Khosrow’s Answer and Zal’s Apology
52 published couplets unchanged;9 notes.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 52 published couplets unchanged;9 notes. |
| Moscow | V395–398:2701–2749;49 main units plus three actually printed at V397n35. |
| Mohl | IV120–122:2762–2813;52 main units. |
| Ganjoor | mahmood/sh35:1–39 and sh36:1–10;49 main units;checked gap for English46–48. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | IV344–348:2721–2772;52 main units. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6Restraint and the debt to Rostam
English 1–6;individual four-edition running-text loci below.
Moscow V395:2701 running text · Mohl IV120:2762 running text · Khaleghi IV344:2721 running text · Ganjoor sh35:1 running body · Moscow V395:2702 running text · Mohl IV120:2763 running text · Khaleghi IV344:2722 running text · Ganjoor sh35:2 running body · Moscow V395:2703 running text · Mohl IV120:2764 running text · Khaleghi IV344:2723 running text · Ganjoor sh35:3 running body · Moscow V395:2704 running text · Mohl IV120:2765 running text · Khaleghi IV345:2724 running text · Ganjoor sh35:4 running body · Moscow V395:2705 running text · Mohl IV120:2766 running text · Khaleghi IV345:2725 running text · Ganjoor sh35:5 running body · Moscow V395:2706 running text · Mohl IV120:2767 running text · Khaleghi IV345:2726 running text · Ganjoor sh35:6 running body
Khosrow answers public criticism by recognizing obligations that limit royal anger. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all make harsh speech offensive to the divine ruler and damaging to Rostam, whose distress would injure Iran. The English opening makes the inward pause into an explicit checking of wrath; the Persian describes resting and reflecting without naming wrath at that point. This is a plausible dramatic interpretation, not an additional action independently stated by every witness. The treasury comparison gives gratitude a public scale: service exceeds payment. English makes that judgment absolute through the inability of any treasure to repay him, while the source comparison says the toil exceeds the treasure. The bodily shield and the enemy’s lost sleep and food retain the concrete cost beneath this royal courtesy.
7–12A public denial and an inward vision
English 7–12;individual four-edition running-text loci below.
Moscow V395:2707 running text · Mohl IV120:2768 running text · Khaleghi IV345:2727 running text · Ganjoor sh35:7 running body · Moscow V395:2708 running text · Mohl IV120:2769 running text · Khaleghi IV345:2728 running text · Ganjoor sh35:8 running body · Moscow V395:2709 running text · Mohl IV120:2770 running text · Khaleghi IV345:2729 running text · Ganjoor sh35:9 running body · Moscow V395:2710 running text · Mohl IV121:2771 running text · Khaleghi IV345:2730 running text · Ganjoor sh35:10 running body · Moscow V396:2711 running text · Mohl IV121:2772 running text · Khaleghi IV345:2731 running text · Ganjoor sh35:11 running body · Moscow V396:2712 running text · Mohl IV121:2773 running text · Khaleghi IV345:2732 running text · Ganjoor sh35:12 running body
All four sources support the sequence of a considerate answer to Zal followed by a forceful address to the chiefs. English compresses the Persian loud or strong voice into speaking aloud and transfers the oath’s opening into the preceding couplet. The register retains one source unit per English couplet while this shared boundary is noted, rather than counting the oath twice. The flock image in the account of Zal’s speech disappears from the English, which presents a less figurative assembly. The denial of obedience to the div remains Khosrow’s declaration, followed by his claim to have seen the other world. Wisdom as a shield preserves the protective force of the Persian armor image. None of these statements should be promoted into a separate narrator’s certification of the vision.
13–18Descent as an answer to accusation
English 13–18;individual four-edition running-text loci below.
Moscow V396:2713 running text · Mohl IV121:2774 running text · Khaleghi IV345:2733 running text · Ganjoor sh35:13 running body · Moscow V396:2714 running text · Mohl IV121:2775 running text · Khaleghi IV345:2734 running text · Ganjoor sh35:14 running body · Moscow V396:2715 running text · Mohl IV121:2776 running text · Khaleghi IV345:2735 running text · Ganjoor sh35:15 running body · Moscow V396:2716 running text · Mohl IV121:2777 running text · Khaleghi IV345:2736 running text · Ganjoor sh35:16 running body · Moscow V396:2717 running text · Mohl IV121:2778 running text · Khaleghi IV345:2737 running text · Ganjoor sh35:17 running body · Moscow V396:2718 running text · Mohl IV121:2779 running text · Khaleghi IV346:2738 running text · Ganjoor sh35:18 running body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all preserve Khosrow’s ordered rebuttal of the attack on his Turanian ancestry. His response joins paternal and maternal descent instead of repudiating Afrasiab’s blood. English captures this double inheritance clearly through the separate father’s father and mother clauses. Its crown won supplies an achievement beyond the Persian identification as a Kayanian descendant; its instruction to let pride subside interprets the demand to stop speaking sharply and keep speech within measure. The intimidating ancestor is praised for power without withdrawing the moral case against his deeds. Fereydoon and Pashang function as the named ancestral credentials in the checked passage. This local comparison confirms those names and the lack of shame, without independently reconstructing the entire genealogy or resolving every historical kinship implied by the speech.
19–24Ambition defended and vengeance completed
English 19–24;individual four-edition running-text loci below.
Moscow V396:2719 running text · Mohl IV121:2780 running text · Khaleghi IV346:2739 running text · Ganjoor sh35:19 running body · Moscow V396:2720 running text · Mohl IV121:2781 running text · Khaleghi IV346:2740 running text · Ganjoor sh35:20 running body · Moscow V396:2721 running text · Mohl IV121:2782 running text · Khaleghi IV346:2741 running text · Ganjoor sh35:21 running body · Moscow V396:2722 running text · Mohl IV121:2783 running text · Khaleghi IV346:2742 running text · Ganjoor sh35:22 running body · Moscow V396:2723 running text · Mohl IV121:2784 running text · Khaleghi IV346:2743 running text · Ganjoor sh35:23 running body · Moscow V396:2724 running text · Mohl IV121:2785 running text · Khaleghi IV346:2744 running text · Ganjoor sh35:24 running body
The fear of Afrasiab is expressed in all four presentations through Iranian lions who dare not wash themselves in the sea. English retains this extraordinary scale rather than reducing it to an ordinary fear of battle. The chest made by Kavus likewise has direct support, though rising above clouds and mortal kind elaborates the source’s royal elevation and the already established flying episode. Khosrow’s defense concerns ambitious aspiration; it does not erase his later fear of repeating Kavus’s failure. Moscow and Ganjoor describe adorning the world through victory, whereas Mohl and Khaleghi use setting it right in the corresponding unit. English justice and reviving breath develop the restorative sense. Its crowned oppressor narrows the more general bad-stock survivors whose disappearance explains why the king believes his worldly task is finished.
25–30The danger of prolonged kingship
English 25–30;individual four-edition running-text loci below.
Moscow V396:2725 running text · Mohl IV121:2786 running text · Khaleghi IV346:2745 running text · Ganjoor sh35:25 running body · Moscow V396:2726 running text · Mohl IV121:2787 running text · Khaleghi IV346:2746 running text · Ganjoor sh35:26 running body · Moscow V396:2727 running text · Mohl IV121:2788 running text · Khaleghi IV346:2747 running text · Ganjoor sh35:27 running body · Moscow V396:2728 running text · Mohl IV121:2789 running text · Khaleghi IV346:2748 running text · Ganjoor sh35:28 running body · Moscow V396:2729 running text · Mohl IV121:2790 running text · Khaleghi IV346:2749 running text · Ganjoor sh35:29 running body · Moscow V397:2730 running text · Mohl IV121:2791 running text · Khaleghi IV346:2750 running text · Ganjoor sh35:30 running body
All four editions connect prolonged reflection on prosperity and lasting rule with the examples of Kavus, Jamshid, Zahhak and Tur. The warning is prospective and self-directed: Khosrow fears becoming like failed rulers, rather than reporting that he has already forfeited legitimacy. English supplies farr in the Jamshid comparison, where the immediate Persian wording concerns losing rank or standing. That interpretive connection belongs in the note rather than being certified as the same noun in every source. The movement toward Hell is likewise a feared consequence of time and corruption, not a new event in the narrative. The subsequent leopard comparison and the claim that no Iranian horseman could face Shideh are shared. English makes the rationale protective of Iran, while retaining the king’s unusually strong judgment of the other warriors’ inability.
31–36Divine support and the packed baggage
English 31–36;individual four-edition running-text loci below.
Moscow V397:2731 running text · Mohl IV121:2792 running text · Khaleghi IV346:2751 running text · Ganjoor sh35:31 running body · Moscow V397:2732 running text · Mohl IV121:2793 running text · Khaleghi IV346:2752 running text · Ganjoor sh35:32 running body · Moscow V397:2733 running text · Mohl IV121:2794 running text · Khaleghi IV346:2753 running text · Ganjoor sh35:33 running body · Moscow V397:2734 running text · Mohl IV121:2795 running text · Khaleghi IV347:2754 running text · Ganjoor sh35:34 running body · Moscow V397:2735 running text · Mohl IV122:2796 running text · Khaleghi IV347:2755 running text · Ganjoor sh35:35 running body · Moscow V397:2736 running text · Mohl IV122:2797 running text · Khaleghi IV347:2756 running text · Ganjoor sh35:36 running body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all condition survival in combat on divine farr and a favorable star. English keeps both terms and carries the conditional syntax across three couplets, so being reduced to dust describes the unsupported combatant, not Khosrow’s actual fate. Pashang is printed in the battle unit in all four sources; its presence here is not an unsupported replacement introduced by English. The five weeks of prayer are also explicit in each running text. English prayer until dawn gives a nocturnal shape to the Persian day and night, slightly reducing that stated temporal span. Being weary of army, crown and throne and packing the baggage are shared concrete declarations. Their perfect or completed English phrasing conveys readiness, but the king has not yet departed within this chapter.
37–42Who is threatened by divine punishment?
English 37–42;individual four-edition running-text loci below.
Moscow V397:2737 running text · Mohl IV122:2798 running text · Khaleghi IV347:2757 running text · Ganjoor sh35:37 running body · Moscow V397:2738 running text · Mohl IV122:2799 running text · Khaleghi IV347:2758 running text · Ganjoor sh35:38 running body · Moscow V397:2739 running text;actual V397n21 second-person alternative · Mohl IV122:2800 running text · Khaleghi IV347:2759 running text · Ganjoor sh35:39 running body · Moscow V397:2740 running text · Mohl IV122:2801 running text · Khaleghi IV347:2760 running text · Ganjoor sh36:1 running body · Moscow V397:2741 running text · Mohl IV122:2802 running text · Khaleghi IV347:2761 running text · Ganjoor sh36:2 running body · Moscow V397:2742 running text · Mohl IV122:2803 running text · Khaleghi IV347:2762 running text · Ganjoor sh36:3 running body
The editions diverge materially at the end of the rebuke. Mohl and Khaleghi address the place where Zal will encounter divine punishment; Moscow’s main text uses a first-person plural form, and Ganjoor a first-person singular. Moscow’s printed local apparatus also records the second-person alternative. English follows the addressed warning and consequently gives Zal’s bewilderment a pointed immediate cause. That reading must not be described as unanimous running text. His inability to meet the king’s eyes interprets the darkening of sight or face in the response. English then calls the king a complete worshipper, supported by Mohl and Khaleghi, whereas Moscow and Ganjoor give a judge of justice and right. Across the four sources Zal acknowledges his own rashness and recognizes Khosrow’s wisdom; the dispute changes direction without requiring a narrator’s diagnosis of possession.
43–48The fuller apology and its placement
English 43–48;individual four-edition running-text loci below.
Moscow V397:2743 running text · Mohl IV122:2804 running text · Khaleghi IV347:2763 running text · Ganjoor sh36:4 running body · Moscow V397:2744 running text · Mohl IV122:2805 running text · Khaleghi IV347:2764 running text · Ganjoor sh36:5 running body · Moscow V397:2745 running text · Mohl IV122:2806 running text · Khaleghi IV347:2765 running text · Ganjoor sh36:6 running body · Moscow V397n35 actual printed apparatus, addition unit 1;checked running-text gap after2745 · Mohl IV122:2807 running text · Khaleghi IV347:2766 running text · Ganjoor checked local gap between sh36:6 and7 · Moscow V397n35 actual printed apparatus, addition unit 2;checked running-text gap after2745 · Mohl IV122:2808 running text · Khaleghi IV347:2767 running text · Ganjoor checked local gap between sh36:6 and7 · Moscow V397n35 actual printed apparatus, addition unit 3;checked running-text gap after2745 · Mohl IV122:2809 running text · Khaleghi IV348:2768 running text · Ganjoor checked local gap between sh36:6 and7
Mohl prints the whole passage continuously. Moscow prints the teaching, unwillingness to separate, and favorable comparison of royal deeds in an actual three-couplet footnote after the statement about earlier kings; these are apparatus evidence, not Moscow running text. Khaleghi prints them in the main sequence, while Ganjoor has a checked local gap between its sixth and seventh apology couplets. The English therefore has positive support for this fuller reconciliation. Its reference to long service in the forgiveness couplet anticipates the belt-of-service image in the next unit. In the fuller passage the king becomes a teacher and wisdom witnesses grief at separation. English makes the comparison between deeds and suffering more explicit through outweighing. The witnesses differ in the precise treasure or toil wording, so support for the passage should not be confused with complete lexical identity.
49–52Affection disclosed through reconciliation
English 49–52;individual four-edition running-text loci below.
Moscow V398:2746 running text · Mohl IV122:2810 running text · Khaleghi IV348:2769 running text · Ganjoor sh36:7 running body · Moscow V398:2747 running text · Mohl IV122:2811 running text · Khaleghi IV348:2770 running text · Ganjoor sh36:8 running body · Moscow V398:2748 running text · Mohl IV122:2812 running text · Khaleghi IV348:2771 running text · Ganjoor sh36:9 running body · Moscow V398:2749 running text · Mohl IV122:2813 running text · Khaleghi IV348:2772 running text · Ganjoor sh36:10 running body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all finish this episode with unwilling separation, acceptance of the apology, the taking of Zal’s hand, and recognition that affection prompted his words. English moves smoothly from shared sorrow to personal reconciliation. Its hope of every heart enlarges the description of a just king with good character, while setting the king’s heart at rest interprets the stated acceptance of a well-wisher’s apology. The physical gesture preserves the sources’ particularly concrete resolution: the elder is drawn into the king’s own seating space. The sun-faced epithet also belongs to the Persian ending. Unlike Khosrow’s earlier report of his own vision, the final recognition of Zal’s loving intention is narrated directly. The subsequent instruction to prepare for departure begins the next chapter and is excluded from this collation.
Source record and limits
52 English couplets and 9 notes. Moscow V395–398:2701–2749 has 49 running units plus three actually printed at V397n35. Mohl IV120–122:2762–2813 has 52 running units. Ganjoor mahmood/sh35:1–39 and sh36:1–10 has 49. Khaleghi IV344–348:2721–2772 has 52. Every declared running unit is allocated once; no source-only unit remains.
Actual Moscow V397n35 prints three added couplets corresponding to English46–48 after main2745; these remain apparatus evidence. Its third couplet has treasure/toil wording rather than a claim of complete lexical identity with Mohl and Khaleghi. Ganjoor sh36:6→7 is a checked local gap for these three units. Actual Moscow397n21 supplies یابی as an alternative to main یابیم at2739. Moscow397n30 supplies worshipper alternative to main judge at2741. Khaleghi local apparatus inspected separately; no unprinted addition notice used as verification. No appendix evidence invoked and no volume-wide appendix absence claimed.
English preserved verbatim. English39 follows Mohl/Khaleghi second-person warning; Moscow main first-person plural and Ganjoor singular differ. Actual Moscow397n21 records the second-person alternative. English41 worshipper follows Mohl/Khaleghi against Moscow/Ganjoor judge. English46–48 have Mohl/Khaleghi main and actual Moscow apparatus support, but a Ganjoor local gap. English26 farr interprets loss of standing;34 dawn narrows day/night prayer; no actual departure, loss of farr or narrator-certified vision asserted. All inherited flags retained, especially C4.21.20 unverified marble.
The Persian reference follows Ganjoor except English46–48, which uses individually checked Mohl running text. Individual running texts and actual apparatus remain distinct. Moscow and Mohl were inspected individually first,then Ganjoor and Khaleghi. Printed-page to one-based PDF offsets are Moscow0,Mohl6,Khaleghi16.
Moscow V397:2739 running text;English39: کجا یابیم و روزگار بدی
Moscow V397n21 actual apparatus;English39: یابی
Mohl IV122:2800 running text;English39: کجا یابی و روزگار بدی
Khaleghi IV347:2759 running text;English39: کجا یابی و روزگار بدی
Ganjoor sh35:39 running text;English39: کجا یابم و روزگار بدی
Mohl IV122:2802 running text;English41: چنین گفت کای شاه یزدان پرست
Moscow V397n35 actual apparatus;English46: کنون گشت کیخسرو آموزگار
Moscow V397n35 actual apparatus;English48: فزونست ازان گنج و کردار شاه
Khaleghi IV347:2766 running text;English46: کنون گشت کیخسرو آموزگار
C4.54 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | V395:2701 running text | IV120:2762 running text |
| 2 | V395:2702 running text | IV120:2763 running text |
| 3 | V395:2703 running text | IV120:2764 running text |
| 4 | V395:2704 running text | IV120:2765 running text |
| 5 | V395:2705 running text | IV120:2766 running text |
| 6 | V395:2706 running text | IV120:2767 running text |
| 7 | V395:2707 running text | IV120:2768 running text |
| 8 | V395:2708 running text | IV120:2769 running text |
| 9 | V395:2709 running text | IV120:2770 running text |
| 10 | V395:2710 running text | IV121:2771 running text |
| 11 | V396:2711 running text | IV121:2772 running text |
| 12 | V396:2712 running text | IV121:2773 running text |
| 13 | V396:2713 running text | IV121:2774 running text |
| 14 | V396:2714 running text | IV121:2775 running text |
| 15 | V396:2715 running text | IV121:2776 running text |
| 16 | V396:2716 running text | IV121:2777 running text |
| 17 | V396:2717 running text | IV121:2778 running text |
| 18 | V396:2718 running text | IV121:2779 running text |
| 19 | V396:2719 running text | IV121:2780 running text |
| 20 | V396:2720 running text | IV121:2781 running text |
| 21 | V396:2721 running text | IV121:2782 running text |
| 22 | V396:2722 running text | IV121:2783 running text |
| 23 | V396:2723 running text | IV121:2784 running text |
| 24 | V396:2724 running text | IV121:2785 running text |
| 25 | V396:2725 running text | IV121:2786 running text |
| 26 | V396:2726 running text | IV121:2787 running text |
| 27 | V396:2727 running text | IV121:2788 running text |
| 28 | V396:2728 running text | IV121:2789 running text |
| 29 | V396:2729 running text | IV121:2790 running text |
| 30 | V397:2730 running text | IV121:2791 running text |
| 31 | V397:2731 running text | IV121:2792 running text |
| 32 | V397:2732 running text | IV121:2793 running text |
| 33 | V397:2733 running text | IV121:2794 running text |
| 34 | V397:2734 running text | IV121:2795 running text |
| 35 | V397:2735 running text | IV122:2796 running text |
| 36 | V397:2736 running text | IV122:2797 running text |
| 37 | V397:2737 running text | IV122:2798 running text |
| 38 | V397:2738 running text | IV122:2799 running text |
| 39 | V397:2739 running text;actual V397n21 second-person alternative | IV122:2800 running text |
| 40 | V397:2740 running text | IV122:2801 running text |
| 41 | V397:2741 running text | IV122:2802 running text |
| 42 | V397:2742 running text | IV122:2803 running text |
| 43 | V397:2743 running text | IV122:2804 running text |
| 44 | V397:2744 running text | IV122:2805 running text |
| 45 | V397:2745 running text | IV122:2806 running text |
| 46 | V397n35 actual printed apparatus, addition unit 1;checked running-text gap after2745 | IV122:2807 running text |
| 47 | V397n35 actual printed apparatus, addition unit 2;checked running-text gap after2745 | IV122:2808 running text |
| 48 | V397n35 actual printed apparatus, addition unit 3;checked running-text gap after2745 | IV122:2809 running text |
| 49 | V398:2746 running text | IV122:2810 running text |
| 50 | V398:2747 running text | IV122:2811 running text |
| 51 | V398:2748 running text | IV122:2812 running text |
| 52 | V398:2749 running text | IV122:2813 running text |
New Naqqali