and39
Mohl and Khaleghi-Motlagh print the nobles’ declaration of service and their question about the closed way as separate running couplets. Moscow and Ganjoor combine these actions in one running couplet. English 37–38 therefore follows a fuller arrangement supported independently by both longer texts. The next two English couplets likewise have direct running support in Mohl and Khaleghi-Motlagh: prolonged distress and a request to disclose the secret to the frontier lords. Ganjoor’s inspected local transition omits them. Moscow prints those two verses in the actual apparatus at V386, note 24, rather than in its running text. That is positive apparatus evidence, not a reconstructed addition notice. ‘Now have lost their way’ follows the petition’s description; it does not establish that the border commanders have physically become lost.
41–46Impossible services and an ordinary denial
English 41–46;individual four-edition running-text loci below.
Moscow V387:2551 running text · Mohl IV113:2608 running text · Khaleghi IV335:2570 running text · Ganjoor sh30:39 running body · Moscow V387:2552 running text · Mohl IV113:2609 running text · Khaleghi IV335:2571 running text · Ganjoor sh30:40 running body · Moscow V387:2553 running text · Mohl IV113:2610 running text · Khaleghi IV335:2572 running text · Ganjoor sh30:41 running body · Moscow V387:2554 running text · Mohl IV113:2611 running text · Khaleghi IV335:2573 running text · Ganjoor sh30:42 running body · Moscow V387:2555 running text · Mohl IV114:2612 running text · Khaleghi IV335:2574 running text · Ganjoor sh30:43 running body · Moscow V387:2556 running text · Mohl IV114:2613 running text · Khaleghi IV335:2575 running text · Ganjoor sh30:44 running body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh all present escalating promises: dry the sea, perfume the earth, uproot mountains, strike enemies and supply wealth. The English preserves their impossible scale as a courtly demonstration of willingness, not a record of practical projects. Its ‘gold or silver’ broadens the Persian reference to treasure and dirhams; the claim remains that material resources can remove a material grievance. The self-description as guardians of the king’s treasure makes their offer sound institutional as well as personal. All four then give Khosrow a courteous correction: he still needs the pahlavans, yet his sorrow is not caused by lack of force, men or treasure. This distinction matters. The English does not make him reject their service; it makes their proposed remedies irrelevant to his particular longing.
47–52A wish withheld from loyal listeners
English 47–52;individual four-edition running-text loci below.
Moscow V387:2557 running text · Mohl IV114:2614 running text · Khaleghi IV335:2576 running text · Ganjoor sh30:45 running body · Moscow V387:2558 running text · Mohl IV114:2615 running text · Khaleghi IV335:2577 running text · Ganjoor sh30:46 running body · Moscow V387:2559 running text · Mohl IV114:2616 running text · Khaleghi IV335:2578 running text · Ganjoor sh30:47 running body · Moscow V387:2560 running text · Mohl IV114:2617 running text · Khaleghi IV335:2579 running text · Ganjoor sh30:48 running body · Moscow V387:2561 running text · Mohl IV114:2618 running text · Khaleghi IV336:2580 running text · Ganjoor sh30:49 running body · Moscow V387:2562 running text · Mohl IV114:2619 running text · Khaleghi IV336:2581 running text · Ganjoor sh30:50 running body
All four running texts deny the appearance of an external enemy and identify a single sustaining desire. They also promise disclosure upon its fulfillment and dismiss the nobles with wishes for victory and joy. The English’s ‘gaining that delight’ interprets the desired fulfillment without naming its object prematurely. Its ‘ardent’ strengthens the emotional temperature, whereas the Persian chiefly emphasizes the heart’s attachment and continuing hope through night and day. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh all close this audience with the pahlavans blessing the king in distress: the farewell does not mean their anxiety has been resolved. The present English chapter ends there. The following lowering of the curtain and renewed solitary grief belong beyond this boundary, even where a Persian web section continues through those verses.
Source record and limits
52 English couplets;9 notes. Moscow V384–387:2513–2562 has50 running units plus actual V386n24 petition evidence;Mohl IV112–114:2568–2619 has52 running units;Ganjoor mahmood/sh30:1–50 has50 running units;Khaleghi IV332–336:2529–2581 has53 running units. All main units counted once;no source-only unit left unaccounted.
Actual Moscow V386n24 prints the prolonged-distress and reveal-the-secret couplets corresponding toEnglish 39–40;these are not Moscow running text. Its additional petition variant in the same note is not substituted for the main text. Ganjoor30:38→39 has checkedlocal gaps forEnglish 39–40. Mohl IV113:2593→2594 has checkedlocal gap for the separate assembly unit present in the other three. No appendix evidence used;no unprinted addition notice counted. Moscow/Ganjoor combined service/question unit allocated once at English38,withshared hemistich at 37. Following curtain/grief units excluded.
Published English unchanged. English 27 condenses an extra assembly unit in Moscow/Ganjoor/Khaleghi;Mohl locally lacks it. English 31–32 order follows Mohl. English 37–38 expands Moscow/Ganjoor combined unit into two,as supported by Mohl/Khaleghi. English 39–40 supported by Mohl/Khaleghi running text and actual Moscow apparatus;Ganjoor local gap. English 9 follows generic rider versus Mohl named Bahman. English 34 shah of mobads follows Mohl. Danbar spelling/geographical identity not certified;folded arms andin prayer are interpretations. All inherited flags retained,especially C4.21.20 unverified marble.
The Persian reference follows Ganjoor exceptEnglish 37,39,40,which use individually checked Mohl running text;edition variants,shared hemistich and redistribution remain distinct. Moscow and Mohl were inspected individually first, then Ganjoor and Khaleghi. Printed-page to one-based PDF offsets are Moscow 0, Mohl 6, Khaleghi 16.
Mohl IV112:2576 main;English 9: بهمن سپهدار کابلستان
Moscow V385:2521 main;English 9: سواری فرستی به کابلستان
Mohl IV113:2601 main;English 34: گشادند لب کای شه موبدان
Ganjoor30:35 main;English 34: گشادند لب کی سپهر روان
Moscow V386n24 actual apparatus;English 39: کنون روزگاری برین برگذشت / دل ما پر آزار و تیمار گشت
Moscow V386n24 actual apparatus;English 40: گر ایذونی که بگشاید این راز شاه / برین مرزبانان گم کرده راه
Khaleghi IV335:2566 main;English 37: همه بندگانیم پیشت به پای / مه پهلوانان فرخندهرای
Ganjoor30:38 main;English 37–38: همه بندگانیم در پیش شاه / چه کردیم و بر ما چرا بست راه
C4.49 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | V384:2513 running text | IV112:2568 running text |
| 2 | V384:2514 running text | IV112:2569 running text |
| 3 | V384:2515 running text | IV112:2570 running text |
| 4 | V384:2516 running text | IV112:2571 running text |
| 5 | V384:2517 running text | IV112:2572 running text |
| 6 | V385:2518 running text | IV112:2573 running text |
| 7 | V385:2519 running text | IV112:2574 running text |
| 8 | V385:2520 running text | IV112:2575 running text |
| 9 | V385:2521 running text | IV112:2576 running text |
| 10 | V385:2522 running text | IV112:2577 running text |
| 11 | V385:2523 running text | IV112:2578 running text |
| 12 | V385:2524 running text | IV112:2579 running text |
| 13 | V385:2525 running text | IV112:2580 running text |
| 14 | V385:2526 running text | IV112:2581 running text |
| 15 | V385:2527 running text | IV112:2582 running text |
| 16 | V385:2528 running text | IV112:2583 running text |
| 17 | V385:2529 running text | IV112:2584 running text |
| 18 | V385:2530 running text | IV112:2585 running text |
| 19 | V385:2531 running text | IV112:2586 running text |
| 20 | V385:2532 running text | IV113:2587 running text |
| 21 | V385:2533 running text | IV113:2588 running text |
| 22 | V385:2534 running text | IV113:2589 running text |
| 23 | V385:2535 running text | IV113:2590 running text |
| 24 | V386:2536 running text | IV113:2591 running text |
| 25 | V386:2537 running text | IV113:2592 running text |
| 26 | V386:2538 running text | IV113:2593 running text |
| 27 | V386:2539 running text; V386:2540 running text | IV113:2594 running text;checked local gap for separate assembly verse before this unit |
| 28 | V386:2541 running text | IV113:2595 running text |
| 29 | V386:2542 running text | IV113:2596 running text |
| 30 | V386:2543 running text | IV113:2597 running text |
| 31 | V386:2545 running text | IV113:2598 running text |
| 32 | V386:2544 running text | IV113:2599 running text |
| 33 | V386:2546 running text | IV113:2600 running text |
| 34 | V386:2547 running text | IV113:2601 running text |
| 35 | V386:2548 running text | IV113:2602 running text |
| 36 | V386:2549 running text | IV113:2603 running text |
| 37 | V386:2550 first hemistich shared with38;main unit counted once at38 | IV113:2604 running text |
| 38 | V386:2550 running text | IV113:2605 running text |
| 39 | V386n24 actual apparatus;checked running-text gap after2550 | IV113:2606 running text |
| 40 | V386n24 actual apparatus;checked running-text gap after2550 | IV113:2607 running text |
| 41 | V387:2551 running text | IV113:2608 running text |
| 42 | V387:2552 running text | IV113:2609 running text |
| 43 | V387:2553 running text | IV113:2610 running text |
| 44 | V387:2554 running text | IV113:2611 running text |
| 45 | V387:2555 running text | IV114:2612 running text |
| 46 | V387:2556 running text | IV114:2613 running text |
| 47 | V387:2557 running text | IV114:2614 running text |
| 48 | V387:2558 running text | IV114:2615 running text |
| 49 | V387:2559 running text | IV114:2616 running text |
| 50 | V387:2560 running text | IV114:2617 running text |
| 51 | V387:2561 running text | IV114:2618 running text |
| 52 | V387:2562 running text | IV114:2619 running text |
New Naqqali