Giv Receives Khosrow’s Patent
20 published couplets unchanged; 4 notes.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 20 published couplets unchanged; 4 notes. |
| Moscow | V404–405:2855–2874; 20 running units. |
| Mohl | IV127–128:2925–2944; 20 running units. |
| Ganjoor | mahmood/sh41:1–20; 20 running units. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | IV355–356:2879–2898; 20 running units. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5A lifetime of service and a diminished household
English 1–5;individual four-edition running-text loci below.
Moscow V404:2855 running text · Mohl IV127:2925 running text · Khaleghi IV355:2879 running text · Ganjoor sh41:1 running body · Moscow V404:2856 running text · Mohl IV127:2926 running text · Khaleghi IV355:2880 running text · Ganjoor sh41:2 running body · Moscow V404:2857 running text · Mohl IV127:2927 running text · Khaleghi IV356:2881 running text · Ganjoor sh41:3 running body · Moscow V404:2858 running text · Mohl IV127:2928 running text · Khaleghi IV356:2882 running text · Ganjoor sh41:4 running body · Moscow V404:2859 running text · Mohl IV127:2929 running text · Khaleghi IV356:2883 running text · Ganjoor sh41:5 running body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all place Gudarz’s petition after Zal’s reward and give the same decisive reckoning: seventy-eight sons and grandsons, with eight remaining. The English therefore preserves the scale of bereavement rather than supplying a new family census. Its movement from royal praise to personal loss makes that arithmetic the petition’s moral pressure. The earlier rulers mark the speaker’s remembered continuity of service; they need not be converted into a historical lifespan calculation. English ease and respite fit Khaleghi’s explicit lack of rest, while Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor describe service without freedom from suffering. The English turns that bodily burden into sustained labor. World-wise also catches the opening description of an experienced man, establishing why his truthful speech carries weight before he asks anything for Giv.
6–10Giv’s hardship becomes a claim upon the king
English 6–10;individual four-edition running-text loci below.
Moscow V404:2860 running text · Mohl IV127:2930 running text · Khaleghi IV356:2884 running text · Ganjoor sh41:6 running body · Moscow V404:2861 running text · Mohl IV127:2931 running text · Khaleghi IV356:2885 running text · Ganjoor sh41:7 running body · Moscow V404:2862 running text · Mohl IV127:2932 running text · Khaleghi IV356:2886 running text · Ganjoor sh41:8 running body · Moscow V404:2863 running text · Mohl IV127:2933 running text · Khaleghi IV356:2887 running text · Ganjoor sh41:9 running body · Moscow V404:2864 running text · Mohl IV128:2934 running text · Khaleghi IV356:2888 running text · Ganjoor sh41:10 running body
All four sources give Giv seven years in Turan, want of sustenance, wild-ass meat and a garment of hunted animal skin. The English keeps the specific food through Gur-e-Khar while broadening the garment into skins and making protection against the air explicit. The sources identify clothing, not a particular season or weather condition. Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor describe the king seeing the care Giv had borne for him; Khaleghi emphasizes hardships endured on the road. English firsthand makes the king a witness to that service without attempting to reconstruct the earlier journey. The petition then links royal withdrawal with Giv’s expectation of kindness. The agricultural suggestion in kindness he has sown frames reward as the fruit of service. Khosrow’s reply, shared across all four texts, exceeds the petitioner’s account and confirms his obligation.
11–15From a blessing to a written grant
English 11–15;individual four-edition running-text loci below.
Moscow V404:2865 running text · Mohl IV128:2935 running text · Khaleghi IV356:2889 running text · Ganjoor sh41:11 running body · Moscow V404:2866 running text · Mohl IV128:2936 running text · Khaleghi IV356:2890 running text · Ganjoor sh41:12 running body · Moscow V404:2867 running text · Mohl IV128:2937 running text · Khaleghi IV356:2891 running text · Ganjoor sh41:13 running body · Moscow V404:2868 running text · Mohl IV128:2938 running text · Khaleghi IV356:2892 running text · Ganjoor sh41:14 running body · Moscow V404:2869 running text · Mohl IV128:2939 running text · Khaleghi IV356:2893 running text · Ganjoor sh41:15 running body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all join the blessing for Giv with thorns in his enemies’ hearts, then move from comprehensive generosity to the named grant of Qom and Isfahan. English pain and fear interpret the hostile-heart image rather than add a separate punishment. All of my wealth renders the inclusive little-and-much formula as royal bounty; the following named territories give that promise a concrete form. Each source also supplies musk, ambergris, silk and a golden seal, so the English preserves the deed’s sensory richness and ceremonial authority. Unlaced and the court’s full sight are scenic elaborations, not independently specified documentary procedures. Patent is an intelligible English name for the royal grant here, without establishing a modern legal category. The cited verse supplies literary materials, not an authenticated ink recipe or surviving charter.
16–20Giv as a living charge and Gudarz’s family response
English 16–20;individual four-edition running-text loci below.
Moscow V404:2870 running text · Mohl IV128:2940 running text · Khaleghi IV356:2894 running text · Ganjoor sh41:16 running body · Moscow V404:2871 running text · Mohl IV128:2941 running text · Khaleghi IV356:2895 running text · Ganjoor sh41:17 running body · Moscow V405:2872 running text · Mohl IV128:2942 running text · Khaleghi IV356:2896 running text · Ganjoor sh41:18 running body · Moscow V405:2873 running text · Mohl IV128:2943 running text · Khaleghi IV356:2897 running text · Ganjoor sh41:19 running body · Moscow V405:2874 running text · Mohl IV128:2944 running text · Khaleghi IV356:2898 running text · Ganjoor sh41:20 running body
The blessing explicitly names Gudarz in all four editions, although the petition and command concern Giv. The English preserves that alternation: the father’s service and the son’s protection belong to one household claim. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi call Giv the king’s remembrance and entrusted charge; Mohl likewise makes him the king’s remembrance but changes the accompanying designation. Living memory aptly personalizes the common first image. All four command obedience to Giv and forbid passing beyond Gudarz’s word. English bow to his royal grant shifts the first command toward the document just issued, then restores personal authority through father and son. In the closing couplet Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi specifically name Gudarz’s people, whereas Mohl names leading warriors more generally. The English family response thus follows the former reading, not an unsupported narrowing of Mohl alone.
Source record and limits
20 English couplets and 4 notes. Moscow V404–405:2855–2874; Mohl IV127–128:2925–2944; Ganjoor mahmood/sh41:1–20; Khaleghi IV355–356:2879–2898. Each contains 20 running units, each allocated once. No source-only unit or checked running-text gap within this chapter.
All positive source claims in this chapter use inspected running text. Local printed apparatus on Moscow V404–405 and Khaleghi IV355–356 was inspected; no apparatus addition is needed to account for these 20 English units. No appendix evidence used. No checked gap within the chapter and no unverified new reading used as support. Adjacent opening of Tus’s petition excluded.
Published English preserved verbatim. Rest at4 most directly matches Khaleghi; family response at20 follows Moscow/Ganjoor/Khaleghi against Mohl’s more general leaders. English19 shifts obedience toward the grant before naming personal authority. Air at7, sown at9, unlaced at14 and full court sight at15 are interpretive or scenic elaborations. No historical lifespan, exact legal category, ink recipe or surviving charter certified. All inherited flags retained, including C4.21.20 marble and the unresolved word after Ravar at C4.57.28.
The Persian reference follows Ganjoor throughout. Moscow and Mohl were inspected individually first, then Ganjoor and Khaleghi. All positive readings cited here are running text. Printed-page to one-based PDF offsets are Moscow 0, Mohl 6, Khaleghi 16.
Khaleghi IV356:2882 running text;English4: به آرام یک روز ننشستهام
Moscow V404:2859 running text;English5: نبیره پسر بود هفتاد و هشت
Ganjoor sh41:7 running body;English7: به دشت اندرون گور بد خوردنش
Mohl IV128:2938 running text;English14: یکی نامه از پادشاه بر حریر
Ganjoor sh41:18 running body;English18: به نزد شما زینهار من است
Mohl IV128:2944 running text;English20: ز گردنکشان هرکه بد پیشرو
Khaleghi IV356:2898 running text;English20: ز گودرزیان هرکه بد پیشرو
C4.58 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | V404:2855 running text | IV127:2925 running text |
| 2 | V404:2856 running text | IV127:2926 running text |
| 3 | V404:2857 running text | IV127:2927 running text |
| 4 | V404:2858 running text | IV127:2928 running text |
| 5 | V404:2859 running text | IV127:2929 running text |
| 6 | V404:2860 running text | IV127:2930 running text |
| 7 | V404:2861 running text | IV127:2931 running text |
| 8 | V404:2862 running text | IV127:2932 running text |
| 9 | V404:2863 running text | IV127:2933 running text |
| 10 | V404:2864 running text | IV128:2934 running text |
| 11 | V404:2865 running text | IV128:2935 running text |
| 12 | V404:2866 running text | IV128:2936 running text |
| 13 | V404:2867 running text | IV128:2937 running text |
| 14 | V404:2868 running text | IV128:2938 running text |
| 15 | V404:2869 running text | IV128:2939 running text |
| 16 | V404:2870 running text | IV128:2940 running text |
| 17 | V404:2871 running text | IV128:2941 running text |
| 18 | V405:2872 running text | IV128:2942 running text |
| 19 | V405:2873 running text | IV128:2943 running text |
| 20 | V405:2874 running text | IV128:2944 running text |
New Naqqali