Zal Admonishes Kay Khosrow
49 published couplets unchanged;9 notes.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 49 published couplets unchanged;9 notes. |
| Moscow | V389–391:2588–2635;48 main units;actual390n15 hand variant and390n32 blessing. |
| Mohl | IV115–117:2645–2693;49 main units;English block order supported. |
| Ganjoor | mahmood/sh32:1–48;48 main units;local gap forEnglish34 blessing. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | IV337–340:2607–2655;49 main units;hand gesture and blessing in main text. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6The welcome is already a lament
English 1–6;individual four-edition running-text loci below.
Moscow V389:2588 running text · Mohl IV115:2645 running text · Khaleghi IV337:2607 running text · Ganjoor sh32:1 running body · Moscow V389:2589 running text · Mohl IV115:2646 running text · Khaleghi IV338:2608 running text · Ganjoor sh32:2 running body · Moscow V389:2590 running text · Mohl IV115:2647 running text · Khaleghi IV338:2609 running text · Ganjoor sh32:3 running body · Moscow V389:2591 running text · Mohl IV115:2648 running text · Khaleghi IV338:2610 running text · Ganjoor sh32:4 running body · Moscow V389:2592 running text · Mohl IV115:2649 running text · Khaleghi IV338:2611 running text · Ganjoor sh32:5 running body · Moscow V389:2593 running text · Mohl IV115:2650 running text · Khaleghi IV338:2612 running text · Ganjoor sh32:6 running body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh place Zal and Rostam’s arrival at the week’s turn and immediately show Iran’s men hurrying to meet them in grief. The English preserves both movement and emotional setting. The men of Zarasp’s lineage prepare or urge their horses for the reception; ‘serve the hour’s needs’ supplies a motive rather than translating a separate duty. Golden footwear and Tus’s Kaveh banner are explicit in all four, although the banner’s waving and dancing is English animation. Gudarz’s tears are likewise shared evidence. ‘Great Rostam waited’ prepares the encounter, but the Persian’s direct action is Gudarz reaching Tahamtan. No edition supplies a distinct interval of waiting that should be added to the episode’s chronology.
7–12The courtiers mistake the king’s withdrawal
English 7–12;individual four-edition running-text loci below.
Moscow V389:2594 running text · Mohl IV115:2651 running text · Khaleghi IV338:2613 running text · Ganjoor sh32:7 running body · Moscow V389:2595 running text · Mohl IV115:2652 running text · Khaleghi IV338:2614 running text · Ganjoor sh32:8 running body · Moscow V389:2596 running text · Mohl IV115:2653 running text · Khaleghi IV338:2615 running text · Ganjoor sh32:9 running body · Moscow V389:2597 running text · Mohl IV115:2654 running text · Khaleghi IV338:2616 running text · Ganjoor sh32:10 running body · Moscow V389:2598 running text · Mohl IV115:2655 running text · Khaleghi IV338:2617 running text · Ganjoor sh32:11 running body · Moscow V389:2599 running text · Mohl IV116:2656 running text · Khaleghi IV338:2618 running text · Ganjoor sh32:12 running body
The accusation that Khosrow has lost his way through Iblis’s words belongs to the grieving courtiers in all four sources. It is not a correction of the preceding dream narrative by the narrator. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh describe the darkened audience hall and access from one week to the next. The English’s ‘only once a week’ makes that recurring pattern explicit, while ‘our hearts can scarcely speak’ adds an emotional response absent from the corresponding access verse. Its apparent conflict with ‘no man’ seeing the king is therefore rhetorical withdrawal followed by the stated exception, not a second chronology. The bent cypress and rose taking quince color are shared images of physical alteration. They convey distress without establishing a particular illness or a supernatural cause.
13–18Zal answers uncertainty with counsel
English 13–18;individual four-edition running-text loci below.
Moscow V389:2600 running text · Mohl IV116:2657 running text · Khaleghi IV338:2619 running text · Ganjoor sh32:13 running body · Moscow V389:2601 running text · Mohl IV116:2658 running text · Khaleghi IV338:2620 running text · Ganjoor sh32:14 running body · Moscow V389:2602 running text · Mohl IV116:2659 running text · Khaleghi IV338:2621 running text · Ganjoor sh32:15 running body · Moscow V389:2603 running text · Mohl IV116:2660 running text · Khaleghi IV338:2622 running text · Ganjoor sh32:16 running body · Moscow V389:2604 running text · Mohl IV116:2661 running text · Khaleghi IV338:2623 running text · Ganjoor sh32:17 running body · Moscow V390:2605 running text · Mohl IV116:2662 running text · Khaleghi IV338:2624 running text · Ganjoor sh32:18 running body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh all frame the evil eye, Iran’s darkened fortune and harm from the stars as possible explanations. The English keeps that uncertainty rather than announcing a verified enchantment. Zal answers with another possibility: weariness of the royal seat. His reminder that health, suffering, happiness and sorrow alternate makes consolation the immediate purpose of the speech. ‘Fortune’s wing’ is English imagery, not an additional celestial agent. All four end this exchange by proposing counsel and a favorable turn for the king. The English’s promise to make his fortune live renders the confidence of that remedy; it does not show that Zal already understands the revealed desire. The difference between the reader’s knowledge and the advisers’ interpretation remains central to the scene.
19–24A royal greeting in two textual forms
English 19–24;individual four-edition running-text loci below.
Moscow V390:2606 running text · Mohl IV116:2663 running text · Khaleghi IV338:2625 running text · Ganjoor sh32:19 running body · Moscow V390:2607 running text · Mohl IV116:2664 running text · Khaleghi IV338:2626 running text · Ganjoor sh32:20 running body · Moscow V390:2608 running text · Mohl IV116:2665 running text · Khaleghi IV338:2627 running text · Ganjoor sh32:21 running body · Moscow V390:2609 running text · Mohl IV116:2666 running text · Khaleghi IV338:2628 running text · Ganjoor sh32:22 running body · Moscow V390:2610 running text · Mohl IV116:2667 running text · Khaleghi IV338:2629 running text · Ganjoor sh32:23 running body · Moscow V390:2611 running text;actual390n15 inquiry/hand variant · Mohl IV116:2668 running text · Khaleghi IV339:2630 running text · Ganjoor sh32:24 running body
The four sources share the movement to the palace, the lifted curtain and the entry of the named chiefs. Moscow and Ganjoor say the king sees their faces; Mohl and Khaleghi-Motlagh specify Dastan’s face, supporting the English’s Zal. Rostam’s voice is recognized in every edition. The king’s response then diverges. Moscow and Ganjoor describe him rising and straightening his bent back. Mohl instead has him asking after the visitors while standing and displaying his hand; Khaleghi has the standing inquiry and a hand-touching expression. Moscow’s actual apparatus at V390, note 15, records the inquiry-and-hand branch. The English therefore follows supported alternative wording, although ‘held his hand out straight’ concretizes the gesture. It should not be treated as a mistranslation of a unanimously printed bent-back reading.
25–30Honor is distributed before advice begins
English 25–30;individual four-edition running-text loci below.
Moscow V390:2612 running text · Mohl IV116:2669 running text · Khaleghi IV339:2631 running text · Ganjoor sh32:25 running body · Moscow V390:2613 running text · Mohl IV116:2670 running text · Khaleghi IV339:2632 running text · Ganjoor sh32:26 running body · Moscow V390:2614 running text · Mohl IV116:2671 running text · Khaleghi IV339:2633 running text · Ganjoor sh32:27 running body · Moscow V390:2615 running text · Mohl IV116:2672 running text · Khaleghi IV339:2634 running text · Ganjoor sh32:28 running body · Moscow V390:2616 running text · Mohl IV116:2673 running text · Khaleghi IV339:2635 running text · Ganjoor sh32:29 running body · Moscow V390:2617 running text · Mohl IV116:2674 running text · Khaleghi IV339:2636 running text · Ganjoor sh32:30 running body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh name the learned visitors by their regional origins and then distribute places according to rank. Zabul and Kabul change positions within the line between witnesses, but the English retains both. The printed middle place-name also varies; its published ‘Danbar’ is preserved without certifying a modern geographical identification. The next movement gives Iran’s chiefs their places and begins Zal’s blessing. English 27 anticipates that speech from the following Persian unit, while 28 carries the blessing itself; the bow is English staging. Zal then measures the present king against a remembered royal succession. ‘Zav, Tahmasp’s son’ interprets the adjacent names genealogically; the local list itself does not spell out the relationship with a word for son. The verse comparison alone is therefore not offered as an independent genealogical proof.
31–35Praise with a separately transmitted blessing
English 31–35;individual four-edition running-text loci below.
Moscow V390:2618 running text · Mohl IV116:2675 running text · Khaleghi IV339:2637 running text · Ganjoor sh32:31 running body · Moscow V390:2619 running text · Mohl IV116:2676 running text · Khaleghi IV339:2638 running text · Ganjoor sh32:32 running body · Moscow V390:2620 running text · Mohl IV116:2677 running text · Khaleghi IV339:2639 running text · Ganjoor sh32:33 running body · Moscow V390n32 actual apparatus;checked local running-text gap after2620 · Mohl IV116:2678 running text · Khaleghi IV339:2640 running text · Ganjoor checked local gap between sh32:33 and34 · Moscow V391:2621 running text · Mohl IV116:2679 running text · Khaleghi IV339:2641 running text · Ganjoor sh32:34 running body
All four texts give Zal’s claim that Siavash was like a son to him and his judgment that Khosrow surpasses the kings he has known in wisdom, stature and divine farr. The English preserves the filial comparison rather than turning it into biological descent. Its next blessing, that Khosrow has filled the world with justice and may remain safe and victorious, stands in the running text of Mohl and Khaleghi-Motlagh. Ganjoor’s checked local sequence omits that couplet; Moscow prints it in the actual apparatus at V390, note 32. The English is thus supported by a fuller transmitted sequence. The final antidote image is present in all four: the king’s name is set against poison. ‘Nush-daru’ gives cultural specificity to the English, but the Persian word at this locus is taryak.
36–40Zal explains the urgency of his journey
English 36–40;individual four-edition running-text loci below.
Moscow V391:2622 running text · Mohl IV116:2680 running text · Khaleghi IV339:2642 running text · Ganjoor sh32:35 running body · Moscow V391:2626 running text · Mohl IV117:2681 running text · Khaleghi IV340:2646 running text · Ganjoor sh32:39 running body · Moscow V391:2627 running text · Mohl IV117:2682 running text · Khaleghi IV340:2647 running text · Ganjoor sh32:40 running body · Moscow V391:2628 running text · Mohl IV117:2683 running text · Khaleghi IV340:2648 running text · Ganjoor sh32:41 running body · Moscow V391:2629 running text · Mohl IV117:2684 running text · Khaleghi IV340:2649 running text · Ganjoor sh32:42 running body
All four editions report unwelcome news and Zal’s hurried response, followed by the account of the king’s order to keep the curtain drawn. They arrange the intervening material differently. Mohl places the messenger’s report and Zal’s eagle-and-ship journey before the astrologers’ gathering, as the English does. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh place the gathering and its celestial question before the messenger report. The register preserves those individual loci instead of assigning a false continuous range to the English order. ‘Brought men of my own’ anticipates the company described nearby. Eagle and ship are shared comparisons for speed, not two actual modes of transport. Zal’s purpose is to ask about what the king conceals; the English’s heart turning away interprets the concealed matter’s emotional significance.
41–45Astrological inquiry and three resources
English 41–45;individual four-edition running-text loci below.
Moscow V391:2623 running text · Mohl IV117:2685 running text · Khaleghi IV339:2643 running text · Ganjoor sh32:36 running body · Moscow V391:2624 running text · Mohl IV117:2686 running text · Khaleghi IV339:2644 running text · Ganjoor sh32:37 running body · Moscow V391:2625 running text · Mohl IV117:2687 running text · Khaleghi IV339:2645 running text · Ganjoor sh32:38 running body · Moscow V391:2630 running text · Mohl IV117:2688 running text · Khaleghi IV340:2650 running text · Ganjoor sh32:43 running body · Moscow V391:2631 running text · Mohl IV117:2689 running text · Khaleghi IV340:2651 running text · Ganjoor sh32:44 running body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh all identify astrologers and leading men, the regional gathering and Indian astronomical tables. The English’s ‘seeking heaven’s aim’ makes their inquiry intelligible without supplying a calculation or a named technical tradition beyond the text. Their question about heaven withdrawing affection from Iran remains the delegation’s diagnosis, not an established account of divine hostility. The next verses set out three resources: treasure, exertion and capable men. ‘Labor’ properly carries the exertion term without limiting it to hired workers. Moscow and Ganjoor say work cannot be done without these resources; Mohl and Khaleghi use a formulation involving honor and battle. The English’s ‘no fame or light’ follows the latter emphasis loosely, while adding light as its own image of viable rule.
46–49A fourth requirement and a prayer for repair
English 46–49;individual four-edition running-text loci below.
Moscow V391:2632 running text · Mohl IV117:2690 running text · Khaleghi IV340:2652 running text · Ganjoor sh32:45 running body · Moscow V391:2633 running text · Mohl IV117:2691 running text · Khaleghi IV340:2653 running text · Ganjoor sh32:46 running body · Moscow V391:2634 running text · Mohl IV117:2692 running text · Khaleghi IV340:2654 running text · Ganjoor sh32:47 running body · Moscow V391:2635 running text · Mohl IV117:2693 running text · Khaleghi IV340:2655 running text · Ganjoor sh32:48 running body
The enumeration deliberately adds a fourth requirement after the three practical resources: praise and prayer to Yazdan, day and night. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh all preserve that turn, so the English has not introduced an accidental counting error. Divine assistance is followed by gifts to the poor and a wish for restored luminosity and protective wisdom. Mohl and Khaleghi’s restraining of a harmful or biting agent supports the English’s threatening oppressor; Moscow and Ganjoor print a different participle at that point, which should not be silently equated with it. ‘Although we know’ supplies a reflective link to the admitted value of wealth. The closing armor-for-the-mind metaphor is shared across all four sources. It remains Zal’s prayer for repair, not confirmation that the king’s revelation was defective.
Source record and limits
49 English couplets; 9 notes. Moscow V389–391:2588–2635 has48 running units plus actualV390n32 blessing; Mohl IV115–117:2645–2693 has49 running units; Ganjoor mahmood/sh32:1–48 has48 running units; Khaleghi IV337–340:2607–2655 has49 running units. All main units counted once; English36–43 rearranges the blocks relative to Moscow/Ganjoor/Khaleghi, following Mohl.
Actual Moscow V390n15 inquiry/hand variant and V390n32 blessing were inspected. English34 has Moscow apparatus evidence, not Moscow main-text coverage. Ganjoor has a checked local gap after32:33 for this blessing. Mohl and Khaleghi print it in the running text. No appendix evidence used; no unprinted addition notice counted. No source-only units. All other English units have individually accounted running-text counterparts in every edition; block order differs.
Published English unchanged. English24 inquiry/hand gesture supported by Mohl/Khaleghi and actualMoscow390n15, against Moscow/Ganjoor main bent-back wording. English34 blessing supported by Mohl/Khaleghi main and actualMoscow390n32; Ganjoor checked local gap. English35 nush-daru specifies Persian taryak. Danbar modern identification and Zav/Tahmasp genealogy are not independently verified by this local collation. English47 follows harmful-agent branch in Mohl/Khaleghi. Clinical diagnosis, literal eagle/ship transport and narratorial endorsement of Iblis/astrology are not certified. Every inherited flag preserved, especially C4.21.20 unverified marble.
The Persian reference follows Ganjoor exceptEnglish34, which uses individually checked Mohl running text. Individual running texts and actual apparatus remain distinct. Moscow and Mohl were inspected individually first,then Ganjoor and Khaleghi. Printed-page to one-based PDF offsets are Moscow0,Mohl6,Khaleghi16.
Mohl IV116:2668 main;English24: بپرسید بر پای و بنمود دست
Khaleghi IV339:2630 main;English24: بپرسید بر پای و بسود دست
Ganjoor32:24 main;English24: چنان پشت خمیده را کرد راست
Moscow V390n15 actual apparatus;English24: بپرسید بر پای و بنمود دست
Mohl IV116:2678 main;English34: بگشتی همه روی گیتی بداد / بیآز آمدن باش پیروز و شاد
Moscow V390n32 actual apparatus;English34: بگشتی همه روی گیتی بداد / بیآز آمدن باش پیروز و شاد
Ganjoor32:34 main;English35: چه زهر آنکه نام تو تریاک نیست
Ganjoor32:46 main;English47: هم او بازدارد گراینده را
Khaleghi IV340:2653 main;English47: همو بازدارد گزاینده را
C4.51 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | V389:2588 running text | IV115:2645 running text |
| 2 | V389:2589 running text | IV115:2646 running text |
| 3 | V389:2590 running text | IV115:2647 running text |
| 4 | V389:2591 running text | IV115:2648 running text |
| 5 | V389:2592 running text | IV115:2649 running text |
| 6 | V389:2593 running text | IV115:2650 running text |
| 7 | V389:2594 running text | IV115:2651 running text |
| 8 | V389:2595 running text | IV115:2652 running text |
| 9 | V389:2596 running text | IV115:2653 running text |
| 10 | V389:2597 running text | IV115:2654 running text |
| 11 | V389:2598 running text | IV115:2655 running text |
| 12 | V389:2599 running text | IV116:2656 running text |
| 13 | V389:2600 running text | IV116:2657 running text |
| 14 | V389:2601 running text | IV116:2658 running text |
| 15 | V389:2602 running text | IV116:2659 running text |
| 16 | V389:2603 running text | IV116:2660 running text |
| 17 | V389:2604 running text | IV116:2661 running text |
| 18 | V390:2605 running text | IV116:2662 running text |
| 19 | V390:2606 running text | IV116:2663 running text |
| 20 | V390:2607 running text | IV116:2664 running text |
| 21 | V390:2608 running text | IV116:2665 running text |
| 22 | V390:2609 running text | IV116:2666 running text |
| 23 | V390:2610 running text | IV116:2667 running text |
| 24 | V390:2611 running text;actual390n15 inquiry/hand variant | IV116:2668 running text |
| 25 | V390:2612 running text | IV116:2669 running text |
| 26 | V390:2613 running text | IV116:2670 running text |
| 27 | V390:2614 running text | IV116:2671 running text |
| 28 | V390:2615 running text | IV116:2672 running text |
| 29 | V390:2616 running text | IV116:2673 running text |
| 30 | V390:2617 running text | IV116:2674 running text |
| 31 | V390:2618 running text | IV116:2675 running text |
| 32 | V390:2619 running text | IV116:2676 running text |
| 33 | V390:2620 running text | IV116:2677 running text |
| 34 | V390n32 actual apparatus;checked local running-text gap after2620 | IV116:2678 running text |
| 35 | V391:2621 running text | IV116:2679 running text |
| 36 | V391:2622 running text | IV116:2680 running text |
| 37 | V391:2626 running text | IV117:2681 running text |
| 38 | V391:2627 running text | IV117:2682 running text |
| 39 | V391:2628 running text | IV117:2683 running text |
| 40 | V391:2629 running text | IV117:2684 running text |
| 41 | V391:2623 running text | IV117:2685 running text |
| 42 | V391:2624 running text | IV117:2686 running text |
| 43 | V391:2625 running text | IV117:2687 running text |
| 44 | V391:2630 running text | IV117:2688 running text |
| 45 | V391:2631 running text | IV117:2689 running text |
| 46 | V391:2632 running text | IV117:2690 running text |
| 47 | V391:2633 running text | IV117:2691 running text |
| 48 | V391:2634 running text | IV117:2692 running text |
| 49 | V391:2635 running text | IV117:2693 running text |
New Naqqali