Afrasiab Sends Envoys to Khosrow
C4.6 Afrasiab Sends Envoys to Khosrow. 78 couplets. Peace terms and alternative duels,staged battle proposals,the outpost clash and Gharan’s report.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | C4.6 Afrasiab Sends Envoys to Khosrow. 78 couplets. Peace terms and alternative duels,staged battle proposals,the outpost clash and Gharan’s report. |
| Moscow | V260–264:416–487,72 running units. Full additions at260n16,263n3 and263n11 support English2,4,45,50,51. Sending-treasure addition261n28. Main curse pronouns and Shideh-attribution differ from English. |
| Mohl | IV21:L9–L23; IV22:L1–L25; IV23:L1–L25; IV24:L1–L12,77 running units. Fuller dispatch,dawn and third-day instructions in main text. Adviser selection precedes farewell. Bloodshed without Shideh. |
| Ganjoor | mahmood/sh5:1–72,72 body units. Checked local gaps for the fuller dispatch,dawn and third-day units. Main curse pronouns and attack attribution align with Moscow. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | IV198–202:422–494,73 running units including bracketed466–467. Actual199n18 preserves the additional treasure catalogue; actual200n17 the night-skirt image. Checked dispatch gaps. Bloodshed without Shideh. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6The embassy begins with variant instructions
English 1–6;edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V260:416 running text; main inexperience;actual V260n14 blessing · Mohl IV21:L9 running text; blessing · Khaleghi IV198:422 running text; blessing · Ganjoor sh5:1 running body · Moscow V260n16 first actual addition · Mohl IV21:L10 running text · Khaleghi IV198:422–423 checked local main gap;no full corresponding reading in relevant printed apparatus · Ganjoor sh5:1–2 checked local body gap · Moscow V260:417 running text · Mohl IV21:L11 running text · Khaleghi IV198:423 running text · Ganjoor sh5:2 running body · Moscow V260n16 second actual addition · Mohl IV21:L12 running text · Khaleghi IV198:423–424 checked local main gap;no full corresponding reading in relevant printed apparatus · Ganjoor sh5:2–3 checked local body gap · Moscow V260:418 running text · Mohl IV21:L13 running text · Khaleghi IV198:424 running text · Ganjoor sh5:3 running body · Moscow V260:419 running text · Mohl IV21:L14 running text · Khaleghi IV198:425 running text · Ganjoor sh5:4 running body
Mohl and Khaleghi open with the father's blessing, also printed in Moscow's actual apparatus, while Moscow and Ganjoor's main text describes the son as inexperienced in life's heat and cold. The English follows the blessing and gives the elevated address a forceful imperious tone. Mohl also prints two fuller instructions: do not let the prospective encounter trouble the heart, and go with the Creator's support against the enemy. Moscow prints both in actual apparatus. Khaleghi and Ganjoor have checked local gaps, so their shorter running sequences are not evidence for those complete additions. English shame or slight narrows the first instruction's emotional meaning beyond the heart-tightening expression. The request for a wise interlocutor remains shared by all four. It establishes a formal embassy before the message turns to the perceived wrongness of a grandson attacking his grandfather.
7–12Responsibility redirected through blood relations
English 7–12;edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V260:420 running text · Mohl IV21:L15 running text · Khaleghi IV198:426 running text · Ganjoor sh5:5 running body · Moscow V260:421 running text · Mohl IV21:L16 running text · Khaleghi IV198:427 running text · Ganjoor sh5:6 running body · Moscow V260:422 running text · Mohl IV21:L17 running text · Khaleghi IV198:428 running text · Ganjoor sh5:7 running body · Moscow V260:423 running text · Mohl IV21:L18 running text · Khaleghi IV198:429 running text · Ganjoor sh5:8 running body · Moscow V260:424 running text; I call you main;actual V260n20 you call me · Mohl IV21:L19 running text; you call me · Khaleghi IV198:430 running text; you call me · Ganjoor sh5:9 running body · Moscow V261:425 running text; first-person self-reproach main;actual V261n1–2 second-person recoil · Mohl IV21:L20 running text; you are of my stock · Khaleghi IV198:431 running text; you are of my stock · Ganjoor sh5:10 running body
All four sources preserve Afrasiab's attempt to explain conflict through divine will, deny Siavash's innocence and ask what wrong Piran and the other slain warriors had done. These are the king's arguments, not impartial conclusions. The English maintains the conditional admission of guilt and the sudden move to his followers' deaths. Its charging, roaring elephants animate a simile attached to bloodied bodies bound upon saddles; the warriors should not consequently be imagined alive. The following curse has a real pronoun division. Mohl and Khaleghi, with actual Moscow variants, make Khosrow's condemnation of his grandfather recoil upon himself through shared descent. Moscow and Ganjoor's main text instead begins with Afrasiab condemning his grandson and reproaching himself. English follows the former direction. The kinship logic is common, but its speaker and target must remain distinct.
13–18Boast and professed fear of judgment
English 13–18;edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V261:426 running text · Mohl IV21:L21 running text · Khaleghi IV198:432 running text · Ganjoor sh5:11 running body · Moscow V261:427 running text · Mohl IV21:L22 running text · Khaleghi IV198:433 running text · Ganjoor sh5:12 running body · Moscow V261:428 running text · Mohl IV21:L23 running text · Khaleghi IV198:434 running text · Ganjoor sh5:13 running body · Moscow V261:429 running text · Mohl IV22:L1 running text · Khaleghi IV198:435 running text · Ganjoor sh5:14 running body · Moscow V261:430 running text; V261:431 running text · Mohl IV22:L2 running text; IV22:L3 running text · Khaleghi IV198:436 running text; IV198:437 running text · Ganjoor sh5:15 running body; sh5:16 running body · Moscow V261:431 running text · Mohl IV22:L3 running text · Khaleghi IV198:437 running text · Ganjoor sh5:16 running body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi agree on the instruction to leave vengeance to Kavus and Gudarz, followed by denial of fear or declining strength. The English preserves the oscillation between intimidation and restraint. Sand and sea become sands along the shore, making the army's immeasurable size into a single landscape rather than a count. The mountain becoming sea remains another extravagant boast. Blood like rain supplies an English explanation of that transformation; the corresponding Persian does not separately describe rainfall. Afrasiab then invokes fear of the Creator and the loss of innocent noble lives. Judge of earth and sky interprets that appeal as accountability. The English anticipates the heads in one couplet and develops them in the next, so the shared Persian unit is counted once. The speech's humanitarian claim does not erase its immediately preceding threat.
19–24An oath purchased with abandoned vengeance
English 19–24;edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V261:432 running text · Mohl IV22:L4 running text · Khaleghi IV199:438 running text · Ganjoor sh5:17 running body · Moscow V261:433 running text · Mohl IV22:L5 running text · Khaleghi IV199:439 running text · Ganjoor sh5:18 running body · Moscow V261:434 running text · Mohl IV22:L6 running text · Khaleghi IV199:440 running text · Ganjoor sh5:19 running body · Moscow V261:435 running text · Mohl IV22:L7 running text · Khaleghi IV199:441 running text · Ganjoor sh5:20 running body · Moscow V261:436 running text; stone mountain main;actual V261n22 Gang · Mohl IV22:L8 running text; Gang and Pashang · Khaleghi IV199:442 running text; stone mountain and Pashang · Ganjoor sh5:21 running body · Moscow V261:437 running text · Mohl IV22:L9 running text · Khaleghi IV199:443 running text · Ganjoor sh5:22 running body
All four texts connect refusal to retreat with possible fear of disgrace, then propose an oath and the preservation of army and treasure. English perhaps usefully keeps the alleged motive speculative. Its additional phrase about wrath and fear passing supplies a future setting for fidelity rather than a separately attested condition. The central price remains abandonment of Siavash's vengeance. English blood once shed makes that cost particularly direct. Proposed brotherhood with Jahan and Shideh also preserves the king's attempt to substitute family relations for war, although the Persian names the second son Pashang here. Mohl and an actual Moscow variant support Gang in the accompanying boast; the other main readings give a stone mountain. The territorial promise is to evacuate lands identified as Iranian. English by law adds a legal cast without establishing modern frontiers or adjudicating the claim.
25–30Treasure and a reconstructed family compact
English 25–30;edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V261:438 running text · Mohl IV22:L10 running text · Khaleghi IV199:444 running text · Ganjoor sh5:23 running body · Moscow V261:439 running text · Mohl IV22:L11 running text · Khaleghi IV199:445 running text · Ganjoor sh5:24 running body · Moscow V261:440 running text · Mohl IV22:L12 running text · Khaleghi IV199n18 actual full addition;main445–446 checked local gap · Ganjoor sh5:25 running body · Moscow V262:441 running text; first half shared withEnglish29;actual V261n28 additional sending verse · Moscow V262:441 running text; first half shared withEnglish29;actual V261n28 additional sending verse · Mohl IV22:L13 running text · Khaleghi IV199:446 running text; first half shared withEnglish29;actual IV199n14 additional sending verse · Ganjoor sh5:26 running body · Moscow V262:441 running text · Khaleghi IV199:446 running text · Ganjoor sh5:26 running body · Moscow V262:442 running text · Mohl IV22:L14 running text · Khaleghi IV199:447 running text · Ganjoor sh5:27 running body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all enumerate ancestral wealth, horses and weapons before the promised shipment and family relationship. The additional catalogue of great men's treasure and the army's needs is running text in Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor but actual apparatus in Khaleghi. A separate sending-ancestral-treasure addition is printed in Moscow and Khaleghi apparatus. Those are identifiable readings, not a general notice of additions. English ordered flow and the explicit destination Iran organize the transfer more clearly than the shared sending half-line, which also supports the next English couplet's son-and-father compact. Zadeshm remains the English spelling beside differing printed forms; no genealogy is reconstructed from the name alone. The proposed conclusion moves from razm to bazm, battle to feast. The English preserves the persuasive appeal of mutual relief without certifying that the offer will be honored.
31–36The duel offered as an alternative settlement
English 31–36;edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V262:443 running text · Mohl IV22:L15 running text · Khaleghi IV199:448 running text · Ganjoor sh5:28 running body · Moscow V262:444 running text · Mohl IV22:L16 running text · Khaleghi IV199:449 running text · Ganjoor sh5:29 running body · Moscow V262:445 running text · Mohl IV22:L17 running text · Khaleghi IV199:450 running text · Ganjoor sh5:30 running body · Moscow V262:446 running text · Mohl IV22:L18 running text · Khaleghi IV199:451 running text · Ganjoor sh5:31 running body · Moscow V262:447 running text · Mohl IV22:L19 running text · Khaleghi IV200:452 running text · Ganjoor sh5:32 running body · Moscow V262:448 running text · Mohl IV22:L20 running text · Khaleghi IV200:453 running text · Ganjoor sh5:33 running body
In all four sources, the conciliatory offer turns into an accusation that Ahriman has bent Khosrow toward his own shroud and made him incapable of receiving counsel. English sought sharpens the suggestion of chosen self-destruction. The invitation to leave the ranks then makes a royal duel the alternative to general slaughter. The English keeps the conditional wish for satisfaction rather than guaranteeing either king victory. Both possible deaths are followed by assurances concerning the surviving army and family. Those promises belong to Afrasiab's terms, not to the commentary's prediction. Safe quarter begins in the English before the Persian protection formula is fully stated in the following unit, making the assurances overlap across the couplet boundary. The register therefore distinguishes shared semantic support from an additional Persian verse and does not infer an unstated succession rule from the son's promised kinship.
37–42The son replaces the experienced challenger
English 37–42;edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V262:449 running text · Mohl IV22:L21 running text · Khaleghi IV200:454 running text · Ganjoor sh5:34 running body · Moscow V262:450 running text · Mohl IV22:L22 running text · Khaleghi IV200:455 running text · Ganjoor sh5:35 running body · Moscow V262:451 running text · Mohl IV22:L23 running text · Khaleghi IV200:456 running text · Ganjoor sh5:36 running body · Moscow V262:452 running text · Mohl IV22:L24 running text · Khaleghi IV200:457 running text · Ganjoor sh5:37 running body · Moscow V262:453 running text; leopard · Mohl IV22:L25 running text; leopard · Khaleghi IV200:458 running text; nahang main;actual IV200n10 leopard · Ganjoor sh5:38 running body · Moscow V262:454 running text · Mohl IV23:L1 running text · Khaleghi IV200:459 running text · Ganjoor sh5:39 running body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi agree that Afrasiab presents himself as an experienced nahang, then offers the girded son if Khosrow will not face him. English veteran preserves experience and retains the Persian image without requiring a modern zoological identification. Its spear is additional wording whose exact equivalent remains unverified in the inspected main texts and relevant apparatus. Pashang is the printed name at the son's offer, while English continues with Shideh. The old father and young supporter give that substitution a family logic. For the next martial simile, Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor have leopard combat, whereas Khaleghi's main text has nahang and its actual apparatus supplies the leopard alternative. English leopard claws follows the supported feline reading but adds the unstained courage. The appeal to heaven then suspends the outcome rather than proving that favor already belongs to either fighter.
43–48Dawn and the first stages of battle
English 43–48;edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V262:455 running text · Mohl IV23:L2 running text · Khaleghi IV200:460 running text · Ganjoor sh5:40 running body · Moscow V263:456 running text · Mohl IV23:L3 running text · Khaleghi IV200:461 running text · Ganjoor sh5:41 running body · Moscow V263n3 actual full addition · Mohl IV23:L4 running text · Khaleghi IV200n17 actual full addition;main461–462 checked local gap · Ganjoor sh5:41–42 checked local body gap · Moscow V263:457 running text · Mohl IV23:L5 running text · Khaleghi IV200:462 running text · Ganjoor sh5:42 running body · Moscow V263:458 running text; river/sea main;actual V263n5 brocade · Mohl IV23:L6 running text; brocade · Khaleghi IV200:463 running text; brocade · Ganjoor sh5:43 running body · Moscow V263:459 running text · Mohl IV23:L7 running text · Khaleghi IV200:464 running text · Ganjoor sh5:44 running body
All four sources propose a night's rest and the mountain's golden crown at dawn, followed by chosen warriors bearing heavy gorzes. Mohl additionally prints the night withdrawing its skirt and hiding its head; Moscow and Khaleghi preserve that verse in actual apparatus, with a checked Ganjoor gap. English spreads the darkness across earth and sky and gives dawn motion, developing a supported personification. Its blood-colored brocade follows Mohl and Khaleghi and an actual Moscow variant; Moscow and Ganjoor main instead make blood a river or sea. The difference changes the imagined surface from flowing water to richly patterned cloth. The next day's cockcrow and elephant-borne drums are shared. The Persian instrument is kus, so English tabiras remains a specific substitution rather than a universally attested noun. None of these preparations establishes a modern tactical formation.
49–54A third day preserved in fuller witnesses
English 49–54;edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V263:460 running text · Mohl IV23:L8 running text · Khaleghi IV200:465 running text · Ganjoor sh5:45 running body · Moscow V263n11 first actual full addition · Mohl IV23:L9 running text · Khaleghi IV200:466 bracketed running text · Ganjoor sh5:45–46 checked local body gap · Moscow V263n11 second actual full addition · Mohl IV23:L10 running text · Khaleghi IV200:467 bracketed running text · Ganjoor sh5:45–46 checked local body gap · Moscow V263:461 running text · Mohl IV23:L11 running text · Khaleghi IV201:468 running text · Ganjoor sh5:46 running body · Moscow V263:462 running text · Mohl IV23:L12 running text · Khaleghi IV201:469 running text · Ganjoor sh5:47 running body · Moscow V263:464 running text; departure before selection · Mohl IV23:L13 running text; selection before departure · Khaleghi IV201:471 running text; departure before selection · Ganjoor sh5:49 running body
The chiefs' intervention and blood in channels are shared in all four presentations, although English reinforce every line gives the instruction tactical precision and dark as wine supplies color. The third day requires separate evidence: Mohl prints two complete couplets, Moscow prints them in actual apparatus, and Khaleghi includes them as bracketed running text. Ganjoor has a checked local gap between the second-day action and the renewed instruction to Shideh. English throne and crown interpret the second added couplet's contrast between heaven's humiliation and honor. The speech then returns to the father's outer direction to seek distant single combat if counsel fails. Finally, the choice of four advisers is placed before departure in Mohl and English but after departure in Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi main. The ordering is recorded without inventing a second selection or a second farewell.
55–60An escort whose violence exceeds its mission
English 55–60;edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V263:463 running text; departure before selection · Mohl IV23:L14 running text; selection before departure · Khaleghi IV201:470 running text; departure before selection · Ganjoor sh5:48 running body · Moscow V263:465 running text · Mohl IV23:L15 running text · Khaleghi IV201:472 running text · Ganjoor sh5:50 running body · Moscow V263:466 running text · Mohl IV23:L16 running text · Khaleghi IV201:473 running text · Ganjoor sh5:51 running body · Moscow V263:467 running text · Mohl IV23:L17 running text · Khaleghi IV201:474 running text · Ganjoor sh5:52 running body · Moscow V263:468 running text; in Shideh’s name main;actual V263n22 without Shideh · Mohl IV23:L18 running text; without Shideh · Khaleghi IV201:475 running text; without Shideh · Ganjoor sh5:53 running body · Moscow V263:469 running text · Mohl IV23:L19 running text · Khaleghi IV201:476 running text · Ganjoor sh5:54 running body
All four texts give the father's tearful farewell, a thousand capable escorts and the approaching force's discovery by Iranian outposts. English bowing makes the son's blessing physical; its well-armed escort develops the Persian statement of martial suitability. The narrative then assigns the attack to inexperienced young Turks at the front. Shideh's relation to their bloodshed differs materially. Moscow and Ganjoor main say it occurred in his name or on his behalf. Mohl and Khaleghi say without Shideh, and Moscow's actual apparatus preserves that reading too. English had not known converts the absence into a statement of ignorance. That is a plausible explanation, but stronger than the local wording itself. The distinction matters because a diplomatic approach has become an armed clash. Iranian wounds and continued fighting remain shared, while the English supplies the sound of weapons.
61–66Stopping the clash and requesting an audience
English 61–66;edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V263:470 running text · Mohl IV23:L20 running text · Khaleghi IV201:477 running text · Ganjoor sh5:55 running body · Moscow V264:471 running text · Mohl IV23:L21 running text · Khaleghi IV201:478 running text · Ganjoor sh5:56 running body · Moscow V264:472 running text · Mohl IV23:L22 running text · Khaleghi IV201:479 running text · Ganjoor sh5:57 running body · Moscow V264:473 running text · Mohl IV23:L23 running text · Khaleghi IV201:480 running text · Ganjoor sh5:58 running body · Moscow V264:474 running text · Mohl IV23:L24 running text · Khaleghi IV201:481 running text · Ganjoor sh5:59 running body · Moscow V264:475 running text · Mohl IV23:L25 running text · Khaleghi IV201:482 running text · Ganjoor sh5:60 running body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all have Shideh arrive, become distressed and recall his warriors. This conduct directly supports disapproval of the continuing attack, even though it does not independently prove what he knew before arriving. English wrongful track makes the judgment explicit. He then follows a diplomatic sequence: request a properly conducted horseman, name the bearer of the message, identify Afrasiab as commander of Chin and invoke the king's maternal grandfather. English ardent spirit makes the clear-hearted designation more emotionally heated, whereas the original also permits intellectual or moral brightness. The kinship formula continues the strategy already present in Afrasiab's proposed terms. The outpost rider's rapid departure is shared by all four; English places his arrival before the king's men without a separately attested audience assembly. No modern location or frontier follows from the retained name Chin.
67–72Khosrow receives the claim of kinship
English 67–72;edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V264:476 running text · Mohl IV24:L1 running text · Khaleghi IV202:483 running text · Ganjoor sh5:61 running body · Moscow V264:477 running text · Mohl IV24:L2 running text · Khaleghi IV202:484 running text · Ganjoor sh5:62 running body · Moscow V264:478 running text · Mohl IV24:L3 running text · Khaleghi IV202:485 running text · Ganjoor sh5:63 running body · Moscow V264:479 running text · Mohl IV24:L4 running text · Khaleghi IV202:486 running text · Ganjoor sh5:64 running body · Moscow V264:480 running text · Mohl IV24:L5 running text · Khaleghi IV202:487 running text · Ganjoor sh5:65 running body · Moscow V264:481 running text · Mohl IV24:L6 running text · Khaleghi IV202:488 running text · Ganjoor sh5:66 running body
All four sources describe the lofty envoy with a black standard, his request for an interlocutor, and Khosrow's shame and hot tears. The English adds a spear as the banner's carrier, although this particular source line names only the standard. Sorrow interprets the tears without resolving whether shame arises from family ties, the encounter or the war itself. Khosrow then calls Shideh his maternal uncle and his equal in stature and manliness. English courage, heart and head enlarges that parity beyond a literal physical comparison. The available representative is Qaren Kavian. English Gharan maintains the translation's established spelling, and of Kaveh's race interprets the epithet rather than independently documenting ancestry. The instruction to greet and listen is common to Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi. It authorizes reception of the message, not acceptance of the king's proposals.
73–78Fair words reported without a settlement
English 73–78;edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V264:482 running text · Mohl IV24:L7 running text · Khaleghi IV202:489 running text · Ganjoor sh5:67 running body · Moscow V264:483 running text · Mohl IV24:L8 running text · Khaleghi IV202:490 running text · Ganjoor sh5:68 running body · Moscow V264:484 running text · Mohl IV24:L9 running text · Khaleghi IV202:491 running text · Ganjoor sh5:69 running body · Moscow V264:485 running text · Mohl IV24:L10 running text · Khaleghi IV202:492 running text · Ganjoor sh5:70 running body · Moscow V264:486 running text · Mohl IV24:L11 running text · Khaleghi IV202:493 running text · Ganjoor sh5:71 running body · Moscow V264:487 running text · Mohl IV24:L12 running text · Khaleghi IV202:494 running text · Ganjoor sh5:72 running body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi preserve the black, shining banner, reciprocal greetings and the young envoy's sweet speech and alert understanding. English honeyed successfully carries the sensory quality of that speech, while shrewd interprets mental alertness without proving deception. The transmitted message concerns rest, feast, war and haste; English peace, war and terms gives a concise account of its alternatives. Gharan's favorable reaction is also shared. The English phrase counsel true is stronger than the immediate description of fine words from a wise speaker, so it should remain his assessment rather than become an independent endorsement of Afrasiab's sincerity. The closing statement that the message was joined with wisdom supports the report's favorable tone. English seemed usefully leaves that judgment provisional. The chapter ends with delivery and appraisal of the embassy, before Khosrow's answer.
Source record and limits
C4.6 contains 78 English couplets and 13 substantive notes. Unique running coverage is 72 Moscow, 77 Mohl, 72 Ganjoor and 73 Khaleghi units, including Khaleghi’s two bracketed third-day couplets. Every declared running unit is accounted for. Moscow actual apparatus supplies five fuller units corresponding to English2,4,45,50,51. English28–29 divide a shared sending-and-kinship unit; English17 anticipates the innocent-heads unit used in18.
Moscow V260–264:416–487; Mohl IV21:L9–L23, IV22:L1–L25, IV23:L1–L25, IV24:L1–L12; Ganjoor mahmood/sh5:1–72; Khaleghi IV198–202:422–494, including bracketed466–467. Mohl L locators count running couplets from the top of each page, excluding headings.
- F&R English: C4.6 Afrasiab Sends Envoys to Khosrow. 78 couplets. Peace terms and alternative duels,staged battle proposals,the outpost clash and Gharan’s report.
- Moscow: V260–264:416–487,72 running units. Full additions at260n16,263n3 and263n11 support English2,4,45,50,51. Sending-treasure addition261n28. Main curse pronouns and Shideh-attribution differ from English.
- Mohl: IV21:L9–L23; IV22:L1–L25; IV23:L1–L25; IV24:L1–L12,77 running units. Fuller dispatch,dawn and third-day instructions in main text. Adviser selection precedes farewell. Bloodshed without Shideh.
- Ganjoor: mahmood/sh5:1–72,72 body units. Checked local gaps for the fuller dispatch,dawn and third-day units. Main curse pronouns and attack attribution align with Moscow.
- Khaleghi-Motlagh: IV198–202:422–494,73 running units including bracketed466–467. Actual199n18 preserves the additional treasure catalogue; actual200n17 the night-skirt image. Checked dispatch gaps. Bloodshed without Shideh.
The English follows Mohl’s fuller dispatch and battle timetable,with actual Moscow apparatus support for the additional units. The curse’s direction changes between main readings,and the phrase without Shideh differs from in his name. These are substantive textual alternatives. The placement of the four advisers likewise differs; no second selection is implied.
Relevant actual apparatus is identified separately from main text. Khaleghi466–467 are bracketed running text,not apparatus. The fuller dispatch has checked local Khaleghi/Ganjoor gaps; the dawn and third-day passages have checked Ganjoor gaps. No appendix evidence or appendix-wide absence is asserted. Apparatus citations concern the readings used here,not an exhaustive transcription of all notes.
Afrasiab’s justification of Siavash’s death and appeals to kinship remain attributed speech. The curse pronouns, Gang/stone mountain, leopard/nahang, brocade/water, adviser-selection order and Shideh’s relation to the outpost attack differ among readings. English59 infers ignorance from a without-Shideh reading. English38 spear and English67 spear as flag-carrier have no verified exact equivalents at their inspected loci. English2 shame,24 by law,48 tabiras and71 ancestry interpret or specify the source. No modern geography,precise animal species,genealogy or treaty enforcement is certified. Checked local gaps are bounded; no appendix evidence is invoked.
- Moscow V260n16 first actual addition; English2 — چو با خسرو آهنگ داری به جنگ / مگردان دل خود بدین کار تنگ
- Moscow V260n16 second actual addition; English4 — برو کآفریننده ات یار باد / سر تخت دشمن نگونسار باد
- Moscow V260:424 main; English11 contrast — گر ایدونک گویم که تو بدتنی
- Moscow V260n20 actual variant; English11 — گویی
- Khaleghi IV198:430 main; English11 — گر ایدونک گویی که تو بدتنی
- Khaleghi IV199n18 actual addition; English27 — ز تاج بزرگان و تخت و کلاه / ز چیزی که خواهی ز بهر سپاه
- Moscow V261n28 actual addition; English28 — ز گنج نیاکان برترمنش / فرستم بنزد تو بی سرزنش
- Mohl IV23:L4 main; English45 — شب تیره زو دامن اندر کشد / یکی پرده از شعر در سر کشد
- Moscow V263n3 actual addition; English45 — شب تیره زو دامن اندر کشد / یکی چادر شعر در سر کشد
- Khaleghi IV200:466–467 bracketed main; English50–51 — سوم روز لشکر بکردار کوه / درآریم در رزم و کین همگروه / ببینیم تا این سپهر بلند / که را خوار دارد که را ارجمند
- Mohl IV23:L18 main; English59 — بناگاه بی شیده خون ریختند
- Moscow V263:468 main; English59 contrast — بنام از پی شیده خون ریختند
- Khaleghi IV201:475 main; English59 — بناگاه بی شیده خون ریختند
C4.6 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | V260:416 running text; main inexperience;actual V260n14 blessing | IV21:L9 running text; blessing |
| 2 | V260n16 first actual addition | IV21:L10 running text |
| 3 | V260:417 running text | IV21:L11 running text |
| 4 | V260n16 second actual addition | IV21:L12 running text |
| 5 | V260:418 running text | IV21:L13 running text |
| 6 | V260:419 running text | IV21:L14 running text |
| 7 | V260:420 running text | IV21:L15 running text |
| 8 | V260:421 running text | IV21:L16 running text |
| 9 | V260:422 running text | IV21:L17 running text |
| 10 | V260:423 running text | IV21:L18 running text |
| 11 | V260:424 running text; I call you main;actual V260n20 you call me | IV21:L19 running text; you call me |
| 12 | V261:425 running text; first-person self-reproach main;actual V261n1–2 second-person recoil | IV21:L20 running text; you are of my stock |
| 13 | V261:426 running text | IV21:L21 running text |
| 14 | V261:427 running text | IV21:L22 running text |
| 15 | V261:428 running text | IV21:L23 running text |
| 16 | V261:429 running text | IV22:L1 running text |
| 17 | V261:430 running text; V261:431 running text | IV22:L2 running text; IV22:L3 running text |
| 18 | V261:431 running text | IV22:L3 running text |
| 19 | V261:432 running text | IV22:L4 running text |
| 20 | V261:433 running text | IV22:L5 running text |
| 21 | V261:434 running text | IV22:L6 running text |
| 22 | V261:435 running text | IV22:L7 running text |
| 23 | V261:436 running text; stone mountain main;actual V261n22 Gang | IV22:L8 running text; Gang and Pashang |
| 24 | V261:437 running text | IV22:L9 running text |
| 25 | V261:438 running text | IV22:L10 running text |
| 26 | V261:439 running text | IV22:L11 running text |
| 27 | V261:440 running text | IV22:L12 running text |
| 28 | V262:441 running text; first half shared withEnglish29;actual V261n28 additional sending verse | IV22:L13 running text |
| 29 | V262:441 running text | IV22:L13 running text |
| 30 | V262:442 running text | IV22:L14 running text |
| 31 | V262:443 running text | IV22:L15 running text |
| 32 | V262:444 running text | IV22:L16 running text |
| 33 | V262:445 running text | IV22:L17 running text |
| 34 | V262:446 running text | IV22:L18 running text |
| 35 | V262:447 running text | IV22:L19 running text |
| 36 | V262:448 running text | IV22:L20 running text |
| 37 | V262:449 running text | IV22:L21 running text |
| 38 | V262:450 running text | IV22:L22 running text |
| 39 | V262:451 running text | IV22:L23 running text |
| 40 | V262:452 running text | IV22:L24 running text |
| 41 | V262:453 running text; leopard | IV22:L25 running text; leopard |
| 42 | V262:454 running text | IV23:L1 running text |
| 43 | V262:455 running text | IV23:L2 running text |
| 44 | V263:456 running text | IV23:L3 running text |
| 45 | V263n3 actual full addition | IV23:L4 running text |
| 46 | V263:457 running text | IV23:L5 running text |
| 47 | V263:458 running text; river/sea main;actual V263n5 brocade | IV23:L6 running text; brocade |
| 48 | V263:459 running text | IV23:L7 running text |
| 49 | V263:460 running text | IV23:L8 running text |
| 50 | V263n11 first actual full addition | IV23:L9 running text |
| 51 | V263n11 second actual full addition | IV23:L10 running text |
| 52 | V263:461 running text | IV23:L11 running text |
| 53 | V263:462 running text | IV23:L12 running text |
| 54 | V263:464 running text; departure before selection | IV23:L13 running text; selection before departure |
| 55 | V263:463 running text; departure before selection | IV23:L14 running text; selection before departure |
| 56 | V263:465 running text | IV23:L15 running text |
| 57 | V263:466 running text | IV23:L16 running text |
| 58 | V263:467 running text | IV23:L17 running text |
| 59 | V263:468 running text; in Shideh’s name main;actual V263n22 without Shideh | IV23:L18 running text; without Shideh |
| 60 | V263:469 running text | IV23:L19 running text |
| 61 | V263:470 running text | IV23:L20 running text |
| 62 | V264:471 running text | IV23:L21 running text |
| 63 | V264:472 running text | IV23:L22 running text |
| 64 | V264:473 running text | IV23:L23 running text |
| 65 | V264:474 running text | IV23:L24 running text |
| 66 | V264:475 running text | IV23:L25 running text |
| 67 | V264:476 running text | IV24:L1 running text |
| 68 | V264:477 running text | IV24:L2 running text |
| 69 | V264:478 running text | IV24:L3 running text |
| 70 | V264:479 running text | IV24:L4 running text |
| 71 | V264:480 running text | IV24:L5 running text |
| 72 | V264:481 running text | IV24:L6 running text |
| 73 | V264:482 running text | IV24:L7 running text |
| 74 | V264:483 running text | IV24:L8 running text |
| 75 | V264:484 running text | IV24:L9 running text |
| 76 | V264:485 running text | IV24:L10 running text |
| 77 | V264:486 running text | IV24:L11 running text |
| 78 | V264:487 running text | IV24:L12 running text |
New Naqqali