Kay Khosrow Battles Shideh
C4.8 Kay Khosrow Battles Shideh.85 couplets,ending with consent to dismounted combat. The killing is outside this chapter.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | C4.8 Kay Khosrow Battles Shideh.85 couplets,ending with consent to dismounted combat. The killing is outside this chapter. |
| Moscow | V270–275:580–660,81 running units. Actual270n28 challenger announcement and271n24 three Rostam contingency units. Main dust and negative condition;actual273n7 blood. |
| Mohl | IV28:L14–L22;IV29–31:L1–L25 each;IV32:L1,85 running units. Announcement and three Rostam units in main,along with blood and the negative condition. |
| Ganjoor | mahmood/sh7:1–81,81 body units. Local gaps at6–7 and16–17 for announcement and Rostam units. Dust and negative dismounting condition in body;differing heaven-turning verb at75. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | IV208–213:588–669,82 running units. Announcement in main,three Rostam units in actual210n3. Blood and negative dismounting condition in main. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6The bright morning and the armed challenger
English 1–6;edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V270:580 running text · Mohl IV28:L14 running text · Khaleghi IV208:588 running text · Ganjoor sh7:1 running body · Moscow V270:581 running text · Mohl IV28:L15 running text · Khaleghi IV209:589 running text · Ganjoor sh7:2 running body · Moscow V270:582 running text · Mohl IV28:L16 running text · Khaleghi IV209:590 running text · Ganjoor sh7:3 running body · Moscow V270:583 running text;leopard · Mohl IV28:L17 running text;battlefield · Khaleghi IV209:591 running text;nahang main;actual IV209n4 leopard · Ganjoor sh7:4 running body · Moscow V270:584 running text · Mohl IV28:L18 running text · Khaleghi IV209:592 running text · Ganjoor sh7:5 running body · Moscow V270:585 running text · Mohl IV28:L19 running text · Khaleghi IV209:593 running text · Ganjoor sh7:6 running body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi open with an azure canopy transformed by yellow gemstone brilliance. English topaz makes that color immediate, though the Persian designation does not by itself establish a modern mineral classification. The rider is called Pashang here in all four, while the English keeps Shideh consistently through the episode. His youth, armor, helmet and accompanying banner are shared features. The approach’s animal comparison varies: Moscow has a leopard, Khaleghi a nahang with leopard recorded in its apparatus, and Mohl describes the battlefield instead. English fierce of eye conveys menace without choosing a species. The arriving sword-bearing figure is still being reported to the king; the expanded language of battle’s fury must not make this announcement an already completed clash.
7–11The announcement and the army’s anguish
English 7–11;edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V270n28 actual full addition · Mohl IV28:L20 running text · Khaleghi IV209:594 running text · Ganjoor sh7:6–7 checked local body gap · Moscow V270:586 running text;jowshan · Mohl IV28:L21 running text;khaftan · Khaleghi IV209:595 running text;khaftan main;actual IV209n11 jowshan · Ganjoor sh7:7 running body · Moscow V270:587 running text · Mohl IV28:L22 running text · Khaleghi IV209:596 running text · Ganjoor sh7:8 running body · Moscow V271:588 running text · Mohl IV29:L1 running text · Khaleghi IV209:597 running text · Ganjoor sh7:9 running body · Moscow V271:589 running text · Mohl IV29:L2 running text · Khaleghi IV209:598 running text · Ganjoor sh7:10 running body
The named challenge is running text in Mohl and Khaleghi and a fully printed addition in Moscow, but absent at the corresponding Ganjoor junction. English preserves this attested fuller announcement, substituting Shideh for Pashang. The king’s laughter then contrasts with his army’s fear in all four presentations. Moscow and Ganjoor name jowshan, while Mohl and Khaleghi main use a different armor or protective garment term; Khaleghi’s apparatus also records jowshan. The English helmet anticipates the next unit, where the golden headpiece and Rohham’s flag are explicit. The soldiers’ source comparison to people roasted over fierce fire becomes inward consumption. That retains their anguish while softening the material simile. Their plea against iron distressing the king’s body acquires sacredness in English, an added evaluation rather than a separately attested adjective.
12–17The throne and the discipline of the ranks
English 12–17;edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V271:590 running text · Mohl IV29:L3 running text · Khaleghi IV209:599 running text · Ganjoor sh7:11 running body · Moscow V271:591 running text · Mohl IV29:L4 running text · Khaleghi IV209:600 running text · Ganjoor sh7:12 running body · Moscow V271:592 running text · Mohl IV29:L5 running text · Khaleghi IV209:601 running text · Ganjoor sh7:13 running body · Moscow V271:593 running text · Mohl IV29:L6 running text · Khaleghi IV209:602 running text · Ganjoor sh7:14 running body · Moscow V271:594 running text · Mohl IV29:L7 running text · Khaleghi IV209:603 running text · Ganjoor sh7:15 running body · Moscow V271:595 running text · Mohl IV29:L8 running text · Khaleghi IV209:604 running text · Ganjoor sh7:16 running body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all make the army distinguish the throne from the king’s hazardous participation in vengeance. Its curse wishes dark earth and frustrated desire on whoever brought him to this point. English broken aim and vow condenses that frustration into a balanced phrase, but does not warrant identifying a particular broken oath. Khosrow answers with greetings and precise orders: nobody is to leave the formation, seek independent combat or disregard Rohham. English hold your rein turns obedience into a visible mounted action. The instruction to watch the outcome when the sun rises high preserves uncertainty about who will suffer. The narrator has not yet certified victory; public royal confidence coexists with a practical arrangement for troops who must remain still while their king risks himself.
18–22Rostam as the contingency for defeat
English 18–22;edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V271n24 second actual full addition · Mohl IV29:L9 running text · Khaleghi IV210n3 first actual full addition;main606–607 checked local gap · Ganjoor sh7:16–17 checked local body gap · Moscow V271n24 first actual full addition · Mohl IV29:L10 running text · Khaleghi IV210n3 second actual full addition;main606–607 checked local gap · Ganjoor sh7:16–17 checked local body gap · Moscow V271n24 third actual full addition · Mohl IV29:L11 running text · Khaleghi IV210n3 third actual full addition;main606–607 checked local gap · Ganjoor sh7:16–17 checked local body gap · Moscow V271:596 running text · Mohl IV29:L12 running text · Khaleghi IV209:605 running text · Ganjoor sh7:17 running body · Moscow V271:597 running text · Mohl IV29:L13 running text · Khaleghi IV210:606 running text · Ganjoor sh7:18 running body
Mohl’s running text explicitly provides for Rostam if Pashang wins, followed by obedience and confidence in the protection he gives an army. Moscow prints all three corresponding couplets in its actual apparatus, with the obedience unit preceding the conditional appointment; Khaleghi prints them together in its apparatus in the Mohl order. Ganjoor has a checked local gap. English therefore preserves a fuller attested contingency, not an inferred succession invented from the context. Its Shideh substitutes the opponent’s familiar name, while command and light extends the source’s request for counsel. Grief and darkest plan elaborate the circumstances of reliance. The ensuing rise and fall of war belongs to all four main presentations. Together, contingency and consolation make the speech responsible command rather than unqualified boasting.
23–28Speed, kinship and the recipient of praise
English 23–28;edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V271:598 running text · Mohl IV29:L14 running text · Khaleghi IV210:607 running text · Ganjoor sh7:19 running body · Moscow V271:599 running text · Mohl IV29:L15 running text · Khaleghi IV210:608 running text · Ganjoor sh7:20 running body · Moscow V271:600 running text · Mohl IV29:L16 running text · Khaleghi IV210:609 running text · Ganjoor sh7:21 running body · Moscow V271:601 running text;wisdom addresses Khosrow · Mohl IV29:L17 running text;wisdom addresses Khosrow · Khaleghi IV210:610 running text;wisdom addresses Khosrow · Ganjoor sh7:22 running body · Moscow V272:602 running text · Mohl IV29:L18 running text · Khaleghi IV210:611 running text · Ganjoor sh7:23 running body · Moscow V272:603 running text · Mohl IV29:L19 running text · Khaleghi IV210:612 running text · Ganjoor sh7:24 running body
The black Behzad, windlike speed, rising dust and Shideh’s cold inward breath are common to Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi. English makes the wind fall behind, an effective intensification of the charger’s ability to catch it. Shideh’s response then addresses the son of Siavash and calls the addressee wise. English grammatically attaches renowned for wisdom to Siavash instead. The distinction matters because Shideh is about to accuse Khosrow of conduct inconsistent with the wisdom expected of him: the direct compliment makes the rebuke pointed. Praising the father preserves ancestral honor but changes the immediate argumentative target. All four retain the Turanian descent and moon-reaching helmet. These are the challenger’s dynastic claims and hyperbole, not independent confirmation of every detail of genealogy or royal reach.
29–34Uncle and nephew in a field of vengeance
English 29–34;edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V272:604 running text · Mohl IV29:L20 running text · Khaleghi IV210:613 running text · Ganjoor sh7:25 running body · Moscow V272:605 running text · Mohl IV29:L21 running text · Khaleghi IV210:614 running text · Ganjoor sh7:26 running body · Moscow V272:606 running text · Mohl IV29:L22 running text · Khaleghi IV210:615 running text · Ganjoor sh7:27 running body · Moscow V272:607 running text; V272:608 running text;grief shared withEnglish33 · Mohl IV29:L23 running text;grief anticipated from IV29:L24 · Khaleghi IV210:616 running text; IV210:617 running text;grief shared withEnglish33 · Ganjoor sh7:28 running body; sh7:29 running body · Moscow V272:608 running text · Mohl IV29:L24 running text · Khaleghi IV210:617 running text · Ganjoor sh7:29 running body · Moscow V272:609 running text · Mohl IV29:L25 running text · Khaleghi IV210:618 running text · Ganjoor sh7:30 running body
All four sources make Shideh accuse his nephew of lacking judgment by initiating combat with his maternal uncle. English seeking that uncle dead states the likely consequence more directly than the immediate Persian accusation of making war. The proposed secluded battlefield is shared, as is the refusal of spectators and helpers. Khosrow’s answer joins a fierce-lion salutation to grief for his innocent father; English brings that grief forward into the salutation couplet and then names Siavash. The register therefore records the overlap instead of counting a second Persian grief statement. The rejection of throne and signet as motives remains explicit in Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi. English field of pain reinforces bereavement, but the claim that vengeance alone brought him remains the speaker’s justification within this confrontation.
35–40The challenge and the protected witnesses
English 35–40;edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V272:610 running text · Mohl IV30:L1 running text · Khaleghi IV210:619 running text · Ganjoor sh7:31 running body · Moscow V272:611 running text · Mohl IV30:L2 running text · Khaleghi IV211:620 running text · Ganjoor sh7:32 running body · Moscow V272:612 running text · Mohl IV30:L3 running text · Khaleghi IV211:621 running text · Ganjoor sh7:33 running body · Moscow V272:613 running text · Mohl IV30:L4 running text · Khaleghi IV211:622 running text · Ganjoor sh7:34 running body · Moscow V272:614 running text · Mohl IV30:L5 running text · Khaleghi IV211:623 running text · Ganjoor sh7:35 running body · Moscow V272:615 running text · Mohl IV30:L6 running text · Khaleghi IV211:624 running text · Ganjoor sh7:36 running body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi agree that a challenge directed at Khosrow cannot properly be answered by an unsuitable substitute. English lesser man emphasizes rank, while royal answer turns the obligation into a compact statement of responsibility. This explains the refusal to delegate without requiring a new rule about all royal combat. The agreement then excludes assistance from either side but protects the standard-bearers. English only would draw near makes that exception clearer than the earlier just you and me might suggest. The two men depart like joyful travelers to a feast in all four sources. The cheerful simile is intentionally striking beside their vengeance and risk: it presents heroic eagerness rather than a peaceful journey, and does not cancel the precautions just negotiated.
41–46Khwarazm and the forbidding arena
English 41–46;edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V272:616 running text · Mohl IV30:L7 running text · Khaleghi IV211:625 running text · Ganjoor sh7:37 running body · Moscow V272:617 running text · Mohl IV30:L8 running text · Khaleghi IV211:626 running text · Ganjoor sh7:38 running body · Moscow V272:618 running text · Mohl IV30:L9 running text · Khaleghi IV211:627 running text · Ganjoor sh7:39 running body · Moscow V272:619 running text · Mohl IV30:L10 running text · Khaleghi IV211:628 running text · Ganjoor sh7:40 running body · Moscow V272:620 running text;اخته زهار · Mohl IV30:L11 running text;گشنه نهار · Khaleghi IV211:629 running text;هیخته زهار;actual IV211n13 variants · Ganjoor sh7:41 running body · Moscow V273:621 running text · Mohl IV30:L12 running text · Khaleghi IV211:630 running text · Ganjoor sh7:42 running body
All four presentations locate the arena in the Khwarazm region and make it hostile even to lion, leopard and eagle. English dry rock and shimmering mirage preserve the sequence of desolation without establishing a modern geographical coordinate. The paired horses and wolf-like fighters likewise remain intact, though field of fire adds an image of intensity where no literal fire is named. The following lion epithet differs: Mohl’s hungry reading gives the English direct support, whereas Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi transmit other forms recorded in the source table. Those forms should remain visible rather than be forced into one speculative explanation. Long lances and a high sun are common. English noon and foaming horses make the prolonged exertion more specific than the immediate Persian wording.
47–52Weapons, blood and the failing horse
English 47–52;edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V273:622 running text · Mohl IV30:L13 running text · Khaleghi IV211:631 running text · Ganjoor sh7:43 running body · Moscow V273:623 running text;arrows included · Mohl IV30:L14 running text;arrows included · Khaleghi IV211:632 running text;arrows included · Ganjoor sh7:44 running body · Moscow V273:624 running text;dust main;actual V273n7 blood · Mohl IV30:L15 running text;blood main · Khaleghi IV211:633 running text;blood main · Ganjoor sh7:45 running body;dust main · Moscow V273:625 running text · Mohl IV30:L16 running text · Khaleghi IV211:634 running text · Ganjoor sh7:46 running body · Moscow V273:626 running text · Mohl IV30:L17 running text · Khaleghi IV211:635 running text · Ganjoor sh7:47 running body · Moscow V273:627 running text · Mohl IV30:L18 running text · Khaleghi IV211:636 running text · Ganjoor sh7:48 running body
The four sources exhaust the lanceheads, wet the horse armor and reins, and continue the exchange with Roman maces, swords and arrows. English sweat sensibly interprets the moisture but leaves arrows unstated. The blackening earth presents a genuine textual alternative: Moscow and Ganjoor main read cavalry dust, while Mohl and Khaleghi main read blood, also actually recorded in Moscow’s apparatus. English blood therefore follows direct evidence and should not be treated as unsupported violence. All four next connect Shideh’s tears with his recognition of Khosrow’s strength and divine farr. The thirsty horse and weakened rider explain the turn toward stratagem. English hands, feet and heat give exhaustion bodily detail, but they do not establish additional injuries or the exact mechanism of the weakening.
53–58The proposal intended to be refused
English 53–58;edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V273:628 running text · Mohl IV30:L19 running text · Khaleghi IV212:637 running text · Ganjoor sh7:49 running body · Moscow V273:629 running text · Mohl IV30:L20 running text · Khaleghi IV212:638 running text · Ganjoor sh7:50 running body · Moscow V273:630 running text · Mohl IV30:L21 running text · Khaleghi IV212:639 running text · Ganjoor sh7:51 running body · Moscow V273:631 running text · Mohl IV30:L22 running text · Khaleghi IV212:640 running text · Ganjoor sh7:52 running body · Moscow V273:632 running text · Mohl IV30:L23 running text · Khaleghi IV212:641 running text · Ganjoor sh7:53 running body · Moscow V273:633 running text · Mohl IV30:L24 running text · Khaleghi IV212:642 running text · Ganjoor sh7:54 running body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi separate Shideh’s private calculation from his public proposal. Exhausted, he imagines asking for dismounted wrestling because royal shame may make Khosrow refuse. The intended escape thus depends on the opponent’s pride, not on confidence that wrestling will be easier to win. English equals, hand to hand clarifies the perceived indignity, though formal equality is not separately stipulated. The dragon’s mouth describes the danger of failing to escape, and remains figurative in all four. Shideh’s spoken comparison between ordinary mounted combat and lion-like hands then conceals his private purpose beneath an honorable challenge. English mounted dance gives the turning reins a graceful rhythm without changing that difference between what the character thinks and what he says.
59–62Recognition and the reversed condition
English 59–62;edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V273:634 running text · Mohl IV30:L25 running text · Khaleghi IV212:643 running text · Ganjoor sh7:55 running body · Moscow V273:636 running text · Mohl IV31:L2 running text · Khaleghi IV212:645 running text · Ganjoor sh7:57 running body · Moscow V273:635 running text; V273:636 running text;reordered ancestry;consequence shared withEnglish60 · Mohl IV31:L1 running text;ancestry;consequence from IV31:L2 · Khaleghi IV212:644 running text; IV212:645 running text;reordered ancestry;consequence shared withEnglish60 · Ganjoor sh7:56 running body; sh7:57 running body · Moscow V273:637 running text;negative نگردم;no verified positive alternative in relevant apparatus · Mohl IV31:L3 running text;negative نگردم;first-person consequence بر کنم · Khaleghi IV212:646 running text;negative نگردم;no verified positive alternative in relevant apparatus · Ganjoor sh7:58 running body;negative نگردم
All four sources let Khosrow recognize Shideh’s device and consider the danger of giving such a powerful opponent rest. English puts recovery before ancestry, reversing two adjacent Persian units while preserving their connection. The crucial next condition, however, changes direction. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all retain the negative verb: if Khosrow does not fight on foot, the adversary will make matters difficult for Iran. Mohl’s consequence is first-person, making Khosrow responsible for the difficulty, but its condition is still negative. English instead says that fighting on foot may make matters difficult. This turns the source’s reason for accepting into a reason for hesitation. No positive alternative was verified in the relevant apparatus. The published lines remain untouched, but the polarity difference is an explicit unresolved textual flag, not a stylistic variation or a difference attributable merely to chapter arrangement.
63–68Rohham’s offer and the refusal of substitution
English 63–68;edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V273:638 running text · Mohl IV31:L4 running text · Khaleghi IV212:647 running text · Ganjoor sh7:59 running body · Moscow V273:639 running text · Mohl IV31:L5 running text · Khaleghi IV212:648 running text · Ganjoor sh7:60 running body · Moscow V273:640 running text · Mohl IV31:L6 running text · Khaleghi IV212:649 running text · Ganjoor sh7:61 running body · Moscow V274:641 running text · Mohl IV31:L7 running text · Khaleghi IV212:650 running text · Ganjoor sh7:62 running body · Moscow V274:642 running text · Mohl IV31:L8 running text · Khaleghi IV212:651 running text · Ganjoor sh7:63 running body · Moscow V274:643 running text · Mohl IV31:L9 running text · Khaleghi IV212:652 running text · Ganjoor sh7:64 running body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all make Rohham object that dismounting would dishonor the king’s birth. His question about the many mounted warriors is an argument for their usefulness: why should the sovereign expose himself when they are present? English guard his throne makes the service relationship more explicit. Rohham supports his offer with descent from Keshvad, so the exchange is not simply courage opposed to fear; lineage and suitable rank are part of the negotiation. Khosrow’s affectionate address acknowledges the volunteer before rejecting him. English trusted friend extends that warmth. The sources then say that Shideh’s descent from Pashang means he will not fight Rohham. The English retains the explanation as a claim within the exchange, not a universal rule established for every duel.
69–74Two advisers and unequal assessments
English 69–74;edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V274:644 running text · Mohl IV31:L10 running text · Khaleghi IV212:653 running text · Ganjoor sh7:65 running body · Moscow V274:645 running text · Mohl IV31:L11 running text · Khaleghi IV213:654 running text · Ganjoor sh7:66 running body · Moscow V274:646 running text · Mohl IV31:L12 running text · Khaleghi IV213:655 running text · Ganjoor sh7:67 running body · Moscow V274:647 running text · Mohl IV31:L13 running text · Khaleghi IV213:656 running text · Ganjoor sh7:68 running body · Moscow V274:648 running text · Mohl IV31:L14 running text · Khaleghi IV213:657 running text · Ganjoor sh7:69 running body · Moscow V274:649 running text · Mohl IV31:L15 running text · Khaleghi IV213:658 running text · Ganjoor sh7:70 running body
All four sources praise Shideh’s exceptional martial standing even while Khosrow refuses Rohham’s offer. The king’s recognition of descent from Fereydoon and unmatched valor makes his acceptance of dismounted combat socially defensible: meeting this opponent need not be shameful. English chief adorns their land softens the more specific source praise of his capacity to order an army, while retaining the admiration. On the other side, the tarjoman advises withdrawal because Shideh cannot stand against Khosrow. English herald is a functional rendering; this passage alone does not establish the official’s precise institutional role. Both advisers seek to preserve their own principal, but their arguments differ. Rohham invokes royal dignity and substitution; Shideh’s adviser invokes the practical wisdom of timely escape from destruction.
75–80The grave and the turning heavens
English 75–80;edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V274:650 running text · Mohl IV31:L16 running text · Khaleghi IV213:659 running text;آواز main;actual IV213n7 آورد · Ganjoor sh7:71 running body · Moscow V274:651 running text · Mohl IV31:L17 running text · Khaleghi IV213:660 running text · Ganjoor sh7:72 running body · Moscow V274:652 running text · Mohl IV31:L18 running text · Khaleghi IV213:661 running text · Ganjoor sh7:73 running body · Moscow V274:653 running text · Mohl IV31:L19 running text · Khaleghi IV213:662 running text · Ganjoor sh7:74 running body · Moscow V275:654 running text;negative برنگذرم · Mohl IV31:L20 running text;negative برنگذرم · Khaleghi IV213:663 running text;negative برنگذرم · Ganjoor sh7:75 running body;بر بگذرم differs · Moscow V275:655 running text · Mohl IV31:L21 running text · Khaleghi IV213:664 running text · Ganjoor sh7:76 running body
Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor describe men’s combat as something that cannot be hidden; Khaleghi main speaks of their report or renown and records the action-centered alternative in its apparatus. English deeds chooses that latter emphasis. All four then combine Shideh’s lifelong pride with frank recognition of an unprecedented opponent’s strength and farr. His preference for burial over flight is explicit, so English I choose the grave sharpens an existing hierarchy of honor and survival. The next verb differs: the three printed main texts have the negative form about escaping heaven’s turning, while Ganjoor displays a positive-looking form. English follows the printed fatalistic direction. The following conditional death in Khosrow’s hand, beyond prevention by friend or enemy, confirms that fatalism without making the coming death already accomplished.
81–85Hope on foot and the final consent
English 81–85;edition readings and verse-level citations below.
Moscow V275:656 running text · Mohl IV31:L22 running text · Khaleghi IV213:665 running text · Ganjoor sh7:77 running body · Moscow V275:657 running text · Mohl IV31:L23 running text · Khaleghi IV213:666 running text · Ganjoor sh7:78 running body · Moscow V275:658 running text · Mohl IV31:L24 running text · Khaleghi IV213:667 running text · Ganjoor sh7:79 running body · Moscow V275:659 running text · Mohl IV31:L25 running text · Khaleghi IV213:668 running text · Ganjoor sh7:80 running body · Moscow V275:660 running text · Mohl IV32:L1 running text · Khaleghi IV213:669 running text · Ganjoor sh7:81 running body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi retain an unresolved tension in Shideh’s final calculation. He acknowledges divine farr and cannot explain the strength he faces, yet hopes that fighting on foot might let him prevail. English streams of blood expands the source watercourse image while keeping it a prospective wish. Khosrow’s response recognizes noble descent, then claims that no Kayanian has tried dismounted combat. This is a royal assertion within the scene, not a separately verified history of every member of the dynasty. All four nevertheless end with consent expressed through the rein metaphor. English preserves that equestrian language at precisely the moment the men are about to abandon their horses. The chapter stops at agreement; dismounting and the fatal outcome belong to the subsequent published section.
Source record and limits
C4.8 contains 85 English couplets and 15 substantive notes. Declared running coverage is81 Moscow,85 Mohl,81 Ganjoor and82 Khaleghi units,all accounted for. English7 has Moscow actual apparatus and Mohl/Khaleghi main support. English18–20 have Mohl main and individually printed Moscow/Khaleghi apparatus support. Ganjoor has checked local gaps for these four units. English32–33 and60–61 share or redistribute source clauses;unique coverage does not double-count them. No source-only running unit falls within the declared reference.
Moscow V270–275:580–660; Mohl IV28:L14–L22,IV29:L1–L25,IV30:L1–L25,IV31:L1–L25,IV32:L1; Ganjoor mahmood/sh7:1–81; Khaleghi IV208–213:588–669. Mohl L locators count running couplets from the top,excluding headings.
- F&R English: C4.8 Kay Khosrow Battles Shideh.85 couplets,ending with consent to dismounted combat. The killing is outside this chapter.
- Moscow: V270–275:580–660,81 running units. Actual270n28 challenger announcement and271n24 three Rostam contingency units. Main dust and negative condition;actual273n7 blood.
- Mohl: IV28:L14–L22;IV29–31:L1–L25 each;IV32:L1,85 running units. Announcement and three Rostam units in main,along with blood and the negative condition.
- Ganjoor: mahmood/sh7:1–81,81 body units. Local gaps at6–7 and16–17 for announcement and Rostam units. Dust and negative dismounting condition in body;differing heaven-turning verb at75.
- Khaleghi-Motlagh: IV208–213:588–669,82 running units. Announcement in main,three Rostam units in actual210n3. Blood and negative dismounting condition in main.
The three Rostam instructions are actual full printed additions in Moscow and Khaleghi,not merely references to an unspecified longer version. The negative in the dismounting condition is present in all four accounts. Blood and dust are genuine alternatives;the English blood image has direct running-text support.
Running text,actual printed variants and full additions,and checked local gaps are separately identified. No appendix evidence or appendix-wide absence is claimed. Apparatus accounts concern the readings discussed,not an exhaustive transcription of all notes. No unprinted addition notice is treated as verified wording.
C4.8.62 has an unresolved substantive polarity reversal:all four inspected main texts say if I do not fight on foot;English says if I fight afoot. No supporting positive variant was verified in the relevant apparatus. C4.8.26 shifts the apparent recipient of the wisdom praise from Khosrow to Siavash. English48 leaves arrows unstated. English49 blood follows Mohl/Khaleghi main and actual Moscow apparatus against Moscow/Ganjoor dust main. English79 follows the printed negative about heaven’s turning against Ganjoor’s differing form. Lion epithets and herald/translator terminology remain qualified;no modern geographical pinpoint,mineralogical identification or dynasty-wide historical claim is certified. Threats and anticipations remain attributed speech. The inherited council-passage coverage exception is unchanged.
- Moscow V270n28 actual addition;English7 — همی گوید آن نامور تیزچنگ / که با شاه گویید کامد پشنگ
- Mohl IV29:L9 main;English18 — اگر زان که پیروز گردد پشنگ / ز رستم بجویید سامان جنگ
- Mohl IV29:L10 main;English19 — همه پیش او بنده فرمان شوید / وز آن درد نزدیک درمان شوید
- Mohl IV29:L11 main;English20 — سپه را که چون او نگهبان بود / همه چاره جنگ آسان بود
- Khaleghi IV210n3 first actual addition;English18 — اگر زانکه پیروز گردد پشنگ / ز رستم بجویید سامان جنگ
- Moscow V273:637 main;English62 — اگر من پیاده نگردم به جنگ / به ایرانیان بر کند جای تنگ
- Mohl IV31:L3 main;English62 — وگر من پیاده نگردم به جنگ / بر ایرانیان بر کنم کار تنگ
- Ganjoor sh7:58 body;English62 — اگر من پیاده نگردم به جنگ / به ایرانیان بر کند جای تنگ
- Khaleghi IV212:646 main;English62 — اگر من پیاده نگردم به جنگ / بر ایرانیان بر کند جای تنگ
- Moscow V273n7 actual variant;English49 — خون
- Khaleghi IV211:633 main;English49 — زمین شد ز خون سواران سیاه
- Mohl IV30:L11 main;English45 — گشنه نهار
- Moscow V272:620 main;English45 — اخته زهار
- Khaleghi IV211:629 main;English45 — هیخته زهار
- Moscow V275:654 main;English79 — هم از گردش چرخ برنگذرم
- Ganjoor sh7:75 body;English79 — هم از گردش چرخ بر بگذرم
C4.8 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | V270:580 running text | IV28:L14 running text |
| 2 | V270:581 running text | IV28:L15 running text |
| 3 | V270:582 running text | IV28:L16 running text |
| 4 | V270:583 running text;leopard | IV28:L17 running text;battlefield |
| 5 | V270:584 running text | IV28:L18 running text |
| 6 | V270:585 running text | IV28:L19 running text |
| 7 | V270n28 actual full addition | IV28:L20 running text |
| 8 | V270:586 running text;jowshan | IV28:L21 running text;khaftan |
| 9 | V270:587 running text | IV28:L22 running text |
| 10 | V271:588 running text | IV29:L1 running text |
| 11 | V271:589 running text | IV29:L2 running text |
| 12 | V271:590 running text | IV29:L3 running text |
| 13 | V271:591 running text | IV29:L4 running text |
| 14 | V271:592 running text | IV29:L5 running text |
| 15 | V271:593 running text | IV29:L6 running text |
| 16 | V271:594 running text | IV29:L7 running text |
| 17 | V271:595 running text | IV29:L8 running text |
| 18 | V271n24 second actual full addition | IV29:L9 running text |
| 19 | V271n24 first actual full addition | IV29:L10 running text |
| 20 | V271n24 third actual full addition | IV29:L11 running text |
| 21 | V271:596 running text | IV29:L12 running text |
| 22 | V271:597 running text | IV29:L13 running text |
| 23 | V271:598 running text | IV29:L14 running text |
| 24 | V271:599 running text | IV29:L15 running text |
| 25 | V271:600 running text | IV29:L16 running text |
| 26 | V271:601 running text;wisdom addresses Khosrow | IV29:L17 running text;wisdom addresses Khosrow |
| 27 | V272:602 running text | IV29:L18 running text |
| 28 | V272:603 running text | IV29:L19 running text |
| 29 | V272:604 running text | IV29:L20 running text |
| 30 | V272:605 running text | IV29:L21 running text |
| 31 | V272:606 running text | IV29:L22 running text |
| 32 | V272:607 running text; V272:608 running text;grief shared withEnglish33 | IV29:L23 running text;grief anticipated from IV29:L24 |
| 33 | V272:608 running text | IV29:L24 running text |
| 34 | V272:609 running text | IV29:L25 running text |
| 35 | V272:610 running text | IV30:L1 running text |
| 36 | V272:611 running text | IV30:L2 running text |
| 37 | V272:612 running text | IV30:L3 running text |
| 38 | V272:613 running text | IV30:L4 running text |
| 39 | V272:614 running text | IV30:L5 running text |
| 40 | V272:615 running text | IV30:L6 running text |
| 41 | V272:616 running text | IV30:L7 running text |
| 42 | V272:617 running text | IV30:L8 running text |
| 43 | V272:618 running text | IV30:L9 running text |
| 44 | V272:619 running text | IV30:L10 running text |
| 45 | V272:620 running text;اخته زهار | IV30:L11 running text;گشنه نهار |
| 46 | V273:621 running text | IV30:L12 running text |
| 47 | V273:622 running text | IV30:L13 running text |
| 48 | V273:623 running text;arrows included | IV30:L14 running text;arrows included |
| 49 | V273:624 running text;dust main;actual V273n7 blood | IV30:L15 running text;blood main |
| 50 | V273:625 running text | IV30:L16 running text |
| 51 | V273:626 running text | IV30:L17 running text |
| 52 | V273:627 running text | IV30:L18 running text |
| 53 | V273:628 running text | IV30:L19 running text |
| 54 | V273:629 running text | IV30:L20 running text |
| 55 | V273:630 running text | IV30:L21 running text |
| 56 | V273:631 running text | IV30:L22 running text |
| 57 | V273:632 running text | IV30:L23 running text |
| 58 | V273:633 running text | IV30:L24 running text |
| 59 | V273:634 running text | IV30:L25 running text |
| 60 | V273:636 running text | IV31:L2 running text |
| 61 | V273:635 running text; V273:636 running text;reordered ancestry;consequence shared withEnglish60 | IV31:L1 running text;ancestry;consequence from IV31:L2 |
| 62 | V273:637 running text;negative نگردم;no verified positive alternative in relevant apparatus | IV31:L3 running text;negative نگردم;first-person consequence بر کنم |
| 63 | V273:638 running text | IV31:L4 running text |
| 64 | V273:639 running text | IV31:L5 running text |
| 65 | V273:640 running text | IV31:L6 running text |
| 66 | V274:641 running text | IV31:L7 running text |
| 67 | V274:642 running text | IV31:L8 running text |
| 68 | V274:643 running text | IV31:L9 running text |
| 69 | V274:644 running text | IV31:L10 running text |
| 70 | V274:645 running text | IV31:L11 running text |
| 71 | V274:646 running text | IV31:L12 running text |
| 72 | V274:647 running text | IV31:L13 running text |
| 73 | V274:648 running text | IV31:L14 running text |
| 74 | V274:649 running text | IV31:L15 running text |
| 75 | V274:650 running text | IV31:L16 running text |
| 76 | V274:651 running text | IV31:L17 running text |
| 77 | V274:652 running text | IV31:L18 running text |
| 78 | V274:653 running text | IV31:L19 running text |
| 79 | V275:654 running text;negative برنگذرم | IV31:L20 running text;negative برنگذرم |
| 80 | V275:655 running text | IV31:L21 running text |
| 81 | V275:656 running text | IV31:L22 running text |
| 82 | V275:657 running text | IV31:L23 running text |
| 83 | V275:658 running text | IV31:L24 running text |
| 84 | V275:659 running text | IV31:L25 running text |
| 85 | V275:660 running text | IV32:L1 running text |
New Naqqali