On the eighth day Gudarz dictates his answer and refuses point by point: Piran’s heart and tongue are strangers, the feud reaches back to Iraj, seventy sons are unavenged, the lands are already taken. Ruyin carries it home; Piran hides it and calls his troops to arms.
1 Upon the eighth day, at the dawn’s first light, Gudarz called in the scribe and bade him write.
2 The scribe began; with every stroke he drew, A tree of vengeance in the answer grew.
3 He first gave praise to God, then turned to state His answer to each point of their debate.
4 “Your letter I have read from end to end, And heard each word that you have wished to send.
5 And Ruyin brought your message to my side, Each matter that you charged him to confide.
6 I marvel that you write such gracious things, And at the honeyed words your letter brings.
7 Your heart and tongue are neighbors far apart; Your soul has gained no wisdom for its part.
8 In every matter you speak fair and wise, With phrases rich in grace before men’s eyes.
9 Whoever lacks true wisdom might believe Your goodwill and the web your words can weave.
10 You are like salt ground glittering in the sun, That seems like water to a distant one.
11 But lies and tricks avail no warrior’s hand, When gorz and sword and kamand fill the land.
12 I want no dealings now but war with you; This is no hour for parleys to renew.
13 No time for league, for love, or painted speech, But time to learn what heaven’s signs will teach.
14 We watch to whom God grants the conquering sun, And strength and fortune when the fight is done.
15 Still hear me now, and let wise counsel guide; Let wisdom lead good fortune at your side.
16 First, you have said: ‘Through kindness and through fear Of God and resurrection drawing near,
17 I do not wish to stir this bitter fight; My heart is cramped by all this wrongful plight.’
18 Your tongue and heart were never joined as one, Though honeyed phrases from your mouth have run.
19 If justice had possessed your heart and breath, You would not first have led the road to death.
20 When Giv first came with nobles, grave and wise, And laid his peaceful counsel before your eyes,
21 With prudent words and honorable speech, You raised war’s iron wall beyond their reach.
22 You armed your army for this bitter fight, And left your land to violate our right.
23 In every clash, aggression was your will; You moved your troops, intent on bloodshed still.
24 Had wisdom come before you took this way, You would have found more peace at last today.
25 Your evil nature, bent on crooked gain, Has driven you from wisdom’s level plain.
26 The nature of your race was formed in guile, And treachery has marked it all the while.
27 You know how high-born Iraj met his doom, When Tur envied his crown and royal room.
28 You know what evil Tur and Salm began, And how injustice spread through every clan.
29 You know how vengeance spread through field and throne, And grief made Fereydoon’s long anguish known.
30 He cursed them ceaselessly with wounded breath, His heart laid open by his loved son’s death.
31 The Giver’s aid sustained him day by day; He nursed that vengeance, would not turn away.
32 Long ages passed; that foul inherited strain Reached Afrasiab through a lawless chain.
33 He sought revenge on Manuchehr, made war On Nohzar, Kay Qobad, and Iran’s shore.
34 You know what wrong he did to Kavus’s crown, And how he ground our prosperous Iran down.
35 At last, with guiltless Siavash’s blood, He laid new feud’s foundation in a flood.
36 You had no thought of justice on that day, When blameless Siavash gave life away.
37 How many chiefs of Iran, crowned with state, Have fallen in this feud through Turkish hate.
38 You next have said: ‘Old man with whitening hair, How long will you stay armed, your blade laid bare?’
39 Know this, old deceiver, tried by time, Who saw life’s rise and fall through every crime:
40 God gave me length of days and fortune bright, That I might avenge Iran in open fight.
41 I mean to send the dust from Turan high, Until its cloud ascends toward the sky.
42 My only fear is God may end my breath, And part my soul and body through my death,
43 Before I win the vengeance I have planned, And set my feet upon your conquered land.
44 You thirdly say: ‘I see no holy awe Of God in you, no reverence for His law.’
45 Do you not know that wanton blood will turn Against the man who lets destruction burn?
46 If gentle words should make me quit the fight, And turn me from the vengeance that is right,
47 God would inquire how I had spent my days, And ask me to account for all my ways:
48 ‘I gave you leadership and strength to stand, With wisdom, wealth, and valor at command.
49 Why did you fail before Iran’s array To arm for Siavash and make foes pay?’
50 And when the Judge asks of my seventy sons, Those noble lives cut off like setting suns,
51 How shall I answer Him who made the world, If fear or charm had kept my banner furled?
52 The fourth point that you raised, O aged chief, Was Siavash, the source of all this grief.
53 You said: ‘For one whose body turns to clay, You should not take the living soul away.’
54 Remember all the foul deeds you have done, And griefs that darkened Iran’s royal sun.
55 Remember wrongs you wrought throughout our land, And monarchs ruined by Turan’s command.
56 What treaties you have broken, feuds begun, What paths toward evil you have always run.
57 How can I think of this and grant release, When all your faithless deeds have murdered peace?
58 Fifth, you say: ‘I shall covenant with you; The chiefs of Turan shall be hostages too.
59 I shall send Khosrow wealth and end this toil, And close the road to suffering on our soil.’
60 Know then, sepahbod of the Turkish land, Our Shah has given us a different command.
61 He ordered me to grapple to the death And shed your blood for Siavash’s last breath.
62 If I refuse to do as Khosrow bade, My soul before its Maker stands dismayed.
63 If you still hope Khosrow will turn to peace, And through these words bid all his anger cease,
64 Send all the wealth and hostages you name, With Lahhak and with Ruyin of your fame.
65 Send them at once to Khosrow; let them ride To Iran, where the road stands open wide.
66 Sixth, you have named Iran’s fair towns and lands, Its prosperous realm, to pass into our hands.
67 You said: ‘To Khosrow I shall yield them all, And all my scattered troops I shall recall.’
68 But God has seized them first; and if you know No word of this, the truth I now shall show.
69 Lohrasp has taken all the western side, As far as Khazar’s marches spreading wide.
70 Southward to Sind, the whole realm is arrayed In gleaming iron like a polished blade.
71 Brave Rostam, with his sharp and trenchant sword, Has raised a day of doom on every horde.
72 Rostam sent Hind’s chief to the Shah that day, His sable standard borne along the way.
73 In Dehestan, Khwarazm, and all that ground Where Turkish raiders raised their heads around,
74 The desert has been cleared of all their band; Our troops now ride on toward Bakhtar’s land.
75 Ashkash rained hail on Shideh in the fight, And brought him near to death beneath his might.
76 He sent Khosrow the captives and the spoil, And purged the region of its war and toil.
77 Now here the contest lies between us two, Where honor or disgrace awaits our view.
78 In battle you have seen the strength they show, Those famous chiefs whose prowess well you know.
79 Come meet me face to face, and you shall see: I shall release you from this talk with me.
80 By God’s own power and the Shah’s command, I shall sink this whole field in blood and sand.
81 Observe, famed captain of the Turkish side, The sun and moon beneath which hopes have died.
82 Heaven has nearly bound you fast and bare; Your fortune’s head is set within the snare.
83 Mark what the Maker lays upon your head For evil deeds and all the blood you shed.
84 Time has revealed your crimes beneath the sky, And evil now repays each former lie.
85 Be heedful now; open your ears and learn What wise men say before the seasons turn.
86 These famous ranks, a hundred thousand strong, Will not be charmed from vengeance for your wrong.
87 They all seek honor, vengeance, war’s red field, And no sweet phrase can make their purpose yield.
88 I reach the seventh point: by oath you try To prove your truth beneath the watchful sky.
89 I will not speak of further bonds with you; Your soul will buy no wisdom, old or new.
90 For every man with whom you swear in trust Will find you break that faith and turn it dust.
91 Your oath brought Siavash to grief and death; Let no man trust the promise of your breath.
92 You did not save him on his evil day, Though in distress he called you every way.
93 The eighth point: you have said, ‘My crown and throne, My fortune, troops, and valor top your own.
94 I hold more treasure, men, and warlike fame, Yet love torments my heart despite my claim.’
95 I think you tested me in war before; You know whether I failed when battles tore.
96 Look once again, and judge me from the start, In every skill and in the warrior’s art.
97 In treasure, fortune, crown and throne, compare; Perhaps I stand above you everywhere.
98 And lastly you have said: ‘Choose men to fight, A few brave champions, proven in their might.
99 I too will choose from Turan’s mounted men The warriors fit to face your champions then.
100 From tenderness toward troops I do not seek To spread revenge against the worn and weak.’
101 You put compassion forward as your plea; Your hidden heart and purpose you can see.
102 The Shah, the ruler of the world, would blame My act, if I withdrew our troops in shame.
103 You also asked that I should meet you here, And face you on this plain with sword and spear.
104 Before me stands a guilty force in arms, That filled Iran with grief and war’s alarms.
105 The Shah will never let me shun the fight, Or turn from vengeance when our cause is right.
106 First, let our armies meet upon this ground, Like mountains crashing with a mighty sound.
107 Let both our armies form their ranks and strive; Perhaps we then shall see which side will thrive.
108 If not, we bring those champions to the field, And make a place where prowess is revealed.
109 My word shall stand, though yours may break in two; I know how little oaths have meant to you.
110 But if your present force cannot withstand My men, then ask your king for a stronger band.
111 Consider carefully your state and need, And weigh the course by which you would proceed.
112 As for the wounded absent from the ranks, Among your kin, allies, and warrior flanks,
113 Wait till the healers make them whole and strong; A brief delay need not detain you long.
114 If you wish for delay and time to heal, Then speak it plainly; otherwise, draw steel.
115 I offer this so, on the battle-day, You cannot find excuse enough to say:
116 ‘You fell upon us suddenly and pressed; You ambushed us and gave no time to rest.’
117 If I seek vengeance for a hundred years, Or now at once, the same resolve appears.
118 There is no hope that I shall quit the fight; For sightless eyes, alike are day and night.”
119 When that reply was finished and made clear, The fairy-faced young envoy then drew near.
120 His belt secured, he rode his rapid steed, With mounted men around him, fit for deed.
121 Then Ruyin left his saddle on the plain, And brought before Gudarz his mounted train.
122 Gudarz then called the Mobadan to hear, And courtly sages gathered quickly near.
123 Wise men and shrewd came swiftly to his side, With clear and ready minds to hear and guide.
124 Before the chiefs, Gudarz then gave the word: “Let all the answer I have written be heard.”
125 The great men heard the cogent answer read, Recited by the scribe, as custom led.
126 They judged the wisdom of Piran as slight, And held his offered counsel thin and light.
127 They praised Gudarz and hailed his honored name, The chosen Pahlevan of deathless fame.
128 He sealed the letter, gave it to the son Of Piran, sprung from Viseh, honored one.
129 When Ruyin rose to go, he bade them bring A robe of honor fitting for a king.
130 Arab steeds with golden trappings came, With crowns and swords in golden sheaths aflame.
131 His comrades too received both silver bright And gold, with caps and belts as each had right.
132 Then Ruyin mounted on his rapid horse, And led his escort back toward Piran’s force.
133 When Ruyin reached his father’s camp, his band Went with him to the chief who held command.
134 He bowed before the throne with lowered face; Piran received him in a close embrace.
135 He gave Iran’s sepahbod’s words their due, And told of all the army in his view.
136 A scribe read out the letter, word by word; Piran’s heart blackened at the news he heard.
137 His heart was full of pain, his soul of fear; He knew a harsh descent was drawing near.
138 He chose restraint and silence in that hour, And hid the message from his gathered power.
139 Then to the troops he said: “Gudarz will yield No change of heart, no peace upon this field.
140 For all the blood of seventy sons once dear, His heart will find no rest from vengeance here.
141 If he, recalling what has passed away, Renews this ancient hatred day by day,
142 Why should I not gird on my arms to fight, Avenging my lost brothers with my might?
143 And for nine hundred chiefs whose blood was shed, Whose bodies in the battle lost each head?
144 In all the lands of Turan none can ride To war like Houman, with his strength and pride.
145 And Nastihan, that cypress spreading shade, Who vanished from the ranks where warriors stayed.
146 Now we must gird for battle, sword in hand; I shall not leave the Iranians our land.
147 By God’s great power, my sword shall end their might, And raise the Day of Doom before their sight.”
148 He chose the fitting horses from his herds, And brought them to the troops to match his words.
149 He mounted all the footmen for the fray, And gave each rider two steeds on that day.
150 He opened up the doors of ancient stores, And gave dinars and wealth in lavish scores.